'At some point reality has to hit,' says ex-Arkane founder Raphael Colantonio on Game Pass — 'this model just doesn't work long-term'

Time of India

6 days ago

(Image via @saudigamer's 'X' Account)
Raphael Colantonio, ex-Arkane Studios founder, has recently delivered a stark assessment of Xbox Game Pass. He suggested that the gaming giant's flagship subscription model harbors fundamental laws.
His comments amidst the recent project cancellations and Microsoft layoffs point to long-term viability concerns that can reshape the industry landscape. He even hinted at the inevitable reckoning of the approach that's been championed by Microsoft.
Raphael Colantonio issues stark warnings
The ex-Arkane Studios founder didn't mince his words on Xbox Game Pass. He straightaway labelled it as an
'unsustainable model'
that has been actively damaging the industry. As per his argument, this damage has been masked for many years by Microsoft's vast financial resources. He called it their
'infinite money'
that's subsidizing it all and artificially propping up the service, but economics is not adding up for most publishers and developers.
Making some bleak core predictions, he said, coexistence with the traditional sales models for Xbox Game Pass is impossible. As he contends, Game Pass faces a binary future. It would either dominate to the point of eliminating all competitors, or Microsoft would be forced to abandon it entirely. In his words,
"
At some point reality has to hit."
Colantonio's comments put a lot of emphasis on the inherent long-term weakness of this model and show increased skepticism from the industry veterans.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
새로 나온 '실비보험', 합리적인 가격과 실속있는 보장으로 최적가 비교가입!...
굿리치 [등록번호:제2006038313호]
가입하기
Undo
These veterans believe the subscription services can devalue games or destabilize the development budgets.
Job cuts and corporate pressures create a ripple effect
Colantonio's critique has emerged amidst the significant turmoil in Microsoft's gaming division. The recent months saw deeper cuts, including some high-profile project cancellations. Rare's Everwild and Initiative's 'Perfect Dark' reboot, apart from studio closures, as per him, these actions were not isolated incidents.
Journalists Tom Warren and Jez Corden have reported that these stemmed from intense financial pressure. As per reports, Microsoft's CFO Amy Hood recently set some aggressive and potentially unrealistic targets for Xbox. As noted, the pressure intensified quite significantly, following Activision Blizzard's massive acquisition. The sheer cost of the deal, together with Game Pass investments trying to be profitable, has created a challenging new financial reality.
Further compounding the struggles of Xbox is Microsoft's strategic pivot. $80 billion, a very significant resource, has been redirected to generative AI, a priority that's been championed by CEO Satya Nadella and Hood. Such a shift within investment focus, completely away from gaming, has further squeezed the operating environment of Xbox, putting it in a precarious position, with further turbulence expected ahead.
Gaming Industry concerns
for Xbox Game Pass are rising
Colantonio is not alone with his skepticism. Even Michael Douse, the Publishing Director at Baldur's Gate 3 developer Larian Studios, has echoed the concern about sustainability. He did highlight a widespread industry question—
"What happens when all that money runs out?"
The fear now deters many publishers from completely embracing the model of Game Pass.
Both Colantonio and Douse are seeing a potential compromise being made.
As per their suggestion, subscription services can find a sustainable niche, keeping the primary focus on back catalogue titles, which are older games that are beyond the initial sales peak. As per their argument, launching major new releases on day one of subscription undercuts traditional sales. It creates unsustainable economics for most publishers and developers not named Microsoft.
Can Xbox Game Pass survive without hurting the industry?
Future of Xbox Game Pass now remains a pivotal question.
As Microsoft continues to balance colossal investments, shifting AI focus and corporate expectations, the viability of the subscription cornerstone does face its sternest test. The warning of Colantonio for now serves as a potent reminder that even all that infinite money cannot defy economic reality forever.
Despite all warnings, Microsoft is pushing Game Pass, banking upon subscriber growth. Yet, with no clear path to profitability and high skepticism from industry, subscription gaming's future remains uncertain.
To wrap up, Colantonio's critique puts forward an important question: Is Xbox Game Pass sustainable?, or is it a bubble that has been waiting to burst?' With Microsoft trying to navigate financial pressures and has been facing a lot of industry backlash, the next few years ahead could determine whether subscription gaming will collapse under its own weight or thrive.
Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.