Israeli commentators warned to 'remain neutral' and not comment on Bambie Thug
The European Broadcasting Union warned Israel's commentators to "remain neutral" and not make comments about last year's Irish hopeful Bambie Thug.
In May last year, a row erupted after Bambie – who qualified for the final – called on Israel to be removed from the song contest after comments made about them by an Israeli Eurovision commentator on Kan, Israel's public service broadcaster.
The commentator warned viewers that their song Doomsday Blue would be "the most scary" of the night. He also noted that Bambie Thug liked to "speak negatively about Israel".
"But we can talk about that later. Prepare your curses," he said. After last year's Eurovision, it emerged that at least 16 delegations had filed complaints about the Israeli delegation's attitude.
It also emerged that as many as six countries threatened to withdraw half an hour before the start of the final, which included Norway, Greece, Portugal, Ireland, the UK and Switzerland. Now in a leaked document to Spanish website, verTele, the letter from the EBU to KAN shows Israel's slap on the wrist from last year.
The site was given access to the 'warning notice' letter that the EBU sent to the Israeli channel KAN for its attitude at Eurovision 2024, as well as the report resulting from the independent investigation that was carried out after the festival, and the document with which the EBU transferred these 'recommendations' to its 'roadmap'.
The document dated May 11, 2024-the day of the Eurovision 2024 final - is the letter that the European Broadcasting Union sent to the Israeli broadcaster. Emailed to Sharon Drikes, KAN Head of Delegation, it states: "We are writing to you further to the reporting of certain breaches of applicable EBU rules for this year ESC by the members of KAN's delegation.
"These concerns namely the Israeli media team and commentators. In particular, we have received official complaints that the Israeli media team has behaved over the past days in a rather intrusive, offensive and provocative manner towards other delegations.
"In that respect, we would kindly remind you that Participating Broadcasters are all required to respect the filming rules applicable for delegations and the ESC Rules2 which set principles to be respected when filming backstage or in the Event premises.
"In particular, it is expected from Participating Broadcasters to respect privacy, provide fair coverage, avoid harmful or offensive content and does not bring disrepute to the ESC."
The letter also addresses the derogatory comments made by KAN hosts towards other performances. "In addition, it has come to our attention that KAN's commentators have made discriminatory comments towards performances of certain countries, and namely towards the Irish performance.
"In that respect, we would like to remind you that Section 2.2.16 of Part 2 of the ESC Rules3 states that 'commentators shall remain neutral and should not make unduly discriminatory comments about the contestants or the songs'.
"In view of this, we hereby give KAN formal notice to respect the rules applicable to the ESC which are there to protect the smooth operation of the ESC and its integrity."
The letter went on to state that the delegation was moved from the delegation area "in order to avoid further incidents and complaints and we hereby urge you to ensure that all members of your delegation abide by all applicable rules and adopt at all times a behaviour in line with the ESC values."
The Union insisted that in order to punish "any behaviour that damages the reputation and/or integrity of the shows" they could apply financial sanctions , outlining in the same letter the rules of the festival that the Israeli KAN allegedly ignored.
Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
‘The first thing they did was put a pint in my hand': Cork fans relive Oasis memories ahead of Dublin gigs
A Cork man who was among the first people to interview Oasis as part of an assignment for his college newspaper says he is 'buzzing' to be attending their Dublin concerts this weekend. Michael Fitzgerald was just 17 years old when he met with the group at Manchester University's student bar in the early 1990s. At the time, they had yet to release their first single and were playing pubs and clubs around England. He said the first thing they did was place a pint in his hand to put him at ease for their interview. The Killeagh native, who was studying aerospace engineering, had been writing for the Mancunion at the time in return for free gig tickets. The now 49-year-old recalled the excitement in the air on the night he first heard Oasis play live. Now, three decades later, he is hoping to relive that same magic at both Croke Park gigs on Saturday and Sunday. The band's 2025 reunion tour was announced in August last year, with tickets selling out in less than a day. It will be Oasis's first time playing on Irish soil since 2028. Michael recalls his first meeting with group. 'Tony McCarroll, who was the drummer at the time, brought me backstage and introduced me to the lead singer Liam. Liam was quite hyperactive and had an amazing energy about him. It was obvious he was on a trajectory. He told me that I should talk to his brother because 'he writes all the songs',' he said. Noel told me that his influences were the Stone Roses and the Beatles. It was really nice to hear a young person flag these bands as musical influences. They were a breath of fresh air He described Noel and Liam at the time as 'your typical brothers'. 'They were like any other brothers really. One minute they were sitting with their arms around each other, the next they were having a cut off one other. They've had their ups and downs of course but that night, for me at least, it was like chatting with my own people. 'Liam was very personable and full of character. Noel was that little bit more introverted. It was while talking about music that he suddenly livened up and became a comedian. ' A lot of his lyrics were like jokes or punchlines. You can tell from his television interviews that he's a funny guy.' The band left an indelible impression on Michael. 'The first thing Tony McCarroll did was put a pint in my hand. For a penniless Irish student like me, a pint at that time was a fortune.' 'They had the humility but also that working-class confidence. They had huge belief in their songs. I think the band bought into it as an opportunity to get out of Manchester, play music, and just explore the world. 'They embraced that opportunity early.' Oasis fan Michael Fitzgerald said it was obvious the Gallagher brothers and the rest of the band were destined for stardom after he spoke with them for his college newspaper. Michael said it was obvious the Gallagher brothers and the rest of the band were destined for stardom. 'Six months later, their first single came out. I couldn't believe all the t-shirts and merchandise with their name. It inspired me to pursue a lot of my own dreams, even if they didn't involve music.' So how does he feel about this weekend's gigs? 'I've already been to Wembley. There is always an unbelievable atmosphere at Oasis concerts. 'It's like going to a match with 80,000 friends where everyone is singing for the same team. You have grandparents, mums, dads, and children. It's quite special actually.' Michael, who will be attending the concert with his sister, was determined to attend as many Oasis concerts as possible. It's like waiting for a bus for 16 years, and all of a sudden seeing three come along at once. I want to enjoy every minute Also making the pilgrimage to Croke Park this weekend will be Shane Farmer, who has been a superfan of the band for as long as he can remember. He will be attending Sunday night's gig. 'I was 15 years of age when I went to my first Oasis concert in Páirc Uí Chaoimh. It was a massive buzz. I was lucky enough to be there both nights. My grandfather was working on the turnstiles. I snuck in as his helper, but I spent the whole gig on the stand watching Oasis.' The experience was life-changing for Shane, who has taken to impersonating Liam on stage. 'I didn't have to pay to go to the concert when I was a teenager, but I made up for that over the years with all the trips and concerts. I've entered karaoke competitions as Liam and won a trip to New York. On one occasion, I got a call from the production team at Stars in Their Eyes, BBC. Superfan Shane Farmer, right, was 15 years old when he went to his first Oasis gig in Cork. Picture Dan Linehan 'They had seen videos of me performing and asked if I would be interested in travelling to the UK to audition for the show. I just froze. I decided against it in the end, because I felt it would just be stressful and take the fun out of it for me. 'I'm far from having a good singing voice, but Liam Gallagher has a very distinct sound that I did my best to try to recreate. I always dressed like him. He wore a zipped up top with a bucket hat, which is quite easy to put together. I've been wearing bucket hats since the nineties, so much so that friends often laugh at me. It's all about the image. Even though I was a lot heavier than Liam Gallagher, it still worked out for me. I still wear the bucket hats to this day.' Shane has enjoyed many Oasis highlights over the years. 'I was lucky enough to shake hands with Liam in Slane in 2009. It only lasted a few seconds, but I'll always remember it. Another highlight was standing outside the front window where the album cover photograph for Definitely Maybe was taken. 'It was that song that kicked off my whole love affair with Oasis so to be standing outside that window was surreal.' The 44-year-old's love for the band has rubbed off on other family members too. 'My five-year-old son Kelvin knows their music because I play it in the garden all the time. He likes wearing bucket hats, but I don't think he knows where that came from.' Shane says he is well known locally for his love of Oasis. 'If you mention Oasis in Midleton, my name will always come up. If there's ever a karaoke session I'll be pushed up to sing Oasis. 'Friends told me I was foolish not to have gone for Stars in Their Eyes, but I just do it for the pure enjoyment.' Kelvin Farmer with his Oasis superfan dad, Shane Farmer, proudly rocking a Liam Gallagher jacket. Picture: Dan Linehan Meanwhile, many fans who weren't lucky enough to secure tickets for Croke Park gigs have made alternative plans to mark the reunion tour. Laura Aherne says she was keen to get her own 'band' back together more than 25 years after they attended an Oasis concert in Atlanta together. 'I was at the concert with my friends Sinéad Kelleher, Margaret O'Mahony, and Lil O'Sullivan in Atlanta years ago. We all lived there at the time, but the four of us are back in Ireland so we really wanted to get the group back together to go to the concert. 'It was the four of us, all on our computers at the same time, the usual carry on. We couldn't get tickets, so we went to see an Oasis tribute band in Bantry.' The concert brought back fond memories for the gang. 'The tribute band was done very well. The concert we went to with the real band was a very different experience. 'The night we were in Atlanta, Liam threw down his instruments and walked off stage but Noel stayed on for a bit longer before telling us all to go home. I can't remember his words exactly, but it was something along the lines of 'go away the lot of you', so more of a drunk rumble. It seemed to happen a lot. 'There was always one walking on and walking off. It was dreadful but fierce entertaining. We always wanted to see them again, but I'm glad we were able to mark their reunion in some way.'
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Rarity and celebrity add value in the memorabilia market
A Fry's Five Boys c1900 advertisement at Victor Mee's next auction underlines how rarity and celebrity add value in a memorabilia market which continues to grow strongly in Ireland. This particular enamel sign is rare. It harks back to days when chocolate — taken in moderation and highly prized — was a special treat for children. The enamel sign, which depicts five boys expressing desperation, pacification, expectation, acclamation and finally realisation that it's Fry's chocolate, leads the online August sale of 930 lots by Victor Mee next Tuesday and Wednesday. The estimate is €4,000-€6,000. A framed advertising mirror for Bendigo Tobaccos. Copper figures of musicians on painted boards from Slattery's of Capel St. in Dublin are of interest. This pub venue and early house licensed since 1821, steeped in music, history and character, has long been a gathering place for market traders, musicians and storytellers. Slattery's is a much-loved hub of Irish culture and traditional music known for performances by everyone from Christy Moore, Donal Lunny and Seamus Ennis to the Arctic Monkeys, Bloc Party, Kate Nash and Townes van Zandt. The unique embossed figures of a fiddle player, a button accordionist, a bodhrán player, a pip player and a tin whistler, a banjo player and a flute player are estimated at €300-€600 each. With hand-drawn illustration by Brian McCormack and copper work by John A Brennan they are redolent of the cultural atmosphere which Slattery's is renowned for. A Youghal Choral Society poster from 1952. An Old Irish Reindeer Whisky Kiloh and Co Cork framed showcard is estimated at €1,200-€1,800 and the auction kicks off with an Allman's of Bandon Old Irish Whisky advertising sign (€50-€80). A Beamish Stout light-up box for a counter dating to the 1970's has an estimate of €50-€100. A framed advertising mirror for Bendigo Tobaccos produced for W & M Taylor Ltd., Dublin and manufactured by A & H Pemberton of Liverpool has an estimate of €3,000-€5,000. In Art Nouveau style, it features hand gilded and reverse painted lettering in rich red, gold and cobalt blue and few examples survive in such well preserved condition. An original Will's Woodbine Cigarettes enamel sign, 150 cm x 92 cm, in well-preserved condition is the sort of lot that is sought after by collectors. The estimate is €300-€500. An embossed copper figure of a fiddle player from Slattery's. Sales like this serve to remind us of how quickly things move on and can stir many memories. Lot 159, for instance, is a framed February 1952 poster for A Royal Jester by Youghal Choral Society at the Town Hall (€40-€80). The catalogue is online.
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
160,000 Oasis fans to descend on Croke Park thi
The first of two Oasis concert takes place at Croke Park today, as the Irish leg of their long awaited reunion tour gets under way. 160,000 fans will descend on Dublin to see the band in their first performance in Ireland since 2009. Its 16 years since a feud between brothers Liam and Noel Gallagher brought the band that defined Britpop to an end. The Oasis split came just weeks after they headlined at Slane Castle in Co Meath But late last year the pair announced that they'd put their differences behind them and the band would reform for a tour. A scramble for tickets ensued, with hundreds of thousands of fans who queued virtually unable secure a seat and many who did, left shocked by the cost put down to a process called dynamic pricing, which sparked an investigation by the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission here Since early July the band have performed 15 nights of their Live 25 tour in the UK in Cardiff, Manchester, London and Edinburgh. Liam and Noel's Mayo-born mother, Peggy, is expected to attend this weekend's performances and with deep ties to both Mayo and Meath, fans will be hoping the Dublin shows will prove particularly meaningful. Extra trains are running in Dublin for the event, there's no early queuing or camping allowed at Croke Park and under 14s mist be accompanied by an adult. Oasis are due on stage around 8pm on both nights.
