Apology for S Korean woman convicted of biting man's tongue as he attacked her
Choi Mal-ja was sentenced to 10 months in prison, suspended for two years, for biting off part of her attacker's tongue as he allegedly tried to rape her in 1964, when she was 18 years old.
Inspired by the country's #MeToo movement, Ms Choi, now 78, has campaigned for years to have her conviction overturned.
Her retrial began in the city of Busan on Wednesday, where prosecutors issued an apology and asked for the court to quash her guilty verdict.
"For 61 years, the state made me live as a criminal," Ms Choi told reporters outside the court ahead of the hearing.
She said she hoped future generations could live a happy life free from sexual violence.
At the start of the trial, Busan's Chief Prosecutor Jeong Myeong-won said "we sincerely apologise".
"We have caused Choi Mal-ja, a victim of a sex crime who should have been protected as one, indescribable pain and agony."
A final ruling is scheduled for 10 September, with legal observers expecting the court to overturn Ms Choi's conviction.
Outside the courtroom after the hearing, Ms Choi raised her fist and said: "We won!"
She celebrated by embracing campaigners from civic organisations who were there to support her.
#MeToo takes hold in South Korea
Why women in Korea are reclaiming their short hair
In 1964, an 18-year-old Choi Mal-ja was attacked by a 21-year-old man, who forced his tongue into her mouth as he pinned her to the ground in the southern town of Gimhae, according to court records.
Ms Choi escaped the attack by biting off 1.5cm (0.59in) of the aggressor's tongue.
The man was sentenced to six months in prison, suspended for two years, for trespassing and intimidation. He was never convicted of attempted rape.
Ms Choi was given a harsher sentence than her attacker for causing him grievous bodily harm.
The court at the time said her actions had exceeded the "reasonable bounds" of self-defence.
Ms Choi's case has since been cited in legal textbooks in South Korea as a classic example of a court failing to recognise self-defence during sexual violence.
'Justice is alive in this country'
After taking inspiration from South Korea's #MeToo movement in the late 2010s, Ms Choi contacted advocacy groups to begin work on petitioning for a retrial.
She filed a petition in 2020, 56 years after the attack, but it was initially rejected by the lower courts. Three years later, the Supreme Court ruled that Ms Choi's retrial could go ahead.
Her fight for justice became well known in South Korea, with Ms Choi and fellow activists holding protests outside the Supreme Court building in Seoul.
"I still can't believe it," Ms Choi said after Wednesday's hearing, the Korea JoongAng Daily newspaper reported.
"But if the prosecution is admitting its mistake even now, then I believe justice is alive in this country."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Prison service was on verge of collapse over space of nine months
The prison service was on the verge of collapsing on several occasions between autumn 2023 and summer 2024, an independent review has found. The review by Dame Anne Owers was published today, August 5, and shows the potential collapse came as a symptom of a systemic problem which led to recurring prison capacity crises over the last 18 years. The review, commissioned by Lord Chancellor Shabana Mahmood in February this year, details the damaging impact on prisons, probation, prison escort services and the courts up and down the country. It details how senior officials in the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) and HM Prison and Probations Service (HMPPS) were meeting daily at times to document, monitor and attempt to resolve the capacity problems at the expense of other aspects of prison strategy and policy. At the height of the prison crisis, frontline staff spent most of their time moving prisoners around and implementing ever-changing release schemes. READ MORE: Girl, four, dies after incident at water park READ MORE: State Pension age to rise in 2026 for people with these birthdays During the crisis, the cost of holding prisoners in police cells reached over £70 million, and construction costs for new prisons nearly doubled, to £10.1 billion Successive governments have been forced to implement last-minute emergency release measures as a result of the crisis. The population pressure has also affected prisons' capacity to operate safe environments, Dame Anne, who previously held the role of Chief Inspector of Prisons between 2001 and 2010, has now said there needs to be a move from crisis management to a strategic approach, this is to ensure the entire prison network as well as probation and other community services are able to work efficiently to prevent offending and reoffending. According to the review, at one point there were fewer than 100 places in adult male prisons, with a COBRA meeting being held in May 2025 following the announcement of the general election and concerns the prison system could collapse during the election campaign. On three occasions, the report said, from 2023 onwards, prisons were running very close to capacity, to the point where the use of early release schemes helped to relieve pressure at the last moment. The report said: "Senior officials were so concerned about a potential breakdown in the criminal justice system that an audit was kept of all decision-making and documents, in case there was a public or parliamentary inquiry. "The system in fact limped through the summer of 2024, helped by the knowledge that relief was coming, in the shape of the new government's pledge to reduce the custodial element of most standard determinate sentences from 50% to 40% (SDS40)." Dame Anne Owers said: 'The scale, likelihood, risks and consequences of the prison capacity crisis could not have been signalled more clearly, at every level of government. "The response was last-minute short-term fixes rather than long-term solutions to the underlying problems. This is part of a repeated pattern of prison capacity crises, under successive governments, which have seriously affected prisons' ability to work effectively and safely. 'This report is the backdrop to David Gauke's review of sentencing and Sir Brian Leveson's review of the criminal courts. The Government should now put in place systems that don't just signal approaching problems, but stimulate action to prevent them. "This involves ensuring not only that prisons have the capacity to work effectively, but that there is proper and sustained investment in community provision, to provide effective support to help reduce offending and reoffending.' Dame Anne made the following recommendations: Developing a ten-year strategy for capacity in probation and community services, similar to the prison capacity strategy published by the Government in December. Establishing an independent advisory body to provide advice and external validation of capacity strategies across both prisons and probation, including the impact of any proposed changes to the criminal justice system. A similar body was recommended in the Independent Review of Sentencing. Mandating the HMPPS Board to evaluate the Prison Service, in discussion with the Chief Inspector of Prisons, and to monitor and report on progress on capacity. Involving the Chief Inspector of Probation and the third sector in discussing the design and delivery of community services, including addiction treatment and housing. Reinvigorating the approach to integrated offender management to bring together agencies to deal with repeat and persistent offenders. Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood said: 'This report lays bare the disgraceful way the last Conservative Government ran our prisons. They added less than 500 cells to the prison estate over fourteen years, released over 10,000 prisoners early under a veil of secrecy, and brought our jails close to total collapse on countless occasions. 'This Government is fixing our prisons, for good. Days after taking office, we took the emergency action required to stop our prisons from collapsing. We have already opened 2,400 new cells since coming into office, on track for 14,000 by 2031. And we are reforming sentencing to ensure we can always lock up dangerous offenders and keep the public safe."
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Tycoon who helped bring F1 to Singapore pleads guilty in rare graft case
Property tycoon Ong Beng Seng pleaded guilty to one charge of abetting the obstruction of justice on Monday in part of a landmark case that led to the jailing of former transport minister S. Iswaran for obtaining valuable items as a public servant last year. However, both the prosecution and defence agreed to grant Ong judicial mercy given his chronic illness, and argued for him to be fined in lieu of imprisonment. He will be sentenced on Aug 15. A second charge of abetting an offence was also taken into consideration. Judicial mercy gives courts the authority to give a more lenient sentence in exceptional mitigating circumstances, such as a terminal illness or when imprisonment could pose a high risk of endangering a life. The defence submitted that Ong suffers from multiple myeloma, an incurable cancer that affects his blood plasma cells and renders him immuno-compromised. The case has been the subject of major intrigue in Singapore, a wealthy financial hub that offers ministers salaries of more than S$1 million ($775,000) to deter graft and prides itself on its reputation for clean governance. Ong had informed Iswaran that his associates had been questioned and a private flight manifest with Iswaran's name on it for a flight from Singapore to Doha had been seized by the corruption watchdog during investigations. This led Iswaran to ask Ong to issue an invoice through Singapore GP, promoter of the Singapore F1 Grand Prix, to bill him for the trip, which prosecutors say Iswaran knew would make it less likely that he would be investigated. Iswaran was sentenced to 12 months in prison in October 2024, the first time a former cabinet member had ever been jailed in Singapore, on charges of obstructing justice and receiving more than $300,000 worth of gifts. In February, Iswaran was put under house arrest for the remainder of his sentence. Ong gave Iswaran tickets to English Premier League soccer matches, the Singapore Formula 1 Grand Prix, London musicals and a ride on a private jet among other favours. Iswaran was an adviser to the Singapore Grand Prix's steering committee, while Ong, 79, owns the rights to the race. The billionaire stepped down as managing director of Singapore-listed Hotel Properties in April.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump-requested Epstein and Maxwell grand jury records cover only two witnesses
The grand jury transcripts President Donald Trump is seeking in New York as he tries to quell his base's outrage over the White House's decision not to release files related to Jeffrey Epstein cover only two witnesses, according to the Justice Department. Those witnesses are an FBI agent and a detective with the New York Police Department, DOJ officials said in a July 29 court filing. Both witnesses testified in the federal grand jury proceedings that led to charges against convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell, who is currently serving a 20-year prison sentence. Only the FBI agent testified before the grand jury that charged Epstein with sex trafficking in 2019. The fact that just two people are on the witness list, both members of law enforcement, could mean the transcripts might not be revelatory, even if they are released. A Manhattan federal district court is currently deciding whether to unseal the records for public viewing. A Florida federal district court separately ruled July 23 that Epstein-related records tied to federal grand jury proceedings in that state must remain private. The New York police detective who testified in the Maxwell-related proceedings in Manhattan was serving with the FBI's Child Exploitation and Human Trafficking Task Force at the time, according to the Justice Department. What will be new in grand jury transcripts? The Justice Department offered a couple of indications in the latest court filing that the transcripts might not reveal much that the public doesn't already know. In addition to just having two witnesses in the transcripts, the court filing suggests that at least a significant portion of what those witnesses said may have been repeated at trial by victims of Epstein and Maxwell. In other words, it wouldn't be new information to the public. "Many of the victims whose accounts relating to Epstein and Maxwell that were the subject of grand jury testimony testified at trial consistent with the accounts described by an FBI agent and the detective," according to the Justice Department's filing. Some of the victims also publicized their accounts in the context of civil lawsuits, the department added. Several witnesses testified in Maxwell's month-long trial in 2021, which ended with her conviction for conspiring to entice and transport minors for illegal sex acts with Epstein and sex trafficking a minor to him. Prosecutors said Maxwell helped Epstein recruit, groom, and abuse minor girls from about 1994 to about 2004, including girls as young as 14. Will transcripts satisfy public outrage over Epstein? Justice Department officials asked for the transcripts to be released at the request of Trump, who said in a Truth Social post on July 17 that he made the request based on "the ridiculous amount of publicity given to Jeffrey Epstein." Department officials have called for redacting personal identifying information if courts approve of making the records public. That caveat could further disappoint members of the public who have clamored for the government to release the names of any potential Epstein clients suspected of participating with the disgraced financier in a sex-trafficking ring. Several officials in Trump's administration have fanned the flames of those conspiracies for years, including FBI Director Kash Patel, who told right-wing media figure Glenn Beck in 2023 that the head of President Joe Biden's FBI had direct control of an Epstein "black book." However, in a memo released July 7, the Justice Department and the FBI said a review of the government's records on Epstein failed to turn up a client list and that no further disclosures were warranted. In the wake of that memo, even some congressional Republicans have clamored for the files' release or introduced legislation to try to force the Trump administration's hand. Republican leadership has so far blocked the legislation, and White House officials continue to resist those calls. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell grand jury records cover only two witnesses Solve the daily Crossword
