Former South Carolina clerk in Murdaugh murder trial arrested on multiple felonies in 2 counties
South Carolina authorities on Wednesday morning charged Becky Hill, the former Colleton County court clerk who presided over the Alex Murdaugh murder trial, with multiple felonies in connection with her conduct surrounding the case.
The South Carolina Law Enforcement Division on Wednesday afternoon announced that Hill, 57, is facing two counts of misconduct and obstruction of justice charges in Colleton County while her perjury charge is filed in Richland County.
Advertisement
Murdaugh's attorney, Dick Harpootlian, said on 'The Story with Martha MacCallum' that he believes the charges will lead to a new trial.
Charging documents state that the crimes stem from a January 2024 hearing in the South Carolina Supreme Court, when Justice Jean Toal ruled that a new trial was not necessary for Murdaugh, who was convicted in the June 2021 murders of his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, on his family hunting estate.
Murdaugh had requested the new hearing based on allegations of jury tampering surrounding Hill, which Murdaugh's defense team had argued warranted a new trial.
Charging documents state that when Toal asked Hill, 'Did you allow anyone from the press to view sealed exhibits?' Hill responded, 'No, ma'am,' which is apparently inconsistent with evidence obtained by authorities.
Advertisement
The State Ethics Commission last year accused Hill of using her official position as Colleton County clerk for financial gain, specifically to promote her book about the Murdaugh case, part of which she admitted to and apologized for plagiarizing.
The SLED charging documents released Wednesday also accuse Hill of promoting her book on social media.
'We are aware of the charges filed against Becky Hill, and while these developments are serious, they are not surprising,' Dick Harpootlian and Jim Griffin, Murdaugh's defense attorneys, told Fox News Digital in a statement.
Former Colleton County court clerk Becky Hill, 57, was charged with multiple felonies Wednesday in connection with the Alex Murdaugh murder trial.
AP
Advertisement
'We have long raised our concerns about her conduct during and after the trial and this arrest further underscores the need to protect the integrity of the judicial process. Every defendant is entitled to a fair and impartial trial and we look forward to Alex Murdaugh finally getting that fair treatment.'
Hill was previously accused of sending herself nearly $10,000 in federal bonuses in the form of child support payments, according to a notice of hearing.
She used federal funds to give food and gifts to court employees, including 'Easter Goodies,' Mother's and Father's Day gifts, and Valentine's Day gifts; paint supplies; flowers and decor; various meals for herself; office furniture; dog food, dog bones and a dog bed, among other items.
SLED charging documents make note of the bonus payments.
Advertisement
Of 12 total jurors who found Murdaugh guilty in 2023, 11 said Hill did not influence their decisions.
Hill faces two counts of misconduct and obstruction in Colleton County, though her perjury charge has been filed in Richland County.
TNS
One said he heard the clerk make comments about watching Murdaugh's body language but said her words did not influence his verdict.
South Carolina attorney Eric Bland, who represented several victims of Murdaugh's financial crimes, said he 'used to think that there was very little chance that our South Carolina Supreme Court would reverse former Chief Justice Jean Toal's decision in February 2024 when she denied Alex Murdaugh a new trial on his double murder conviction because of Becky Hill alleged jury interference.'
'I thought that if he was to get any relief, it would come after he exhausted his state court appeals and it would be on the federal level,' Bland said in a Wednesday post on X.
'According to the State Paper, the perjury charge arises out of her testimony that she gave in the February 2024 hearing in front of Justice Toal. I think this further complicates the situation and increases the chances that he will get a reversal and a new trial. It still will come down to whether the federal standard for alleged jury tampering should have been applied by Justice Toal or she was correct in applying the state standard.'
Myra Crosby, a dismissed juror in the Murdaugh murder trial, also known as the 'egg juror' after she apparently asked to collect a dozen eggs from the jury room before leaving, told Fox News her belief that 'Hill finally being held accountable for the atrocities she did during this trial is a good start.'
Advertisement
'I am hopeful but not confident that the State will do the right thing,' she said in a Wednesday statement.
'If the state believes in their case they should not have a problem giving Alex Murdaugh another trial. One where they don't have a tainted verdict. I would think that [the] 6th Amendment being upheld would be more important than protecting a verdict. It remains to be seen as to what will happen but I am praying that I can have a justice system that I can believe in again rather than a corrupt good ol boy system.'
She further suggested that juries on future cases be sequestered and instructed not to speak with anyone, including court officials like Hill.
Advertisement
'Not everyone has been a juror and, when questioned by a court official, knows that it is wrong. I certainly didn't,' she said.
The former court clerk, who held her position for about four years, resigned in March following allegations of jury tampering in the Murdaugh trial but maintained that her decision to leave office was not the result of her conduct during the double murder trial.
'Another significant impact in our clerk's office was in 2023, when we had to manage one of the biggest trials in South Carolina history. Our small town came together and made everyone proud,' Hill said during a news conference at the time to announce her resignation.
Advertisement
'Managing a trial with such importance to the people of South Carolina, as well as to the national and international media interest and public scrutiny, has caused me to reflect upon decisions involving my stay in the office of the clerk of court.'
She added that her decision not to seek re-election in 2024 would allow her to 'focus on being a wife, a mother and a grandmother,' and that she wants to provide 'ample time to other Republican candidates' interested in the position of Colleton County court clerk.
Her former attorney, Justin Bamberg, who has represented victims of Murdaugh's financial crimes, said at a March news conference that Hill's decision had nothing to do with any pending investigations involving the clerk.
Fox News' Kelly Skehen contributed to this report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
State withheld records in Rio Arriba sheriff death investigation
The New Mexico Department of Public Safety took 42 days — far beyond the 15 days allowed by state statute — to release information this week about the mysterious April death of Rio Arriba County Sheriff Billy Merrifield. Forensic pathologists reported May 15 that Merrifield's Easter morning death was due to the toxic effects of fentanyl and alcohol. Other questions remained unanswered, including whether the sheriff knowingly consumed fentanyl and where he may have obtained it. In the days after Merrifield was found dead in his patrol car April 20, The New Mexican filed a public records request for related police reports and other information. At first, the Department of Public Safety refused to release additional records. Next, it described the request as burdensome, buying the agency more time. After additional complaints from The New Mexican, it released a batch of investigative reports Thursday evening — 42 days after receiving the request. Those records — 105 pages of reports, photos and other documents — show the agency's investigators have not yet determined how Merrifield ingested the fatal dose of fentanyl that caused his death, along with alcohol. The recent secrecy over Merrifield's death reflects a pattern of slow-walked disclosure of public records like state police reports and lapel camera footage, shielding public information on homicides, crashes, police shootings around the state and other public safety-related incidents. The department's initial decision to withhold police reports from the investigation — as well as documents in another unrelated case — appears to have potentially run afoul of state public records laws and a Supreme Court ruling in recent years. Department of Public Safety spokesperson Herman Lovato declined to respond to some questions about the matter in an email Friday, but he wrote each request through the New Mexico Inspection of Public Records Act 'is addressed individually' by department staff. 'If it involves an active or ongoing investigation, records that are complete will be produced if not subject to an exception, even on an active or ongoing investigation,' Lovato wrote. 'If the records have not been completed because of an active or ongoing investigation, they may be temporarily withheld until completed.' He wrote the department's process 'aligns with New Mexico Supreme Court precedent and the requirements of IPRA.' However, the department's written reason for denying a recent request for state police reports tied to Merrifield's death did not appear consistent with the process Lovato described. In response to a request from The New Mexican seeking reports on Merrifield's death, a staff member at the department's records division wrote in early May, 'this is still a active/on going investigation and I was not given the approval to release the documents as they are still being [processed].' About two weeks later, the department's reasoning changed, with a different staffer writing the request for reports was 'overburdensome.' The records were finally released Thursday after The New Mexican submitted a complaint concerning an alleged violation of the Inspection of Public Records Act to the Department of Justice — and after sending emailed questions about the records request to officials that day. Advocate: Court ruling 'clear' Christine Barber, the executive director of New Mexico Foundation for Open Government, said in an interview the department's initial denial of the request appeared to potentially violate a state Supreme Court ruling a few years ago on the specific topic of records in active law enforcement investigations. The ruling came as a result of a lawsuit brought by Andrew Jones against the Department of Public Safety, which had denied his request for records related to a state police investigation into the fatal shooting of his brother by Albuquerque police officers. Barber said the 2020 ruling was clear, holding that 'the status of a criminal investigation as 'ongoing' does not serve to exempt public records related to the investigation from inspection under [the Inspection of Public Records Act].' 'Sometimes government agencies need to be reminded of the law,' Barber said, noting past litigation between the Foundation for Open Government and the Department of Public Safety. In a 2007 settlement between the department, the foundation and several news publications — including The New Mexican — department officials agreed to provide records like incident reports within the 15-day timeline required by state law. An attorney for the government transparency group said at least one other journalist reported receiving a similar response recently when requesting the reports on Merrifield's death, but she added she did not recall other recent instances of state law enforcement agencies explicitly citing an open investigation as the reason for denying or delaying the production of records. The Department of Public Safety cited the Supreme Court's decision in a letter denying a different request from The New Mexican earlier this year for an incident report in a different death investigation. In the letter, staff acknowledged the court ruling stated exemptions to public records law 'cannot be interpreted so broadly as to withhold records simply due to the existence of an ongoing investigation.' The letter described exemptions that allow for redactions of parts of records, like names of potential subjects and informants, and ultimately stated the agency would withhold the entire report. 'Once the investigation is closed and no longer subject to these legal restrictions, certain records may become available for inspection,' the letter states. Weeks to fulfill requests While records are not usually withheld outright by the Department of Public Safety, it often takes several months to disclose reports from an investigation. In the past two years, The New Mexican has submitted at least 24 requests to the Department of Public Safety seeking reports or other documents such as the agency's written policies, lists of employees or financial data — not including requests for records like police lapel camera footage. The department provided the requested records in an average timeframe of more than two months per request. A little more than half of the requests for police reports or other documents were deemed 'broad' or 'burdensome' by the department's record staff, which allows for delays longer than 15 days. As of Friday, records have not been provided in response to two of the requests. Department of Justice spokesperson Lauren Rodriguez said attorneys from the division that investigate public records complaints had contacted the Department of Public Safety earlier this week regarding the complaint from The New Mexican. The investigators — after being assigned a complaint — usually contact the government agency in question to obtain more information, she said. They are trying to determine if there is actually noncompliance as well as whether the agency's staff knew their actions were out of compliance and whether they acted purposely in denying or delaying a records request. Apart from the complaint submitted against the Department of Public Safety by The New Mexican, the department has been the subject of one other records-related complaint so far this year to the Department of Justice, Rodriguez said. Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham's office did not respond to an email seeking comment on the Department of Public Safety's practices concerning the release of public records. Lujan Grisham stood behind the department when asked about the issue last year, with a spokesperson writing the governor 'defers to law enforcement authorities to determine when the release of information is appropriate based on the status of ongoing investigations, notification of next of kin, etc.'
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Teen accused of killing mother's boyfriend, Paulding County deputies say
The Brief Javar Summerhour, 17, is in custody after allegedly shooting and killing his mother's boyfriend, 31-year-old Anthony Brown, in Hiram, Paulding County. The incident occurred at a home on Westend Way. Summerhour is currently held in the Paulding County Jail without bond. PAULDING COUNTY, Ga. - A 17-year-old is behind bars after Paulding County deputies say he shot and killed his mother's boyfriend. What we know Deputies were called to a home on Westend Way in Hiram just after 7 p.m. Friday. That's where they found the body of 31-year-old Anthony Brown. The suspect had already fled the scene. Deputies say the suspect's family cooperated with the investigation, and as a result, 17-year-old Javar Summerhour was captured shortly after without incident. It was later revealed that Brown was dating Summerhour's mother. It's not clear what led to the gunfire. Summerhour is being held in the Paulding County Jail without bond. This is an ongoing investigation. What you can do Anyone who has any information regarding this case is encouraged to call the Paulding County Sheriff's Office Tip Line at (770) 443-3047 or send a message via the Paulding Sheriff mobile app. The Source This preliminary information has been confirmed by the Paulding County Sheriff's Office.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Cambridge mother killed in Hwy. 401 crash: OPP
A mother is dead and her child injured following a two-vehicle collision on Highway 401 in Milton Saturday, Ontario Provincial Police reported. The OPP said a section of the busy highway near James Snow Parkway is shut down while officers investigate. The crash happened on the eastbound express lanes. The OPP said it appears a 40-year-old woman from Cambridge, Ont., was driving when she struck a guard rail and was then hit by a pickup truck around 10:11 a.m. She was pronounced dead at the scene. Her six-year-old daughter was taken to hospital with minor injuries. The three people in the pickup truck weren't injured, police said. Any witnesses are being asked to contact the Mississauga OPP detachment. Traffic is being diverted in the area.
