Technology glitches mar second day of testimony at Hockey Canada trial
In a sweltering hot courtroom on her second day of testimony, London Police detective Tiffany Waque, the Crown's first witness, played clips of videos that showed players from the 2018 Canadian World Juniors team and the complainant in the Hockey Canada sexual assault trial drinking, talking at the bar and dancing at Jack's — a bar and nightclub on Richmond Street that is popular amongst university and college students.
Advertisement
The video clips from a June evening in 2018, prior to the alleged incident at the Delta Armouries Hotel, are the first pieces of evidence presented in the Crown's case against the five defendants. Michael McLeod, Carter Hart, Alex Formenton, Dillon Dubé and Cal Foote are all facing sexual assault charges in connection with the alleged incident; all five players pleaded not guilty last week.
The complainant, then 20, alleges that she was sexually assaulted in the hotel following a Hockey Canada gala celebrating the team's 2018 World Junior Championship run.
At multiple points during Waque's testimony, the surveillance videos, many of which were not accompanied by sound, were paused to allow her to identify for the jury who was in the video and which camera angles from within Jack's — the main bar, an auxiliary bar, the dance floor — captured the video. One of the first videos showed Brett Howden approaching the complainant at the bar; a short time after, he returned with McLeod. The complainant and McLeod could be seen on video talking and, at one point, taking a shot together. Later, in another silent surveillance video, Waque identified McLeod and the complainant dancing together amid a crush of other people and strobing lights.
In addition to surveillance video, Waque also showed jurors multiple videos from Drake Batherson and one from McLeod that show the players in various stages of revelry throughout their night at Jack's — jumping, singing and dancing together.
One video showed Batherson, Howden and Cale Makar dancing to The Killers' 'Mr. Brightside' song. Another video showed Tyler Steenbergen and Makar with Chris Brown's 'Yeah 3x' in the background. A third video showed McLeod, Batherson, Howden, Foote and Maxime Comtois huddled in a semicircle, facing the camera, singing along to the song 'Pursuit of Happiness' by Kid Cudi:
I'm on the pursuit of happiness and I know
Everything that shine ain't always gonna be gold
Advertisement
Matt Maccarone, who was identified as a 'sponsor but not part of the team,' was shown in multiple videos talking with players at the bar. Jurors also saw one video that featured Howden, McLeod and Jake Bean, the latter of whom was sitting on Maccarone's shoulders.
The five players who are defendants in the case watched the videos from their respective defense tables.
There were multiple delays in Tuesday's proceedings because of technical issues within the courtroom. Justice Maria Carroccia, who is presiding, explained that there was a piece of equipment that was 'overheating' because of the temperature of the courtroom. Carroccia dismissed the jurors early for the day telling them:
'We've got no choice. We can't get the equipment to work properly and … it's very, very hot.'
— The Athletic's Dan Robson contributed reporting remotely from Toronto.
(Photo by Peter Power / AFP via Getty Images)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
8 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Troy Ryan confirmed to return to Canadian women's hockey team's Olympic bench
CALGARY - Troy Ryan has been tasked with coaching the Canadian women's hockey team to another Olympic gold medal in 2026 in Milan-Cortina, Italy. Ryan was behind the bench in Beijing in 2022 when the Canadian women reclaimed hockey gold from the United States in a 3-2 final. The U.S. had beaten Canada 3-2 in a shootout for the title in 2018 in Pyeongchang, South Korea, where Ryan was an assistant coach. Hockey Canada's announcement Thursday confirmed Ryan's return, although he'd signed an unprecedented four-year extension in 2022 that would make him the longest-tenured coach of the national women's team. Ryan navigated Canada to both an Olympic gold medal in Beijing and world championship wins in 2021, 2022 and 2024 after taking over midway through the 2019-20 season for Perry Pearn. Canada lost this year's world championship final 4-3 in overtime to the U.S. in Ceske Budejovice, Czechia. Korie Cheverie, former national team forward Caroline Ouellette and Britni Smith will be Ryan's assistant coaches in Italy, with Brad Kirkwood serving as goaltending consultant, Hockey Canada said in a statement. The coaches were chosen by women's team general manager Gina Kingsbury in consultation with Hockey Canada president and chief executive officer Katherine Henderson and senior vice-president of high performance and hockey operations Scott Salmond. 'It is always an honour and privilege to be in this leadership position as we set our expectations and goals for the Olympics,' Ryan said. 'We have a tremendous coaching staff that is committed to the vision and process, and I am excited for the journey ahead. We know our athletes are motivated to compete, and we are eager to begin the work towards achieving something extraordinary in seven months time.' Canada won a silver medal in 1998 in Nagano, Japan, where women's hockey made its Olympic debut. Four straight gold medals followed in 2002, 2006, 2010 and 2014. Canada's preparation for Italy will be different than previous Olympic Games because of the Professional Women's Hockey League starting its third season. Hockey Canada will fit training blocks around the PWHL's schedule. Ryan is head coach of the PWHL's Toronto Sceptres. Cheverie is head coach and Ouellette an assistant coach of the Montreal Victoire. 'We have made a conscious effort to create an environment for our athletes where consistency among our coaches creates trust and accountability in each other,' Kingsbury said. 'Our staff are experienced, detail-oriented and passionate as they give our team the confidence to grow, compete and meet the challenges of both short-term and long-term competition. We continue to build something special with our group and we are excited to see it all come together as we compete for a gold medal in Milan.' Cheverie of New Glasgow, N.S., was Ryan's assistant in the 2022 Olympic Games and for every world championship since 2021. Montreal's Ouellette, a four-time Olympic and six-time world gold medallist, has been Ryan's assistant in four straight world championships. Smith of Port Perry, Ont., coached at Syracuse University for the past three seasons and was Ryan's assistant at this year's world championship. Calgary's Kirkwood has been the team's goaltending consultant for the last decade and works with Ryan and the Sceptres as a goaltending assistant coach. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 31, 2025.
New York Times
18 hours ago
- New York Times
How Blue Jackets' Evan Gardner emerged as a top goalie prospect
MINNEAPOLIS — When Saskatoon Blades general manager Colin Priestner broke the news to Evan Gardner following a Nov. 30 game that he didn't get invited to Hockey Canada's selection camp for the 2025 World Junior team, he immediately broke down into tears. 'What else can I do?' Gardner asked. Nothing, Priestner told him. Advertisement 'He had the highest numbers of anyone, the most wins, and he did it last year too,' Priestner said on a phone call back in December. 'I wouldn't be surprised if he's the starter or the backup next year, and you've just got to dust yourself off and prove them wrong.' Eight months later, almost to the day, Gardner was standing inside Ridder Arena wearing Hockey Canada workout gear at the World Junior Summer Showcase, where he's vying to make the 2026 team in Minneapolis. 'I was pretty heartbroken not to get an invite at Christmastime,' Gardner said. 'Last summer, I didn't get an invite either, so I was really working towards that winter, and to hear that I didn't get it, it kind of tore me apart. So I really put in a ton of time into my craft and a ton of work with my goalie coach (Jeff Harvey) back in Saskatoon to hopefully get an invite here, and it panned out, so I'm super pumped. This is something that's super special for me. It's something I've been wanting to do for a long, long time.' He's not the front-runner. Returnees Carter George and Jack Ivankovic both played well in Canada's disappointing quarterfinal exit in 2025 and were sent home early on Thursday to leave Gardner and Sharks first-round pick Joshua Ravensbergen to play Canada's final two games against Sweden and the USA. At the moment, he's vying to be the team's No. 3. But he's used to a little adversity. It's the 19-year-old goaltender's first Hockey Canada experience. He never played for them at the U17 or U18 levels. He grew up in Fort St. John, British Columbia, a town of about 20,000 people, and they only had AA hockey at the time. He was always on the A team until he moved to Kelowna to enroll at RINK Hockey Academy. He was a third-round pick in the 2021 WHL bantam draft and is the first to say that if it weren't for the delayed COVID draft pushing it from the spring and into December, he would have been drafted much later. His play with the RINK Hockey Academy's U18 team in the fall that year earned him the third-round selection. Advertisement He didn't make the Blades as a 16-year-old and was their backup to start his NHL Draft season the following year. When NHL Central Scouting released its players to watch list for the 2024 draft, he was given a 'W' rating, which indicates a 6th/7th round candidate. On their midterm list that year, he was their No. 16-ranked North American goalie. He's also on the smaller side (Hockey Canada lists him at 6-foot and 175 pounds, and the WHL lists him at 6-foot-1 and 177 pounds). But he just kept playing well, and as the year went on, he took the net in Saskatoon from the veteran Austin Elliott (who backstopped the London Knights to an OHL title and Memorial Cup this spring after the Blades released him to hand the net to Gardner). By year's end, he'd posted a .927 save percentage. Despite having played just 30 WHL games, NHL Central Scouting moved him up to No. 7 on their final list. He then posted a .910 save percentage in another 15 playoff games. The Blue Jackets selected him in the second round of the draft and made him the fourth goalie selected after Ilya Nabokov, Mikhail Yegorov and George, who was selected three spots in front of him. There were members of the Blue Jackets organization who liked him better than George, and it became an internal debate for them ahead of the draft. Gardner has felt the love from the Blue Jackets, too. 'Their goalie staff is unbelievable there, and they have so much faith in me,' he said. 'They've treated me great, I've learned a lot from them, and I can't wait for what the future holds.' After a solid post-draft season as Saskatoon's starter, Gardner now has a .917 save percentage across 74 career WHL regular-season games and has already signed his entry-level contract with the Blue Jackets. In the spring, he made his AHL debut with the Cleveland Monsters and stopped 16 of 19 shots in a 3-0 loss. Advertisement When he maps out his path, he stops himself to chuckle. The third-round selection in the WHL draft lit a fire under him. 'There were, I believe, six goalies taken in front of me (in the WHL),' he pointed out, remembering the number. Getting cut by the Blades at 16 grew that fire. 'I was just hoping a team would take a flier on me. That's all I wanted, was just to show a team what I was capable of, and then I had a great second half and kind of took over in the playoffs,' he said. Once Gardner started getting starts early on in his draft year, Dan Da Silva, Saskatoon's head coach, said they could see the breakout second half coming. 'They were always quality starts and we had a really good team in front of him, but there came a point where we just felt that we were most comfortable with him back there as the last line of defence and for a 17-year-old goalie to give you that type of confidence in your chances to win a game, that speaks volumes to the work he had put in to get himself to that,' Da Silva said on a phone call on Wednesday. Gardner has done it while managing Type 1 diabetes. 'He is beloved by all of his teammates. He's a very popular guy in the room. He's a very happy-go-lucky guy. He's always got a smile on his face. He's easy to talk to,' Da Silva said. 'He obviously does a lot there with his diabetes situation and handles that extremely well, and mature beyond his years for someone having to deal with that.' He was diagnosed eight years ago this summer, when he fell ill on a trip with his parents to Kelowna for a Blue Jays baseball camp and had to be hospitalized. His parents had noticed some symptoms crop up, including some weight loss. He still has to check his blood sugar levels during games, though he no longer has to take a finger-prick test to do so and instead uses Dexcom, a glucose monitoring system on his phone. Advertisement 'I have a few things that are connected to me. I have a pump,' he said, lifting his right sleeve to reveal it on his shoulder. 'During intermissions, I'm always checking it. Lots of snacks during the intermissions just to make sure I'm not going low during the game.' He also missed all of February last season with a lower-body injury. Hockey Canada — who were in touch with Harvey and Monsters goalie coach Brad Thiessen about Gardner through last season, even after they didn't invite him to selection camp — were impressed by how he managed the starter workload, how he played once he returned in March from his injury and how he played in his AHL debut. Harvey and Thiessen also raved about him to Dan De Palma, Team Canada's goalie coach. 'Evan's been playing good goal for a long time now, and I understand why he'd be disappointed (last December) and rightly so, but he just kept playing good,' De Palma said. 'Evan has earned it. He earned the right to be here, and arguably he could have been here before, but he's here now, which is great.' De Palma describes Gardner as a very sound, technical, competitive goalie who doesn't make mistakes. In working with him this week, he has found him to be very coachable as well. 'So he's got that talent, he's got that work ethic, and then he's able to continue to learn,' De Palma said. 'Really polite, respectful, engaging. He's just a super young man, and I've heard a lot about him from Jeff and Brad, and they couldn't speak highly enough about him, and I think he has even exceeded what I thought he would be.' De Palma, who was a small goalie himself, doesn't see size in his evaluations either. (With Gardner, George and Ivankovic, three of Canada's goalies at the summer showcase were on the smaller side.) 'I don't look at height, I don't look at a whole lot of that in terms of anything. It's just 'who's going to stop the puck?' and obviously there's more to it than that and that's oversimplified, and for sure a guy that's taller has a little bit of an advantage, but at the end of the day if he's the best guy for the job to help us win a gold medal then that's all that we care about,' De Palma said. Advertisement In his debut in the Red-White game, Gardner stopped 14 of 17 shots in a 4-3 shootout loss, but two of the goals came on the power play, and the other was with the opposing net empty. He also stopped the first five shots he faced in the shootout, before finally giving up the winner in the sixth round in a bit of a duel with Ravensbergen. Da Silva has always been most impressed by Gardner's ability to read plays. 'He's a very smart goaltender. He can read shooters really well, he can read how plays are developing and knows where everybody is on the ice and if there's guys backdoor or high slot. He's always got his head on a swivel, and he's always checking and scanning the ice,' he said. 'He's very sound positionally. He doesn't get out of position. You don't see him scrambling or sliding past his posts or getting out of position very much at all. He knows his crease very well, he knows his posts very well, and he just uses his size. He's very, very calm in there.' Gardner believes his skating is actually his No. 1 attribute. 'I'm able to put myself in spots, my habits, and the little things you can pick up on if you really watch me that I believe help set me up for success down the road and ahead of what's happening (in) the play,' he said. 'And then when it comes down to it, I just find a way to stop pucks, which is what everyone wants, right? I compete on it, and I just find a way to stop pucks.' Last year, Priestner estimated Gardner alone was probably worth a third of the Blades' wins. 'He's just so consistent. He rarely has a bad game, and if he does, it's a one-off,' Priestner said. 'He's so projectable because he's so consistent. He doesn't have those games where he's not very good; he's just always really good.' After one more year in the WHL with the Blades, they think he'll offer that for the Monsters and then the Blue Jackets someday, too. 'We're pretty biased, but he's a special goalie,' Priestner said. (Photos courtesy of Steve Hiscock / WHL)
Hamilton Spectator
a day ago
- Hamilton Spectator
‘If I had the opportunity to apologize to Mr. Lee I would': Final girl to be sentenced in fatal swarming of Kenneth Lee
The last girl to face sentencing in the death of Kenneth Lee says she takes full responsibility for her part in the swarming attack. After her tearful apology in Superior Court on Wednesday, the now 17-year-old girl learned it is unlikely she will return to jail, with the Crown agreeing she has served her time already. 'I wanted to apologize, even though I know it wouldn't make anything better. And if I had the opportunity to apologize to Mr. Lee, I would,' said the girl, crying as she stood before Justice Philip Campbell in a second-floor courtroom. The girl was previously found guilty of manslaughter, with Campbell ruling she had stabbed Lee, non-fatally, with a pair of small scissors. At the beginning of her trial, the girl attempted to plead guilty to manslaughter but it was rejected by the Crown in favour of prosecuting her for second-degree murder. At trial, the Crown unsuccessfully accused her of being responsible for dealing the fatal blow to Lee. Also apologizing to Lee's family and friends, the girl reflected on her youth at the time — she was 14 in December 2022 when she and seven others attacked Lee in a downtown parkette. She said she did not consider the consequences of drinking, smoking weed and participating in the assault. 'Since then I've been focused on changing for the better,' the girl read from a prepared statement, 'I know I'm on the right path now.' As she concluded, she said: 'I've also been grateful for the chance to prove I'm not taking my freedom for granted.' After hearing from one of the girl's defence lawyers Wednesday, the Crown said it had reassessed the credit the girl was owed for the 240 days she'd already spent in pre-trial custody, as well as being subjected to unconstitutional strip searching while in detention. Crown attorney Sarah De Filippis said any custodial sentence that was warranted had already been served. She argued instead for 16 months probation and a lengthier minimum participation in the support program. De Filippis said the girl should be commended for taking initiative to seek out supports after she was released on bail in August 2023, saying she is a strong case for rehabilitation — the primary purpose when sentencing young people under the Youth Criminal Justice Act. Crime scene photos show the parkette where Kenneth Lee was fatally stabbed taken by Toronto police in the hours after his murder. She reflected on the level of scrutiny placed on her and this prosecution, noting even a 'Law and Order: Toronto' episode was based on some of the facts in this case. The girl, she said, dealt with it 'admirably.' Defence counsel Kathryn Doyle told the court that any additional time in jail would prevent the girl from attending her new high school in the fall to complete Grade 12 and several community programs she actively participates in. Doyle told the court about the 'remarkable progress' the girl had made in accepting responsibility, addressing the underlying issues that led to her criminal behaviour and finding herself one semester away from being able to graduate high school. She referenced a psychological assessment filed with the court that documented that turnaround. Earlier in the hearing, the court heard how the girl came to have two small pairs of scissors when she was arrested shortly after the swarming. One of the assessments referred to her and some of the other girls shoplifting at a Shoppers Drug Mart where she stole popsicles and an eyebrow grooming kit containing a pair of scissors. Later, during the attack, cellphone video showed the girl bending to pick up a pair of scissors during one of the waves of assault on Lee. Doyle said it would be reasonable to infer some of the other girls had also stolen eyebrow kits and that the girl picked up an additional pair of scissors. At some point during the attack, Lee was fatally stabbed in the heart — something even he did not realize until he was more thoroughly examined by paramedics flagged down to the parkette. He died in hospital shortly after. Campbell earlier found the girl had wielded one of the two pairs of scissors she was arrested with and stabbed Lee with them, but that she did not deal the fatal blow. Much was made at the girl's trial about whether the pair of scissors or a knife — one was earlier seen in the hands of her companions on the subway system's surveillance footage — was capable of killing Lee. A knife was never recovered. None of the girls were found guilty of fatally stabbing him. All eight girls were originally charged with second-degree murder, but none were convicted of that offence. Six of the eight girls were ultimately guilty of manslaughter and two to lesser assault charges. The judge will make a sentencing decision in the girl's case on Friday. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
