Major blow to Pornhub as France's highest court re-introduces age verification
The ruling from the state council on Tuesday comes only weeks after the Paris administrative court suspended a governmental decree requiring age verification for EU-based porn websites in June.
Today's decision is the latest development in the dispute championed by French Digital Minister Clara Chappaz, affecting adult websites including Pornhub, YouPorn and Redtube which are owned by Cyprus-based company Aylo as well as xhamster-owner Hammy Media.
"The State Council has decided: the law has to be followed," wrote Chappaz on X.
But the council's ruling only suspends the June court decision and does not pre-empt the forthcoming preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU).
The CJEU must determine whether the French government's decree requiring EU-based porn companies to comply with national law conflicts with EU law.
In short, this is merely a temporary victory for Chappaz, as the CJEU could still annul the French government's decree for failure to comply with EU law.
It remains unclear whether Aylo will shut down its websites in France, as it did in June to protest enforcement of the French SREN law – the law the government decree aimed at enforcing.
The European Commission on Monday proposed new guidelines to protect minors online. France claimed victory, saying the Commission's proposal enshrined its own approach mandating age verification for accessing pornographic website throughout the EU.
Aylo did not respond to a request for a comment at the time of reporting. (vib)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euractiv
an hour ago
- Euractiv
Commission chief urges Zelenskyy to ‘preserve' independence of anti-corruption bodies
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen on Sunday urged Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy to safeguard the independence of two key anti-corruption bodies, after a bill that would have placed them under presidential control sparked heavy backlash. Ukraine must " preserve independent anti-corruption bodies, which are cornerstones of Ukraine's rule of law," v on der Leyen wrote on X following her conversation with the Ukrainian leader. The warning comes after Ukraine's parliament on Tuesday approved amendments to a bill that would have placed two Ukrainian anti-corruption agencies under the supervision of the prosecutor general, who is appointed by the president. These changes have sparked domestic protests and drawn criticism from key allies, including European leaders. In a statement on Wednesday, the Commission said von der Leyen had "strong concerns" about the legislation. By Thursday, Zelenskyy had announced a reversal of the proposed changes, after thousands took to the streets in protest. The rule of law and independence of these bodies are central to the country's accession to the EU. "Rule of Law remains in the very center of EU accession negotiations" Enlargement Commissioner Marta Kos wrote on X following Tuesday's parliamentary vote. French President Emmanuel Macron also weighed in a post on X on Sunday, stressing the importance of safeguarding the independence of both bodies as a key step toward Ukraine's EU accession. Ukraine has " achieved a lot on its European path" von der Leyen added. "It must build on these solid foundations." (de)
Euractiv
2 hours ago
- Euractiv
Germany unlikely to fall foul of EU deficit rules
The European Commission will probably not impose a so-called excessive deficit procedure on Germany for breaching the EU's budget deficit cap this year, EU Economy Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis told the Financial Times. Germany's new conservative-led coalition government has said it does not expect a planned spending spree, including on defence, to be found in breach of EU rules that cap budget deficits at 3% of GDP. Berlin's budget deficit is expected to come in at 3.3% of GDP this year, but since defence spending fully accounts for the amount over 3%, Germany "is likely not to end up in (the) excessive deficit procedure" Dombrovskis was quoted as saying in the FT interview published Sunday. An excessive deficit procedure allows the Commission and EU finance ministers to issue recommendations on setting a corrective course to bring a member state's deficit back within the 3% limit. A country's failure to do so can in principle eventually lead to a fine. "We have to see the execution, because it's close (but) if everything holds, then it should not be the case for this year's budget," Dombrovskis said, adding that a final assessment would take place in the spring when data for 2025 is available. Under the EU's new fiscal rules, which the previous German government helped negotiate, member states can exclude some defence spending from their deficits. (de)
Euractiv
a day ago
- Euractiv
Hungary's Orban says he will not back EU budget unless funds released
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán threatened on Saturday to torpedo the European Union's new seven-year budget unless Brussels unlocks all suspended EU funds. The nationalist leader has for years clashed with Brussels over issues including migration, LGBTQ rights, and what critics see as eroding democracy in Hungary. The EU has suspended billions of euros earmarked for Hungary while a rule-of-law dispute drags on. "The approval of the new seven-year budget requires unanimity and until we get the remaining (frozen) funds, there won't be a new EU budget either," Orbán said in a speech at a summer university in the Romanian town of Baile Tusnad. The European Commission has proposed a €2 trillion EU budget for 2028-2034, with a focus on economic competitiveness and defence. Orbán also criticised the EU for supporting Ukraine and accused Brussels of planning to install a "pro-Ukraine and pro-Brussels government" in Hungary at next year's vote. He also accused EU leaders of risking a trade war with US President Donald Trump's administration that Europe "cannot win." "The current leadership of the EU will always be the last to sign deals with the United States and always the worst deals," Orbán added, urging a change in the bloc's leadership. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen will meet Trump on Sunday in Scotland in search of a trade deal. Orbán, who has dominated the past four national elections, faces a tough new opposition challenger Peter Maygar. His centre-right Tisza party has a firm lead over the ruling Fidesz in most polls at a time of economic stagnation. Magyar told a rally on Saturday that Hungary must be firmly anchored in the EU and NATO military alliance, and promised to secure all suspended EU funds if his party wins in 2026. "Hungary is an EU member and our relations as allies cannot be built on a political style of putting a spoke in the wheel," Magyar said, adding that while Tisza cannot support the proposed EU budget in its current form, it would be open to negotiations. "We need to make a clear and firm decision that our place has been and will be in Europe," Magyar said, criticising Orbán's close relations with Russia. (de)
