Major blow to Pornhub as France's highest court re-introduces age verification
The ruling from the state council on Tuesday comes only weeks after the Paris administrative court suspended a governmental decree requiring age verification for EU-based porn websites in June.
Today's decision is the latest development in the dispute championed by French Digital Minister Clara Chappaz, affecting adult websites including Pornhub, YouPorn and Redtube which are owned by Cyprus-based company Aylo as well as xhamster-owner Hammy Media.
"The State Council has decided: the law has to be followed," wrote Chappaz on X.
But the council's ruling only suspends the June court decision and does not pre-empt the forthcoming preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU).
The CJEU must determine whether the French government's decree requiring EU-based porn companies to comply with national law conflicts with EU law.
In short, this is merely a temporary victory for Chappaz, as the CJEU could still annul the French government's decree for failure to comply with EU law.
It remains unclear whether Aylo will shut down its websites in France, as it did in June to protest enforcement of the French SREN law – the law the government decree aimed at enforcing.
The European Commission on Monday proposed new guidelines to protect minors online. France claimed victory, saying the Commission's proposal enshrined its own approach mandating age verification for accessing pornographic website throughout the EU.
Aylo did not respond to a request for a comment at the time of reporting. (vib)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euractiv
9 hours ago
- Euractiv
The Brief – EU AI code passes the Meta stress test, now it's time for hardball
The EU wants to set the global standard for responsible AI regulation. But it fears that complicated digital rules could block its nascent AI industry from succeeding in the intensifying race for AI dominance. Nowhere have these rivalling ambitions clashed more than over the EU's new general-purpose AI Code of Practice, which details the AI Act's vague requirements for ChatGPT and the likes. 1,000 lobbyists with irreconcilable views have fought it out over 12 heated months. While companies demanded minimal requirements, the Commission promised an innovation-friendly implementation. For their part, civil society and MEPs panicked that the Code (which grants presumed compliance) would undermine an essential part of the AI Act. The make-or-break moment has now arrived, as companies decide whether or not to sign on to the final Code. The world's wealthiest companies will have few qualms in signing a weak Code, which will grant them a cheap and easy path to making their most powerful technology AI Act compliant. But a more exacting Code runs the risk of having no signatories at all – making a mockery of the Commission's business-friendly pitch. A sigh of relief in the Berlaymont then, when ChatGPT-maker OpenAI and French challenger Mistral said they would sign last week. Meta, by contrast, will not sign the Code. This is good news: The tech giant's refusal signals that the intense industry pressure failed to fully warp the Code to Meta's liking. Commission let tech firms water down key AI Act text, NGOs claim The allegations come at a critical juncture in the EU's development of its AI rulebook. Mark Zuckerberg is hell-bent on winning the AI race. He has reportedly offered salary packages of €260 million – worth more than 99.996% of European companies – to at least 10 top AI researchers to poach talent for a new 'superintelligence' team. At the same time, he and Meta have repeatedly demonstrated that they are bad-faith actors who must be dragged kicking and screaming to comply with EU laws. In June last year, Meta halted its AI rollout in Europe after its opt-out scheme to train AI on social media posts was peppered with data protection complaints. It warned that EU rules would create a 'gap in the technologies that are available in Europe,' versus the rest of the world. In April, it relaunched AI features with a minimally adjusted opt-out scheme to train on users' posts. The pattern is clear: First, Meta rolls out a model it knows will challenge EU laws, preferring to lawyer up rather than practise due diligence. Then it loudly accuses the EU of strangling innovation and causing legal uncertainty, threatening to pull its products from the market. When push comes to shove, it makes marginal adjustments that stretch the law to its limits. It's not just AI training – the company battles with all the EU's digital laws. Meta has been clashing with the Commission over its "pay or consent" advertising model, for which it was fined €200 million in April and could still face further fines. Meta is under investigation for breaching the EU's digital platforms law, and is separately accused of partnering with sanctioned Russian publishers. Zuckerberg, who alone holds majority voting shares in the €1.5 trillion company, is spearheading Meta's cynicism. After Donald Trump took office, Zuckerberg turned on a dime to dismiss fact-checking as censure and praised growing 'masculine energy' in the private sector. Meta is calling for Trump to intervene against EU enforcement of digital rules, which Zuckerberg has likened to tariffs. The list goes on. Time and again, Meta has shown it has no interest in honest and constructive dialogue. Zuckerberg is moving fast to break things, including the EU's AI rulebook. Meta's condemnation should be a relief. 'What will, however, not be voluntary for Meta is to be compliant with the AI Act by 2 August,' said a Commission spokesperson today. Roundup Strategic joint procurement of critical raw materials and tighter business-to-business links are set to form the backbone of a new 'EU-Japan Competitiveness Alliance,' according to a draft summit communiqué seen by Euractiv, which is expected to be launched on Wednesday as EU leaders visit Asia. Fungicide-icide – An EU expert group has confirmed it has decided against the use of the fungicide potassium phosphonate in organic agriculture because the chemical is synthetic and leaves traces in food that persist for years. EU speaks on Israel aid killings – EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas told her Israeli counterpart Tuesday that Israel's military 'must stop' killing civilians at aid distribution points in Gaza, after the World Health Organization said its facilities in Gaza had been targeted by Israeli forces. Across Europe The Polish arm of Canadian-founded Central European Petroleum has announced Poland's largest-ever oil and gas discovery near Świnoujście off the Baltic coast, which could hold over 33 million tons of market-grade gas and provide Poland and the EU with much-needed gas. Anti-corruption changes – Ukraine MPs approved amendments to remove the independence of two Ukrainian anti-corruption bodies Tuesday, a day after the arrest of one of the agency's officials. The bodies will be placed under control of the prosecutor general, who is appointed by the president. Iran persists with nuclear programme – Iran is scheduled to meet Britain, France and Germany in Istanbul on Friday, but the nation has said it has no plans to abandon its nuclear programme, including uranium enrichment, despite the 'severe' damage caused by US strikes to its facilities. Iran will also meet with Chinese and Russian representatives on Tuesday.
Euractiv
10 hours ago
- Euractiv
European court says Turkey did not provide ‘fair trial' in app use case
The ECHR condemned on Tuesday "the domestic courts' categorical approach to the use of ByLock". "Under that approach, anyone whose use of ByLock was established by the domestic courts could, in principle, be convicted on that sole basis of membership in an armed terrorist organisation," the Strasbourg-based court said. Gulen, a cleric who died in 2024, was once a close ally of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan before the two became bitter enemies. He relocated to the United States in 1999 and never returned. Ankara considers ByLock to be the preferred communication tool of those allegedly responsible for the failed coup in 2016, which left 250 people dead and was followed by mass arrests and purges on a scale unprecedented in Turkey's modern history. Authorities have detained more than 25,000 people accused of belonging to the Hizmet movement since then, some 9,000 of whom have been held in custody, according to the Istanbul prosecutor's office. ECHR sees 'a systemic problem' It noted "a systemic problem" affecting a large number of people that must be resolved at the national level. Since the Grand Chamber's 2023 judgment, "the court has already given notice to the respondent government of 5,000 similar applications, and thousands more are still accumulating on its docket," the ECHR added. As of late June, Turkey had 21,050 pending applications to the court – which make up 35% of the total – followed Russia with 8,050 applications (13.4%) and Ukraine with 7,300 (12.1%). (vib)
Euractiv
10 hours ago
- Euractiv
EU tells Israel to stop killing Gazans at aid points
EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas told her Israeli counterpart Tuesday that Israel's military "must stop" killing civilians at aid distribution points in Gaza. Meanwhile, a spokesman for the bloc also condemned any attacks against the World Health Organisation after the agency said its facilities in Gaza had been targeted by Israeli forces. Kallas wrote on X that "the killing of civilians seeking aid in Gaza is indefensible." "I spoke again with Gideon Saar to recall our understanding on aid flow and made clear that IDF must stop killing people at distribution points," she wrote. The EU, early this month, said it had struck a deal with Israel to allow more access into Gaza amid Israel's devastating military operation. EU and Israel reach Gaza aid deal, Kallas says A "substantial increase of daily trucks" would happen in the "coming days", the EU's top diplomat said. Kallas has laid out a series of actions that EU states could take against Israel unless the dire humanitarian situation in Gaza improves. "All options remain on the table if Israel doesn't deliver on its pledges," Kallas wrote in a post on X. European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen joined the calls by saying, "civilians cannot be targets. Never." "The images from Gaza are unbearable," von der Leyen wrote. "Civilians in Gaza have suffered too much, for too long. It must stop now. Israel must deliver on its pledges." EU officials have said there have been some improvements for aid access to Gaza, but that a lot more needs to be done. Foreign ministers call for immediate Gaza ceasefire in joint statement "Only an immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire can end the suffering," said Equality Commissioner Hadja Lahbib on X. "Channels are open and pressure is actually being put on the Israeli counterpart, so time is of the essence," EU spokesman Anouar El Anouni said. The spokesman also condemned attacks on "any WHO premises or any hospitals" after the UN agency said Monday its facilities in Gaza had come under Israeli attack. "Let's be clear: premises of WHO must not be attacked and must be protected," he said. WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said the Israeli military had entered the UN agency's staff residence, forced women and children to evacuate on foot, and handcuffed, stripped and interrogated male staff at gunpoint. (mm)
