Latest news with #YannLePallec
Zawya
13 hours ago
- Business
- Zawya
African Banker at Davos - Is the ‘Africa risk premium' fact or myth?
One of the most contentious and emotionally-charged topics among African leaders and financial experts is what they consider the unfairly low ratings they receive from interna- tional credit rating agencies such as S&P, Fitch, etc. They argue that the perception of African risk is often much greater than the reality and this seeps into the ratings – making loans to Africa much more expensive – the so-called 'Africa premium'. Mamadou Toure, co-founder of Africa House, who moderated the session, ar- gued that countries in other continents with similar or lower levels of stability are rated higher than African countries. Responding, Yann Le Pallec, president of ratings agency S&P Global, said their evaluations are grounded in rigorous, data-driven methodologies. He said that ratings agencies exist to provide investors with the right informa- tion to help their decision-making. 'We do fundamental credit analy- sis, which means that we try to assess whether a country is likely to pay back its debt according to terms and con- ditions of the bonds, which are likely bought on the international market,' he explained. He pointed out that the methodolo- gies employed by ratings agencies are transparent and publicly available, which he said meant that third par- ties can verify and even replicate the model to check the conclusions ar- rived at. 'We are a pure knowledge analysis company. But it's when we compare and contrast our views with those of investors that we can understand whether we're seeing a good picture and whether we've done a good job. And that creates, day to day, an ef- fective challenge for our analysts to improve the quality of the product,' he continued. S&P Global, Le Pallec said, en- courages third parties to challenge its findings in order to ensure greater transparency and improvement. Are countries 'painted with the same brush'? Critics of the ratings agencies contend, however, that their decision-making is compromised by lack of knowledge and understanding of the unique fea- tures of African economies. They argue that ratings agencies paint all African countries with a sim- ilar brush, ignoring the differences between them. Le Pallec acknowledged these challenges, noting that the con- tinent has a 'multiplicity of economies that are very different from each other in terms of GDP growth, ease of doing business and other factors'. Lack of easily accessible data in any economy, he argued however, can itself be indicative of the country's creditwor- thiness. Attempts by African countries to take control of how they are portrayed, Le Pallec said, are welcome and will help debunk unhelpful myths. 'It is in everyone's interest to make sure that investors have got the right information, the right intelligence, so that they can make their decisions,' he suggested. Multilateral development banks must also play a greater role in channelling funds to the continent, which he says has a lot of potential. 'By 2035, 65% of the global GDP growth will be generated by emerging markets and frontier markets. The bulk of those are based in Africa. That's the opportunity we're talking about,' he stressed. Africa risk premium is real, say critics Speaking on the same panel, Ndidi Okonkwo Nwuneli, president of the ONE Campaign, stressed the critical need for Africans to take control of the narrative surrounding the continent, to counter the damaging effects of misconceptions and generalised risk assessments. She argued that Africa is often un- fairly treated as a monolithic entity, with assessments based on the continent's weakest links rather than recognising the diversity of its 54 countries. 'Every time I have the opportunity, I say I want to talk about countries. So we're not talking about Africa, but rather we are talking about Nigeria, Kenya or South Africa,' she said. Negative reporting, insufficient data and biased credit ratings, Nwuneli ar- gued, are responsible for the 'Africa risk premium', which means that Af- rican countries face higher borrowing costs than other regions. This mispricing costs African na- tions billions annually, exacerbating debt distress in countries that are already struggling, she argued. To address this, Nwuneli called for the creation of a Cost of Capital Commis- sion, using Africa's current position as G20 host to prioritise the issue on the global agenda. Akinwumi Adesina, president of the African Development Bank, is among those who have backed the creation of an African credit rating agency as an alternative to the US-based giants. Such an agency would have superior data on and insight into the continent to enable it to make better assessments of countries' fiscal positions, he told African Banker. (See page 52.) 'Some people think that it's just the African Union going to set up some agency for itself. Actually, it would be an independently-run, top-notch professional agency that provides the counterfactuals,' he explained. 'When you go to the doctor and run tests, you have the right to ask for a second opinion, don't you? Yes, so it's time to do that.' Moky Makura, of campaign group Africa No Filter, put the cost of nega- tive media stereotypes on the conti- nent at $4.2bn, but argued that the real figure could be much higher. 'It's much bigger than that but this figure is meant to get people talking. And this is an amount that can educate 12m children in Africa,' she explained. More Africans, she said, must be engaged in telling compelling stories about the continent, helping to reshape percep- tions and showcase Africa's progress and potential. The ultimate goal, she said, is to foster a more balanced and accurate global understanding of Africa. ■ Moky Makura, of campaign group Africa No Filter, put the cost of negative media stereotypes on the continent at $4.2bn. © Copyright IC Publications 2022 Provided by SyndiGate Media Inc. (
IOL News
04-06-2025
- Business
- IOL News
S&P Global Ratings maintains positive outlook for South Africa's economy
The S&P Global logo is displayed on its offices in the financial district in New York City Image: File. S&P Global Ratings has said that the outlook for the country remains positive, during its South Africa Capital Markets Conference in Johannesburg on Wednesday. S&P global experts and industry leaders, engaged in dynamic panel discussions during the conference. Yann Le Pallec, President of S&P Global Ratings, highlighted Africa's potential for growth, particularly in sub-Saharan regions. He projected that the region's real GDP is expected to increase by 4% over the next two years, outperforming advanced economies that are anticipated to grow by a mere 1.5%. "Despite issues faced in African economies, there is potential to attract investment from all regions,' Le Pallec said, emphasising the continent's pivotal role in the global energy transition. Le Pallec addressed the pressing need for enhanced electricity access across Africa, noting that approximately 600 million people in sub-Saharan Africa currently lack reliable power. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ He mentioned the plans from both the World Bank and the African Development Bank to provide electricity access to 300 million individuals, demonstrating a commitment to improving infrastructure. G20 and the economy As experts convened on a panel to deliberate on the geopolitical climate and the implications of tariff policies, Danelee Masia, a senior economist at Deutsche Bank, underscored the need for South Africa to navigate the evolving global order. She stated that South Africa's strategic alliances with Middle Eastern countries could potentially bring in foreign direct investment, which is crucial for the nation's economic landscape. Jeff Gable, the head of Macro and Fixed Income Research at Absa, echoed the importance of US participation in the upcoming G20 conference. He warned that a lack of US engagement could overshadow the efforts made in preparing for the conference and detract from the discussions on pressing global issues. Growth in South Africa In terms of South Africa's growth, Annabel Bishop, the chief economist at Investec Bank, pointed out that the South African Reserve Bank has forecasted a mere 1% economic growth. Bishop attributed recent instability in the global financial markets to uncertainty surrounding tariffs and the Government of National Unity (GNU). She expressed cautious optimism that diplomatic negotiations could potentially lead to lower tariffs later in the year. "While we saw a pause and lot of negotiations on tariffs made from around the world, including South Africa's one where Ramaphosa and SA's team went to the White House and spoke about trade and other issues, it is key to understand that this process could allow for much lower tariffs later in the year," Bishop added. Bishop further said, "We have our forecast at 1.3% it could possibly drop to 1.2 or 1.1%,but we are optimistic that this year will see almost double of what economic growth came out of last year." Ravi Bhatia, a director and lead analyst at S&P Global Ratings, reiterated a positive outlook for South Africa, noting the nation's structural strengths and the ability to maintain a low inflation environment. Bhatia said, "That facilitates from a government point of view that it is relatively is easy to fund the deficit through domestic funding making for less exposure to foreign exchange risk and still have room on raising external financing. SA is fairly new on raising money from multilaterals, and they are working on that so what we seeing is they are able to finance. The GNU is good in that it survived despite many disagreements. Having other parties there alongside the ANC, it is putting reformist pressure on the ANC to push reforms at a faster rate. It has been impressive that despite the disagreements over the Budget, the GNU held together." "What we have not seen that it is delivering higher growth and that is where there is a bit of a disconnect. We still have around 1.5% in the forecast period we are looking at, it is not great because it means incomes in SA are flat. Efforts have been made in the fiscal space and a push towards fiscal consolidation. To unlock finance, the IMF (International Monetary Fund) will push the SA government to push their structural reforms and getting the SOEs (state-owned enterprises) in order. The macro story is quite good; the checks and balances between the Treasury and SARB are sound and not something the IMF will focus on. It will be more on structural reforms, SOEs and labour market reforms as well as higher growth, Bhatia said.
