Is the DA's call for policing power devolution just a cop-out?
Image: Ian Cameron/Facebook/Supplied
The DA's repeated call for the devolution of policing powers is facing sharp scrutiny with one political analyst labelling it a copout.
The debate surrounding devolution reemerged over the weekend after Portfolio Committee on Police chairperson Ian Cameron (DA), attended a ride-along in Manenberg.
Cameron posted on social media about his ride-along which he undertook with fellow DA MPs Lisa Schickerling and Nicholas Gotsell, and how they joined the Special Operations team of the City of Cape Town's metro police in Manenberg and surrounds on Friday.
'I am a firm believer that they should have more policing powers. Why wouldn't we allow this brilliant group of people to be able to do more? Just imagine if we could do something like ballistic testing and gang violence investigation, decentralised? The impact for communities that suffer under the scourge of violence would be significant,' Cameron said.
'...It's so exciting to see the work that they do, along with law enforcement, and of course, the renowned LEAP programme.
'I want to zoom in on Metro (Police), this past week I brought a motion in Parliament to ask once again that the Minister of Police (Senzo Mchunu) please give more policing power to Metro Police.
'It is significant because (they) not only do incredible work on the ground, but if they have more policing power, they could actually put more people behind bars, and keep them there…
'Imagine if they could do more investigations, or if they could do some of the ballistic testing? The legislation already allows for this,' Cameron said.
In another post, Cameron elaborated that municipal officers may currently arrest and confiscate weapons but cannot build court-ready case dockets.
He said that function is reserved for SAPS, 'where backlogs, skill shortages, and delays continue to cause severe disruptions in justice being served, if at all.'
'The Police Minister has the power to change this immediately. Under the SAPS Act, he can devolve investigative functions to competent municipal authorities via regulation. He has the legal authority.'
In response to Cameron's remarks Police Minister Senzo Mchunu's spokesperson, Kamogelo Mogotsi, said: 'The ministry's focus is on ensuring that the high levels of crime in the country are reduced. A number of enablers have been identified by the ministry, which will be used to fight crime.
'Furthermore, following the National Policing Summit which was convened in April, various measures will be implemented that will usher in a new type of policing - one that is effective, efficient, responsive and professional.'
However, political analyst Sanusha Naidu explained that this issue has been an ongoing gripe for the DA regarding what they can and cannot do under the safety and security portfolios.
Naidu said that the party is seeking to mimic what the National Party wanted to do during the negotiation for the transition into democracy, 'in other words, what they want is not a unity state, but rather a devolved set of powers that are defined along the lines of a federal state'.
'...This discussion around a unity state versus a federal state is that you can't go back (to when the Constitution was being made) and ask the question, as you have a Constitution that defines powers,' Naidu said.
'You have a Constitution that essentially enables for a unity state.
'The Western Cape is a push-and-pull factor of tension. It is constantly in an elasticity of tension, as you have that one issue of 'look at us, we've done so well'... The DA has used the idea that it is the ruling party in the Western Cape to push a narrative that 'we have a better handle on how to govern', now the reason why they are able to push that is because…everywhere else is broken.
'So if you look at what the DA tried to do in Gauteng, and Eastern Cape when Athol Trollip was part of the DA… they are constantly trying to push the narrative that 'we govern better' but what they don't tell you is that the governing comes from such a low base in comparison to the rest of the country.'
'When you think about the optics and narrative when you live in the City of Cape Town, you can see the contradictions of that narrative… It is a complete copout to say that you can't address the issue because we don't have the powers to do so. It is easy.
'However, let's make the assumption that we give you the powers to do so, will you be able to do it, and I think that they are hiding behind this argument… There is no tried and tested argument because we don't have a benchmark for them to try it,' Naidu said.
'There is no benchmark to say, 'hang on, is there another method or methodology or another intervention you can make?' If you are still waiting for these powers to be devolved, you have to go back to the Constitution."
[email protected]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
5 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
DA WC retains ward in the Matzikamma Municipality town of Vanrhynsdorp
CAPE TOWN - In the ongoing battle for the grassroots vote in the Western Cape's rural communities, the Democratic Alliance (DA) has retained its ward in the Matzikamma Municipality town of Vanrhynsdorp. The party has recently been embroiled in a bitter battle to retain control over the hung council after the Western Cape High Court recently overturned an attempt by a coalition of the African National Congress (ANC), Patriotic Alliance (PA) and Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) to wrest control. Wednesday's by-election result is the DA's highest ever vote tally in that ward, which was originally won by the PA in the 2021 municipal election before its councillor defected to the DA. DA Western Cape leader Tertuis Simmers said its councillor Richard van Huyssteen will continue the party's trend of solid governance. Meanwhile, the ANC said while it's disappointed by the outcome in Matzikamma, where it's only placed third, it's managed to retain ward three in the Knysna Municipality by only 31 votes, with the PA nipping at its heels. Lukhanyiso Nohana will now take charge as the councillor. ANC Western Cape spokesperson Khalid Sayed said, despite the Knysna victory, it will nevertheless be dissecting the reasons for the 8% decline in support. "The Knysna Municipality is now able, through the ANC-led coalition, to continue improving the state of the municipality and serving all residents."
The Star
9 hours ago
- The Star
Angie Motshekga deserves to be fired for defending SANDF misconduct
Chris Hattingh | Published 4 hours ago The Democratic Alliance (DA) believes Defence Minister Angie Motshekga's conduct in shielding General Rudzani Maphwanya from accountability is so serious that it deserves for her to be fired. Her latest defence of Maphwanya's misconduct in Tehran shows she is unfit for office and is causing irreparable harm to South Africa's image. Instead of holding General Maphwanya accountable for overstepping his constitutional mandate, Motshekga endorsed his version of events and declared herself 'satisfied' with his report. By doing so, she has chosen to side with an unelected general who engaged in unsanctioned political diplomacy in Iran. This is a blatant violation of the SANDF Code of Conduct. According to Iranian state media, Maphwanya pledged 'common goals' with Tehran, endorsed its stance on Gaza, and promised deeper strategic ties. These are political pronouncements no soldier has the authority to make. Motshekga's decision to shield him undermines one of the cornerstones of our democracy: civilian oversight of the military. Instead of safeguarding South Africa's constitutional and diplomatic interests, she has rubber-stamped conduct that weakens our standing among democratic allies and strengthens ties with authoritarian regimes. Her failure is not just an error of judgment and a failure of leadership. By placing political expedience above accountability, she has sent the message that generals may act as they please without consequence, while ministers will look the other way. This cannot be tolerated in a constitutional democracy. South Africa is already struggling with strained international relations. Now, under Motshekga's watch, our global credibility and national security are being further eroded. Every day she remains in office deepens the damage. President Ramaphosa has a duty as Commander-in-Chief of the SANDF to act decisively. He must hold Motshekga and General Maphwanya accountable, and send a clear signal that South Africa remains committed to constitutional order, civilian control of the military, and respect for democratic values. The DA will not allow our nation's hard-earned democratic principles to be trampled by a Minister who has failed in her most basic duty: to put South Africa first. Chris Hattingh MP - DA Spokesperson on Defence and Military Veterans
The Citizen
10 hours ago
- The Citizen
Land in hand but no money to build: Gauteng housing project vacant due to lack of foresight
A housing scheme aimed at giving 100 000 beneficiaries fully serviced plots of land has seen ambitions unrealised A land ownership scheme to empower the building of assets has not realised its intended goals. The Rapid Land Release Programme (RLRP) envisioned the handing over of fully serviced plots of land across Gauteng for recipients to develop homes to their own specifications. However, roughly seven years after its launch, the vast majority of stands remain empty, despite having been allocated to beneficiaries. 99% of plots still vacant The RLRP was launched in 2018 by then premier David Makhura and was continued during Premier Panyaza Lesufi's administration. The programme featured roughly 100 000 fully serviced stands and moved away from providing the turnkey apartments common in other social housing projects. The provincial government stated four years ago that the stands were ready for allocation, but to date, only a fraction of stands have seen development. At a recent oversight visit to Palm Ridge Ext 14 by the DA, officials explained that of the 2 200 stands allocated to recipients in the area, only 13 had seen any construction. Speaking to community members, DA representatives were told how constant delays, broken promises and a lack of support had left the stands bare. 'There seems to be no forethought given to how beneficiaries will build and maintain their homes or cover service costs,' stated DA Gauteng shadow Human Settlements MEC Mervyn Cirota. 'It is also unacceptable that the government proceeded with the programme despite knowing that most beneficiaries could not afford to build, secure loans or pay for services.' MEC disputes figures However, Gauteng Human Settlement MEC Tasneem Motara disputed the figures, saying the DA's claims of more than 2 000 undeveloped stands was 'factually incorrect'. 'The project comprises of 758 stands which were developed in 2021/2022 financial year, all of which have been allocated, with title deed registration currently underway,' Motara told The Citizen. The MEC said the 758 stands were part of the broader project called the Ikagelang RLRP and that beneficiaries were approved in line with the National Housing Needs Register and have their ownership linked with housing subsidy systems. Once obtaining the title deeds, beneficiaries receive full ownership; with the only proviso that developments meet municipal planning and building regulations. Motara clarified that under the RLRP, beneficiaries did not need to wait until receiving title deeds to begin construction as the stands had services pre-installed and were given certified letters of allocation. 'This document enables beneficiaries to apply for building plan approval from the municipality and to commence construction in line with municipal building regulations. 'In short, the allocation letter is the enabling instrument, beneficiaries are not left in limbo. 'Palm Ridge Ext 14 therefore remains a key element of our broader human settlements strategy, contributing to both land ownership and spatial transformation,' Motara said. 'Defeats the purpose' The DA claims that the project has cost at least R500 million so far and is calling for the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) to look into the whereabouts of the funds. 'Palm Ridge is just a small microcosm of the whole RLRP. There is no indication whether a transfer has taken place so there may be an allocation, but that is only the first step,' Cirota told The Citizen. Cirota noted the project suffered from insufficient funding, a hold up in deeds transfers and failure to assist beneficiaries with planning. 'It is a multi-pronged attack, and if one of those elements falls away, then the whole process comes tumbling down. 'What is the purpose of having the land if you cannot build a house on the land or maintain the property. It defeats the whole purpose of the whole project,' Cirota said. NOW READ: Gauteng's housing crisis: 150 years to clear the backlog
