Treaty Negotiations Minister says settlements with iwi can't be 'open ended'
Photo:
RNZ / Marika Khabazi
The Treaty Negotiations Minister says money and time spent on progressing settlements with iwi can't be "open ended".
Paul Goldsmith told reporters the process "can't be as long as forever."
It comes as NZ First is drafting a member's bill forcing Aotearoa's largest iwi, Ngāpuhi, into a
single commercial settlement
.
Last week Goldsmith said it was the government's preference to have one commercial settlement for Ngāpuhi, and on Tuesday said he wouldn't put a timeline on concluding that.
He wouldn't say whether there should be a limit on the amount of money or time spent on reaching a settlement, but said he wasn't comfortable spending as much or as long as it took.
"I don't think it can be open ended. Can't be as long as forever.
"We do need to make progress at some time, but we haven't put an exact date."
When asked if it would be within the political term, he said he wouldn't make any commitments around this, "it's only 18 months".
"There's a tension between - we don't want to impose an unrealistic deadline, but likewise, we don't want things to go on past 2040 when we want to be celebrating our bicentenary.
"We're encouraging proper movement as best we can."
He said currently the various hapū of Ngāpuhi were trying to get an agreement around a mandate to negotiate, "and we're still at that stage."
'Peeni Henare.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
Labour's Peeni Henare - of Ngāpuhi descent - said Goldsmith's comments had "fiscal envelope tones", referring to 1994 when the then government suggested capping the amount allocated for settlements.
"It's certainly got fiscal envelope tones to it, and that's what they tried to do to our people in the 1990s.
"I suspect that while it might not be an official policy of this government, it's front of mind in terms of the expenditure on settlement."
In regards to Jones' potential Members Bill, Henare said "Ngāpuhi is unique".
"Whatever Mr Jones thinks is going to bring Ngāpuhi to the table, he is misguided if he thinks forcing a bill to bring Ngāpuhi to the table is going to do that.
"I think it's going to be a dismal failure by him and this government."
He said it would go against the "good faith" provisions that had seen settlements conclude.
"If they do that, I think they're setting a really bad precedence."
Labour leader Chris Hipkins.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
Labour leader Chris Hipkins also said he didn't think sending "veiled threats" was useful. He said everyone needed to continue negotiating in good faith.
Hipkins said the National government's "hostile position" towards Māori was likely to make Treaty settlements in the next few years "very, very difficult to achieve".
He referenced the discussion around the "agree to disagree" clause, which he called an "elegant way out of the issue" of determining who was sovereign.
In 2023, the previous Labour government initialled a Deed of Settlement with East Coast iwi Te Whānau a Apanui which included an "agree-to-disagree" clause where the iwi maintained it was a sovereign nation while the Crown also maintained its own sovereignty.
Goldsmith said that was
not something the government was comfortable acknowledging
and that the Crown was sovereign and represented the "democratic will" of New Zealand.
RNZ has contacted Ngāpuhi for comment.
The NZ Herald reported Ngāti Hine leader Pita Tipene had ruled out a settlement with the current government following Goldsmith's comments.
Hipkins said if the government walked away from that, it would mean debates around sovereignty would again be "front and centre" of the Treaty settlement debate, which wasn't helpful for the country moving forward.
Finance Minister Nicola Willis.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
The Finance Minister Nicola Willis confirmed the government had a goal of progressing and settling any outstanding Treaty claims.
"What we need to do is keep in good faith progressing our desire to negotiate."
She said it was up to Ngāpuhi to decide that they too wanted to do that.
"Settlements have proven to be a really effective tool for advancing relationships between iwi and the crown.
"I would say that any leader needs to be responsive to the needs of their people. Leaders change, but the needs of people don't tend to."
The Greens co-leader Marama Davidson said the Treaty of Waitangi was not something to be settled, and wasn't about "ending something", it was an "enduring relationship".
"It needs to go on for as long as it needs to go on for."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 minutes ago
- RNZ News
New scheme aims to cut out supermarkets, source local produce
A new scheme aims to cut out supermarkets and get fruit and vegetables grown next door or down the road onto people's plates. A group of agencies in Wellington is working to produce direct from local growers and create an online platform where shoppers can bypass big mark-ups and eat seasonally too. The process starts at lush urban farm Kaicyle, tucked down a side street in inner-city Wellington. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Silverbeet, celery, baby carrots and spring onions line the garden surrounded by the industrial warehouses and carparks of Newtown. "It's winter so it's slow season but we grow all sorts of different things, but we try to grow things that people want," co-manager Ellie Clayton told Checkpoint. "At the moment we've got heaps of silverbeet, and just a great, cheap staple for people." The farm is one of several in the Wellington region participating in the pilot, co-ordinated by Wesley Community Action, Kaibosh food rescue and Health NZ - which aims to put local produce on people's plates at an affordable price. Growers in Kāpiti and Horowhenua are also part of the scheme. "It's great for local growers because it means we can just harvest what's needed and what's been ordered, and then we can get this really great fresh Kai that we are harvesting on a Thursday morning, and people can pick it up on the Thursday morning, and cook it for Thursday dinner," Clayton said. Co-manager Ellie Clayton. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Kaibosh Food Rescue Wellington city operations manager Luke Campbell said his team were "the wheels" of the operation. Drivers from food-rescue charity pick up the orders as part of their regular routes and deliver them to packing hubs around Wellington, the Wairarapa and the Kāpiti Coast. "We've got a mission of zero food poverty and zero food waste, and so anyway we can help facilitate that, that's what we do. "So connecting food, with the people that need it. Nobody wants to grow food or sell food or be part of food and see it go in the bin." Kaibosh Food Rescue Wellington city operations manager Luke Campbell. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Ten minutes away, volunteers are busy filling boxes of fresh fruit and vegetables. Wesley Community Action's co-ops co-ordinator Cory Hope was rummaging through some of the days offerings. "These are daikon radishes, so this is something we try to introduce because they actually grow really well, they're really healthy, and they're really versatile. "You can cook them, you can have them raw, I like to make a pickle out of them. [We've got] your classic kiwi fruit from up north, kūmara from up north as well." Hope said the social agency already had a co-op scheme which provided $15 boxes of produce to participants, and about six tonnes of produce was delivered to 1100 families each week. The new pilot - jointly organised by Wesley Community Action and Health NZ - allows shoppers to hop online, on a platform called Coshop, and buy what they want. Wesley Community Action's co-ops co-ordinator Cory Hope. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Local growers set their own prices, but Hope said the boxes run cheaper than the supermarkets with packing done by volunteers, and distribution done by the food rescue. "Most of the mahi is done by our fantastic volunteers, and we only charge a levy to cover administrative and freight costs. "That's it, there's no profit involved at all. So generally we run about 15 - 25 percent cheaper than the supermarkets," Hope said. According to Ministry of Health data from 2023-2024, one in four children live in households where food has run out often or sometimes. One in two Pacific and one in three Māori children were living in households where food ran out sometimes. 26 percent of children lived in households where they often or sometimes ate less because of lack of money. Hope said regional food resilience needed a boost - but it was hard for local growers to build a market channel for their goods, and currently difficult for people to access local produce at an affordable price. "They have an income, you might have a job, but it's tricky to make ends meet each week. So buying affordable access to fresh healthy kai, hopefully that will leave a few more dollars in people's pockets to spend on bills or something else." The pilot finishes at the end of August, but Hope said the goal was for the model to be replicated and expanded throughout the city. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
33 minutes ago
- RNZ News
The Panel with Ali Jones and Simon Pound Part 1
Tonight, on The Panel, Wallace Chapman is joined by panellists Ali Jones and Simon Pound. First up, thousands of secondary school teachers walked off the job today in a dispute over pay. The Panel talks to Paul Stevens, a teacher at Auckland's Rangitoto College and a PPTA representative. Then they hear from independant Cameron Bagrie about the Reserve Banks decision to whack 25 points off the OCR - what does it mean for mortgage holders looking to refix? To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Government 'revising' pay offer to teachers but says union must compromise too
Teachers strike outside Parliament on Wednesday. Photo: JOHN GERRITSEN / RNZ The government is revising its pay offer for secondary teachers, following a nationwide strike, but the union would need to compromise too, Public Service Commissioner Sir Brian Roche said. Thousands of members of the Post Primary Teachers Association (PPTA) walked off the job to protest their pay talks , forcing the closure of many secondary schools. Teachers on picket lines told RNZ the government's offer of a one percent pay rise every year for three years was "despicable, insulting and terrible". The Public Service Commission, which was overseeing the government's side of the pay talks, had been at pains to note that teachers in the first 10 years of their career get annual pay rises of about 13 percent a year as they progress up the pay scale. But teachers said most of them were at the top of the scale and the one percent increases would be all they received. Roche told RNZ in a statement: "This was always going to be a difficult bargaining round - the strike is evidence of that. Now that has happened, we have to find a way forward - we owe that to the students, parents and teachers." "Our initial offer clearly hasn't hit the mark, and we are doing work on a revised offer." He said the union's claim was not realistic. "The PPTA's current set of claims would cost taxpayers $1.7 billion over four years. That's equivalent to an extra $67,000 for every full-time secondary teacher. It's unaffordable, unreasonable and unrealistic. Sir Brian Roche is the Public Service Commissioner. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone "Bargaining is about compromise and to date, and somewhat regrettably, the PPTA has refused to offer any real compromise on these claims. The government is committed to working with the PPTA to get a resolution." Education Minister, Erica Stanford, said the union should have called today's strike off because it had agreed to further talks. But PPTA president Chris Abercrombie said: "The government knew it had an opportunity yesterday to make a reasonable offer to us which could have encouraged us to reconsider our action. Unfortunately, no such offer was forthcoming." Meanwhile, on picket lines, teachers said they were frustrated that they had to strike to try to force a better offer from the government. Wellington teacher Catharine de Montalk said she and her colleagues would be losing money if they accepted the offer. "I don't particularly want to be here. I feel like since my career started 20 years ago that I've been doing this every single pay round and it does get tired, it does get old but one percent is actually the lowest... it is an insult," she said. A teacher outside Parliament during the strike. Photo: RNZ / John Gerritsen Outside Parliament, maths teacher Jennifer Crisp said the government's offer was not reasonable. "We think that's entirely incorrect. It's not a reasonable offer in this economy. Not when MPs have been given more than double that," she said. In Christchurch, teacher Richard Allen said the government's offer was never going to fly. "The knew that that wasn't going to be acceptable right from the start and so it's a shame that it's come to this. To be fair we all want to teach so give us something more reasonable that we can work towards," he said. Several Wellington commuters said they supported the striking teachers. Christian Shaw said the picket at Wellington Railway Station prompted him to do some online research which showed politicians were getting much better annual pay rises than what teachers were being offered. "They're willing to line their own pockets, more than happy, year after year, but they don't want to give our teachers, our nurses... they just cut pay equity which is so important to so many people and they're just taking the absolute piss," he said. His mate Jack Dyer said teachers were not paid enough - and he'd know, having abandoned the profession because of the pay rates for new teachers. "I studied to become a teacher. I got my diploma of teaching for secondary schools and the starting rate there is just atrocious. Like after four years of study, a bachelor's and a diploma, you're coming out and making less than the median wage in Wellington, which is just bizarre," he said. Meanwhile, primary school teachers, support staff and principals belonging to the Educational Institute, Te Riu Roa, were holding stop-work meetings this week and next to discuss their pay talks. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
