Former war correspondent felt she would die during 'harrowing' Irish Ferries journey
Retired journalist Susan Burt (75) said in the Circuit Civil Court on Wednesday that she, her partner Chris Sawyer and seven passengers from Co Mayo had felt they were not going to survive during what she described as a horrific nightmare over three days when the Epsilon had been unable to dock anywhere during a three-day journey from Cherbourg to Dublin.
Advertisement
Barrister John Wilde Crosbie, counsel for Ms Burt told Judge Christopher Callan the vessel had been forced to sail back and forth during the storm until the weather improved and it could continue to Dublin. It had set out on February 7th, 2016 and had not docked in Dublin a day late on the 9th.
'The vessel lurched so violently that people were screaming,' Burt, who lives in England and Brussels, told the court. 'Things were flying through the air, dishes were smashing and furniture sliding up and down decks and cabin floors. As the ship would roll we had to crawl.'
She said the ship would turn over so far after being hit by huge waves that passengers felt it would capsize. It seemed to go on forever.
'It was a very long drawn out harrowing and awful experience,' she told Mr Crosbie, who appeared with Evan O'Dwyer of O'Dwyer Solicitors, Ballyhaunis, Co Mayo.
Advertisement
'I thought I was going to die. I felt 'this is it,'' she said. 'We were being thrown about and our car was absolutely squashed as vehicles criss-crossed the car deck.'
In 2023 Noel Rowland, of Bridgemount, Belcarra, Castlebar, Co Mayo, his wife, and three children, Florence, Beau and Jude, now all resident in Brussels; Chris Sawyer, also Brussels, and two other passengers also living in Brussels but with Irish connections, settled their claims against Irish Ferries.
Ireland
Man released without charge after death of woman o...
Read More
At that time the court approved settlement offers of €14,500 each for the three Rowland children. Other settlements were not disclosed. Ms Burt's claim was put back until today for full trial.
Cross-examined by defence barrister Roisin Haughey, who appeared with Noble shipping Law Solicitors for Irish Ferries, Ms Burt said she had not developed Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and had not been physically injured during the harrowing experience.
Advertisement
Psychological experts for both parties put the absence of PTSD and her not having a requirement for medication down to her stoic attitude and impressive personal coping ability. Her counsel said she had nevertheless suffered psychological damage as a result of her experience.
Judge Callan reserved judgment on his assessment of damages in a case in which Irish Ferries had conceded liability.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
14 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Investigation into death of man at Stryker plant still ongoing after two years
An investigation by the Health and Safety Authority (HSA) into the death of a contract worker at a Cork factory over two years ago is still ongoing, an inquest has heard. John Murphy (41), a married father from Condonstown, Watergrasshill, Co Cork, sustained third-degree burns across 75 per cent of his body after a suspected explosion at the US medical device manufacturer Stryker's plant in Anngrove, Carrigtwohill, Co Cork on April 18th, 2023. Advertisement He died from his injuries almost two months later on June 9th, 2023, in the specialist burns unit in St James's Hospital in Dublin where he had been transferred after originally being treated at Cork University Hospital for 24 hours. Another work colleague of the deceased was also injured in the workplace accident. Mr Murphy was working for a facilities management company, Apleona, on the roof of the Stryker factory at the time of the fatal incident. He was able to make it down off the roof but became unresponsive a short time later and never regained consciousness before his death. Advertisement An inspector with the HSA, Frank Kearns, told a brief sitting of Dublin District Coroner's Court on Wednesday that the circumstances of Mr Murphy's death were still under investigation. Asked by the coroner, Clare Keane, if there was a particular reason why the matter was still with the HSA, Mr Kearns said he was just aware that it was still under investigation but confirmed a file on the case would be forwarded to the Director of Public Prosecutions. The HSA inspector noted the death had taken place in 2023 but added that such cases 'do take a lot of time.' Mr Kearns said he would ensure that Mr Murphy's family, who did not attend the latest proceedings, would be notified of the outcome of the hearing. Advertisement Dr Keane granted the application by the HSA for a six-month adjournment of the inquest under Section 25 (1) of the Coroners Act as criminal proceedings are being considered. In a newspaper interview earlier this year, the deceased's family outlined how they were heartbroken at not knowing when they will get closure from his death. Mr Murphy's parents and siblings said no family should have to wait so long for answers over the death of a loved one following a workplace tragedy. 'We have no closure. That is all we want. We are two years waiting for answers. We don't want to still be waiting for them at John's third or fourth anniversaries,' said his mother, Eileen. Advertisement In March 2024, Mr Murphy's family initiated High Court proceedings against Stryker Ireland Limited and Apleona Ireland Limited over his death. A High Court judge also granted their application to have a legal representative attend an engineering inspection of the factory. Meanwhile, trade union Siptu said 'grave health and safety concerns' have been raised about Stryker's operations in Cork following another fire at one of its facilities last week. Siptu spokesperson, Neil McGowan, said the trade union was calling on the US company's chief executive, Kevin Lobo, to intervene at the highest level to ensure that a meeting between local management and worker representatives took place. Advertisement Concerns have been expressed about claims that an automatic alarm system failed to sound following a fire at Stryker's Tullagreen plant in the IDA Business Park in Carrigtwohill on August 6. No injuries were sustained during the incident and all staff were safely evacuated from the building. 'This latest fire highlights a deeply troubling pattern over a number of years at the Stryker plants in Carrigtwohill,' said Mr McGowan. The company, which began operations in Ireland in 1998, now employs 4,100 staff across six locations in Cork. Siptu said its members have been raising health and safety concerns with Styrker about its plants in Carrigtwohill since 2019.
BreakingNews.ie
44 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
New IRA had planned earlier attack on detective John Caldwell, court told
Police have uncovered what they believe was a failed attempt to murder detective John Caldwell in the weeks before he was seriously wounded in a gun attack by dissident republicans, a court has heard. The details were revealed as two men appeared at Dungannon Magistrates' Court on charges linked to the attempted murder of the senior Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) officer in Omagh, Co Tyrone, on February 22nd, 2023. Advertisement Mr Caldwell was shot several times while he was off duty and with his young son, packing up after coaching a youth football team. The attack was claimed by the New IRA. Forensic officers at the scene of the shooting in 2023 (Liam McBurney/PA) Mr Caldwell has since retired from the PSNI on medical grounds. A number of people have previously appeared in court charged with offences linked to the shooting attack. Advertisement Caoimhin Murphy, 25, from Altowen Park, Coalisland, and Liam Robinson, 45, of Ardstewart, Stewartstown, are both charged with preparation of terrorist attacks and perverting the course of justice. Both men appeared in court on Wednesday via videolink from Musgrave Street police station in Belfast. Neither responded when asked if they understood the charges. A detective sergeant told the court he could connect both men to the offences. Advertisement After the court was told there was a challenge to the connections, a prosecution barrister said the investigation into the shooting of Mr Caldwell had been a 'complex, circumstantial case,' pointing out that several people had already been charged. She said: 'When the original individuals were charged, that was subsequent to the attempt on DCI Caldwell on the 22nd February of 2023. 'Investigations obviously continued, and through those investigations it was ascertained the case is there was a prior attempt on the 1st February 2023.' She said of the first attempt on the detective's life, an Audi and a Volkswagen vehicle had been used, and when he was later shot, two Ford Fiestas had been used. Advertisement She told the court the case against Murphy is that it is alleged he had moved a vehicle involved in the first failed attack, moved a vehicle involved in the later attack and had been involved in burning a car after the detective was shot. The case against Robinson is that it is alleged he assisted in the recovery of a vehicle used in the first attempt, moved a vehicle in the second attempt and assisted in burning a car. The detective sergeant told the court: 'The investigation has identified what is believed to have been a failed attempt to attack DCI Caldwell on the 1st February. 'On this occasion, DCI Caldwell wasn't at Youth Sport, which would have been his usual routine. Advertisement 'At that time, a Volkswagen Tiguan on false registration plates was observed on CCTV entering the youth sports site in similar fashion to the movements of the Fiesta number one on the 22nd, the evening of the attempt.' The officer laid out elements of the police investigation, which stretched over events on a number of dates in February 2023 and included phone and CCTV evidence, and what police believe are suspects taking place in 'walk and talk' conversations. He said the shooting of the detective is believed to have been 'a joint venture between a number of active service units', including Belfast and Tyrone New IRA. The officer told the court that on the night Mr Caldwell was shot, he had arrived at football training earlier than usual. He said police believe the attack had been planned to take place when he arrived at the sports complex, but was delayed because of his early arrival. He added: 'He was not shot until 8 o'clock that night, an hour and a half after what we would suggest was the planned attack.' Murphy's defence solicitor, Peter Corrigan, told the court there was 'not one iota' of surveillance evidence linking his client to any of the vehicles used in the shooting. Robinson's solicitor, Gavin Booth, said it was not part of the prosecution case that his client had taken part in the shooting of Mr Caldwell and had been in Coalisland at the time of the attack. The prosecuting barrister said it was a 'circumstantial case in its truest form'. She said: 'One strand may be weaker than the other; that is what a circumstantial case is. 'But when they are all layered on top of the other, the consequences of those meetings, the prosecution says that there is sufficient material before the court to connect both accused to the charges.' Mr Corrigan: 'It is a circumstantial case, but it is a circumstantial case which fails at connection because there are alternative explanations. 'It is all based on speculation and conjecture and does not close alternative explanations.' John Caldwell's life is still under threat, a court was told (David Young/PA) District Judge Rafferty said he was satisfied both could be connected to the offences. Police objected to a bail application for Robinson, with the detective sergeant stating it is believed he has a 'trusted role' in the IRA. He added: 'The New IRA have made a claim of responsibility for this terrorist attack. 'In addition to trying to justify the shooting of DCI Caldwell as a senior Crown forces member, the group further claimed that Irish Republican Army intelligence are now in possession of security information regarding the out of bounds movement of Crown force personnel.' He added: 'The threat to the life of John Caldwell continues to this day with his name appearing on a bonfire in the Creggan estate as we speak, along with cross-hairs indicating he continues to be a target.' He said the threat posed by the group was 'real and imminent'. The judge denied bail to Robinson. Both defendants were remanded in custody. Robinson will appear in court again on September 2nd, and Murphy will appear on August 20th to make a bail application.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Simon Harris ‘did all he could' on child scoliosis case, Donohoe says
The Tánaiste 'did all he could' in engaging with health officials about a child with scoliosis who later died, a senior minister has said. Simon Harris has faced calls to resign over unmet pledges around child spinal surgery waiting lists made several years ago. Advertisement It comes amid heightened scrutiny on the matter after the death of nine-year-old Harvey Morrison, who suffered from scoliosis, on July 29th. His parents, Gillian Sherratt and Stephen Morrison, learned last August that Harvey had been removed from Children Health Ireland's (CHI) scoliosis waiting list without their knowledge. After they publicly raised their son's case, Harvey, from Clondalkin, received spinal surgery last December after waiting for years. By then, his spinal curve had reached the point where it could not be fully corrected. Advertisement While he spent years on a waiting list, his spinal curve caused his rib cage to twist around his lungs and heart, severely restricting his breathing. While health minister in 2017, Mr Harris pledged that no child would wait more than four months for scoliosis treatment. Opposition politicians have joined Harvey's mother and father in calling for the Fine Gael leader's resignation, further criticising Mr Harris for failing to meet his parents. Asked if he stood by his party leader on Wednesday, Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe said Mr Harris has a commitment to supporting families dealing with scoliosis. Advertisement 'Minister Harris, as minister and then as taoiseach and Tánaiste, when he became aware of the needs of the particular family in question here, did all he could in terms of engaging with the Department of Health, in terms of engaging with the HSE, and I'm very conscious that we have a family who have lost a loved one who are grieving at the moment, and we have to respect that and allow them to make the points that they believe are important. 'But alongside that, Simon and the Government have placed huge focus on how we support young children with scoliosis. 'We always want to do more. We always want to make more progress. But additional resources, additional clinical support and operating theatres have all been made available to focus in on supporting those children.' He added: 'Those who are waiting for care have seen a reduction in how long they're waiting. Advertisement 'We're seeing a reduction in the number of people on the waiting list. 'But we know we need to do more, and we will always continue to prioritise this as a vital health issue.' Pressed on whether Mr Harris should be accountable for failures to meet the commitment to cut waiting lists to four months, and resign, Mr Donohoe said: 'We're all accountable through the appearances that we make in front of the Dáil, the questions we deal with in relation to matters of health or any aspect of public policy.'
