a day ago
Christopher Dummitt: Canada's long-standing tradition of sweeping its British roots under the rug
Article content
As we toured through buildings from this historic village, each devoted to a different artisanal skill or aspect of life, the kids seemed perplexed. There was a blacksmith, a tinsmith, a print shop, a general store, and a schoolhouse. Each interpreter walked the kids through the seemingly primitive, yet amazingly complex, sets of skills and networks of knowledge that were represented at each station.
Article content
The tinsmith used eleven different specific tools as he made a star-shaped Christmas decoration. He pointed out that the tin he used would have had to be imported from Britain. The printing press was an amazing invention that transformed 16th century Europe and the societies that emerged out of it. It needed expensive skilled labour and was constantly being updated and modified to be more efficient. Tied to the market and democracy, the printing press was part of what made this rustic little village (and the real ones it is meant to represent) part of a wider network of ideas and things. There were also weavers using complex machines that were, in some ways, the first computers.
Article content
Article content
And yet, at several points, as the interpreters turned to the kids for questions, one kept surfacing: 'Did the Indigenous make this?' Because they must have, right?
Article content
To which the interpreters replied, 'No,' and moved on.
Article content
So much of the social studies curriculum in Ontario tells kids to center Indigenous peoples and knowledge. How could these amazing things not come from Indigenous cultures?
Article content
It was at the replica church that things really got weird, though. There was no interpreter in this building, and so the kids were happy to run amok. One child walked up to the front and — reaching for the closest thing in his mind he could think of that might be a prayer — in mock, sonorous tones, he recited a land acknowledgment, which he knew by heart. Of course, he did.
Article content
Canadian schools got rid of the Lord's prayer a generation ago. It didn't fit with a modern diverse Canada. It has been replaced by land acknowledgments.
Article content
There was a time, not too long ago, when the school system didn't operate this way — when Indigenous history and contemporary concerns were not a major focus. There has been a lot of progress to rethink how we approach the Canadian past.
Article content
But there's also the Canadian tradition of turning a good thing into a stupid mess.
Article content
These young children know that they need to respect Indigenous cultures — and know that these cultures were sophisticated and fascinating. That's what they've learned.
Article content
But what they don't have are the lessons from an earlier time that would balance out this new appreciation. Instead, their lessons speak against an earlier way of thinking about the country. Without that earlier knowledge, what these kids are getting is the now off-balanced focus on reconciliation, relationships to the land, and inclusivity.
Article content
What they lack is the broader story of the settler societies that created Canada — about the dynamism of centuries of progress from the Scientific Revolution to the Enlightenment to the creation of modern forms of democracy, liberalism, and parliamentary institutions. Yet, this isn't part of the elementary curriculum.
Article content
This isn't the fault of any individual teacher (many of whom are wonderful).
Article content
