Former Hamilton lawyer barred from practising after law society says she failed 'extremely vulnerable' clients
The Law Society Tribunal made the decision Thursday in the case involving Victoria Bruyn, at the request of the Law Society of Ontario (LSO), which regulates lawyers and paralegals in the province.
As first reported by CBC Hamilton in 2023, and according to subsequent LSO investigations, Bruyn has a pattern of promising to help clients successfully navigate Canada's complicated refugee process, but then failed to complete their applications, show up for hearings or submit evidence, and in some cases lied about it.
The LSO has received nine complaints against Bruyn since March 2024, said Gloria Ushirode, who's conducting the investigations. Bruyn has not co-operated with the LSO, including providing any materials, and the investigation is ongoing, Ushirode said.
"The complaints allege, among other things, a failure to serve extremely vulnerable refugee claimants and serious integrity breaches that seem to demonstrate a pattern of dishonest conduct in an attempt to cover up ineffective service," Ushirode wrote in an affidavit filed with the Law Society Tribunal.
On Thursday morning, Bruyn attended the tribunal's virtual hearing.
She told the panel she isn't opposing her licence being suspended. She's no longer practising law and was appointed as an adjudicator to Ontario's Landlord and Tenant Board last year, but is on a leave of absence.
"I just want to put it on the record that I do have a response to these allegations ... I do intend to challenge these allegations."
Clients seeking refugee status
In some of the cases, Bruyn accepted payments through Legal Aid Ontario, a provincial agency that helps people who need but can't afford legal assistance. She was suspended from the roster last year, said Ushirode in the affidavit.
In two other cases, clients paid her a total of $10,500 in fees without completing any work and Bruyn never provided refunds, LSO lawyer Kristin Bailey said at the hearing.
"All the clients involved in this are extremely vulnerable and face potentially dire consequences," Bailey said.
They include people fleeing Lebanon, Angola, Colombia, Ukraine, Saudi Arabia and Mexico, according to case documents the LSO provided to the tribunal. Once they switched from Bruyn to different lawyers, they were granted permission to stay in Canada.
One of the clients, whose name has not been released, was connected to Bruyn through legal aid, to assist her with her refugee application in 2021, said the documents. She'd fled Mexico after witnessing a neighbour's murder, and almost being kidnapped twice. She'd also experienced domestic violence in Canada and mental health issues connected to trauma and abuse.
Bruyn never met the client before the hearing for her refugee claim and never advised her to gather evidence such as a report from a mental health professional about what she's experiencing — a service that legal aid would have pay for, the LSO said.
Bruyn didn't submit any evidence on behalf of her client, even after the Refugee Protection Division gave her an extension, said the LSO. As a result, the woman's refugee claim was denied. Bruyn told her she'd file an appeal, but never did.
The woman was almost deported back to Mexico, but a new lawyer, retained through a local refugee organization, intervened and helped her get a temporary resident permit, said Ushirode's affidavit. She's currently applying for more permanent status.
Number impacted remains unknown
Because Bruyn hasn't co-operated with the LSO's investigations, it doesn't know the true number of clients who've been impacted or the extent of misconduct, said Bailey.
The complaints filed to the LSO concerned Bruyn's conduct between 2021 and 2025, and included CBC Hamilton stories about Bruyn, including one on client Sarah Arvanitis.
Arvanitis's experience with Bruyn in 2023 almost left her stranded in the U.S., separated from her daughter and husband in Hamilton for months, she said. She filed a complaint shortly after, but LSO closed that file later that year, stating in its decision there was "insufficient evidence of professional misconduct to support further action."
Arvanitis's complaint is not included in the nine the LSO presented to the tribunal this week.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
2 hours ago
- National Observer
Carney says trade talks in 'intense phase' after Trump notches a win with European Union
Prime Minister Mark Carney said Monday that Canada's negotiations with the United States are in an "intense phase" after President Donald Trump achieved a critical agreement with the European Union days away from his tariff deadline. The prime minister's comments come after Trump last week told reporters that Canada wasn't a priority ahead of his Aug. 1 deadline to make trade deals. "There are many aspects to these negotiations," Carney said in P.E.I. "We are engaged in them but the assurance for Canadian business, for Canadians, is we will only sign a deal that's the right deal, that's a good deal for Canada." The EU framework announced Sunday gave Trump a much-needed win as he looks to realign global trade — and it indicates that no nations are likely to get a reprieve from his tariffs. It sets a 15 per cent tariff on most goods, including European automobiles. Trump said 50 per cent tariffs will remain on steel and aluminum. Other details of the deal remain unclear, including its effects on measures the US considers trade irritants, such as Europe's digital services taxes and non-tariff barriers. Trump said the EU had agreed to buy US$750 billion worth of US energy and invest an additional US$600 billion in the United States. The president recently said that countries will have to "buy down" the threatened tariff rate. Baseline tariffs were also a part of trade deal frameworks previously announced for Japan, Vietnam, Indonesia, the Philippines and the United Kingdom. Countries around the world have been watching to see how many trade deals materialize before the deadline, and what can be gleaned from them for their own negotiations with the Trump administration. Christopher Sands, director of Johns Hopkins University's Center for Canadian Studies, said the EU deal builds on Trump's negotiating style — he loses interest, suggests no deal will happen, insults the other side and "then at the 11th hour something comes through." "I know there's been a lot of negativity around a Canada security and economic agreement but it doesn't necessarily mean that we are doomed," Sands said. "It may be that we are close and we have a surprise deal." Trump sent a letter to Carney threatening to impose 35 per cent tariffs if Canada doesn't make a trade deal by Friday. The White House has said those duties would not apply to goods compliant with the Canada-US-Mexico Agreement on trade, better known as CUSMA. Carney and other Canadian officials have been downplaying expectations that a deal will be made by Friday. Most of the goods Canada sends to the US are CUSMA-compliant and won't be affected by the 35 per cent duties. The Canadian economy is still being slammed by Trump's Section 232 tariffs on steel, aluminum and automobiles, and will be hit by copper tariffs the president has said will take effect by the week's end. So far, Trump's trade deals "are really bad omens for Canada," said William Pellerin, a trade lawyer and partner at the firm McMillan LLP. "(It shows) that the tariffs, particularly the sectoral tariffs, are stickier than we would have thought," Pellerin said. "If none of those countries were able to secure a drop in the sectoral tariffs, that is certainly bad news." Those Section 232 duties are a key target for Canadian negotiators and Pellerin said it's unlikely any deal will be struck by Ottawa if they remain at their current levels. While there are similarities between the Canada-US negotiations and those involving Europe, Carney said there are also many differences. While Europe is looking to end its reliance on Russian energy, Carney said Canada is a reliable supplier of energy to the United States. The prime minister said negotiations remain complex but "there is a landing zone that's possible." "But we have to get there," he said. The EU agreement also averts significant retaliatory duties from a major United States customer — meaning that if Canada can't reach a deal with Washington, it would be more isolated if it attempts to retaliate against the US. Canada and China have implemented retaliatory tariffs in response to Trump's trade war but, to allow talks to continue, Ottawa didn't move forward with additional duties. Ontario Premier Doug Ford said Monday he supports a dollar-for-dollar tariff response, particularly to Trump's treatment of Canada's steel and aluminum industry. "I'm confident with Prime Minister Carney, I know he's going to do his very best to get a deal," Ford said. "But I don't trust President Trump." BC Premier David Eby said Canada is in a "different position" than the European Union or Japan, given the deeply integrated nature of North American supply chains. "We are a reliable partner, we are a good partner, but we also won't get kicked around," he said. Sands said Carney's recent move to limit imports of foreign steel into Canada will help shore up the domestic market during the tariff tumult while also avoiding the ire of the Trump administration. The prime minister recognizes you can engage in retaliation, Sands said, but "it doesn't bring you much joy." He said there are other actions, such as import quotas, that would better protect Canadian markets. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 28, 2025.
Edmonton Journal
3 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
Braid: Separatism debate heats up as referendum question goes to court
Elections Alberta is taking the separatists to court. It could be some show. Article content The elections office asks Court of King's Bench to decide whether a referendum question proposed by separatists is unconstitutional. Article content Article content Article content Whatever happens in court, the separatist drive for a referendum question is stalled for some time. Article content Some separatists are claiming the system is rigged against them, because any King's Bench judge who hears the case will be a federal appointee. Article content Another problem awaits. A related question has already been approved by Elections Alberta, the independent body established by the legislature. Article content Under the law, there can't be two questions on the same general subject. Article content Article content The pro-Canada leader of this campaign is former PC Deputy Premier Thomas Lukaszuk. Article content He's now branded 'Tommy the Commie' by separatists who seem deeply annoyed that he got the jump on them. Article content He sure did. Lukaszuk's question was approved just before Canada Day. That kicked off a 30-day period for organizing that ends Wednesday. Article content After that, the group can start collecting official signatures to trigger a provincewide vote. Article content Lukaszuk's question was approved while a previous law was in effect. It requires him to gather 300,000 names, all fully checked and approved, in only 90 days. Article content Article content Bizarrely, after Lukaszuk's question was allowed, the UCP proclaimed legislation that lowers the bar to 177,000 signatures over 120 days. Article content That's a much more reasonable goal. But Lukaszuk may be stuck with the old one.
CTV News
5 hours ago
- CTV News
Ontario photographer receives box of staples instead of $2,577 camera lens they ordered
An Ontario photographer is frustrated after her $2,577 camera lens is replaced with box of staples. An Ontario woman who enjoys photography wanted to buy a special camera lens she found online. But, when the shipment arrived, she opened it to find a box of staples instead. 'I was completely shocked. I didn't know what to do,' Viktoryia Shkel of Maple, Ont. told CTV News Toronto. Shkel is a photography enthusiast and said she wanted to upgrade to a more advanced camera lens. She said she found one online on Canon Canada's website for $2,577 that was part of a 'damaged box' sale. However, when the shipment arrived in mid-June, Shkel said she opened the box to find it was full of staples. 'The box was supposed to contain a Canon EF 24-70mm lens, and instead there was a box of staples,' she said. Shkel told CTV News she contacted Canon Canada to explain what happened, and sent photos of what she received. 'They notified me that all protocols were followed... they said the lens was inspected in the facility and by the time the lens left, everything was intact.' She said that while the outside box was sealed, the box for the camera lens had been opened—something that is standard with open or damaged box sales. 'There was no safety seal,' she said. Shkel claimed the box of staples weighed the same as what the camera lens would. But, following an internal investigation by Canon Canada, she was told she would not be getting a refund. box of staples Viktoryia Shkel of Maple, Ont. shows the weight of the box of staples she received instead of a $2,577 camera lens. (Supplied) 'I'm completely heartbroken. I'm completely shocked this happened to me and I'm really, really upset.' In late 2023, CTV News reported on a similar story with the Mankad family of Brampton. The family had ordered a laptop, but received two books instead. 'Someone must have opened the box, took out the laptop and replaced it with two books of equal weight and size,' Hardik Mankad said at the time. With CTV News' help, the Mankad family got a refund. In Shkel's case, CTV News reached out to Canon Canada and a spokesperson said in a statement, 'Internally, we have launched an investigation with our customer care and warehouse teams to examine what may have occurred.' 'We can confirm that our current process for outbound shipments require a weight verification of the product(s) held within and must match our strict weight measurements before being sent. Both our warehouse and shipping partner have confirmed that the outbound package did match the measurements and weight that would be expected for the lens model purchased, however based on the information provided by Viktoryia, it appears that the package may have been tampered with after departing our facility.' 'This is an unusual situation that we have not previously encountered, but while we continue the investigation with our shipping partner, we understand that the customer is currently bearing the financial burden of this loss. Customer satisfaction is a top priority for our brand, and we are currently in the process of issuing a refund to this customer for the cost of the lens.' Shkel has now received a full refund and plans to buy a new lens in person at a camera store.
