Man who killed elderly woman in e-scooter hit-and-run avoids further prison time
Mary Bernie (87), known as Peg, died from her injuries three days after Aaron Gumble knocked her down with a stolen e-scooter at Eccles Street, Dublin 7.
He had been on bail for theft offences at the time, and
was jailed for six-and-a-half years
last year and disqualified from driving for 10 years.
In that case, he pleaded guilty to dangerous driving causing death on June 20th, 2023, leaving the scene and theft of an e-scooter from the underground car park of the Mater Public Hospital.
In his latest case to be finalised, Gumble (29) of Drumalee Park, North Circular Road, Dublin 7, pleaded guilty on Wednesday to incidents in central Dublin on July 21st and September 6th, 2021.
Dublin District Court heard that during the first incident at an Ellis Quay apartment block at 11.39pm, Gumble opened a door with a kick.
He forcibly opened a second door leading into a courtyard where CCTV filmed him trying to enter the underground car park, but he failed to get in and left the scene.
The court heard on the second date at 11.45pm that a resident returned to his city centre apartment and found his €750 bicycle, which had two locks attached, was missing. One lock was still attached to a rack, and the other was broken on the ground. The bicycle was taken and never recovered.
Judge Treasa Kelly noted his 144 prior convictions included vehicle theft, burglaries, attempted theft, theft, and trespass, but he had received a lengthy sentence last year for the dangerous driving causing death incident.
Pleading for leniency, defence solicitor Aoife McTaggart acknowledged her client's 'appalling record'; however, she stressed the charges before the court went back a few years, when a younger Gumble was less wise.
She asked the judge to consider that her client pleaded guilty without waiting for disclosure of evidence and to give him credit.
Since going into custody, he has made great efforts in Mountjoy Prison, where he ended up in the progression unit and has been an 'enhanced prisoner', taking course after course. The solicitor added that he was also drug-free.
Passing sentence, Judge Kelly noted the mitigating points raised, that he had 'turned a corner,' and that he had already been serving a jail term for several years. She imposed a six-month concurrent sentence from Wednesday.
Gumble stood silently throughout the hearing and spoke only to say, 'Thanks, judge' at the end of the proceedings.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Irish in Germany are caught between starkly different perspectives on the war in Gaza
There was plenty for Tánaiste Simon Harris to discuss on Friday in Berlin with his new German foreign minister colleague, Johann Wadephul. After a chilly meeting of Irish and German foreign ministers last year, no joint press conference was planned this time around. Berlin and Dublin, traditionally close partners on EU and foreign policy, have found themselves far apart following the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on October 7th 2023, which claimed at least 1,200 lives. In his January 2024 visit, then-tánaiste Micheál Martin suggested Berlin's view of the Gaza conflict was constrained 'by the historical prism of the Holocaust', though 'evolving'. Germany's position has evolved quite a bit further since then, with growing public outrage here over Israel's Gaza blockade, settler violence in the West Bank and a Palestinian death toll nearing 60,000. A more critical tone towards Israel from the new German government, however, has yet to be matched in any significant policy shift. The current Israel-Hamas conflict, for many Irish people living in Germany, resembles what John le Carré once called a 'looking glass war'. In their daily lives here and during visits back to Ireland, the German-Irish negotiate two separate minefields with one common denominator: dissent from the majority opinion – or attempts at differentiation in the public debate – are often denounced. READ MORE The most visible sign of tension surrounds two Irish citizens who face expulsion from Germany in connection with their alleged role in pro-Palestinian demonstrations, including a violent confrontation at a Berlin university. Their precise role in what happened there has yet to be established and, in an emergency injunction, a Berlin court has halted expulsion proceedings until after trial, likely in the autumn. That didn't stop Berlin's governing mayor Kai Wegner prejudging them, in a national newspaper, as 'anti-Semitic criminals'. Many Irish people here who join Gaza solidarity marches, as they would if they were in Ireland, report harassment in their workplace and police violence. Some face charges they view as spurious and – after 18 months and counting – the charges have neither come to trial nor been dropped. That keeps them flagged in police databases, making every re-entry to Germany a stressful business of arbitrary delays and border police questions. For them, this is official Germany's intentional chilling effect for holding the 'wrong' views on Gaza. (A similar chilling effect, critics of Israel's Gaza war say, follows German efforts since November 2023 to outlaw every public utterance of 'from the river to the sea' as an illegal slogan supporting the proscribed Hamas group. In May a Berlin court dismissed one such prosecution as a politicised endeavour lacking evidence and any legal standing.) The colonial framing of the Gaza conflict, as popularised by Kneecap, gets an airing in Germany, particularly in universities, but others reject it as ill fit for the complexities of the conflict All of this is attracting outside attention. Last month the Council of Europe, the continent's leading human rights body, sent a two-page letter of concern to the Berlin federal government. Police violence, limits to freedom of assembly and 'the blanket classification of criticism of Israel as anti-Semitism', the letter warned, do a disservice to democracy and may even endanger it'. While German officials dismiss such concerns, campaigners are already collating information about the crackdown they see. And writer Maxim Biller has even devised a diagnosis for the motivation: Morbus Israel, Germany's Israel disorder. 'At the core of [this] neo-German Orient neurosis is, very loosely: Germans' disappointed love for their former victims,' he argued in a column for Die Zeit weekly. His polemical text was later removed from the Zeit website following protests over his description of the 'strategically correct but inhumane hunger blockade of Gaza'. [ An Irishman in Berlin: 'For Germans, everything is forbidden unless it allowed' Opens in new window ] As the conflict drags on, though, some Irish in Germany wonder – quietly and cautiously – if Ireland has a disorder of its own. Earlier in the conflict, before everything was eclipsed by the real and justified horror over children being starved – or shot dead by Israel soldiers – one Irish acquaintance asked: where was the Irish protest over Hamas contempt for – and human rights violations of – its own people? Given the unprecedented degradation in Gaza, such questions may seem like cynical what-aboutery. Yet another middle-aged Irish acquaintance, living in Germany as long as the Belfast Agreement, wondered aloud recently how Irish people, who resented the IRA killing people on their behalf, feel about Hamas doing the same for Palestinians? The colonial framing of the Gaza conflict, as popularised by Kneecap, gets an airing in Germany, particularly in universities, but others reject it as ill fit for the complexities of the conflict. After a strange start, Germany's debate has shifted radically in recent months. The popular Bild tabloid still ignores the reality in Gaza and denounces Palestinian solidarity marchers as 'Jew haters', but other outlets offer a broader and more challenging range of views. [ Israeli foreign minister finds shifting moods as he visits Berlin Opens in new window ] On Wednesday, the Süddeutsche Zeitung daily printed a harrowing 5,000-word report on the starve-or-be-shot reality in Gaza. A day later, it ran a full-page essay by French-Israeli sociologist Eva Illouz, asking 'Is anti-Zionism a form of anti-Semitism?' With large Jewish, Israeli and Palestinian communities, Germany's Israel-Gaza-Hamas debate is messy, emotional, confused and conflicted. A diverse range of voices compete to be heard, airing grievances which not all share but are nonetheless real. Two conflicts are playing out, as Berlin arms one side and tries to feed the other. Attempting to meet two non-negotiable postwar obligations – to Israel and human dignity – has created a domestic conflict of conscience with an equally unpredictable outcome. By comparison, many Irish living in Germany perceive Ireland's debate as Irish people telling other Irish people, at no personal cost and from a safe distance, how terrible things are for the Palestinians. A recent public television poll here asked who respondents feel is responsible for the plight of the civilian population in Gaza. Some 69 per cent said the Israeli government was fully or partly to blame while 71 per cent said the same of Hamas. How would a similar poll look in Ireland? Ireland and Germany hold competing views on the conflict, yet both have considerable credibility among Palestinians and Israelis respectively. How can our two countries leverage that good will for a better future in the Middle East? That is a debate worth having.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Tour de France's version of VAR? Get ready for yellow card controversy
The 2025 Tour de France could see yellow cards issued for bad behaviour by riders thanks to cycling's answer to VAR. Every touch of shoulders, switch of wheels, dramatic acceleration and multilingual insult in the peloton will be scrutinised by a growing number of in-race cameras and UCI commissaries. As part of the UCI's bid to expand its repertoire of disciplinary and investigative tools, cards can be awarded for everything from celebrating a team-mate's win to riding on the pavement. The card system was trialled last year and is now being integrated into World Tour racing. If, during this year's Tour, a rider is given two yellow cards during the race, he may be disqualified and suspended for seven days, while any rider accumulating three cards in 30 days is liable to be suspended for 14 days. The first rider to be suspended under the new system was the Dutch rider Oscar Riesebeek, of the Alpecin-Deceuninck team, who received two yellow cards in three days in May. 'Looking back, I realise my behaviour in the race was not only wrong, but also put fellow riders at risk,' he said. READ MORE Although there are not yet referees brandishing cards in riders' faces, they are, just as in other sports, subject to a degree of interpretation. An overlong 'sticky bottle' – a rider holding on for too long to drinks bottles passed up from his team car – may also be sanctioned, although the exact time allowed remains unclear. Oscar Riesebeek. Photograph: David Stockman/BELGA MAG/AFP via Getty Images In the past high-profile riders such as the 2014 Tour winner, Vincenzo Nibali, and the former British national time trial champion, Josh Tarling, have fallen foul of race commissaries and been evicted from races for protracted 'sticky bottles'. More seriously, assault, intimidation, insults, threats, improper conduct, including pulling the jersey or saddle of another rider, or hitting them with a helmet, knee, elbow, shoulder, foot or hand, will also be sanctioned. But there have also been some accusations of over-zealous rule-making on the part of the UCI, particularly when it comes to riders raising their arms at the back of a finish line sprint, in celebration of a team-mate's success. 'What is yellow and what isn't yellow?' the sprinter Jasper Philipsen, Riesebeek's team-mate and winner of three stages in last year's Tour, said, after a crash in the Baloise Belgium Tour led to fellow rider Davide Bomboi being punished. 'He had done nothing wrong,' said Philipsen. 'Yellow was unjust and unnecessary.' But while cameras will be used to punish aggressive, dangerous or unsporting behaviour, they will also play a role in detecting any other signs of technical fraud, such as motor doping, during the race. During each stage, the UCI will run an 'incident and performance monitoring programme', effectively watching the peloton through a battery of lenses, not just for unsporting behaviour but also for unusual or suspicious body language while riding. 'Anything that arouses suspicion will be identified, enabling better targeting of checks,' the UCI said. The UCI will have multiple cameras watching the race, according to the UCI jury member and commissaire Kenneth Simonsson. UAE Team Emirate riders cycle through Lille city centre during the team presentation day on Thursday ahead of this year's Tour de France. Photograph: Anne-Christine Poujoulat/AFP via Getty Images 'We have five motorbike cameras, two helicopters and fixed cameras in the finish area, totalling 14 different feeds, during the stage. We record any incidents and share it with our jury colleagues, to discuss after the race.' This is in addition to the usual post-race bike checks on the stage winner, the leader of each classification, a selection of random riders and 'any rider who gives rise to suspicion, for example following the pre-stage control or as a result of events identified during in-race monitoring'. The UCI says this heightened strategy enables it to 'continuously monitor changes and anomalies in bike equipment and configuration,' through 'pre-race magnetometer scans, incident and performance monitoring, and post-race X-ray inspections'. The man leading the fight on motor doping, a former US homeland security investigator, Nick Raudenski, remains keen to keep a low profile at major races, but says monitoring rider behaviour is an increasingly important tool in his efforts to prevent technological fraud. The American has likened the threat of motor doping to a 'technological arms race'. The UCI president, David Lappartient, was more blunt. 'If we have a case of cheating with a motor in the bike – sorry, but it will destroy our sport,' Lappartient said in 2024. Raudenski sees VAR as an essential component for 'watching how performances happen, watching biomechanical behaviour, watching how riders are acting and how they react to us, when we do a bike check'. Aligned with the greater scrutiny is an appeal to the consciences of those working within the sport, after the UCI launched an informant reward programme last year to further accelerate investigation of technological fraud. 'We want people who have an interest in doing the right thing,' Raudenski said. 'We have to move towards a culture of integrity.' – Guardian
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Such a lovely family': Mother and daughter who died in Donegal crash named locally
A mother and daughter who died following a road crash near Carndonagh, Co Donegal on Wednesday evening have been named locally. They were Natalie McLaughlin and her six-year-old daughter Ella McLaughlin from Carndonagh. Ms McLaughlin's partner, Tyrone Irwin, is still in a serious condition at Altnagelvin Hospital in Derry but his injuries are not understood to be life-threatening. The couple's other daughter, Rhea Rose (2), was transferred to the Royal Victoria Hospital from Altnagelvin for specialist treatment but her injuries are also understood to not be life-threatening. READ MORE The crash happened at 6.30pm on Wednesday following a collision between a car and a van at Glentogher, Carndonagh. Ella was pronounced dead at the scene while her mother, father and sister were rushed to the nearest hospital across the border in Derry. The driver of the van, who is in his late teens, was treated at the scene but his injuries are not understood to be serious. The scene of the crash. Photograph: Joe Dunne/North West Newspix Ms McLaughlin was initially treated at Altnagelvin Hospital in Derry but was transferred to the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast where she died yesterday afternoon as a result of her injuries. Ms McLaughlin, who was in her 20s, was well-known in her native Carndonagh where she worked as a nurse in a local doctor's surgery. She qualified with a Bachelor of Science in Adult Nursing from Ulster University and began working as a Registered Nurse in 2022. Her parents – Ella's grandparents, Danny and Joanne, and both extended families were last night being comforted by friends. Cathaoirleach of the Inishowen Municipal Authority, Cllr Martin McDermott, said his thoughts and prayers are with the entire family. 'Words fall short at this time, what can anybody say? They are such a lovely family and so well respected in our local community,' he said. 'It's just devastating. The loss of anybody on our roads is difficult for any community to take. 'But the loss of a mother and daughter, particularly given the fact that they are so young, is even more poignant and more difficult to accept. 'People are just numb and there is very little I can add to that other than to keep them all in our thoughts and prayers.' Gardaí continue to investigate all aspects of the collision. The road on which the collision occurred, the R240 at Carrowmore, was closed for a technical examination by Forensic Collision Investigators but reopened yesterday afternoon. Gardaí are appealing to anyone who may have witnessed this collision to contact them. Any road users who may have camera footage and were travelling in the area between 6pm and 6.30pm on Wednesday, 2nd July is asked to make this footage available to investigating Gardaí. Anyone with information is asked to contact Buncrana Garda station on 074 932 0540, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda station.
