Latest news with #TheHighCostofFreeParking
Forbes
16-04-2025
- Automotive
- Forbes
The High Cost Of Free Parking: Why Cities Must Rethink Curb Space
In cities across America, parking is often perceived as an entitlement—a public good that should be abundant and free. But as urban planners and economists have long argued, 'free' parking isn't free at all. Instead, it imposes hidden costs on cities, businesses, and residents, shaping transportation choices in ways that undermine public safety and economic vitality. The legacy of free or underpriced parking dates back to post-World War II planning policies that prioritized automobile use over other forms of transportation. Today, many cities still require developers to provide excessive off-street parking, while curbside spaces are often priced far below their true market value. The result? More congestion, increased emissions, and inefficient land use that prioritizes cars over people. Donald Shoup, the UCLA economist and author of The High Cost of Free Parking, famously argued that underpriced parking distorts urban economies. It encourages car dependency, contributes to traffic as drivers circle for spots, and disincentivizes investment in public transit, biking, and walkable neighborhoods. Worse, these hidden costs are passed on to everyone—including those who don't drive—in the form of higher housing prices, reduced public space, and increased pollution. Cars parked in a major city While free parking may feel like a convenience, its costs ripple through the economy in ways that few recognize. Consider these realities: Many cities worldwide have taken bold steps to reform their parking policies, using pricing as a tool to manage demand and encourage sustainable transportation. In London and Singapore, congestion pricing has helped reduce traffic and fund public transit improvements. In Europe, over 250 cities have implemented Low Emission Zones (LEZs) that charge or restrict the most polluting vehicles. These policies recognize that curb space is a valuable asset and should be managed accordingly. Closer to home, San Francisco's SFpark program uses demand-based pricing to adjust parking fees in real time. The results? Reduced congestion, improved parking availability, and increased transit use. Other cities, including Los Angeles and Washington, D.C., have also begun experimenting with dynamic pricing models to optimize curb space. To create more livable, sustainable cities, we must rethink how parking is priced and managed. Here's what policymakers should prioritize: The high cost of free parking is an economic and environmental burden that cities can no longer afford to ignore. As urban populations grow and climate challenges mount, we must shift toward policies that prioritize efficient, equitable, and sustainable use of curb space. By pricing parking appropriately, eliminating outdated minimums, and reinvesting in smarter mobility solutions, cities can create more vibrant, walkable, and resilient communities. The question isn't whether we can afford to charge for parking—it's whether we can afford not to.
New York Times
19-02-2025
- General
- New York Times
Donald Shoup, Who Made Parking an Entertaining Subject, Dies at 86
Donald Shoup, a professor of urban studies whose provocative and occasionally amusing 734-page treatise on the economics of parking sparked reforms in thousands of cities, helping reduce traffic, create green space and make cities more walkable, died on Feb. 6 at his home in Los Angeles. He was 86. The cause was a stroke, his wife, Pat Shoup, said. Professor Shoup was an intellectual hero to urbanists. His disciples called themselves the Shoupistas — their Facebook group has more than 8,100 followers — and referred to their bearded guru as Shoup Dogg, after the rapper Snoop Dogg. Professor Shoup, who bicycled to his office at the University of California, Los Angeles, in khaki pants and a tweed sport coat, did not rap. But he managed to take a dry subject — parking — and turn it into an entertaining one. 'Many of us,' he liked to remind conference audiences, 'were probably even conceived in a parked car.' In his 2005 book, 'The High Cost of Free Parking,' a hefty tome that legions of urban studies students have lugged around to the detriment of their spinal cords, Professor Shoup explained the problems that city planners created by providing too much free or underpriced parking after automobile use soared in the early 20th century. He liked to quote George Costanza, the bald, neurotic 'Seinfeld' character: 'My father didn't pay for parking, my mother, my brother, nobody. It's like going to a prostitute. Why should I pay when, if I apply myself, maybe I can get it for free?' To Professor Shoup, that quote showed the economic calculus that drivers make: Instead of paying for a pricey garage, they are tempted to keep looking and waiting for an elusive (and cheaper) spot to become magically available — wasting energy and creating traffic and air pollution in the process. 'The curb spaces are like fish in the ocean: a parking space belongs to anyone who occupies it, but if you leave it, you lose it,' Professor Shoup wrote. 'Where all the curb spaces are occupied, turnover leads to a few vacancies over time, but drivers must cruise to find a space vacated by a departing motorist.' As cities grew, free or inexpensive parking was regarded as an inalienable right. City planners mandated that developers provide off-street parking for residential and commercial projects, incentivizing driving over other forms of transportation. It was a waste of valuable land, Professor Shoup noted, that contributed to urban sprawl. He drew on the board game Monopoly to illustrate his point. 'In Monopoly, free parking is only one space out of 40 on the board,' he wrote. 'If Monopoly were played under our current zoning laws, however, free parking would be on every space. Parking lots might cover half of Marvin Gardens, and Park Place would have underground parking.' The problem would mushroom. 'Free parking would push buildings farther apart, increase the cost of houses and hotels, and permit fewer of them to be built at all,' Professor Shoup wrote. 'Smart players would soon leave Atlantic City behind and move to a larger board that allowed them to build on cheaper land in the suburbs. Connecticut Avenue would not be redeveloped with hotels, the railroads would disappear and every piece on the board would move more slowly.' He proposed a three-pronged solution: Ban off-street parking requirements, letting developers (and market forces) dictate how much parking to supply; employ dynamic pricing for on-street parking, raising prices when demand is highest; and spend the resulting increased revenue from meters to spruce up sidewalks, encouraging more walking. 'The High Cost of Free Parking' was widely praised, especially for turning parking into a riveting read. 'When I told a group of transportation colleagues about the book, they expressed both disbelief and sympathy — how could there be that much to say about parking, let alone anything interesting?' Susan Handy, a professor of environmental science and policy at the University of California, Davis, wrote in The Journal of Planning Education and Research. 'But as Shoup adeptly shows, parking is interesting, and it is hugely important.' The book captured the attention of progressive policymakers and grass roots activists, who began pushing for cities big and small to adopt Professor Shoup's ideas. 'Don is treated in some places like Einstein, like he has discovered the theory of relativity,' Bonnie Nelson, a founder of Nelson\Nygaard, a transportation consulting firm, told The Los Angeles Times in 2010. More than 3,000 cities have adopted some or all of Professor Shoup's recommendations, according to the Parking Reform Network, a nonprofit that champions the book's ideas. 'The size and breadth of this book gives it authority,' Tony Jordan, the group's founder, said in an interview. 'You can literally stand on it when you make an argument.' Donald Curran Shoup was born on Aug. 24, 1938, in Long Beach, Calif. His parents were Francis Elliott Shoup Jr., a captain in the U.S. Navy, and Muriel Shoup, who ran the home. When Donald was 2, the Shoups moved to Honolulu, where his father was stationed. 'The only thing I'm famous for is that I was living in Honolulu when Pearl Harbor was attacked,' he recalled in an interview with the American Planning Association. 'So I think everything has been very calm ever since. If you start with Pearl Harbor as your first memory, life seems very easy.' He studied electrical engineering and economics at Yale and then did his graduate studies there in economics, receiving his doctorate in 1968. After teaching at the University of Michigan, he joined U.C.L.A.'s department of urban planning in 1974. Back then, parking wasn't exactly in vogue as a scholarly subject. He covered his office door with cartoons about it. 'Because most academics cannot imagine anything less interesting to study than parking, I was a bottom feeder with little competition for many years,' Professor Shoup wrote in 'The High Cost of Free Parking.' 'But there is a lot of food down there, and many other academics have joined in what is now almost a feeding frenzy.' He was married for 59 years to Ms. Shoup, who helped edit his writing. She is his only immediate survivor. Professor Shoup loved being called Shoup Dogg, she recalled, and even used the nickname as his website address. 'He would do absolutely anything,' she said, 'to get people to pay attention to the important issue of parking.'
Yahoo
13-02-2025
- General
- Yahoo
Donald Shoup, renowned parking guru and UCLA professor, dies at 86
Over more than a half century of clear writing, clever quips and exhaustive scholarship, Donald Shoup became one of the world's foremost experts and influencers on a topic seemingly as mundane as it is universal: parking. Shoup, an economist and distinguished professor emeritus of urban planning at UCLA, died Feb. 6 after a brief illness. He was 86. Shoup's central argument, published most expansively in his 700-page seminal work "The High Cost of Free Parking," was that everything that most people think about parking was wrong. Free street parking, Shoup wrote, makes parking and driving worse. The low cost creates a scarcity of spaces that leads people to spend time and fuel circling blocks in misery. And city planners' efforts to solve this problem by mandating that homes and businesses provide more cheap parking only worsen the situation. According to Shoup, this parking conundrum is foundational to many of the ills in modern urban life: congestion, sprawl, pollution and high housing costs. Read more: 'Gimme Shelter': How parking lots explain California's housing crisis Shoup presented his ideas with a cheerful countercultural undercurrent and sprinkle of quirky history. In a 2014 interview with The Times, Shoup noted that the first parking ticket for an expired meter was given to a Protestant minister in 1935. The fine was dismissed, Shoup said, 'on the then-novel explanation that the minister had gone to get change for the parking meter.' Shoup's message, persistence and style gained him legions of followers around the globe. The most ardent called themselves 'Shoupistas.' The professor embraced the attention and happily accepted a playful moniker for himself, 'Shoup Dogg.' Michael Manville, chair of urban planning at the UCLA Luskin School of Public Affairs, said Shoup leaned into the spotlight because he realized it would help spread his ideas and because he just liked talking to people about parking. "He spent so much time with his writing because he wanted to make it accessible," said Manville, who first met Shoup as a UCLA graduate student in 2001. "He spent so much time with presentations because he wanted to make them entertaining. He built a method where he was always ready to explain to an activist group or a politician, 'Hey, the missing part here is parking.'" Shoup acknowledged that inveighing against free parking was not popular. He began a 2006 article in academic journal Transport Policy by nodding to parking conventional wisdom through a quotation from George Costanza, the obsessive sidekick from the 1990s sitcom "Seinfeld." Parking at a garage, Costanza said, was 'like going to a prostitute.' 'Why should I pay when, if I apply myself, maybe I can get it for free?' Costanza said. Read more: He puts parking in its place While Shoup mostly traveled by bicycle, he told The Times for a 2010 profile that, when he drove, he often circled the block searching for free parking. 'I don't like paying for parking,' he said with a shrug. 'But free parking is ultimately not beneficial.' Shoup's policy prescriptions attempted to take into account the public's prevailing views. He believed that cities should charge market prices for street parking and that the resulting revenue should be directed to improvements in the surrounding community. This blending of classical economic theories on supply and demand and understanding political realities helped build his practical influence, wrote Bill Fulton, a former student of Shoup's and an expert on California planning issues, in a remembrance published this week. 'If you give that money back to the neighborhood where the paid parking is occurring, you can provide a tangible benefit to that neighborhood — and begin to overcome political opposition to paid parking,' Fulton wrote. Shoup was born in 1938 in Long Beach. His father was a captain in the U.S. Navy and the Shoups were stationed in Honolulu when Pearl Harbor was bombed. In 1968, Shoup earned a PhD in economics at Yale and, in six years, became a professor at UCLA. He remained there his entire career, retiring in 2015. Fulton recalled that Shoup used to joke that he came upon parking as his life's work because it was 'the bottom of the barrel.' Most public policy academics studied more prestigious national and state issues leaving few interested in plumbing the depths of local policy. Among the few who explored local government, everyone ignored two issues: parking and sewage. 'Don didn't want to study sewage,' Fulton wrote. 'So he studied parking.' As mayor of Ventura in 2010, Fulton brought Shoup's ideas into reality through a parking strategy for the city's downtown. The city began charging for some of its parking spaces, which spurred employees of local businesses to use nearby free city lots, freeing up curb spaces for customers. By that point, numerous cities around the country were experimenting with Shoup's ideas. The Parking Reform Network, a nonprofit founded to advance Shoup's ideas, has documented policies in more than 3,000 cities that rely on Shoup's research. On the nonprofit's website, over 70 people — including mourners from Bogotá, Colombia; Mexico City; Istanbul; Brisbane, Australia; and elsewhere — have shared memories of Shoup and celebrated his scholarship. Read more: Column: Donald Shoup, UCLA's parking guru, on how L.A. should manage its meters One of the biggest changes inspired by Shoup's work came in 2022 when Gov. Gavin Newsom signed legislation that eliminated mandatory parking requirements for most developments near mass transit across California. Newsom said the law would reduce the cost of housing while lowering climate change-inducing car trips. 'Housing solutions are also climate solutions,' Newsom said. The law took effect when Shoup was 85 years old. Shoup liked to acknowledge his later-in-life success, according to his wife, Pat Shoup. He published "The High Cost of Free Parking" when he was 67. 'He always said it was fine to be a late bloomer if you made it to the flower show,' Pat wrote in her husband's death notice. 'He made it and left a long trail of blossoms in his wake to benefit others.' Shoup remained active following his retirement from UCLA. He continued to teach and was often seen within the Luskin School of Public Affairs building, per a remembrance published by the university. Rep. Laura Friedman (D-Glendale) marveled at Shoup's energy and how the professor continued to inspire people. Recently, she watched a crowd filled with people of all ages rapt as he gave a lecture on reforming handicap parking laws to increase access for people with disabilities. Friedman, who authored the 2022 parking law when she served in the state Legislature, said the army of Shoup adherents provided a critical mass of support as she tried to move the bill forward. 'He inspired a passion among his students and fellow academics that turned his work into a movement,' Friedman said. 'That's what was unique about him.' Shoup is survived by his wife Pat, brother Frank Shoup, his niece Allison Shoup, nephew Elliot Shoup, Elliot's wife Megan and their three children. There will be no funeral or church service, but UCLA will celebrate his life at a later date. In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to the Donald and Pat Shoup Endowed Fellowship in Urban Planning at the UCLA Luskin School or the Parking Reform Network. Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Los Angeles Times
13-02-2025
- General
- Los Angeles Times
Donald Shoup, renowned parking guru and UCLA professor, dies at 86
Over more than a half century of clear writing, clever quips and exhaustive scholarship, Donald Shoup became one of the world's foremost experts and influencers on a topic seemingly as mundane as it is universal: parking. Shoup, an economist and distinguished professor emeritus of urban planning at UCLA, died Feb. 6 after a brief illness. He was 86. Shoup's central argument, published most expansively in his 700-page seminal work 'The High Cost of Free Parking,' was that everything that most people think about parking was wrong. Free street parking, Shoup wrote, makes parking and driving worse. The low cost creates a scarcity of spaces that leads people to spend time and fuel circling blocks in misery. And city planners' efforts to solve this problem by mandating that homes and businesses provide more cheap parking only worsen the situation. According to Shoup, this parking conundrum is foundational to many of the ills in modern urban life: congestion, sprawl, pollution and high housing costs. Shoup presented his ideas with a cheerful countercultural undercurrent and sprinkle of quirky history. In a 2014 interview with The Times, Shoup noted that the first parking ticket for an expired meter was given to a Protestant minister in 1935. The fine was dismissed, Shoup said, 'on the then-novel explanation that the minister had gone to get change for the parking meter.' Shoup's message, persistence and style gained him legions of followers around the globe. The most ardent called themselves 'Shoupistas.' The professor embraced the attention and happily accepted a playful moniker for himself, 'Shoup Dogg.' Michael Manville, chair of urban planning at the UCLA Luskin School of Public Affairs, said Shoup leaned into the spotlight because he realized it would help spread his ideas and because he just liked talking to people about parking. 'He spent so much time with his writing because he wanted to make it accessible,' said Manville, who first met Shoup as a UCLA graduate student in 2001. 'He spent so much time with presentations because he wanted to make them entertaining. He built a method where he was always ready to explain to an activist group or a politician, 'Hey, the missing part here is parking.'' Shoup acknowledged that inveighing against free parking was not popular. He began a 2006 article in academic journal Transport Policy by nodding to parking conventional wisdom through a quotation from George Costanza, the obsessive sidekick from the 1990s sitcom 'Seinfeld.' Parking at a garage, Costanza said, was 'like going to a prostitute.' 'Why should I pay when, if I apply myself, maybe I can get it for free?' Costanza said. While Shoup mostly traveled by bicycle, he told The Times for a 2010 profile that, when he drove, he often circled the block searching for free parking. 'I don't like paying for parking,' he said with a shrug. 'But free parking is ultimately not beneficial.' Shoup's policy prescriptions attempted to take into account the public's prevailing views. He believed that cities should charge market prices for street parking and that the resulting revenue should be directed to improvements in the surrounding community. This blending of classical economic theories on supply and demand and understanding political realities helped build his practical influence, wrote Bill Fulton, a former student of Shoup's and an expert on California planning issues, in a remembrance published this week. 'If you give that money back to the neighborhood where the paid parking is occurring, you can provide a tangible benefit to that neighborhood — and begin to overcome political opposition to paid parking,' Fulton wrote. Shoup was born in 1938 in Long Beach. His father was a captain in the U.S. Navy and the Shoups were stationed in Honolulu when Pearl Harbor was bombed. In 1968, Shoup earned a PhD in economics at Yale and, in six years, became a professor at UCLA. He remained there his entire career, retiring in 2015. Fulton recalled that Shoup used to joke that he came upon parking as his life's work because it was 'the bottom of the barrel.' Most public policy academics studied more prestigious national and state issues leaving few interested in plumbing the depths of local policy. Among the few who explored local government, everyone ignored two issues: parking and sewage. 'Don didn't want to study sewage,' Fulton wrote. 'So he studied parking.' As mayor of Ventura in 2010, Fulton brought Shoup's ideas into reality through a parking strategy for the city's downtown. The city began charging for some of its parking spaces, which spurred employees of local businesses to use nearby free city lots, freeing up curb spaces for customers. By that point, numerous cities around the country were experimenting with Shoup's ideas. The Parking Reform Network, a nonprofit founded to advance Shoup's ideas, has documented policies in more than 3,000 cities that rely on Shoup's research. On the nonprofit's website, over 70 people — including mourners from Bogotá, Colombia; Mexico City; Istanbul; Brisbane, Australia; and elsewhere — have shared memories of Shoup and celebrated his scholarship. One of the biggest changes inspired by Shoup's work came in 2022 when Gov. Gavin Newsom signed legislation that eliminated mandatory parking requirements for most developments near mass transit across California. Newsom said the law would reduce the cost of housing while lowering climate change-inducing car trips. 'Housing solutions are also climate solutions,' Newsom said. The law took effect when Shoup was 85 years old. Shoup liked to acknowledge his later-in-life success, according to his wife, Pat Shoup. He published 'The High Cost of Free Parking' when he was 67. 'He always said it was fine to be a late bloomer if you made it to the flower show,' Pat wrote in her husband's death notice. 'He made it and left a long trail of blossoms in his wake to benefit others.' Shoup remained active following his retirement from UCLA. He continued to teach and was often seen within the Luskin School of Public Affairs building, per a remembrance published by the university. Rep. Laura Friedman (D-Glendale) marveled at Shoup's energy and how the professor continued to inspire people. Recently, she watched a crowd filled with people of all ages rapt as he gave a lecture on reforming handicap parking laws to increase access for people with disabilities. Friedman, who authored the 2022 parking law when she served in the state Legislature, said the army of Shoup adherents provided a critical mass of support as she tried to move the bill forward. 'He inspired a passion among his students and fellow academics that turned his work into a movement,' Friedman said. 'That's what was unique about him.' Shoup is survived by his wife Pat, brother Frank Shoup, his niece Allison Shoup, nephew Elliot Shoup, Elliot's wife Megan and their three children. There will be no funeral or church service, but UCLA will celebrate his life at a later date. In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to the Donald and Pat Shoup Endowed Fellowship in Urban Planning at the UCLA Luskin School or the Parking Reform Network.
