Liberal MP criticizes Modi's G7 invitation in meeting with Prime Minister Carney
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrives to receive visiting Angolan President João Lourenco at the Indian presidential palace in New Delhi, India on Saturday, May 3, 2025. (AP Photo/Manish Swarup)
OTTAWA -- B.C. Liberal MP Sukh Dhaliwal said he met with Prime Minister Mark Carney Wednesday morning to push back against the decision to invite Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the G7 summit in Alberta next week.
In an interview with The Canadian Press before that meeting took place, Dhaliwal said he spoke with hundreds of people who don't want Modi to attend the upcoming leaders summit -- some of them members of the Liberal caucus.
'We as Canadians take pride to be a champion on human rights. We are the country of law and justice,' Dhaliwal said Tuesday. 'When it comes to protecting fundamental rights and serving justice for the victim, it is non-negotiable.'
In 2023 and 2024, former prime minister Justin Trudeau and the RCMP said there was evidence linking agents of the Indian government to the murder of Canadian Sikh separatism activist Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Surrey, B.C., in June 2023.
Last October, RCMP Commissioner Mike Duheme said the police force had evidence linking Indian government officials to other crimes in Canada, including extortion, coercion and homicide.
Justice Marie-Josee Hogue, who led the public inquiry into foreign political interference last year, reported that China and India are among the primary actors behind foreign inference operations targeting Canada.
Carney issued an invitation to Modi in a phone call on June 6.
Dhaliwal said Wednesday that he met with Carney Wednesday before the weekly Liberal caucus meeting and shared concerns about that invitation that were raised by constituents.
'Now that (Modi's) invited, we have to move forward,' Dhaliwal said. '(Carney) is alarmed about the issue and he will be very strong in dealing with those issues that are important to Canadians.'
Gurbux Saini, another B.C. Liberal MP, said the decision to invite Modi to the G7 and the invitation extended to Saudi Arabian Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman are undermining Canada's reputation as a champion of human rights.
'It is a damaging thing because we have been known in the world as caring and compassionate people who love human rights, and this is something the prime minister is aware of and it has been brought to his attention,' Saini said Wednesday.
Canada has invited Saudi Arabia's de facto leader to the G7 summit, according to two Canadian government officials who were not authorized to speak publicly about Canada's invitation list.
As of mid-afternoon Wednesday, Riyadh had not indicated whether it had accepted the invitation.
Carney did not respond to reporters' questions on his way into the caucus meeting Wednesday.
International Trade Minister Maninder Sidhu said some of his constituents have raised concerns with him about 'invitations to leaders.'
'But I think it's important to note that at this time, at a time of crisis, we need to be able to collaborate and of course work out some issues,' Sidhu said before entering the caucus room.
The crisis Sidhu referred to is the tariff war with the U.S.
Dhaliwal, who represents the riding where Nijjar was killed, said Tuesday the invitation betrays Canadian values.
'Before we invited him, Prime Minister Modi should have committed that he and his team or his associates or his departments will fully co-operate with the Canadian authorities,' Dhaliwal said Tuesday.
Carney said he wants to keep policing matters separate from Canada's responsibilities as G7 chair and has argued that India, one of the world's largest economies, belongs at the table.
Carney has said India agreed to continue 'law enforcement dialogue.'
Modi's comment on his Friday call with Carney did not mention policing.
The NDP condemned the decision to invite Modi. At a press conference on Parliament Hill Wednesday morning, Alberta NDP MP Heather McPherson accused the Carney government of putting 'profits over people.'
'That's appalling. For me, what it indicated, this government has consistently and very clearly chosen profits and the economy over human rights,' McPherson said.
'I think all Canadians expect their government to provide good, family-sustaining jobs, but not at the expense of human rights.'
At a Tuesday webinar organized by the Asia Pacific Foundation, a federal think tank, experts argued Canada can use the G7 summit to build a functional relationship with India on trade, clean energy and dealing with China.
C. Raja Mohan of the Council for Strategic and Defense Research in New Delhi argued that South Asia's political concerns are going to continue to resonate across the English-speaking world, in part due to high emigration to places like Canada, the U.S. and Britain.
He said that creates 'a structural problem' where foreign interference and extremist elements among Sikh activists can create tensions for both India and other countries.
'This is going to get worse. After all, politics is not going to cease, either in the West or in India,' he said.
Mohan argued Ottawa and New Delhi must find ways to address these issues through sustained, long-term law enforcement co-operation, rather than 'public posturing.'
'How do you prevent Indian politics from poisoning Canadian politics, or prevent political mobilization within the ... Anglo-American world from ... generating problems for India?' he asked.
'This is something we have to manage over the longer term, and there are not going to be these high-minded, declaratory solutions to this.'
Michael Kugelman, a senior fellow with the Asia Pacific Foundation, said he suspects India will be observing how Ottawa responds to any protests against Modi in Canada.
'New Delhi will be watching this very closely,' he said.
Kugelman said the G7 visit could be a way to build trust between Canada and India, and might lead to more a substantive reset of relations before the November G20 summit in South Africa.
By David Baxter and Dylan Robertson
With files from Nick Murray
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 11, 2025.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
36 minutes ago
- CBC
Ottawa turns down St. John's $5M plan to turn commercial space into homes
The federal government has turned down a $5 million plan from the City of St. John's to turn commercial property to residential units, according to a member of city council. While the money would not have been limited to downtown properties, St. John's city councillor Ron Ellsworth said the proposal was part of a push to get more people living in the city's downtown area. "If we want the downtown businesses, if we want the downtown services and programs to continue to serve, we need people living in the downtown and we have a lot of older commercial buildings that are very hard for conversion," he said in an interview with The St. John's Morning Show. The city applied for the money through the housing accelerator fund, a Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) initiative paid for by the federal government, intended to speed up housing development. The city of St. John's received $10.4 million from the fund last year, after the rejection of another previous application. CBC News has asked the CMHC to comment on why it turned down the city's proposal. Ellsworth said the city applied for the money in response to former federal housing minister Sean Fraser's challenge for "aggressive" ideas to tackle housing. "This was an opportunity to do something different, something unique. And while it was well received, obviously like all of us, you have a limited amount of funding and the federal government decided other projects ranked higher and we were not successful," he said. Ellsworth said the city wouldn't take on the task of converting commercial properties itself; rather, it would use the money to work with commercial property owners. Downtown business association in favour Scott Cluney, executive director of the Downtown St. John's business association, said he's all for commercial to residential conversions in the downtown area. "One of the things that makes a strong, vibrant downtown is more people living in the downtown," he said. "The more people who live in the downtown supports the business community in the downtown." Cluney said he doesn't necessarily believe converting commercial properties to residential units would drive commercial rent up — especially if buildings remained as mixed-use, with businesses at street level and residential units on upper floors. Though the city wasn't successful with its proposal, Cluney said he's heard from property owners who are considering commercial to residential conversions. "It's something that a lot of property owners have been looking at a fair bit in the past as especially as it relates to some of the older stock buildings," he said. Some projects are already under development. On June 3, St. John's city council advanced a proposal to convert 275 Duckworth St., a commercial property built in 1911, to residential units. Raising the Roof, a non-profit group, is planning to turn the building into 34 affordable micro-units. Ellsworth voted in favour of the proposal. "We're trying to encourage our diversity of housing options and this is the real first option we've had for the downtown core," he said. The city is in Year 2 of a housing master plan, using the $10.4 million to modernize regulations and eliminate certain fees for developers. Ellsworth said the next phase for the city is working with community organizations on further housing initiatives.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
CBRM councillors call for thorough review of fire departments, equipment and staffing
Councillors in the Cape Breton Regional Municipality have called for a full review of volunteer and career fire services over concerns about the number of departments and the cost of staffing and equipping them. This week, Coun. Gordon MacDonald called for a thorough review following talks over a lengthy list of issues raised at last week's meeting. "We know through our discussions at the committee of the whole last week that there are many deficiencies and inefficiencies happening in fire services," he said Tuesday. "We've really got to start identifying where these issues are, what [are] the issues that they're causing to fire services, where the resources are needed the most [and] how best we are able to get those resources to protect the citizens of the CBRM." Last week, the Glace Bay volunteer fire department threw up its hands and ceded budgeting of its operations entirely to CBRM's fire service. At the same time, the municipality's fire chief and deputy chief warned council that more than 20 fire trucks in various stations across the municipality are nearly 25 years old and are about to reach the end of their useful life and could cost at least $20 million to replace. Council also heard from the regional fire chiefs association that volunteer ranks are getting desperately slim. Councillors unanimously agreed to have the chief administrative officer conduct a review, but they did not set a timeline on the review or determine how it should be done. In 2016, CBRM commissioned a consultant to review the fire service, resulting in what's known as the Manitou report. It recommended centralizing control and funding of the entire fire service and eliminating some stations, but that has not happened. Deputy Mayor Eldon MacDonald said that report would be a good starting point. "We need to provide our services [as] fast and efficient to our residents as possible and currently that's not happening and that review is much needed," he said. Two stations in Sydney are staffed around the clock by unionized career firefighters. CBRM also has 32 volunteer departments throughout the county. Three of them — in the former towns of Glace Bay, New Waterford and North Sydney — are considered composite stations that are owned and run by volunteers but also have a full-time career firefighter on hand around the clock. Fire service officials say the rising cost of firefighting equipment and vehicles has made it unaffordable for many volunteer departments to operate as they used to, citing that as the main reason Glace Bay handed its budgeting over to the municipality. CBRM does provide grants for equipment and vehicles, but Deputy Chief Craig MacNeil said a basic truck now costs around $900,000 without the modifications required for local equipment and needs. He would not say that CBRM has too many departments and vehicles, but he has been asking volunteer departments about the possibility of downsizing the fleet. List of pressures going to province "We have 130 pieces of equipment right now in CBRM," he said. "That's the exact same amount of equipment [Halifax Regional Municipality] has. We have a lot of fire trucks and a lot of fire stations." MacNeil said even if a 25-year-old truck still runs, the insurance industry considers it as being at the end of its life, and keeping it in service could cost the municipality and property owners more in insurance premiums. Council has not decided how it will handle the 22 aging vehicles but has agreed to review and consider the list, and Mayor Cecil Clarke said it will be added to a list of financial pressures that CBRM intends to take to the provincial government. The overall review is also expected to consider volunteer numbers, which are a concern as well, Westmount fire Chief Rod Beresford told council last week. Beresford, who chairs CBRM's association of regional chiefs, said even in departments where numbers are higher, the volunteers are not all fully trained. In Westmount, a suburb on the opposite side of the harbour from Sydney, only one volunteer works in the area during the day, Beresford said. And a neighbouring department with more volunteers does not always have a fully trained complement, he said, so backup firefighters might be able to arrive on scene with a truck, but might not be trained to fight a large structure fire. That's why he asked for and got approval for an automatic response from career firefighters in Sydney for any call involving a possible or working structure fire in Westmount's territory. Meanwhile, a provincewide review of fire governance that's also underway is expected to be completed by the end of this year.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Some fishing groups say relationship with DFO is heading in positive direction
The heads of two Nova Scotia fishing groups say there are signs that the often-contentious relationship between the industry and the federal Department of Fisheries and Oceans is now heading in a promising direction. In Nova Scotia, a perceived lack of enforcement over unlicensed fishing in the baby eel fishery has been one of the sources of that contention, as well as illegal lobster fishing in the southwestern part of the province. Colin Sproul, president of the Unified Fisheries Conservation Alliance, said he believes there's a "course correction" happening with the federal department. "I think that each time a new minister has been appointed, there's been a hope that they would set a new direction on this issue and the department, but I feel like this time we've seen some evidence that that's the way it's going," he said. "And I've heard that from some of my colleagues as well." One of the things Sproul pointed to was increased enforcement in the baby eel fishery on Nova Scotia's South Shore. He said this has included more arrests and seizing more vehicles and juvenile eels, known as elvers, this year. The valuable eels have fetched up to $5,000 per kilogram in recent years, before being shipped off to Asia where they are grown to adulthood for food. Their value has made them attractive to illegal fishers. According to DFO's website, fishery officers have carried out 1,074 riverside inspections, 144 inspections at holding facilities and 295 inspections at airports in the 2025 season. "It's one more indication to me that a new prime minister and a new minister of fisheries are taking the extreme dangers to Nova Scotia's resources seriously," said Sproul. Fisheries Minister Joanne Thompson was appointed to the position in mid-March, shortly before Prime Minister Mark Carney called a federal election. She retained the position post-election. Sproul also applauded DFO removing unauthorized traps from Malpeque Bay, P.E.I., in late May and June. Lennox Island First Nation says those traps belong to its moderate livelihood fishery. The Mi'kmaq have a right to fish for a "moderate livelihood" outside of the commercial fishery that's rigorously regulated by the federal government, a right that was reaffirmed by the Supreme Court of Canada's Marshall decision in 1999. And while a subsequent clarification, known as Marshall II, said the government can regulate a resource in certain circumstances, it has been up to Ottawa, in consultation with First Nations, to establish what constitutes a moderate livelihood. That has not happened. Lennox Island First Nation set 1,500 moderate livelihood lobster traps this year — 100 traps each for 15 fishermen from the community — but DFO has said it approved only up to 1,000. Sproul said the Unified Fisheries Conservation Alliance respects and supports treaty rights, but believes the fisheries minister has sole regulatory authority. The minister was recently in Nova Scotia. According to an email from DFO, Thompson visited Cape Breton from June 6 to 8 to attend the Canadian Coast Guard College graduation ceremony, visited a local search and rescue station and met with stakeholders in the fishing industry. It's unclear how many meetings were held and with what groups. Dan Fleck, executive director of the Brazil Rock 33/34 Lobster Association, did not attend any of these meetings. He said there appears to be more willingness from the federal government to listen and learn. "It's nice to be listened to, it's nice to be heard," he said. Fleck said he's been pleased with the enforcement actions against the illegal elver and lobster fishing industries. "We're seeing some positive signs that those are going to be addressed," he said.
