
Pilots: Deliberate ambiguity in report timeline to shift blame
2
Kolkata: Serving and retired pilots have expressed concern over what they term "deliberate" ambiguity in the timeline mentioned in the preliminary probe report by Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) on the AI 171 crash.
They allege this has been done to absolve the aircraft manufacturer of responsibility and pin the blame on the pilots.
They also point out that the word "transition" of fuel switches used in the report attempts to insinuate that they were manually moved. "This is an American expression. In India, it would normally have been written: The switches were moved. It is the fuel valves that transition while the switches can move from RUN to CUT OFF or vice versa," a veteran pilot said.
While several timelines are mentioned in the report, it is unclear at the crucial phase immediately after takeoff, when the two engines momentarily shut down after fuel flow stopped. AAIB provides the timestamp to the exact second for a number of actions. The aircraft started rolling at 8:07:37 UTC (13:37:37 IST, ie, 37 seconds past 1.37pm). The aircraft and ground sensors recorded the lift-off at 08:08:39 UTC (13:38:39 IST).
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years
IC Markets
Learn More
Undo
It then states the aircraft achieved the maximum recorded airspeed of 180 knots (333 kmph) at 08:08:42 UTC (13:38:42 IST).
You Can Also Check:
Kolkata AQI
|
Weather in Kolkata
|
Bank Holidays in Kolkata
|
Public Holidays in Kolkata
Thereafter, the timelines become unclear. It says immediately after, engine 1 and engine 2 fuel cutoff switches transitioned from RUN to CUT OFF position one after another with a time gap of 01 second. It then states: "In the cockpit voice recording, one of the pilots is heard asking the other why he cut off.
The other pilot responded that he did not do so."
"When did all of this happen and in which sequence? That is a crucial segment of the flight when something catastrophic happened that took down the plane. It is not possible to move both switches from RUN to CUT OFF in a second. The SOP as laid down in the manual for reviving engines during a dual engine failure is to move the switches from RUN to CUT OFF and back to RUN. The pilots in the ill-fated aircraft did so and we know the engines were revived, but the plane crashed because it did not gain enough altitude to clear the buildings," another captain explained.
The report goes on to state that CCTV footage obtained from the airport showed the Ram Air Turbine (RAT) getting deployed during the initial climb immediately after lift-off, but the time is not mentioned. The next timestamp is when the RAT hydraulic pump began supplying hydraulic power, 08:08:47 UTC (13:38:47 IST). A pilot pointed out that since the RAT takes around 7-8 seconds from auto deployment to begin functioning, the plane should have lost the engines around 08:08:40 UTC (13:38:40 IST).
"If that is so, then how did the plane achieve the maximum airspeed 2 seconds later at 08:08:42 UTC (13:38:42 IST)?" he said.
Another pilot said it was critical to know the exact conversation that took place in the cockpit from the start of the takeoff run to the Mayday call, adding: "This is not just for the sake of learning why flight AI 171 crashed but to ensure that another flight does not meet the same fate in future."
Another captain also pointed out that both pilots were wearing headsets and spoke on different channels, as is mandatory procedure during takeoff. "Then why is there no clarity on who said what, it's available in the cockpit voice recorder?" he said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
‘Sita's birthplace to get Ayodhya-like makeover'
Patna: CM Nitish Kumar on Saturday inspected the site of the approved comprehensive development plan for the Shri Janki Janmabhoomi Mandir area at Punaura Dham in Sitamarhi district, widely believed to be the birthplace of Goddess Sita. Before reaching Punaura Dham, the CM inaugurated development projects worth around Rs 650 crore in Madhubani district. During the site visit, officials briefed Nitish on the facilities that will be created for devotees by the tourism department within the temple complex, preparations for the foundation stone laying ceremony on Aug 8 and the broader development plan for the Shri Janki Janmabhoomi Mandir area. The plan is modelled on the overall redevelopment of the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Teerth Kshetra in Ayodhya. Nitish said the Shri Janki Janmabhoomi at Punaura Dham would witness comprehensive development on the lines of the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Teerth Kshetra. Issuing instructions to officials, the CM stressed the importance of developing religious rituals, facilities for pilgrims and general amenities at the Maa Janki Mandir premises. "The old structure of the Maa Janki Temple building will be preserved as it is," a communique from the Chief Minister's Office (CMO) said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 3 & 4 BHK Starts ₹1.65 Cr in Kukatpally Honer Signatis Book Now Undo The foundation stone for the Rs 882-crore development project will be laid on Aug 8. A nine-member trust, headed by the state's chief secretary, has been formed for the construction and redevelopment of the Maa Janki Mandir at Punaura Dham. Earlier in the day, Nitish led a high-profile roadshow in Laukahi, Madhubani district, where he laid foundation stones for various infrastructure and tourism-related projects. The roadshow began at the helipad and concluded at the event venue. He also unveiled a statue of former Bihar minister, the late Hari Prasad Sah, and paid floral tribute. Among the key projects launched was an approach road including a road overbridge (ROB) at a cost of Rs 178 crore, located near the railway-level crossing between Khajauli and Jaynagar railway stations. Nitish also launched a project worth Rs 31 crore for the development of tourism infrastructure at Phulhar Sthan in Harlakhi.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
150-ton Sufi shrine moved after demolition notice in UP
1 2 3 4 Bareilly: A Sufi shrine weighing over 150 tons was moved 27 feet using machinery after PWD issued a demolition notice in Sambhal in June. Situated on the Agra-Bijnor state highway, the shrine was relocated with a hydra machine and a crane to free the busy thoroughfare. A few temples and mosques were either partly or fully demolished in Sambhal in the recent past as part of the ongoing road widening project. Sambhal tehsildar, Dheerendra Singh, said on Saturday: "The shrine of Yaqoob Shah Ali Chishti was on a PWD road, and we had to give an ultimatum due to road widening work." After inspecting the site a week ago, Singh had extended the demolition deadline to July 24. To save the shrine, which people from all communities visit, the committee decided to relocate it. The scientific procedure cost around Rs 10 lakh. Before the move, a seven-foot-deep pit was dug with a bulldozer and an iron-sheet box was built around the shrine to ensure its safety. Subsequently, a new pit was dug 27 feet behind the road and the shrine was relocated in an L-shape there; the entire work began in June. "We were given an ultimatum until July 24. Work was delayed due to rain. The exact weight was not known as the structure is old. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like A Truck Driver's Salary in the Canada Might Surprise You Truck Driving Jobs | Search Ads Undo Upon examination, the contractor estimated it to be over 150 tons. Now the shrine has been moved, and the dargah's remaining work will be completed soon," said Ragib Hasan, a member of the shrine committee. The local administration started the process 15 days after the PWD notice. The committee also voluntarily dismantled part of a mosque and madrassa nearby and requested time to relocate the shrine, for which they were granted 15 more days. Contractor Dilshad Ansari from Roorkee, Uttarakhand, who was part of the project, said, "We've shifted two temples in Uttarakhand in the past. This is the first time we managed to move a mazaar. It was an old mazaar and we had to do it in a meticulous manner."
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Air India pays interim compensation to kin of 166 Ahmedabad crash victims
The plane crash, one of the worst air disasters in India in decades, involved a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner operating as Air India flight AI171 Press Trust of India Mumbai