Jaws at 50: the most significant piece of negative publicity sharks have ever received
great white shark
on the east coast of the United States.
Previously unknown in Irish waters, there are now confirmed records of this species as far north as the Bay of Biscay but reports around Ireland and the UK are confined to anecdotal sightings. Ireland is a globally recognised hotspot for other shark species, such as the basking shark, porbeagle and tope shark, but great whites have yet to be formally recorded here. Found throughout the world's oceans, great white sharks were historically common throughout the Mediterranean before overfishing caused major declines. In 2024, a team of scientists embarked on a major survey with the goal of documenting the presence of the great white shark in Irish waters. Dr Nick Payne of Trinity College Dublin, who led the expedition, said he was optimistic about the team's chances of confirming its presence off the Irish coast.
I have never seen a great white shark but I have had an encounter with the largest fish in the Atlantic Ocean. I was sailing off the coast of Mayo when a pair of fins appeared in the water beside the boat, moving slowly on the surface. As the fins came closer, I realised that they were both part of the same animal, a basking shark. It moved sinuously across the sea with a large open mouth capturing the rich harvest of plankton. Basking sharks were once plentiful around the Irish coastline, migrating into our waters in summer and disappearing in the winter. The location of my sighting was not far from Keem Bay at the very western tip of Achill Island. This is a cliff-bound cove with a beautiful sandy beach at its head. Throughout the early 20th century this was the location for the capture and killing of basking sharks and large quantities of the valuable shark oil were exported to England.
[
Eye on Nature: If bees can't see red, why is one drawn to this red poppy?
Opens in new window
]
A shortage of fuel after second World War led to an increasing market for shark oil for use in certain industrial products. The slow-moving basking sharks swam into the bay to feed on dense swarms of plankton near the sea surface. Here they became entangled in nets set by the islanders who then launched their lightweight curraghs and killed the struggling fish, stabbing them with scythe blades attached to long poles. Over a 30-year period up to the 1970s more than 12,000 basking sharks were landed on Achill – an average of at least 400 fish per year. Not surprisingly, catches declined markedly towards the end of this period and, with the availability of alternative mineral oils, the market for shark oil disappeared, allowing the few remaining animals to survive. Today, basking sharks are back, their population slowly recovering from this classic example of overfishing.
READ MORE
Other shark species are not immune from the pressures of overfishing either. These species fill ecological niches that are important in maintaining a balance within the ecosystem. Their removal can result in cascading effects that have a negative effect on marine biodiversity right down through the food chain. Irish waters are known to contain 71 cartilaginous fish species (sharks and rays), over half of the European list. Of these, 58 were assessed using the latest international categories in the Irish Red List. Six species were considered to be critically endangered – Portuguese dogfish, common (blue) skate, flapper skate, porbeagle shark, white skate and angel shark. For example, numbers of angel sharks recorded in tagging programmes show a decline of over 90 per cent since the 1980s. A further five species were assessed as endangered while six more species were rated as vulnerable. Sharks tend to grow slowly and produce small numbers of young each year, which can make them particularly vulnerable.
[
How plans for new Guggenheim museum have triggered major biodiversity row in Spain
Opens in new window
]
While there are no longer any vessels fishing commercially for threatened cartilaginous fish in Irish waters, some are taken as by-catch in other fisheries, involving both Irish and non-Irish boats. Ireland is not unique in this as, since 1970, the global abundance of sharks and rays has declined by 71 per cent owing to an 18-fold increase in relative fishing pressure. Sharks could use some good PR to encourage better protection and recovery of the threatened species.
Richard Nairn is an ecologist and writer. His latest book is Future Wild: Nature Restoration in Ireland
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
14 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ireland has potential to become global leader in femtech, report says
Ireland could become a global leader in technology, research and innovation focused on women's health, if the right supports are put in the place, a new report has said. The new report, Femtech in Ireland: The Case for Prioritising Women's Health Research and Innovation, is calling on the Government to prioritise the development of femtech in Ireland, by offering greater supports for femtech research and start-ups, and integrate femtech into national health innovation strategies. Ireland has a strong background in medtech, digital health and pharmaceuticals, but femtech is underdeveloped and underfunded, despite women making up half the population. The report is seeking focused funding calls for women's health research and innovation through State agencies, specific funding to commercialise that research, and the establishment of a femtech lab in a healthcare setting with a fast access to clinicliniciansients, data and a test-bed. READ MORE It s also encouraging researchers, clinicians and academics to investigate conditions that affect women only, differently and disproportionately, highlighting the need for the inclusion of sex and gender analysis in research design. The report, which was produced by Health Innovation Hub Ireland (HIHI), and the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at University College Cork (UCC), says improving support for women's health innovation and entrepreneurship could not only address health inequities, but also offer additional economic potential for Ireland, while also strengthening Ireland's life sciences and technology sectors. 'We need to invest in women's health – not just for equality, but because it's smart research, healthcare, and smart economics. There is a real buzz in the femtech innovation sector in Ireland today, with new ideas and start-ups being developed throughout the country,', said Dr Tanya Mulcahy, Director of HIHI and founder of FemTech Ireland. 'We've supported many of them through HIHI, enabling access to clinicians, patients and researchers. It's a sector that is attracting female founders, and provides a new avenue for young researchers, but it's a sector that needs more support- this report is our call to action.' The femtech sector itself is expected to be worth more than $97 billion by 2030, while closing the women's health gap could give the global economy a $1 trillion boost each year by 2040. It could also help unlock new medical treatments and interventions for the wider population. The sector could also encourage more woman founders into the start-up sector, with more than 75 per cent of femtech companies having a woman founder. Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill said the report was an important step toward better care for women across Ireland. 'It supports the work we're already doing through the Women's Health Taskforce and highlights how innovation can help us go even further.' The report was also welcomed by Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment Peter Burke. Ireland's first programme to support innovation in women's health, Femtech@HIHI, was launched two years ago. It has now supported more than 30 Irish start-ups that developing everything from wearable tech to track menopause symptoms, to smarter devices for pelvic health and fertility, all aimed at supporting women's health. 'We are witnessing extraordinary advances in healthcare technology and innovation,' said Professor John R Higgins, principal investigator of Health Innovation Hub Ireland and Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University College Cork and Cork University Maternity Hospital. 'In women's health however, a long-standing gap in research has meant that these innovations have not always translated into meaningful solutions. This gap in evidence directly impacts the development of technologies. Now is the time to bridge that divide – with focused funding, targeted research, and innovation supports.'
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Goliath's Curse: Powerful if uneven portrait of societal collapse sings the praises of Irish citizens' assembly
Goliath's Curse: The History and Future of Societal Collapse Author : Luke Kemp ISBN-13 : 978-0241741238 Publisher : Viking Guideline Price : £25 'A pin in the hands of a child,' James Connolly once told his fellow Irish republicans, 'might pierce the heart of a giant.' This was Connolly's version of David and Goliath, the biblical story about a hulking Philistine warrior killed by an Israelite shepherd boy's slingshot. Even the most arrogant and intimidating colossus, in other words, may be more vulnerable than they look. According to Luke Kemp's learned, provocative and deeply unsettling book about how societies come crashing down, today's equivalent of Goliath is staring us in the mirror. Our current civilisation is more complex, sophisticated and interconnected than any the world has ever seen. That is precisely why a single, well-aimed blow at one of its vital organs could have devastating consequences. 'Once you pull on the thread of collapse, the entire tapestry of history begins to unravel,' Kemp warns in his typically melodramatic introduction. 'The darker angels of our nature are flying us towards evolutionary suicide.' READ MORE These may be bold claims, but Kemp is certainly well qualified to make them. The young Australian is a research affiliate at Cambridge University 's Centre for the Study of Existential Risk (CSER), created in 2012 to work out how humanity can avoid various dystopian futures. Climate change , nuclear weapons , AI -driven robots and a bioengineered pandemic are all obvious threats on CSER's radar screen. Above all, however, Kemp and his colleagues want to identify the root weaknesses that result in societies being destroyed by their challenges rather than overcoming them. Goliath's Curse is a project with its academic roots fully on show. Copious maps, diagrams and statistical data underpin Kemp's analysis of 324 case studies, stretching roughly 4,000 years from the Bronze Age empires to the disintegration of Somalia. He includes potted histories of once-mighty regimes that eventually bit the dust, most notably ancient Rome, Mesoamerica's Aztecs and multiple Chinese dynasties. Many famous thinkers have put forward theories on this subject, but CSER's research can apparently prove most of them wrong. To take just one example, Kemp vigorously disputes Thomas Hobbes's dictum that life in a community without strong rulers will always be 'nasty, brutish and short'. By contrast, the most recent archaeological evidence suggests that even our hunter-gatherer ancestors co-operated well and were not innately violent. Instead, Kemp points his finger at a different culprit. Inequality, he declares, is the 'constant variable' or Achilles' heel that sooner or later causes all Goliaths to buckle. If people stop believing they are 'all in it together', the upshot will be a game of thrones that nobody actually wins. Whether it's Mayan cities or west African kingdoms, Kemp argues, the pattern is much the same. Goliaths flourish for a while before becoming victims of their own success, with prosperity leading to status competition, fighting over resources and 'state capture by private elites'. When drought, disease or an invasion comes along, their disillusioned citizens are unable to pull together and see it off. By now, it is obvious why Kemp thinks our Goliath's alarm systems should be flashing red. The 21st century's defining characteristics so far are social fragmentation, economic insecurity, attacks on democracy and declining faith in public institutions. No wonder that our response to looming catastrophes such as global warming can often make a rabbit caught in the headlights look decisive. [ From the archive: Ireland 'one of world's best five places' to survive global societal collapse Opens in new window ] As if Kemp's readers weren't nervous enough already, he compares civilisation to a badly designed ladder whose rungs break away once they have been climbed. Today's global Goliath has now reached such dizzying heights that any slip could be fatal. 'If we were hit by a plague like the Black Death,' he speculates, 'we would be likely to fall apart in a way that medieval Europe did not.' Unfortunately, Kemp's overblown conclusion suggests he is better at diagnosing Goliath's problems than prescribing solutions. Stretching his analogy to breaking point, he urges us to become Davids instead and slay the giant while there is time to replace him with a superior model. 'Open democracy' is Kemp's silver bullet, with Ireland's citizens' assembly on abortion cited as an example of how more inclusive decision-making can produce better laws. He also calls on voters to elect leaders who will scrap nuclear weapons, tech monopolies and fossil fuel use in an epilogue with the pithy subheading: 'Don't Be a Dick.' It's impeccably worthy, but far too vague to inspire much confidence. All this, to be fair, is a simplification of Kemp's sprawling 450-page narrative which contains lengthy diversions on warfare, technology, colonisation and other related issues. Goliath's Curse clearly belongs to the 'great unifying theory' genre that has produced international best-sellers such as Malcolm Gladwell's The Tipping Point and Yuval Noah Harari's Sapiens. It may lack their widespread appeal, however, since Kemp is no great prose stylist and his didactic tone has a wearying effect. Ironically enough, this feels like a Goliath of a book – exceptionally powerful, undeniably impressive but occasionally just a little too sure of itself.
Irish Times
3 days ago
- Irish Times
Liver cancer: ‘The saddest part is that most of the cases are preventable'
Liver cancer kills more than 700,000 people each year. However, three in five cases could be prevented, according to a comprehensive analysis published in the journal Lancet. The research found that prevention could be accomplished by addressing the disease's major causes – hepatitis B, hepatitis C, alcohol -associated liver disease and liver disease linked to metabolic risk factors such as obesity . With nearly 900,000 new cases globally each year, liver cancer is the sixth most common cancer and the third leading cause of death from cancer. If cases continue to rise at the current rate, the number of new annual diagnoses will almost double, rising to 1.5 million globally in 2050, the study predicted. There are two broad categories of liver cancer – primary liver cancer and metastatic (secondary) liver cancer. About 370 people are diagnosed with primary liver cancer each year in Ireland. It is twice as common in men than it is in women. READ MORE The researchers estimated that liver disease from alcohol use and metabolic dysfunction together would account for nearly a third of new liver cancer cases by 2050. The findings align with what liver specialists have seen in their clinics for years. 'Liver cancer is common. It causes immense suffering and death, and the saddest part for me as a physician is that most of the cases are preventable,' said Dr Brian Lee, an associate professor of medicine, who was not involved in the study. Improved screening, vaccination and treatment in recent years have helped stem viral hepatitis. But the threat of liver cancer from heavy alcohol use and metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease, or MASLD, formerly known as nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, 'has been underrecognised and underestimated,' said Dr Ahmed Kaseb, a professor of gastrointestinal medical oncology. A vast majority of liver cancers arise in people with cirrhosis, says Dr Hashem El-Serag, chairman of the department of medicine at Baylor College of Medicine in Texas and one of the authors of the new study. Cirrhosis, or advanced and largely irreversible scarring of the liver, damages healthy tissue and prevents the organ from working normally. [ Doctors share 19 tips for looking after your liver: Don't drink alcohol every day, but do drink coffee, and lose weight Opens in new window ] The hepatitis B and C viruses cause inflammation that, if left untreated, can scar and damage the liver, potentially leading to cirrhosis. And both alcohol and metabolic dysfunction lead to abnormal deposits of fat in the liver, which can also result in inflammation. Dr Lee says the accumulation of fat and inflammation acts as a 'highway' to liver scarring, which in turn can injure DNA and lead to cancer. 'There could be multiple ramps to get on to that highway,' he said. The new paper found that the share of liver cancers resulting from hepatitis B and hepatitis C is expected to drop to 63 per cent in 2050, from 68 per cent in 2022. But the burden of liver cancers resulting from alcohol and MASLD is expected to grow. An estimated four in 10 adults worldwide have MASLD, a condition in which fat builds up in the liver. Risk factors include obesity and Type 2 diabetes. A subset of patients with MASLD will go on to develop an advanced form called metabolic dysfunction-associated steatohepatitis, or MASH, which has been described as a silent killer because it can progress to cirrhosis and liver cancer without being noticed. Current guidance recommends monitoring for liver cancers in patients who have a history of viral hepatitis or established cirrhosis. Patients with MASH typically don't meet that criteria, Dr Kaseb said, but they could have liver scarring without symptoms, and nobody would know. That's why screening for liver disease needs to begin at the primary care level, where cases can easily go undetected, said Dr Mary Rinella, a hepatologist at University of Chicago Medicine and the lead author of guidelines for the management of MASLD. She recommended that doctors use a metric called the Fib-4, which uses routine blood test results to estimate the amount of liver scarring, to screen high-risk patients. These include people who have Type 2 diabetes or obesity with at least one other metabolic risk factor, such as high cholesterol. [ 'A serious threat to public health': Doctors warn about delay to mandatory alcohol health labels Opens in new window ] MASLD is reversible with lifestyle changes, including a healthy diet and increased exercise, and weight-loss drugs have recently been shown to be effective at reversing scarring as well. 'If you stop the reason or the impetus for scarring and injury in the liver, then you're going to have less impetus for the development of cancer,' says Dr Rinella. There is no national liver cancer screening programme in Ireland, so it's important to talk to your doctor about surveillance if you have a liver disease such as hepatitis B or C, genetic haemochromatosis or liver cirrhosis, as the risk of liver cancer is higher. [ Parents facilitating a 16-year-old's 'prinks' is a sign of our weird relationship with alcohol Opens in new window ] Alcohol-related liver disease is also on the rise. In research published in July , Dr Lee and his colleagues showed that the risk of alcohol-related liver disease among heavy drinkers (at least 10 drinks per week for women and 15 for men) in the United States more than doubled between 1999 and 2020, despite similar alcohol use over that period. That suggests that heavy drinkers today may be more sensitive to the effects of alcohol on the liver than those in the past, Dr Lee said. In Ireland, while average alcohol consumption per adult has shown signs of falling, the incidence of binge drinking continues to be pronounced. Drinking heavily and having a metabolic condition such as obesity can independently damage the liver, but patients who fall in both categories are at an especially high risk. These trends are likely to continue. 'Alcohol use is increasing,' says Dr Rinella. 'Obesity and diabetes are increasing.' 'I expect that we're going to continue to see a high burden of liver disease,' she added. – This article originally appeared in the New York Times
