With Lloyds shares red hot, investors should consider this AIM alternative
As Lloyds (LSE:LLOY) shares edges closer to what many investors would consider fair value, my attention is turning to alternative options in the UK banking sector. One AIM-listed name that stands out is Arbuthnot Banking Group (LSE:ARBB). It's much smaller, with a markedly different profile, but appears to be an attractive proposition.
And while Lloyds remains a staple for income and stability, Arbuthnot offers a blend of value, growth, and yield. This could appeal to investors seeking something beyond the big high street banks.
Looking at the numbers, the contrast between the two banks is striking. In 2025, Arbuthnot is forecast to deliver earnings per share (EPS) of 129.6p. At a share price of around 950p, this equates to a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 7.3.
This is a notable discount to Lloyds. The larger bank is expected to post EPS of 6.5p and trades on a forward P/E of 11.8 for the same year.
Moving to 2026, Arbuthnot's EPS is forecast to rise to 152.2p. This brings the P/E down to just 6.2. Meanwhile, Lloyds' EPS is expected to reach 9.1p, reducing its P/E to 8.4. By 2027, Arbuthnot's P/E is projected to fall to 5.5, compared to Lloyds at 7.
Arbuthnot also wins on the dividend yield. The bank's dividend per share is forecast at 53p in 2025, rising to 57p in 2026 and 61p in 2027. That translates to a yield of 5.6% in 2025, moving up to 6% in 2026 and 6.4% in 2027.
Lloyds, by comparison, is expected to pay out 3.4p per share in 2025, 4p in 2026, and 4.6p in 2027, for yields of 4.5%, 5.4%, and 6%, respectively. While Lloyds' income is well covered by earnings, Arbuthnot's payout ratios are similarly conservative. The latter's dividend cover is expected to remain above 1.9 times through the forecast period.
Moreover, Arbuthnot trades at a price-to-book ratio of just 0.54 in 2024, well below Lloyds at 0.75, and both are below the sector average, suggesting value in the shares.
Arbuthnot's revenue is expected to climb from £179.5m in 2024 to £182.6m in 2025, £193.7m in 2026, and £209.7m in 2027. Lloyds, meanwhile, is forecast to grow revenue from £18.4bn in 2024 to £19.4bn in 2025, and £22.1bn by 2027. In other words, I think we're looking at a similar growth story but just a very different size.
While the absolute numbers are not comparable, Arbuthnot's growth rate is strong, and it continues to grow its loan book and deposit base at a healthy clip. Recent results show deposits rising 17% year on year, with a stable loan book and a loan-to-deposit ratio of just 57%. By comparison, Lloyds's is over 90%.
However, Arbuthnot's size may heighten risks. It operates in a more specialised, relationship-driven niche and the economic outlook is uncertain, with the UK economy dragging and regulatory changes on the horizon.
Nonetheless, this stock certainly interests me. Investors may want to consider this alternative.
The post With Lloyds shares red hot, investors should consider this AIM alternative appeared first on The Motley Fool UK.
More reading
5 Stocks For Trying To Build Wealth After 50
One Top Growth Stock from the Motley Fool
James Fox has positions in Lloyds Banking Group Plc. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Lloyds Banking Group Plc. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.
Motley Fool UK 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
33 minutes ago
- Forbes
Newcastle United Already Facing Challenges In A Pivotal Summer Window
Newcastle United wanted Bryan Mbeumo and, by all accounts, believed the Cameroonian would be just as keen to move to St James' Park. This was before Manchester United made its interest known in Mbeumo with the Brentford attacker now seemingly on his way to Old Trafford. Newcastle quickly ditched its effort to sign the 25-year-old. The Magpies had also been linked with Matheus Cunha before being beaten to the punch on the signing of the Brazilian by Manchester United. A trend is developing of Newcastle losing out on its summer transfer targets to rivals that have more Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) headroom on the balance sheet. This is shaping up to be a pivotal summer for Newcastle. Last season was a positive one as Eddie Howe's team won the Carabao Cup and finished in the Premier League's top five to qualify for next season's Champions League. In theory, this should give Newcastle a platform to build on as the Saudi-owned club moves towards being an English soccer superpower. In Alexander Isak, Bruno Guimaraes and Sandro Tonali, Newcastle has three players it can continue to build around. In other areas of the squad, though, Howe needs reinforcements to push his team higher up the Premier League table next season. This is where this summer's transfer business will be key. Joao Pedro is reportedly a target for the Magpies. The Brazilian enjoyed a positive 2024/25 campaign for Brighton and has been linked with Liverpool. With the Premier League champions currently moving for Florian Wirtz, though, Newcastle could get a deal done for Pedro first. The race is on for the Brighton attacker's signature. Pedro is talented, but doesn't fill an obvious hole in Newcastle's team. He is most comfortable in a central position where the Magpies are already strong. Right wing, where Mbeumo operates, is a greater need, and Pedro is capable of playing there, but Newcastle's summer strategy so far has been somewhat scattergun. There is still plenty time for Newcastle to implement its summer transfer plans, although the departure of Paul Mitchell as the club's sporting director won't have helped matters. The Magpies have gone through two sporting directors, including Dan Ashworth, in the space of two years and so it's under surprising that their transfer strategy is somewhat garbled. Newcastle is technically the richest club in the world such is its backing from Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund (PIF), but progress to date has been slow due to the Premier League's PSR and other factors. This summer, however, presents an opportunity to accelerate growth.
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Here are three major retailers that have closed Glasgow stores this year
As we reach the halfway mark of 2025, we've put together a list of several major retailers that have closed down or are closing down their stores in Glasgow. Brands, including Superdry and Michael Kors, are among some of the retail giants to have shut down their shops in and around the city already. Meanwhile, other retailers, including Scotts, have announced they are set to close down stores in the city. Here are three beloved retailers which have closed down their stores across the city, and two which are set to shut down their stores: READ MORE: Major retailer suddenly closed down Glasgow Silverburn store READ MORE: Global retailer suddenly closed down Braehead storeSuperdry's former store in Silverburn Shopping Centre, Glasgow (Image: Newsquest) One major clothing retailer recently closed down one of its shops in Glasgow's Silverburn Shopping Centre, and another one of its branches in Brahead Shopping Centre in Renfrew, Renfrewshire. On June 9, we reported how Superdry had shut down its Silverburn store. A sign on the venue's window revealed the devastating news. It said: "This store is now closed. You can continue to shop the full collection at Braehead Shopping Centre, Renfrew (Image: Newsquest) Meanwhile, on June 10, we revealed how the global retailer had also shut its shop in Braehead, near Glasgow. A spokesperson for the leisure facility confirmed the news to the Glasgow Times. In a statement, they said: 'Superdry is leaving Braehead Shopping Centre and we wish the staff well for the future." READ MORE: Popular retailer announced closure of Glasgow Fort storeClosing down sign on Tessuti (left), image of Glasgow Fort (right) (Image: Newsquest) Another retailer which is set to close down its store at Glasgow's Fort is Tessuti. The established and popular clothing seller will be closing its shop at the East End shopping complex. Signage appeared on the store's window recently, confirming the sad news. It read: "Closing down. Up to 70 per cent off." It is unclear when the store will be closing down. READ MORE: Retail giant announced shock closure of Glasgow Fort storeClosing down sign on Scotts store at Glasgow Fort (Image: Newsquest) On top of Tessuti, another big retailer announced it would be closing down its store at Glasgow's Fort as well. On June 9, we reported that the retail giant Scotts revealed the shock closure of its store at the centre. A sign was placed on the shop's window confirming the news; however, it is unclear when the store will close its doors. READ MORE: World-renowned retailer suddenly 'closed' Glasgow store READ MORE: Global retailer speaks out after closure of Glasgow storeMichael Kors former shop on Glasgow's Buchanan Street (Image: Newsquest) In April, we reported how a world-renowned fashion brand mysteriously shut down its shop in Glasgow city centre. Michael Kors, known for its luxury handbags, shut its shop on Buchanan Street. Following its shock closure, the retailer told the Glasgow Times that its store on the Style Mile was 'currently closed'.Size? former store in Glasgow city centre (Image: Newsquest) READ MORE: Mystery as popular Glasgow store suddenly 'closes down' In January, popular streetwear retailer size? suddenly closed its Glasgow city centre store. The brand pulled down the shutters on its shop on Royal Exchange Square on Saturday, January 18. It was never revealed why the retailer decided to close down its city centre store.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
'We've tried to cut costs where we can'
A couple whose company sells car cleaning products around the world say the last 18 months have been the hardest of their 20 years in business. Autobrite Direct, based at Festival Park in Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, was set up by husband and wife Mark and Jill Moss in their garage in 2005. Despite experiencing huge growth from humble beginnings, the increased cost of living has forced them to adapt. "We've moved into manufacturing now, we've tried to cut costs where we can. We'll be alright, but it's not nice," Mrs Moss said. "We're lucky we've got a brand that's been established for 20 years," she added. When they set up the firm, Mark had been cleaning lorries for a living, but needed to take on something less strenuous after injuring his back. "Me and Mark are just dead normal people," Mrs Moss said. "We go in the warehouse, we pack orders, we fill bottles." Despite that, they were "very proud" of what they had built together, she said. She added that they were also heavily involved in the firm's social media marketing, which has meant people got to know them as well as their products. Mr Moss said: "We are the business. We deal with a lot of the local community, we get to speak to a lot of people." Follow BBC Stoke & Staffordshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram. 'Constantly cleaning' boy becomes celeb car washer Car wash provides mental health support for staff Autobrite
