Leading fund manager accuses Albanese govt of ‘gaslighting' Aussie taxpayers over its contested unrealised gains tax proposal
The Albanese government's proposal to double the tax rate to 30 per cent on funds in super accounts above $3 million has sparked fears for small business owners, farmers who hold properties in their self-managed super funds, and startup investors, who use SMSF's as an investment vehicle.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers has claimed the tax would initially only hit 80,000 Australians, which even Assistant Treasurer Daniel Mulino conceded was not true, estimating about 1.2 million, or 10 per cent of taxpayers, will pay the tax within 30 years.
However, Wilson Asset Management founder Geoff Wilson said he believes in 30 years' time more than half the workforce would be paying this tax on unrealised gains, predicting about 8.1 million Australians will be paying tax on 'imaginary gains' by 2055.
'Albanese and Chalmers are gaslighting the Australian people by saying it's only 80,000 people,' he told SkyNews.com.au.
Mr Wilson said having to pay tax on profits you may never make seemed 'immoral'.
'Chalmers is so desperate to get it through and won't see logical sense - either he has a death wish and doesn't want to stay as treasurer or he wants to use division 296 tax for housing and other investment shares,' Mr Wilson said.
He said the Albanese government had 'made all these promises and someone's gotta fund it', adding the tax was 'illogical' and 'badly thought out'.
It came after Australian Council of Trade Unions secretary Sally McManus told Channel 9 the tax on unrealised capital gains on super balances above $3 million had 'got to be indexed' to ensure more people 'don't end up' falling into the bracket.
'But that's a very long time in the future,' she said.
Newly appointed Shadow Finance Minister James Paterson said the policy was 'wrong in principle' and the Coalition would 'fight this every step."
'Unless the government was willing to walk away from the two key principles in this bill, which is taxing unrealised gains and failing to index the threshold, then there's no conceivable world in which we could support it,' Mr Paterson told Sky News on Tuesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
16 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
The quiet partnership behind a $1 billion superannuation collapse
As the sun set on 2018, two little-known fund managers were toasting the property deal of a lifetime – the bargain-basement purchase of a sprawling resort overlooking the Coral Sea in Port Douglas. The men, Falcon Capital's David Anderson and Paul Chiodo of Keystone Asset Management, had big dreams of turning the tired three-star hotel into a six-star luxury resort the likes of which had never been seen on Australian shores. Two years later, Chiodo and Anderson pulled off a coup by signing major hotel chain Accor to bring the first-ever ultra-luxury Fairmont resort to Australia and recruiting celebrity gardener Jamie Durie to help design the incredible complex. It would mark the start of a six-year rollercoaster business relationship between Anderson and Chiodo that ended in more public ignominy than either could have imagined. They are now under investigation by the corporate watchdog for criminal and civil breaches of their responsibilities as fund managers, including fraud, according to thousands of pages of documents filed in the Federal Court. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) compiled the dossier to convince a judge to freeze the assets of both men and ban them from leaving the country. The regulator has yet to launch substantive court proceedings against any of the players, and may not, but to win the orders, which are regarded as draconian, it had to show it would have a good case. Chiodo and Anderson did not appear at the hearings to oppose ASIC's applications but both deny the allegations, and neither has been charged as a result of ASIC's long-running investigation. Chiodo and Falcon (Anderson's company) both separately sought to stop liquidators taking control of their business, claiming they had been unfairly targeted. Anderson did consent to receivers being appointed over his personal assets, including his home, in April. What the public has not been aware of before is that Chiodo and Anderson have long been business partners and worked together to sow the seeds for what would become a $1 billion superannuation disaster for 12000 people across the country. Anderson's First Guardian Master Fund and Falcon Capital businesses have collapsed, likely wiping out the entirety of the $446 million in retirement savings invested in the fund. Chiodo's similarly sized Shield Master Fund and Keystone business have also collapsed, putting at risk $480 million in superannuation of their 6000 clients. ASIC suspects much of the super savings in the two funds had been squandered on pet projects, luxury cars and what the regulator says are unusual payments to the men's private companies. Both men have denied these allegations, saying ASIC has misunderstood their businesses and that its suspicions of mismanagement are unfounded and unfair. This masthead is not suggesting those allegations are true, just that they have been made as part of ASIC's long-running and ongoing investigation into the men. Liquidators are now picking through the wreckage of each group and have found many of the investments made by Anderson and Chiodo 'have no value', and returns for investors, particularly in the First Guardian business, are expected to be as low as 20 cents in the dollar or less. Now an investigation by this masthead has found deep ties between the men. Drawing from 7000 documents filed by the regulator in its cases against the men and information provided by more than a dozen sources working within associated businesses or familiar with the ASIC investigation, this masthead can reveal the two had for seven years been business partners and co-investors, including in six different property projects and investment group CF Capital. Anderson also invested one-fifth of First Guardian's funds – or $95 million – into Chiodo's property business and helped him restructure when it got into financial trouble in 2021. It can also be revealed that Anderson and Chiodo used the same investment scheme marketers and financial planners to promote their now failed funds as part of a plan to allow Anderson to recoup that $95 million investment in Chiodo's business. Chiodo confirmed to this masthead that he and Anderson had been joint venture partners in a range of projects over several years. But he insisted that - other than the $95 million investment - there were no existing ties between their businesses or the use of the same group of investment promoters, including financial planning group Venture Egg boss Ferras Merhi. He also said that he and Anderson had not been on good terms since around 2021. 'It's not linked, they [the funds] are not linked, it was not a case of 'hey Ferras can you help us out with our problem?'. There were separate agreements,' Chiodo said. The business partnership between Chiodo and Anderson brought together two different skill sets. Blue blood Anderson, 43, moved in the worlds of investment banking and high finance. At the age of 20 he told the Herald Sun that, while watching the 2000 tech stocks crash on the large electronic sharemarket boards in the foyer of the ASX building, he had predicted the rout: 'At least this crash is going to knock some sense into people.' After joining Falcon, by 2018 Anderson – a fine dining and craft beer fanatic – had amassed a large portfolio of farming land and wanted more deals, focusing his sights on property in Port Douglas. Chiodo, a man with equally large aspirations, was there to help. From a blue-collar background, Chiodo had been working in property development for years, initially in mid-sized residential projects in Melbourne and a high-end set of apartments in Port Douglas. He was also looking for new deals, and when the large resort property in the tropical idyll came on the market in late 2018, the pair agreed to team up to buy it. Loading The $300 million project would need a lot of money to succeed. To help fulfil the dream development, Anderson and Chiodo set up a property fund to bring in new investors. That fund would hold the Port Douglas resort project, five of Chiodo's smaller-scale residential developments in the holiday town and smaller ones in the Melbourne suburbs of Glenroy, Ashburton, Bentleigh and Doncaster East. Anderson's First Guardian would manage the fund as trustee, invest $95 million and help bring in investors and grow the fund to $500 million. In 2019, Anderson and Chiodo set up another business, CF Capital. It was owned by First Guardian, operated by Chiodo and licensed under Falcon's financial services licence. Chiodo told this masthead that, at the time, he and Anderson relied on the marketing skills of Sean Niven, a former senior manager within collapsed property investment group Westpoint, to draw customers into the fund. Niven had introduced the two men, Chiodo told this masthead. At the time, Niven had just exited bankruptcy, and it is not suggested he handled money for either Chiodo or Anderson. Years later Niven would be banned from working in financial services. Niven is not under investigation by ASIC in relation to the current scheme, and not accused of wrongdoing in relation to it. The arrangement between the trio was going well until about mid-2021, when the pandemic inflated costs and pushed out the timelines of the fund's property projects. Niven has also pleaded guilty to lying to his bankruptcy trustee in 2020. Soon cracks emerged between Anderson and his board over First Guardian's hefty investment in the Chiodo fund, documents obtained by this masthead indicate. Under pressure from Anderson's board at Falcon Capital, Anderson and Chiodo decided to cut most of the ties between the two groups – First Guardian would sell the CF business and pass on oversight of Chiodo's fund to Chiodo. Minutes from a Falcon board meeting in February 2022 show the relationship between Chiodo and Falcon's board had frayed and that Anderson told the Falcon board he would sever ties with Chiodo. 'The [Chiodo fund] was restructured due to its dire financial position. The handover of trustee services went well,' the minutes note. They also record an audit report had deemed the fund 'insufficient and inconclusive'. The minutes show Chiodo initiated a statutory demand in the Supreme Court of Victoria against First Guardian for not making payments to him as required under their business arrangements. 'This was deemed … to be delusional, and highly unlikely to succeed. Chiodo played down this pathway to avert his creditors from going after him and to divert attention toward First Guardian. FGC [First Guardian Capital] was ahead in terms of its investment flows ... FGC was not in a debt position but rather equity. 'DA [David Anderson] stated that Chiodo had withdrawn the Stat Demand. 'It is now deemed that [Chiodo] is a hostile manager and that a full redemption program would be set in train by DA.' This masthead asked Chiodo if his fund was in trouble and that was why he made the claim. Loading 'What a load of crap!!! This was purely FGC [First Guardian Capital] not willing to honour our settlement agreement,' he said. Anderson would go on to devise a redemption plan to recoup First Guardian's investment in Chiodo's fund by quickly driving thousands of customers into Chiodo's business. Details of this plan have been confirmed by three sources familiar with First Guardian business and correlate with Falcon's board minutes and a timeline presented by ASIC to the court as part of its actions against Chiodo and Anderson. Under the plan, Chiodo established the Shield Master Fund to bring in new investors. That new fund then absorbed Chiodo's financially troubled property investment vehicle. To supercharge the business, Anderson put Chiodo in touch with Merhi and his business partner Osama 'Sammy' Saad. Merhi and Saad would bring in social media marketing expert Rashid Alshakshir, the former business partner of feared outlaw bikie Hasan Topal. Alshakshir, Merhi and Saad would devise a customer funnel, using social media ads encouraging people to 'find their lost super' or consolidate multiple accounts. Ultimately, it drove customers to Merhi and Saad's financial planning business and then onto Chiodo and Anderson's funds. There is no suggestion that Merhi, Saad and Alshakshir had knowledge of the fund's investments or any misuse of their clients' money, only that ASIC is investigating whether they breached obligations to their clients as financial advisers. As Chiodo's fund grew to $480 million, Anderson had the chance to recoup First Guardian's $95 million in the fund. He never did. Chiodo insisted to this masthead that his and Anderson's use of the same marketing strategy was not a joint plan. Instead, he said: 'David was trying to convince Ferras to allocate a greater portion [of customers] to his fund in order to cover David's need for the redemption.' Anderson and Chiodo would pay out $100 million – or 10 per cent of the money invested with them – to their marketing crew, who now drove Bentleys and other flash cars and had upgraded to lovely homes in Melbourne's better northern suburbs. As the funds swelled with super savings, both men allegedly went on a spending spree using other people's money. Anderson bought a dream home in Melbourne's leafy Hawthorn overlooking the Yarra River and pumped millions into fine dining restaurants via a business arrangement with celebrity chef Scott Pickett and, separately, set up two restaurants in inner Melbourne, one a South-east Asian eatery with 18 craft beers on tap. Chiodo would burn millions pulling together a portfolio of wish-list luxury development proposals in K'gari, Fiji and Venice, rent a corporate box at the MCG and host events with sporting stars like Floyd Mayweather and Josh Giddey. When ASIC came knocking on Chiodo's door in late 2023, Anderson was suddenly focused on First Guardian's investment in the Chiodo fund. In May 2024 Anderson attempted to sell the investment to an American group which never paid, and the investment remained within the Shield fund. Whether that investment, like many others made by Anderson and Chiodo, will ever be reclaimed for investors remains to be seen. Loading As for the property in Port Douglas, despite Chiodo claiming to have spent more than $70 million on works to build the resort, the project was never developed. Earlier this year receivers appointed agents to sell the property on behalf of its lenders. No return is expected for Chiodo's investors from the sale.
The Age
16 minutes ago
- The Age
The quiet partnership behind a $1 billion superannuation collapse
As the sun set on 2018, two little-known fund managers were toasting the property deal of a lifetime – the bargain-basement purchase of a sprawling resort overlooking the Coral Sea in Port Douglas. The men, Falcon Capital's David Anderson and Paul Chiodo of Keystone Asset Management, had big dreams of turning the tired three-star hotel into a six-star luxury resort the likes of which had never been seen on Australian shores. Two years later, Chiodo and Anderson pulled off a coup by signing major hotel chain Accor to bring the first-ever ultra-luxury Fairmont resort to Australia and recruiting celebrity gardener Jamie Durie to help design the incredible complex. It would mark the start of a six-year rollercoaster business relationship between Anderson and Chiodo that ended in more public ignominy than either could have imagined. They are now under investigation by the corporate watchdog for criminal and civil breaches of their responsibilities as fund managers, including fraud, according to thousands of pages of documents filed in the Federal Court. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) compiled the dossier to convince a judge to freeze the assets of both men and ban them from leaving the country. The regulator has yet to launch substantive court proceedings against any of the players, and may not, but to win the orders, which are regarded as draconian, it had to show it would have a good case. Chiodo and Anderson did not appear at the hearings to oppose ASIC's applications but both deny the allegations, and neither has been charged as a result of ASIC's long-running investigation. Chiodo and Falcon (Anderson's company) both separately sought to stop liquidators taking control of their business, claiming they had been unfairly targeted. Anderson did consent to receivers being appointed over his personal assets, including his home, in April. What the public has not been aware of before is that Chiodo and Anderson have long been business partners and worked together to sow the seeds for what would become a $1 billion superannuation disaster for 12000 people across the country. Anderson's First Guardian Master Fund and Falcon Capital businesses have collapsed, likely wiping out the entirety of the $446 million in retirement savings invested in the fund. Chiodo's similarly sized Shield Master Fund and Keystone business have also collapsed, putting at risk $480 million in superannuation of their 6000 clients. ASIC suspects much of the super savings in the two funds had been squandered on pet projects, luxury cars and what the regulator says are unusual payments to the men's private companies. Both men have denied these allegations, saying ASIC has misunderstood their businesses and that its suspicions of mismanagement are unfounded and unfair. This masthead is not suggesting those allegations are true, just that they have been made as part of ASIC's long-running and ongoing investigation into the men. Liquidators are now picking through the wreckage of each group and have found many of the investments made by Anderson and Chiodo 'have no value', and returns for investors, particularly in the First Guardian business, are expected to be as low as 20 cents in the dollar or less. Now an investigation by this masthead has found deep ties between the men. Drawing from 7000 documents filed by the regulator in its cases against the men and information provided by more than a dozen sources working within associated businesses or familiar with the ASIC investigation, this masthead can reveal the two had for seven years been business partners and co-investors, including in six different property projects and investment group CF Capital. Anderson also invested one-fifth of First Guardian's funds – or $95 million – into Chiodo's property business and helped him restructure when it got into financial trouble in 2021. It can also be revealed that Anderson and Chiodo used the same investment scheme marketers and financial planners to promote their now failed funds as part of a plan to allow Anderson to recoup that $95 million investment in Chiodo's business. Chiodo confirmed to this masthead that he and Anderson had been joint venture partners in a range of projects over several years. But he insisted that - other than the $95 million investment - there were no existing ties between their businesses or the use of the same group of investment promoters, including financial planning group Venture Egg boss Ferras Merhi. He also said that he and Anderson had not been on good terms since around 2021. 'It's not linked, they [the funds] are not linked, it was not a case of 'hey Ferras can you help us out with our problem?'. There were separate agreements,' Chiodo said. The business partnership between Chiodo and Anderson brought together two different skill sets. Blue blood Anderson, 43, moved in the worlds of investment banking and high finance. At the age of 20 he told the Herald Sun that, while watching the 2000 tech stocks crash on the large electronic sharemarket boards in the foyer of the ASX building, he had predicted the rout: 'At least this crash is going to knock some sense into people.' After joining Falcon, by 2018 Anderson – a fine dining and craft beer fanatic – had amassed a large portfolio of farming land and wanted more deals, focusing his sights on property in Port Douglas. Chiodo, a man with equally large aspirations, was there to help. From a blue-collar background, Chiodo had been working in property development for years, initially in mid-sized residential projects in Melbourne and a high-end set of apartments in Port Douglas. He was also looking for new deals, and when the large resort property in the tropical idyll came on the market in late 2018, the pair agreed to team up to buy it. Loading The $300 million project would need a lot of money to succeed. To help fulfil the dream development, Anderson and Chiodo set up a property fund to bring in new investors. That fund would hold the Port Douglas resort project, five of Chiodo's smaller-scale residential developments in the holiday town and smaller ones in the Melbourne suburbs of Glenroy, Ashburton, Bentleigh and Doncaster East. Anderson's First Guardian would manage the fund as trustee, invest $95 million and help bring in investors and grow the fund to $500 million. In 2019, Anderson and Chiodo set up another business, CF Capital. It was owned by First Guardian, operated by Chiodo and licensed under Falcon's financial services licence. Chiodo told this masthead that, at the time, he and Anderson relied on the marketing skills of Sean Niven, a former senior manager within collapsed property investment group Westpoint, to draw customers into the fund. Niven had introduced the two men, Chiodo told this masthead. At the time, Niven had just exited bankruptcy, and it is not suggested he handled money for either Chiodo or Anderson. Years later Niven would be banned from working in financial services. Niven is not under investigation by ASIC in relation to the current scheme, and not accused of wrongdoing in relation to it. The arrangement between the trio was going well until about mid-2021, when the pandemic inflated costs and pushed out the timelines of the fund's property projects. Niven has also pleaded guilty to lying to his bankruptcy trustee in 2020. Soon cracks emerged between Anderson and his board over First Guardian's hefty investment in the Chiodo fund, documents obtained by this masthead indicate. Under pressure from Anderson's board at Falcon Capital, Anderson and Chiodo decided to cut most of the ties between the two groups – First Guardian would sell the CF business and pass on oversight of Chiodo's fund to Chiodo. Minutes from a Falcon board meeting in February 2022 show the relationship between Chiodo and Falcon's board had frayed and that Anderson told the Falcon board he would sever ties with Chiodo. 'The [Chiodo fund] was restructured due to its dire financial position. The handover of trustee services went well,' the minutes note. They also record an audit report had deemed the fund 'insufficient and inconclusive'. The minutes show Chiodo initiated a statutory demand in the Supreme Court of Victoria against First Guardian for not making payments to him as required under their business arrangements. 'This was deemed … to be delusional, and highly unlikely to succeed. Chiodo played down this pathway to avert his creditors from going after him and to divert attention toward First Guardian. FGC [First Guardian Capital] was ahead in terms of its investment flows ... FGC was not in a debt position but rather equity. 'DA [David Anderson] stated that Chiodo had withdrawn the Stat Demand. 'It is now deemed that [Chiodo] is a hostile manager and that a full redemption program would be set in train by DA.' This masthead asked Chiodo if his fund was in trouble and that was why he made the claim. Loading 'What a load of crap!!! This was purely FGC [First Guardian Capital] not willing to honour our settlement agreement,' he said. Anderson would go on to devise a redemption plan to recoup First Guardian's investment in Chiodo's fund by quickly driving thousands of customers into Chiodo's business. Details of this plan have been confirmed by three sources familiar with First Guardian business and correlate with Falcon's board minutes and a timeline presented by ASIC to the court as part of its actions against Chiodo and Anderson. Under the plan, Chiodo established the Shield Master Fund to bring in new investors. That new fund then absorbed Chiodo's financially troubled property investment vehicle. To supercharge the business, Anderson put Chiodo in touch with Merhi and his business partner Osama 'Sammy' Saad. Merhi and Saad would bring in social media marketing expert Rashid Alshakshir, the former business partner of feared outlaw bikie Hasan Topal. Alshakshir, Merhi and Saad would devise a customer funnel, using social media ads encouraging people to 'find their lost super' or consolidate multiple accounts. Ultimately, it drove customers to Merhi and Saad's financial planning business and then onto Chiodo and Anderson's funds. There is no suggestion that Merhi, Saad and Alshakshir had knowledge of the fund's investments or any misuse of their clients' money, only that ASIC is investigating whether they breached obligations to their clients as financial advisers. As Chiodo's fund grew to $480 million, Anderson had the chance to recoup First Guardian's $95 million in the fund. He never did. Chiodo insisted to this masthead that his and Anderson's use of the same marketing strategy was not a joint plan. Instead, he said: 'David was trying to convince Ferras to allocate a greater portion [of customers] to his fund in order to cover David's need for the redemption.' Anderson and Chiodo would pay out $100 million – or 10 per cent of the money invested with them – to their marketing crew, who now drove Bentleys and other flash cars and had upgraded to lovely homes in Melbourne's better northern suburbs. As the funds swelled with super savings, both men allegedly went on a spending spree using other people's money. Anderson bought a dream home in Melbourne's leafy Hawthorn overlooking the Yarra River and pumped millions into fine dining restaurants via a business arrangement with celebrity chef Scott Pickett and, separately, set up two restaurants in inner Melbourne, one a South-east Asian eatery with 18 craft beers on tap. Chiodo would burn millions pulling together a portfolio of wish-list luxury development proposals in K'gari, Fiji and Venice, rent a corporate box at the MCG and host events with sporting stars like Floyd Mayweather and Josh Giddey. When ASIC came knocking on Chiodo's door in late 2023, Anderson was suddenly focused on First Guardian's investment in the Chiodo fund. In May 2024 Anderson attempted to sell the investment to an American group which never paid, and the investment remained within the Shield fund. Whether that investment, like many others made by Anderson and Chiodo, will ever be reclaimed for investors remains to be seen. Loading As for the property in Port Douglas, despite Chiodo claiming to have spent more than $70 million on works to build the resort, the project was never developed. Earlier this year receivers appointed agents to sell the property on behalf of its lenders. No return is expected for Chiodo's investors from the sale.
Sky News AU
16 minutes ago
- Sky News AU
Australia is ‘rewarding Hamas' with Palestinian recognition
Former Israeli government spokesperson Eylon Levy says Australia is 'rewarding Hamas' for October 7 with Palestinian recognition. 'I hope the Australian government is holding some serious crisis talks to discuss how on Earth they ended up on the same side as a globally prescribed terrorist jihadi organisation,' Mr Levy told Sky News host Andrew Bolt. 'Australia is rewarding Hamas for the October 7 massacre.'
