Latest Home Run Derby winners prove contest curse is a myth
The theory goes that the high-intensity, maximum-effort swings in the Derby throw off a player's mechanics, leading to slumps. However, a closer look at the past four Derby winners debunks this notion. Data shows that the curse is largely overstated, and Seattle's Cal Raleigh remains a strong power asset for fantasy managers in the second half of 2025.
Let's begin with last season's winner, Teoscar Hernández, who stepped into the Derby after batting .261 with 19 home runs and 62 RBIs in the first half of the season. He finished the first round with 19 homers, won a swing-off in Round 2 to advance to the finals, then narrowly edged out Bobby Witt with another 14 home runs to earn the title.
3 Cal Raleigh #29 of the Seattle Mariners celebrates with teammates after scoring during the eighth inning against the Houston Astros at T-Mobile Park on July 18, 2025 in Seattle, Washington.
Getty Images
Typically a mid-tier power guy whose career-best 32-homer mark in 2021, the year MLB basically used a golf ball, Hernández went on to produce just as well in the second half. His strikeout rate remained well within the range of his career norms, and his batting average actually jumped 20 points.
In 2023, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. won the Derby and also showed no signs of a curse. In the first half, he posted a .274 average with 13 home runs and a 15.6 percent strikeout rate.
Post-Derby saw a slight dip in average, but he also hit the same number of homers in fewer games and dropped his strikeout rate to just 13.4 percent. A high-quality hitter, Guerrero never changed.
3 Teoscar Hernandez #37 of the Los Angeles Dodgers warms up prior to the game against the Milwaukee Brewers at Dodger Stadium on July 18, 2025 in Los Angeles, California.
Getty Images
Juan Soto's 2022 Derby win is often cited as evidence of the curse, but context matters. In the first half with Washington, Soto hit .250 with 20 home runs, 43 RBIs, and a 13.7 percent strikeout rate. After winning the Derby, he was traded to San Diego, and his second-half stats dipped to a .231 average with just seven home runs and a 15.5 percent strikeout rate. Not a steep decline in plate discipline, but the power was sapped by the cavernous dimensions of Petco Park. But was it the Derby that led to the reduced numbers, or was this decline more about adjusting to a new team and environment?
Pete Alonso, the 2021 Derby winner, further debunks the myth as he carried his momentum into the second half with more homers in fewer games, better plate discipline numbers overall and a batting average increase by almost 30 points. Fantasy managers who bet on Alonso's power were rewarded.
3 Juan Soto strikes out swinging in the 7th inning at Citi Field for David Wright Day at Citi Field in Queens, New York, USA, Saturday, July 19, 2025.
JASON SZENES FOR THE NEW YORK POST
The data is clear. Three of the past four Derby winners either maintained or improved their performance post-Derby, with Soto's dip explained by external factors. For Raleigh, his power profile, plate discipline and switch-hitting ability make him a safe bet to avoid any mythical curse. Fantasy managers should confidently roster him, expecting robust home run and RBI contributions in the second half of 2025. The Home Run Derby is a showcase of power, not a swing wrecker.
Howard Bender is the head of content at FantasyAlarm.com. Follow him on X @rotobuzzguy and catch him on the award-winning 'Fantasy Alarm Radio Show' on the SiriusXM fantasy sports channel weekdays from 6-8 p.m. Go to FantasyAlarm.com for all your fantasy baseball news and advice.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
23 minutes ago
- Forbes
The New York Knicks Hit A Home Run With This Offseason Move
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA - JANUARY 15: Guerschon Yabusele #28 of the Philadelphia 76ers talks to ... More Jalen Brunson #11 of the New York Knicks at the Wells Fargo Center on January 15, 2025 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Knicks defeated the 76ers 125-119 in overtime. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and/or using this photograph, user is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. (Photo by) I know it has been nearly a month since it happened, but I still cannot stop thinking about how great an addition it was for the New York Knicks to sign Guerschon Yabusele. We'll get to the specifics in just a moment. But here is the short of it: he addresses one of their most pressing issues, helps bolster a strategy that worked well for them last postseason, and came to them at an absolute bargain compared to his actual production. Yabusele Gives The Knicks Bench Some Much Needed Depth While it turned out that their bench wasn't as terrible as Tom Thibodeau's Machiavellian treatment of the starters would suggest, they still didn't have much bite once the starters left the floor. Last season, the Knicks ranked dead-last in bench points per game, and based on the chart below, it wasn't even close: Yabusele will step in and immediately become their bullpen's best reliever. According to Estimated Plus-Minus (arguably the best one-number metric on the market because it incorporates tracking data), Yabusele placed in the 84th percentile in the entire league on the offensive side of the ball (per Dunks & Threes). That ranks higher than any non-starter from last year's Knicks team. Heck, that ranks higher than everyone not named Jalen Brunson or Karl-Anthony Towns. Yabusele Lets The Knicks Play More Double Big Lineups One of the biggest leaguewide storylines from last season was the re-emergence of double big lineups. All across the league, teams were having success with two titans in the frontcourt. The Knicks were not immune to this trend, as they posted a net rating of +8.3 in the 165 minutes that Towns and Mitchell Robinson shared the floor (per PBP Stats). For those who aren't hyper familiar with Yabusele's game, he is like the Diet Coke version of Towns. He's a big man who can hit triples (38%), put the ball on the floor (97th percentile true shooting on drives, per and offer some playmaking/passing (52nd percentile Passer Rating). Even a lesser version of this player archetype is incredibly valuable because it allows your team to go double big alongside a traditional center (i.e., Robinson) without sacrificing floor spacing. Yabusele gives the Knicks another key to unlocking their best lineup. Now, the Knicks have more lineup versatility/flexibility in the event that one of Towns/Robinson is injured or gets into foul trouble. Yabusele's Contract Is A Steal For The Knicks Yabusele signed with the Knicks for a little less than the full taxpayer mid-level exception. To be exact, his average annual value (AAV) over the next two years will be 5.6 million dollars (per Spotrac). However, based on my formula for estimating production value, if Yabusele can emulate his numbers from 2024-25, he will be worth roughly 14.1 million dollars in 2025-26. That difference of 8.5 million dollars makes him one of the five best value signings of the offseason thus far (to see the rest of those contracts, be sure to check out this link here). With most of their assets tied up in their formidable starting five, the Knicks faced a nearly impossible mission: trying to improve a bench with limited resources to do so. To be fair, the job still isn't finished (insert Kobe Bryant snippet). The Knicks could use one more two-way wing to complete their ten-man rotation (they would do well to re-sign Landry Shamet or sign Amir Coffey). But if this does end up being it for them, the Knicks did a great job adding a perfect-fitting piece to a team that came two wins away from the NBA Finals.
NBC Sports
an hour ago
- NBC Sports
Seattle's Cal Raleigh calls his 40th homer ‘a cool milestone' during the catcher's historic season
Cal Raleigh reached another landmark in his incredible season Saturday night when he drilled his 40th home run deep into the right field bleachers at Angel Stadium. Becoming the seventh catcher in major league history to hit 40 homers has been all but inevitable for Raleigh ever since the Seattle Mariners slugger got to the All-Star break with 38 — and then won the Home Run Derby. Raleigh still felt the 40th was special, mostly because it broke a tie and propelled the Mariners to a valuable 7-2 victory in their playoff chase. 'It's a cool milestone to hit, and I'm very thankful for it, and it's a cool moment for sure,' Raleigh said. 'I look back to 20 or 30, and that was cool, and 40 is definitely very cool as well. I'm not trying to downplay it, but I'm glad we got the win tonight, and I'll look back one day and it will be cool.' Raleigh is the first player in the majors to hit 40 this season, doing it before the calendar even turns to August. He crushed a 2-0 fastball from struggling Angels reliever José Fermin, driving it 416 feet with a 113.5-mph exit velocity. The shot put the Mariners up 3-2, and they added three more runs in the inning to take control of their second win in three games in Anaheim. 'I'm sure it feels great to get to 40,' Seattle manager Dan Wilson said. 'I'm sure he wants to get to 41 as soon as possible, because he knows it helps us win ballgames, and at this point, that's what he's looking for. Knowing Cal, he wants us to win. But a big milestone for sure. The season, the numbers that he's put up is pretty staggering. This is just another one of those notches on the belt.' Although he was the Mariners' designated hitter Saturday, Raleigh joined an elite club of hitters who primarily played catcher during their 40-homer seasons. Johnny Bench and Mike Piazza did it twice, while Roy Campanella, Todd Hundley and Javy Lopez were joined in 2021 by Kansas City's Salvador Perez, who set the single-season record for catchers with 48. Perez's mark is eminently reachable for Raleigh, who would need to average just one homer a week for the rest of the regular season to top it. Raleigh is only the fifth player in Mariners history to hit 40 homers, and he joins elite Pacific Northwest company: Ken Griffey Jr., Alex Rodriguez, Nelson Cruz and Jay Buhner. 'They're really good players,' Raleigh said. 'They're some of the best that's ever come through here, so very honored to be a part of that group. It's a cool thing. Just try to keep going and see how far we can take it.' Raleigh also tied Griffey (1998) for the most homers in Seattle history through 105 games of a season while becoming only the eighth player in major league history to hit 40 in his team's first 105 games — just the second to do it in the 21st century, joining Aaron Judge (2022). Raleigh even reached his latest landmark on a day when his AL MVP candidacy indirectly got a boost: Judge, the obvious front-runner for his third award in four seasons, went on the 10-day injured list with a flexor strain in his right elbow — although the Yankees superstar's absence isn't currently expected to be lengthy. Raleigh's production has actually slowed in July. He came into Saturday night's game batting .162 with just 11 hits in 18 games this month, although six of those hits were homers. Raleigh had two hits and struck out three times Saturday night, but Wilson has seen progress in Raleigh's approach at the plate in recent days. 'I think for the most part, it's an adjustment period,' Wilson said. 'Teams start to pitch around you a little bit, and I think you become aware of that and start making the adjustments there. But I think he's just been very consistent pretty much all this season, and I think that's what's been so great for me to see, and for all of us to benefit from. He's just been so consistent, and to do this while raising his batting average at the same time, pretty incredible.'
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Cowboys give tight end Jake Ferguson $52M extension as Micah Parsons waits for payday
The Cowboys settled up with one of their young stars, as maybe their brightest still awaits a new deal. The Dallas and starting tight end Jake Ferguson agreed to a four-year, $52 million extension, the team announced Sunday. NFL Network's Ian Rappaport first broke the news. The signing marks Ferguson as the highest-paid tight end in franchise history, and also includes a guaranteed $30 million, along with a signing bonus worth $12 million. Even with the deal done, the Cowboys still have a lingering contract issue with defensive star Micah Parsons. Advertisement Ferguson, 26, was a fourth-round pick in the 2022 NFL Draft out of Wisconsin, selected No. 129 overall. 3 Jake Ferguson catches a pass in the endzone during the fourth quarter against the Washington Commanders at AT&T Stadium on January 05, 2025 in Arlington, Texas. Getty Images Over 47 career appearances, including 38 starts, he has recorded 149 receptions for 1,429 yards and seven touchdowns. Advertisement His best showing came in 2023 with a Pro Bowl season, where he put up 71 catches, 761 yards, and five touchdowns. Last year, his numbers dipped to 59 receptions for 494 yards across 14 starts, and he did not record a touchdown all season long. Despite the down year, Ferguson lands the extension, securing his role as the Cowboys' starting tight end long-term as he enters his prime years. 3 Jake Ferguson has agreed to an extension with Dallas. Getty Images Advertisement Ferguson's extension puts him as the seventh-highest paid tight end in the NFL, and also guarantees he's signed through at least 2028. Star defender Micah Parsons still awaits his extension. The stud edge rusher is not yet at training camp, hoping that a new lucrative extension blesses his bank account before the start of the season. 3 Micah Parsons looks on from the field against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers at AT&T Stadium on December 22, 2024 in Arlington, Texas. Getty Images Advertisement To date, there is no commitment from Dallas, and the fans aren't letting team owner Jerry Jones forget it. Fans heckled Jones at camp over the weekend, and are pleading for the team to ink Parsons long-term. Parsons is entering the last year of his rookie contract, making roughly $24 million this season, and is slated to hit free agency following the 2025 campaign. The Cowboys finished 7-10 last season, in what was an injury-riddled disappointment, missing the playoffs for the first time since 2020.
