15-04-2025
Rick Scott has the right idea. It's time for permanent daylight saving time
Last week, a U.S. Senate committee held a hearing on the Sunshine Protection Act, a bill that would making daylight saving time permanent. It's an issue we've been debating in this country for years: In 2022, the Senate unanimously passed similar legislation from Sen. Rick Scott, but it later died in the House.
This latest hearing signals renewed interest in ending the twice-yearly clock change.
I agree — it's time to lock the clock.
Every March and November, we find ourselves either springing ahead — and losing an hour of sleep — or falling back and enjoying that extra hour. If you have children or pets, you know the chaos that ensues with the time change. Bedtime schedules are upended, and pets demand meals at off-times.
In 2018, the Florida Legislature passed legislation to make daylight saving time permanent, and Scott, who was governor at the time, signed it into law. More sunshine in the Sunshine State — it was a win. But it didn't actually happen; the change needs federal approval.
When Secretary of State Marco Rubio was serving in the U.S. Senate, he introduced the Sunshine Preservation Act in 2018, and in 2019, and then reintroduced it with co-sponsors in 2021 and 2023. In a joint opinion piece published in 2021, on Rubio and Sen. James Lankford, a Republican from Oklahoma, wrote that they had 'bispartisan solution' for the debate: 'Let's lock the clock and let our kids and families enjoy more sunshine year-round.'
Fast forward to January 2025, when Scott introduced the act again, saying it 'would end the twice-yearly time change and make daylight saving time the national year-round standard.' Seven Democrats joined him supporting the act, including Sen. Alex Padilla from California, where the state has already voted to the lock the clock.
During April 10 hearing by the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation — titled 'If I Could Turn Back Time: Should We Lock the Clock?' — Scott continued to make his case, saying, 'the American people are sick and tired of changing their clocks twice a year — it's unnecessary, confusing and completely outdated.'
There are potential downsides to the idea. Critics argue that permanent daylight saving time would lead to darker mornings, disruption in our circadian rhythm and have negative effects on public health. And, as the Miami Herald noted in an editorial in December, when the U.S. made daylight saving time permanent in 1974, the outcry over the ensuing morning darkness led to a reversal after just 10 months.
These concerns have merit. The delay in winter sunrises, particularly in northern states, could impact schoolchildren, commuters and shift workers who start their day in the dark.
But the real problem is changing the clocks. The abrupt time shift causes a change in our sleep, increases risk of heart attacks and strokes, and a higher number of car accidents., according to the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
Most Americans support ending clock changes. In a recent study by the Center for Public Opinion Research at Stetson University 75% of Americans supported the idea to stop changing the clocks twice a year and 54% of Americans favored year-round daylight saving time.
Nearly 20 states have passed bills to keep daylight saving time permanent. They're just waiting for congressional approval. Last week's the Senate committee is a step in the right direction.
Here in Florida, the economic benefits can't be overlooked. By locking the clocks to daylight saving time, Floridians would enjoy more daylight hours, which could offer a boost to retail shopping and restaurants as people stay out later and spend more. Tourists would be able to spend more time enjoying outdoor activities rather than retreating to their hotel rooms when the sun sets early.
Longer days are also good for the environment. More natural light in the evening hours means less electricity consumption for lighting, potentially reducing our carbon footprint.
The 'lock the clock' effort has bipartisan support. Republicans and Democrats may not be able to agree on much these days but they've found one issue: permanent daylight saving time.
Mary Anna Mancuso is a member of the Miami Herald Editorial Board. Her email: mmancuso@
