
Alberta's transgender ban in women's sports exempts visiting out-of-province athletes
Tourism and Sport Minister Andrew Boitchenko said the discrepancy is out of his hands.
'We don't have authority to regulate athletes from different jurisdictions,' he said in an interview.
In a followup statement, ministry spokeswoman Vanessa Gomez added it's due to outside sporting organizations being bound by out-of-province or international guidelines.
She added the rules allow the government 'to do what is best for Albertan athletes, while also showcasing Alberta as a premier destination for national and international sport events.'
Starting Sept. 1, the province will block transgender athletes from Alberta who are 12 and older from competing in female amateur sports. It's one of a suite of changes surrounding transgender health, education and sport introduced last year by Premier Danielle Smith's United Conservative Party government.
The laws sparked polarizing debate.
Proponents, including Smith, say it's about fairness on the playing field, so girls are not battling opponents with biological advantages. Detractors say it's about stigmatizing and punishing those in the transgender community.
Hannah Pilling, a track athlete who petitioned in favour of restricting transgender people in female sports, has welcomed the new regulations. She said in an interview she hopes Smith's government takes it further.
'It's kind of hard to enforce that on other athletes that are coming to compete in Alberta, but it's definitely still not completely fair,' Pilling said.
She added that she would like to see future rules apply to men's divisions.
Transgender athlete Allison Hadley said the exemption for out-of-province athletes suggests the legislation is not really about fairness or safety.
'If I had the resources to (move), honestly, I probably wouldn't be in Alberta now,' she said. 'We're here in a province that doesn't want us to be in the public or exist in many ways.'
Hadley said she didn't pick up cross-country skiing to win medals. She said she was in it for the health benefits, the motivation that competition brings to her training and the camaraderie on the trail.
'It really sucks to have that taken away,' she said.
Mark Kosak, head of the Alberta Colleges Athletic Conference, said a restriction preventing transgender athletes from coming to Alberta to compete might have stopped the organization from ever hosting a national championship again.
'So there's some relief from us,' Kosak said.
He said the conference hosts more than 1,000 events a year and, of those, between 40 and 50 host out-of-province competitors.
He said he's unaware of any transgender athletes competing in the conference.
Kosak added that the sporting community didn't ask for the government's new rules.
'This is not a priority. This is not a concern,' he said. 'It's not an issue.'
The rules will be enforced through a complaint-driven process. Female athletes subject to complaints need to prove their sex registration at birth.
For those who were born elsewhere but live in Alberta and can't retrieve documents that clearly state their sex at birth, Boitchenko said the government will look at 'alternative documents.'
'We'll be looking at (it) case by case, making sure that nobody feels that they can't compete just because they lost certain documents,' he said.
Possible sanctions could be written warnings or code of conduct violations.
Bennett Jensen, legal director at LGBTQ+ advocacy group Egale, said the validation process alone is a 'gross violation of the privacy of all women and girls.'
He said the government is introducing a complaint-based 'snitch line' for complaints that will spur even more public policing of women's bodies and gender presentation among young girls — whether they're transgender or not.
He said a 12-year-old, at a vulnerable stage of her life, could be subject to scrutiny and humiliation based on her physical appearance.
Jensen also said the government's biological advantage argument falls apart in many instances, including for those athletes receiving hormone replacement therapy.
Boitchenko said inclusion is the goal, and the government is planning to expand grants to encourage sporting organizations to create coed divisions where numbers allow.
Pilling's father, Dave Pilling, said he sits on the board for the Southern Alberta Summer Games, where they introduced open categories in all sports this year.
But for the Alberta Colleges Athletic Conference, Kosak said creating coed divisions across the majority of sports is 'totally impractical and unrealistic.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 12, 2025.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
White Sox CF Luis Robert Jr. sidelined for 2nd straight game because of adductor soreness
CHICAGO (AP) — White Sox center fielder Luis Robert Jr. missed his second straight game on Saturday night because of adductor soreness. Robert felt the injury when he stole second in the ninth inning of Wednesday's 11-9 victory at Tampa Bay. The White Sox were off on Thursday, and Robert rested during Friday night's 12-5 win against the Cubs. Robert was available off the bench on Saturday, but he rested during a 6-1 loss to the North Siders. 'Still sore, but better than yesterday,' manager Will Venable said. 'He ran around, looks good, just not quite there yet.' Robert is batting .375 (12 for 32) with two homers and nine RBIs during a nine-game hitting streak, showing signs of breaking out after a miserable start to the season. With the rebuilding White Sox in last place in the AL Central, he could be on the move ahead of Thursday's trade deadline. Robert, who turns 28 on Aug. 3, is batting just .206 with 10 homers and 41 RBIs in 84 games. But he also has career-high 26 steals and plays solid defense in center. He hit a career-best 38 homers in 2023. Also Saturday, Shane Smith threw about 55 pitches to Josh Rojas, Tim Elko and Brooks Baldwin. The All-Star right-hander is coming back from a sprained left ankle. 'I think it went pretty well,' Smith said. 'Good feel for the stuff. It's really cool to face our guys. I can get an insight what they are doing and what they see a little bit easier. Yeah, it felt good to be back on the bump.' Venable said Smith looked good, and he wasn't certain about the next step for the pitcher. 'We're going to map that out here,' he said. 'I'm not sure if it's going to be another live BP or a rehab assignment.' Thursdays Keep up to date on sports with Mike McIntyre's weekly newsletter. The 25-year-old Smith was selected by the White Sox in December's Rule 5 draft. He got off to a solid start in his first year in the majors, but he is 0-4 with an 11.29 ERA in his last five games. Smith got hurt during a July 17 workout at PNC Park. The White Sox are monitoring his innings over the last part of the season, and he is hoping the IL stint will help him finish strong. 'Just like making sure mechanics are there,' he said. 'Stuff you don't neglect during the middle of the week but you can really work on stuff once you are feeling good. That's all I'm trying to do, make sure the body is in the right spot, and make sure the mechanics and delivery are in the right spot.' ___ AP MLB:


Edmonton Journal
2 days ago
- Edmonton Journal
Saturday's letters: High-speed rail, MLB team would make Alberta a powerhouse
Article content What would be a daring nation-building project for Alberta? The province is planning for a high-speed rail link between Edmonton and Calgary that would travel 1,000 km/h. Article content Edmonton is 299 kilometers from Calgary. By high-speed rail, that is about 18 minutes. With Calgary's population about 1.6 million and Edmonton's population about 1.5 million, combined they have a population of 3.2 million. That is larger than MLB cities of Milwaukee, Kansas City, Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky, Denver-Aurora-Broomfield, Baltimore, Tampa Bay, St. Louis, San Diego and approximately equivalent to the size of Minneapolis-St. Paul. Article content Article content Article content At the same time, build a major league baseball stadium in both Edmonton and Calgary that is connected to the high-speed rail. Their combined populations could thus share a MLB team, playing half the home games in each city, each year. By the time the high-speed rail and new baseball stadiums are completed by all-Canadian contractors using all-Canadian materials, President Trump is gone. Article content Article content Alberta ought to qualify for a MLB franchise. Connect the two downtowns and the two airports to high-speed rail as well. It would make Edmonton-Calgary and Alberta an economic, cultural and sports powerhouse. Name the MLB team the Alberta High-Speed Commuters or perhaps the Alberta Rivals. Article content As a B.C. resident, I'd appreciate it if Premier Smith would stop sticking her nose in non-Alberta issues. Some of her recent comments about how B.C. ostrich farms should deal with avian flu and her ongoing comments about putting oil pipelines through B.C. are but two of her attention-getting, interfering, divisive, diversionary comments. Article content Article content I suggest she pay more attention to fixing some of Alberta's problems such as rising measles cases, health-care problems and increasing wildfires. (among others) Fix things in your own backyard and deal with your own problems, mistakes, or shortcomings before offering advice or criticism of others. Article content Bev Yaworski, Delta, B.C. Article content Laurier Park, zoo entrance neglected Article content After many years, I had the pleasure to visit Laurier Park. What a shock! At the entrance to the park and Valley Zoo, visitors are greeted by five-feet tall weeds and dozens of deep potholes. Further in, with the exception of diamonds and picnic shelters for which you pay, I found overgrown vegetation resembling a jungle. No attempt to even clear the edges. Article content It is unsightly and more so, unsafe. Why spend millions upgrading Hawrelak Park when the rest gets intentionally neglected?


Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Fifty-nine people moved out of tents and into homes
The province has moved 59 people from encampments to housing as it works on a strategy to find shelter for an estimated 700 Manitobans who live in encampments. 'They're taking pride and flourishing,' Housing, Addictions and Homelessness Minister Bernadette Smith said Friday of the people who have been housed. 'We want to make sure everyone gets the proper support and they're successful.' Since the government's strategy Your Way Home was announced in January, 53 of the 59 former tent residents have moved into social housing. Six live in private rentals, a spokesman for the minister said. MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES Housing, Addictions and Homelessness Minister Bernadette Smith said nicer weather draws more people to tent living, but the province is working with the city, the federal government, community partners and private landlords to 'get people into housing that's a more desirable place for them.' In March, the federal-provincial welfare top-up program to help those living in encampments afford market rents stopped accepting new applications. In May, the province announced 67 new social housing units, all of which are occupied, Smith said Friday. As expected, encampments have expanded during the summer, prompting neighbours and Winnipeg city councillors to express concern about health and safety concerns — for residents in and near the tent villages, and motorists who drive by them. 'This is what happens when you normalize this type of living in tent encampments' said Marion Willis, executive director of St. Boniface Street Links. 'In the past, people seeking resources looked for someone to house them. Now they're told 'come and join us,' she said Friday. 'We've normalized an incredible level of social dysfunction,' Willis said. On Friday, Coun. Ross Eadie, whose Mynarski ward is home to several encampments, released a letter he had written to Smith, Winnipeg Mayor Scott Gillingham and one of his constituents who's asked officials to address the 'crime' and 'chaos' from encampments. 'Your Way Home has the policy of providing 24/7 support for those getting out of encampments,' Eadie wrote. 'Well, we need 24/7 support for the residents living near encampments.' Smith said nicer weather draws more people to tent living, but the province is working with the city, the federal government, community partners and private landlords to 'get people into housing that's a more desirable place for them.' 'We are doing everything we can to bring as many units online as possible, and we believe the province is also working to bring every possible housing unit online as quickly as they can.'–Jamil Mahmood The head of Main Street Project, which received the only contract from the city to move people from tents to housing, said many more units are needed — and quickly. 'We are doing everything we can to bring as many units online as possible, and we believe the province is also working to bring every possible housing unit online as quickly as they can,' executive director Jamil Mahmood said in a statement Friday. Main Street Project hopes to have another 12 social housing units available in the next two weeks that can house 15 to 20 people from encampments, he said. 'The social housing being brought online has all the supports needed for people to be successful,' Mahmood said. The non-profit organization is concerned about those in private rentals relying on rent top-ups becoming at risk for homelessness again, he said. 'The rent top-up highlights how the private sector cannot fill this gap, and the need for more funded social housing is key to addressing this housing crisis,' Mahmood said. Two years ago while campaigning to become premier, Wab Kinew said it was not 'realistic' to rely on social housing alone to end chronic homelessness — that the province needs to work with the private sector and landlords to move people out of bus shelters and tents into housing. 'The premier was right on the mark,' said Willis with Street Links, which relies on private rental units to move their clients from tents to apartments. Even without the federal-provincial rent subsidy, Street Links has housed 28 people so far this month in private rentals, she said. On Friday, they were in the process of housing a couple — a pregnant woman and her partner — who had been living in a tent in the West End. They had been receiving food and water from outreach workers who suggested they get on the social housing wait list. 'It's more efficient to work with people in a housed situation than an unhoused situation,' said Willis. Low-barrier housing with some stability and security is better than no housing, she said BROOK JONES / FREE PRESS FILES Encampments have expanded during the summer, prompting neighbours and Winnipeg city councillors to express concern about health and safety concerns — for residents in and near the tent villages, and motorists who drive by them. 'You're in a house that has heat, with a toilet and fridge and stove,' she said. 'A terrible place to live is a dirty encampment on the riverbank.' On Thursday, Kinew said that when his government took office, it was constrained by the lack of housing units after the former government sold some of its housing stock. He said they're in the process of building and restoring social housing units and helping those estimated 700 Manitobans move from tents to homes. 'We're working hard,' said Kinew, who credited city and non-profit partners for working together. 'We're all on the same page,' he said. 'It's just going to take years of consistent effort to get to that 700 number. When we first committed to this, we said it would take eight years. We're two years in. If we maintain this pace, I think we'll get to where we need to go,' the premier said. — with files from the Brandon Sun Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.