Judge turns back challenge to MBTA housing law
Plymouth Superior Court Justice Mark Gildea granted the Healey administration's motion to dismiss the latest challenges to the 2021 law, which supporters see as a key tool to spur development of much-needed housing in more than 170 eastern Massachusetts cities and towns.
Marshfield, Middleton, Hanson, Holden, Hamilton, Duxbury, Wenham, Weston and Wrentham had each filed legal complaints against the law in recent months, contending that it should not be enforceable after the Division of Local Mandates in Auditor Diana DiZoglio's office deemed the measure an unfunded mandate.
Plaintiffs said allowing multifamily housing by right in at least one reasonably sized zone as the law requires could force them to absorb significant new infrastructure costs with no state assistance.
But Gildea concluded the possible costs are 'indirect,' which means the law is not an unfunded mandate, and that grant programs are available to help shoulder some of the burden.
'Even if [the law] was an unfunded mandate, the Municipalities have failed to allege sufficient facts concerning any anticipated amounts associated with future infrastructure costs beyond a speculative level,' Gildea wrote in a 40-page decision.
Some of the plaintiffs laid out their own issues with the law as well, such as Middleton arguing that it should not be classified as an MBTA community and therefore should not be subject to the mandatory zoning reforms.
Jason Talerman, an attorney for some of the towns, said in an email that plaintiffs are 'disappointed with the result and find the decision to be contrary to applicable law.'
Most of the 177 communities subject to the law have approved new zoning reforms, putting them in compliance, according to the Healey administration.
In January, the Supreme Judicial Court upheld the MBTA Communities Act as a constitutional law the attorney general can enforce with legal action. The high court required the Healey administration to redo the regulation-setting process.
WWLP-22News, an NBC affiliate, began broadcasting in March 1953 to provide local news, network, syndicated, and local programming to western Massachusetts. Watch the 22News Digital Edition weekdays at 4 p.m. on WWLP.com.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
2 hours ago
- Fox News
Jasmine Crockett proclaims she hates the Heritage Foundation ‘with everything in my in my body'
Rep. Jasmine Crockett, D-Texas, said that she hates The Heritage Foundation "with everything in my body" during recent remarks she gave during a panel at the Martha's Vineyard African American Film Festival. "People don't understand how terrible the Heritage Foundation is when I tell you I hate them with everything in my body," Crockett said last week during a panel conversation with MSNBC's Al Sharpton and Rep. Ayanna Pressley, D-Mass. The conversation was advertised as "an inspiring fireside chat, where they'll explore the power of joy as a political act, cultural anchor, and driving force behind justice, storytelling, and community transformation." During Crockett's remarks about hating The Heritage Foundation, Pressley interjected, saying, "Project 2025, they laid it all out," appearing to refer to a list of policy recommendations put forth by various conservative organizations, including The Heritage Foundation. Crockett then went out to blast The Heritage Foundation's work. "So, Heritage Foundation has been around for a very long time," Crockett said. "And yes, we became familiar with Project 2025. We probably became familiar a little too late, but nevertheless, other work that they did and other work that they're doing is something that we don't do. One of the things that they do is they constantly are doing polling, but besides doing polling, they do focus groups." She also voiced her disapproval of heartbeat bill legislation that makes it illegal to have an abortion after six weeks of pregnancy. The Supreme Court's June 2022 Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization decision ended the recognition that abortion is a constitutional right and gave the states the power to determine what their abortion laws would be. Crockett said The Heritage Foundation is using focus groups to change public opinion. "But what they did is, they were listening to these focus groups, and they were trying to figure out how can we get people emotionally aroused," Crockett said. She then said The Heritage Foundation is operating similar to a car dealership. "And it's just like when you think about when you're going in to buy a car knowing you don't need that car but it smells good, it look good, you get real emotional," Crockett said. "And we actually have laws in most states that allow for you to come down from the high and allow you to take that car back. So when we allow ourselves to just get very emotional, then all logic is out the window."
Fox News
3 hours ago
- Fox News
DC mayor travels to Martha's Vineyard amid Trump's federalized crime crackdown of city
Washington, D.C., Mayor Muriel Bowser is out of town Thursday after traveling to Martha's Vineyard for a family matter, Fox News has learned. The Democrat was not in the District Thursday, and a source confirmed she traveled north to the Massachusetts island vacation hot spot. The mayor was traveling for a "family commitment," according to her office. She's expected back in the city Friday. "The mayor has a family commitment and had to pick up her daughter," the mayor's office said when asked about her trip to Martha's Vineyard. "She will return to the District tomorrow." Bowser made the trip to the Massachusetts island after President Donald Trump federalized the city's police department Monday after a spate of high-profile crimes. Trump announced Monday morning during a packed press conference that he was federalizing the Metropolitan Police Department under the District of Columbia Home Rule Act, which allows the president to assume emergency control of the capital's police force for 30 days. "Our capital city has been overtaken by violent gangs and bloodthirsty criminals, roving mobs of wild youth, drugged-out maniacs and homeless people," Trump said. "And we're not going to let it happen anymore. We're not going to take it." Hundreds of National Guard troops have since converged on the nation's capital, and the FBI, the Drug Enforcement Administration, U.S. Capitol Police and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives are assisting with Trump's law and order crackdown and sweeps of the city. Since the 2020 crime wave, the nation's capital has been rocked by shootings that have left innocent children dead, a trend of juveniles committing carjackings that have turned deadly in some cases; and shoplifting crimes and attacks on government employees, summer interns and others, including the fatal shooting of 21-year-old congressional intern Eric Tarpinian-Jachym in June. Democratic lawmakers and local leaders have slammed Trump over the move, arguing crime has fallen in recent years after the wildly violent crime trends of 2020 that rocked cities nationwide. Though crimes have trended downward in recent years after the heavy crime of 2020, the lethality of crimes in D.C. has spiked dramatically, meaning the chances of being victimized in the city have dropped, but the chances of dying as a victim of violent crime have increased. The Council on Criminal Justice published a study in July examining violent crime data from 17 large U.S. cities between 2018 and 2024, specifically diving into the lethality of violent crimes in those cities. It found Washington, D.C., had the highest lethality level of the group, which included cities such as Baltimore and Chicago, at a 38% increase in lethality in 2024 compared with 2018. Lethality in D.C. jumped 341% when compared to 2012 data, the study found, reporting there were 13 homicides per 1,000 serious violent crimes in 2012 and 57 homicides per 1,000 serious violent crimes in 2024. Bowser slammed the federalization of the city during a townhall meeting Tuesday. "This is a time where community needs to jump in," Bowser said during the meeting community leaders, which was livestreamed on X. "We all need to, to do what we can in our space, in our lane, to protect our city and to protect our autonomy, to protect our home rule and get to the other side of this guy and make sure we elect a Democratic House so that we have a backstop to this authoritarian push." She called Trump's effort "an intrusion on our autonomy." When Trump first federalized the city, Bowser called the move "unprecedented" but added that she wasn't "totally surprised."
Politico
12 hours ago
- Politico
PAC to basics
ANOTHER DAY, ANOTHER AD — Twenty-six days out from Boston's preliminary election, the super PAC backing Mayor Michelle Wu is betting that Boston voters' disapproval of President Donald Trump can boost the incumbent in September. The 'Bold Boston' super PAC is releasing two more digital spots today, including one that highlights the money trail between top Wu opponent Josh Kraft, Trump and congressional Republicans. It's the second ad the PAC has put out this cycle that yokes Kraft to the president. Another spot released in June used similar messaging, pointing to donors who propped up Trump in the 2024 election who have also funneled money into the 'Your City Your Future' super PAC that's supporting Kraft. The strategy seems to be paying off if you look at the latest public polling from July, which had Kraft's favorability underwater. And it's not one that's exclusive to Boston. In New York, the city's Democratic nominee for mayor, Zohran Mamdani, has made Trump the center of his bid to unseat embattled New York Mayor Eric Adams. Mamdani launched a 'Five Boroughs Against Trump' tour earlier this week to pitch himself to voters in the city as the only candidate in the general election race (that still includes his Democratic primary foe, former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo) willing to take on the White House. Wu has been leveraging the president's lack of popularity in the city since her campaign began, both painting herself as a bulwark against the Trump administration and highlighting any connections between the president and her top rival. Kraft has repeatedly said he doesn't support the president, who his father, Robert Kraft, was once close with — and who reportedly more recently helped a top law firm broker a deal with Trump. But ramping up his own criticism of the president hasn't stopped the mayor from trying to make the connection. The other ad hitting Boston-area screens today doesn't mention the president, but paints Wu as a politician willing to fight against the administration and congressional Republicans. The title 'Our City' is a nod to a line from Wu's testimony before the House Oversight Committee in D.C. this spring. GOOD THURSDAY MORNING, MASSACHUSETTS. Have a tip, story, suggestion, birthday, anniversary, new job, or any other nugget for the Playbook? Drop me a line: kgarrity@ TODAY — Gov. Maura Healey has no public events. Rep. Katherine Clark and local officials celebrate the groundbreaking of the new Revere High School at 9 a.m. in Revere. Sen. Ed Markey and state officials tour the Greenfield Fire Department and hold a roundtable discussion with Franklin County first responders at noon in Greenfield. Rep. Lori Trahan hosts a press conference to highlight the impact of the congressional budget bill at 10:30 a.m. in Lawrence. Boston Mayor Michelle Wu cuts the ribbon at the newly renovated Harambee Park at 10:30 a.m. in Dorchester, speaks at the Nubian Markets Boston Double Up Food Bucks launch at 5 p.m. in Roxbury and attends the opening ceremonies of the annual Fisherman's Feast at 6 p.m. in the North End. DATELINE BEACON HILL — Safety-net hospital fund deficit rises to $290M by Christian M. Wade, The Eagle-Tribune: 'A shortfall in a state fund that helps safety-net hospitals pay medical costs for large numbers of uninsured and low-income patients has ballooned to nearly $290 million, according to newly released state health data. Preliminary estimates from the state's Executive Office of Health and Human Services show a deficit in the Health Safety-Net Fund is projected to increase from $198 million to more than $290 million in the fiscal year that ended June 30.' — Suffolk County Sheriff Steve Tompkins resigns from college board amid extortion charges by Chris Van Buskirk, Boston Herald: 'Suffolk County Sheriff Steve Tompkins resigned from the Roxbury Community College Board of Trustees, where he serves as chair, days after he was arrested in Florida on charges that he extorted a Boston-based cannabis company. Tompkins offered his formal resignation in a brief Tuesday letter to Gov. Maura Healey after Republicans called on the governor to remove him from the position. Former Gov. Charlie Baker, a Republican, appointed Tompkins as board chair in 2019.' — Pot entrepreneur, lobbyist Frank Perullo is alleged extortion victim of Suffolk Sheriff Steven Tompkins by Andrew Ryan, The Boston Globe: 'The marijuana executive identified as 'Individual A' in the federal indictment of Suffolk County Sheriff Steven Tompkins is longtime Boston lobbyist and political consultant Frank Perullo, business records and financial disclosures show. Prosecutors portray Individual A as a victim of extortion by Tompkins, who they say used his position to elbow his way into a share of Perullo's nascent pot firm, and then demanded his money back when his $50,000 investment tanked. … Perullo is not accused of any wrongdoing; instead he is portrayed in the indictment as the victim of extortion.' — 'Corruption' or 'just cheap'? Mixed reactions to sheriff's extortion charges by Saraya Wintersmith, GBH News: 'Residents, advocates and business leaders shared mixed views on the federal charges against Suffolk County Sheriff Steve Tompkins, ranging from bewilderment at the alleged corruption to doubts on the severity of the charges. Plus, just days after the indictment, many local leaders —including top politicians — have reserved judgment while the legal process plays out.' LOOK WHO'S HERE — Former governor and NCAA President Charlie Baker is at Boston College this morning to announce a collaboration between the NCAA and Team IMPACT, a non-profit that matches children facing serious illness and disability with college sports teams. MIGRANTS IN MASSACHUSETTS — Massachusetts immigrants who had legal status lose work in home and health care by Sarah Betancourt, GBH News: 'Parole for Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans, and Venezuelans launched in 2022 as a path for immigrants from specific countries to flee persecution, environmental disasters, and economic instability. They applied for the program from their home countries with the help of a U.S. sponsor, were vetted, and allowed to live and work in the U.S. for two years at a time. The Trump administration ended the CHNV program and moved up the dates the immigrants were told they stay in the U.S. ... After a Supreme Court decision reversed a temporary injunction barring the move, more than half a million immigrants across the country immediately lost their legal status, effectively becoming undocumented. While the injunction is off the books, the deeper legal issue could still eventually be decided in parolees' favor as arguments play out in lower courts.' — Inside one of the most understaffed immigration courts in the country by Ximena Bustillo, WBUR: 'The Chelmsford Immigration Court opened last year as a way to reduce the backlog on the overloaded Boston court, which used to process immigration cases for much of New England. Chelmsford and Boston are now the only courts located in New England, two of about 70 immigration courts and adjudication centers nationwide. Eight months into the Trump administration, there are only seven judges listed on the court's website, down from the 21 intended to serve. One of those seven is set to retire in the coming days, NPR has learned. Another has been detailed to review cases in Indianapolis.' PLANES, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES ON THE RIGHT TRACK — MBTA General Manager Phil Eng isn't worried about the shipment of Red Line cars that are still languishing in the port of Philadelphia after federal officials seized the cars that were shipped from China, he told WBUR. THE LOCAL ANGLE — Fall River assisted living inspection reports reveal lax reporting, state code violations by Emily Scherny and Dan Medeiros, The Herald News: 'A review of state inspections at the Gabriel House assisted living facility reveal repeated citations for lax reporting of resident emergencies and staff improperly trained in several respects, including the facility's emergency management plan. It remains unclear what that plan was. When asked for a copy of Gabriel House's emergency management plan, the state Executive Office of Aging and Independence provided a July 2015 document from Gabriel House that promised a plan but did not contain specifics.' — Republic demands Teamsters drop health insurance request, union says by Caroline Enos, The Salem News: 'Striking Teamsters Local 25 members say Republic Services Inc. won't return to the negotiation table unless they drop their request to take the union's health insurance instead of packages provided by the trash hauler. Republic told The Salem News Wednesday evening this is 'inaccurate information.' It's been about a month and a half since the Teamsters went on strike, and about a month since the union and hauler last sat with a federal mediator to negotiate on July 18.' — Bristol County district attorney's race off to an early start by Grace Ferguson, The New Bedford Light. HEARD 'ROUND THE BUBBLAH TRANSITIONS — Ali Noorani will be the next president of the Barr Foundation. HAPPY BIRTHDAY — to POLITICO's Peter Canellos, Dani Rodrik, Augusta Davis and Mark Mitchell.
