Andy Cohen officially says goodbye to NYC penthouse of 20 years

New York Post

9 hours ago

From Bravo to Broadway, Andy Cohen is officially saying goodbye to his longtime home.
Emmy-winning playwright and screenwriter Danny Strong and his partner, actor and producer Caitlin Mehner, have officially closed on Cohen's longtime West Village penthouse duplex for its full $12 million asking price, The Post has learned.
The deal, which was finalized on June 26, caps a swift transaction that entered contract just over a month earlier.
11 Emmy-winning playwright and screenwriter Danny Strong and his partner, actor/producer Caitlin Mehner, have officially closed on Andy Cohen's penthouse duplex at 2 Horatio Street for its $12 million asking price.
Getty Images for Prime Video
The 3,500-square-foot co-op, located at 2 Horatio Street, was assembled over two decades by Cohen, the Bravo star and producer behind 'Watch What Happens Live' and 'Top Chef.'
Designed by architect Gordon Kahn with interiors by Eric Hughes, the home is known for its bold use of color, sweeping views of Manhattan landmarks, and dramatic custom details — including a sculptural walnut, steel and glass staircase connecting its two levels.
11 The 3,500-square-foot West Village co-op, which overlooks Jackson Square Park, entered into contract in May after eight months on the market and initially listed for $14 million.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
Strong, whose musical Chess heads to Broadway this fall, called the duplex 'my dream home,' previously telling The Post, 'We are so excited to be moving there.'
He and Mehner, new parents to a 7-month-old daughter, had been looking for more space to accommodate their growing family.
11 Designed by architect Gordon Kahn with interiors by Eric Hughes, the home includes a chef's kitchen, a nanny's room, and a glass-and-steel staircase leading to a home office.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
11 It features 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, two fireplaces, and striking details like a gold-tiled bar, marble fireplaces, and a spa-like main bathroom with Empire State Building views.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
11 The couple, now parents to a 7-month-old daughter, cited their growing family as a reason for the move.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
The purchase also marks a bit of a real estate shuffle.
Strong is in contract to sell his current residence at 299 West 12th Street — the sam Emery Roth-designed building where Cohen just purchased a new penthouse for $18.21 million, The Post reported.
That unit reportedly features over 2,000 square feet of outdoor space, something Cohen had long been seeking.
'Outdoor space was the decision! I always have coveted outdoor space,' Cohen told People. 'There is a dearth of inventory in the West Village with outdoor space, so when I found something that was meaningful enough for me to leave my dream apartment … that's what it took.'
11 The residence occupies 3,500 square feet.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
11 Strong, who wrote 'Empire,' 'Dopesick,' and two 'Hunger Games' films, is also in contract to sell his unit at 299 W. 12th Street—ironically, the same building where Cohen just bought a new $18.21 million penthouse.
Oliver Rodriguez/Shutterstock
11 The wet bar.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
The sale also marked a professional milestone for real estate broker and former Million Dollar Listing New York star Ryan Serhant, who shared news of the contract on Instagram back in May.
'Congrats @bravoandy,' he wrote, adding, 'Thanks for trusting me and @serhant with your home.' Serhant later told The New York Times, 'It's one of those treasures that you wait your whole career for.'
Cohen had initially listed the property for $14 million in September 2024 before cutting the price by $2 million earlier this year.
The duplex ultimately found a buyer after about eight months on the market.
11 A living space.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
11 One of two fireplaces in the home.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
11 An ensuite bathroom.
Eytan Stern Weber, Evan Joseph Images
Serhant and Donna Strugatz of Serhant represented the listing, while Jonathan Stein of Douglas Elliman represented Strong.
Inside, the home features 4.5 bathrooms, two wood-burning fireplaces, wide-plank oak floors, and 25 windows offering views of Jackson Square Park, the Empire State Building, and the Chrysler Building.
The main suite boasts a custom dressing room, a corner bath with a teak soaking tub, and a marble steam shower. Other highlights include a lacquered bar, a gold-tiled powder room, and a chef's kitchen with cobalt blue cabinetry.
Strong is best known for scripting Recount, The Butler, Dopesick, and two Hunger Games films.