Proposed sweeping powers for FBR will cripple economy: PBF
Speaking to the media, Muhammad Naseer Malik, Chairman (Central Punjab) of the PBF, said the Finance Bill introduces a range of unprecedented and undemocratic enforcement clauses that violate the principles of fair taxation and due process. He warned that these proposals will create an environment of fear and intimidation, where businesses operate under constant threat of legal action without the protection of proper checks and balances.
PBF highlighted specific provisions of the Finance Bill 2025 that it says are particularly damaging to business confidence and fundamental rights:
Section 37AA allows for the arrest of individuals without a warrant, solely on the basis of suspicion of tax fraud, paving the way for arbitrary detentions and harassment. Section 14AE empowers FBR officials to seize business premises and property without judicial oversight or meaningful safeguards.
The Section 37B authorizes the detention of businesspersons for up to 14 days, with possible extension by a magistrate, even before the conclusion of an investigation. Further, Section 11E permits FBR to make tax assessments and initiate recovery based purely on suspicion, bypassing the need for a complete inquiry or verifiable evidence.
Section 33 (13 & 13A) introduces 10-year prison terms and Rs10 million fines for vaguely defined 'tax fraud,' which the PBF warns could criminalize genuine business errors or disputes.
Section 32B grants private auditors quasi-legal authority, allowing them to act with powers that blur the line between auditing and prosecution — a move PBF considers both unconstitutional and dangerous.
'These provisions do not promote tax compliance — they institutionalize fear, harassment, and unchecked power,' Malik said. 'They will push the business community to the edge, and many will be forced to shut down operations or move abroad.'
The PBF also criticized the existing tax structure, pointing out that the effective tax burden on businesses has soared to between 50% and 60%, the highest in the region. This includes a 25% corporate tax, 25% tax on dividends, super tax, sales tax, withholding taxes, and high import duties. According to the Forum, these combined pressures make investment, expansion, and job creation impossible under the current fiscal regime.
In addition to demanding the complete withdrawal of the above clauses, the PBF is calling for a reduction in interest rates to 6% to support business recovery and economic growth. The Forum believes that a more balanced tax policy - coupled with targeted reforms and incentives - could double public spending on education and health without suffocating the productive economy.
Naseer Malik also warned if the Finance Bill 2025 is passed in its current form, Pakistan's economy will face irreversible damage. If the government thinks it can collect taxes without taxpayers, it is free to try. And if the FBR believes it can run an economy without businesses, let it go ahead; the consequences will be clear soon enough.'
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
an hour ago
- Business Recorder
Govt launches risk coverage scheme for small farmers & underserved areas
The government, in a bid to enhance access to credit for small and marginalised farmers, has rolled out a new risk coverage scheme for banks and microfinance banks (MFBs). According to the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), the initiative is aimed at encouraging financial institutions to extend fresh financing to farmers by offering government-backed coverage against potential loan losses. Under the scheme, which will remain effective from July 1, 2025, to June 30, 2028, banks will be able to provide production loans for crops, as well as loans for dairy, livestock, and fisheries, with the government sharing part of the risk. The scheme will cover all commercial banks/Islamic banks/specialised banks/MFBs. Small and subsistence holding farmers from Sindh and Punjab, and all types of landholding farmers from KPK, Balochistan, AJK & Gilgit and Baltistan can benefit from the scheme. Under the scheme, financing of up to Rs3 million will be provided, with a tenor of up to 12 months except for sugarcane, where it is 18 months. 'The loan will be considered as a loss in case the repayment of loan/installment is overdue by 12 months,' said SBP. Under the scheme, the government would provide 10% first loss coverage on the outstanding agri loan portfolio, applicable to new borrowers and incremental financing to existing ones. Importantly, payment of a risk coverage claim shall not obviate banks from the right of recovery of the defaulted amount. 'Banks shall continue with their regular procedure for recovery of loans,' said SBP. To incentivise banks to attract new borrowers, the Federal Government will pay Rs10,000 per new borrower to the bank, to meet the operational cost, to the extent of the net increase in the number of borrowers over the previous year. 'Banks shall evaluate their net increase in number of borrowers at the end of each fiscal year and lodge the claims electronically with Financial Inclusion Support Department (FISD), SBP BSC within 15 working days,' said SBP.
Express Tribune
10 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Govt moves to cut port delays, speed up clearance
A high-level committee has finalised recommendations to cut container dwell time at Karachi Port and Port Qasim, aiming to improve cargo clearance and reduce congestion at Pakistan's two key seaports. According to an official statement, the proposals were presented on Tuesday to Federal Minister for Maritime Affairs Muhammad Junaid Anwar Chaudhry, who directed that the plan be sent to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) the same day. He asked FBR to prepare an implementation strategy within two weeks. The meeting was joined by Acting Karachi Port Trust (KPT) Chairman Rear Admiral Ateequr Rehman and Port Qasim Authority's (PQA) Director Operations Rear Admiral Muhammad Khalid via video link from Karachi. The committee, chaired by Umer Zafar Sheikh, Additional Secretary at the Ministry of Maritime Affairs, included representatives from KPT, PQA, Pakistan Customs, FBR, and terminal operators. The minister said the reforms will align Pakistan's ports with global benchmarks by ensuring faster clearances, smoother trade flows, and lower business costs. He also restructured the committee, giving it the mandate to act as an implementation body, coordinate with FBR, and monitor progress. The plan addresses delays in goods declaration filing, adjudication, lab testing, transportation, and gate-out processes. Key steps include promoting pre-arrival filing, imposing fines for late submissions, and holding virtual hearings to speed up adjudication. Expanded lab facilities and rapid screening technologies have been recommended to reduce testing delays. To ease congestion, the committee proposed quicker auctioning of overstayed cargo, expansion of grounding space, and more labour and customs examiners. It suggested round-the-clock customs assessments, examinations, lab work, and shipping services. Transport improvements include extending bonded transit, simplifying tracker installation, adding escort staff, and lifting night restrictions on heavy vehicles. Infrastructure plans call for truck holding areas, rail freight corridors, and multi-modal transport to reduce road reliance. The digitalisation push includes AI-based risk profiling of importers, an integrated stakeholder portal within WeBOC, e-auction facilities, and real-time links between terminals, traders, and transporters. The free period for containers under the green and yellow channels will also be reduced from five days to three, with penalties for non-compliance.
Business Recorder
14 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Port congestion: Suggestions aimed at slashing container dwell time finalised
ISLAMABAD: To improve cargo clearance efficiency and easing congestion at the country's two key seaports, the Ministry of Maritime Affairs has finalised a set of recommendations to reduce container dwell time at Karachi Port and Port Qasim. The recommendations prepared by the Karachi Port Trust and Port Qasim Authority in collaboration with other experts were presented to the Federal Minister for Maritime Affairs, Muhammad Junaid Anwar Chaudhry, here on Tuesday. The minister instructed that the recommendations be forwarded to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) earliest, with directions to prepare an implementation plan within two weeks. Acting Chairman Karachi Port Trust, Rear Admiral Ateeq ur Rehman, and Rear Admiral Muhammad Khalid, Director Operations of Port Qasim Authority joined the meeting via video link from Karachi. The committee itself was established by the minister and is chaired by Umer Zafar Sheikh, Additional Secretary, Ministry of Maritime Affairs, with representation from KPT, PQA, Pakistan Customs, terminal operators, FBR, and other relevant stakeholders. The minister emphasised that the plan seeks to align Pakistan's port operations with global benchmarks, enabling faster clearances, smoother trade flows, and reduced operational costs for businesses. He also restructured the committee, assigning it a new mandate as an implementation body responsible for coordinating with the FBR and monitoring progress within the specified timeframe. The recommendations focus on addressing bottlenecks across the clearance chain, from delays in goods declaration filing, adjudication, and laboratory testing, to issues related to transportation, examination, auctioning, and gate-out processes. Key measures include promoting early or pre-arrival filing of goods declarations, shortening the filing window, and introducing fines for late submissions. Virtual hearings have been proposed to speed up adjudication, while the use of rapid screening technologies and expanded laboratory facilities has been advised to reduce testing delays. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
