Will Zohran Mamdani help or hurt New York's economy?
The 33-year-old Democratic socialist proposed plans that would transform the city – including a free bus programme and freezing rent increases on rent-stabilised apartments – paid for by a heightened income tax for millionaires and an increase in the corporate tax rate.
Those promises catapulted him to ultimately win the mayoral primary 12 points ahead of his next closest competitor, Andrew Cuomo, who had been endorsed by the likes of former President Bill Clinton.
McKayla Lankau, a 25-year-old tech worker, had canvassed for Mamdani's campaign. She lives in Bushwick, a Brooklyn neighbourhood which Mamdani won by a 79-point margin, and said housing was among the many economic policies that emboldened her to vote for Mamdani.
'I believe that if people are living a better life in a more affordable community, we all will, and Zohran's campaign fulfilled that from my perspective,' said Lankau.
As the cost of living rises and US President Donald Trump continues a rightward march as he shapes political discourse, many voters feel Democratic leaders have offered little more than symbolic gestures and strongly worded statements.
Mamdani, a three-term state assembly member, presented something different– a campaign centred around grassroots organising over big donors, detailed policies over vague slogans, and the kind of charisma and gravitas that defined other change candidates like Barack Obama's successful presidential bid in 2008 or Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's surprise win of the House of Representatives in 2018.
Affordability was central to Mamdani's message – and it resonated. But Mamdani also faces another side of New York – the ultra-wealthy investor class. They are the ones who have made New York City known as the epicentre of global finance and commerce. They are a powerful force to be reckoned with, and they are not happy.
'They are mad that they lost, and they're used to getting their way. They're used to setting the rules…. Mamdani ran a transparent, clear campaign and New Yorkers showed up in droves to support it,' political strategist Adin Lenchner of Carroll Street Campaigns told Al Jazeera.
Some investors and lenders are threatening to pull out of deals amid fears of new taxes and regulations. Michael Comparato, a managing director at Benefit Street Partners, said he walked away from a $300m hotel investment in New York. 'The financial capital of the world could be in the hands of a socialist. Hard to fathom,' he posted on LinkedIn. Comparato did not respond to requests for comment.
While Democratic socialism – an ideology that believes in shifting power from corporations to workers within the framework of a capitalist democracy – is different from socialism, that sentiment echoed across the city's financial power players.
Hedge fund manager Bill Ackman said he was 'gravely concerned' about Mamdani's rise, warning that the city would become 'economically unviable'. He pledged to support a more 'centrist' candidate. Pershing Square, his firm, declined to comment.
'The fear isn't about economics, I think it's about power,' Lenchner said. 'That doesn't mean the policy is unsound. I think affordability is economic growth.'
Mamdani's funding proposals are ambitious but not unprecedented. He would raise the city's corporate tax rate to 11.5 percent – matching New Jersey next door – up from the current corporate tax rate of up to 7.25 percent. Fortune 500 firms like Johnson & Johnson and Prudential Financial base their headquarters in New Jersey despite its higher rate. Mamdani's campaign estimates this would generate $5bn annually.
Historically, higher rates haven't driven business away. In the late 1990s, private sector employment grew at an annualised pace of 2.6 percent, while wages and private sector salaries increased by 9.6 percent.
'I think there's a lot of exaggeration here on the part of the wealthy investor class on how much this is going to economically harm New York,' Daniel Wortel-London, professor of history at Bard College and author of The Menace of Prosperity: New York City and the Struggle for Economic Development, told Al Jazeera.
Mamdani also proposes a new tax of an additional 2 percent on individuals earning more than $1m. That is projected to raise another $4bn annually. Today, earners who make $1m already pay a combined federal, state and local tax burden of about 46 percent (37 percent of that is the federal income tax set by the federal government).
Currently, the marginal local rate for someone making $40,000 (3.82 percent) is nearly identical to a millionaire's (3.88 percent), due to New York City's flat local tax structure for anyone making more than $50,000 annually.
Still, Mamdani can't unilaterally change tax policy. Any adjustments would require approval from Governor Kathy Hochul. Wortel-London says that shared priorities between Mamdani and Hochul – such as expanding childcare – could create opportunities for collaboration, including on free bus service proposals that would also need state buy-in.
The state already raised personal income taxes on millionaires in 2021 under then-Governor Cuomo, pushing rates to 46 percent (when state, local and federal income taxes are combined), the highest in the country.
Anthony Scaramucci, founder of SkyBridge Capital and a former Trump White House communications director, warned in a podcast with journalist Katty Kay that Mamdani's platform could accelerate the migration of wealthy residents to states like Florida. Scaramucci did not reply to a request for comment.
To an extent that is true, according to the Citizen Budget Commission, a New York-based nonpartisan think tank. Because of the millionaire migration, the city missed out on $2bn of tax revenue that ended up going elsewhere.
As per the data, the net negative migration for the highest income earners was highest in 2020 and 2021 – when the COVID-19 pandemic was at its peak and could have been a major contributing factor behind the move, as was the case all over the country with people moving out of cities – and began trending back towards historical rates in 2022.
With the exception of that period, high-income earners did not leave at a significantly higher rate before or after.
However, just because millionaires are moving out doesn't mean that new ones aren't moving in. According to a Henley & Partners report, New York has gained more new millionaires than any other city in the world – up 45 percent from 2014 to 2024.
'Most high earners really don't relocate just to avoid taxes. They certainly don't really relocate across the country. Most high-earners are staying in the city for prestige or their family or a culture. I think there have been scares before. We've seen it when [former Mayor] Bill de Blasio got in. They were also worried about tax hikes, and they didn't leave in droves,' Wortel-London said.
Rather than courting the ultra-wealthy, Mamdani's economic pitch is aimed at small businesses, which employ the majority of New Yorkers. He plans to appoint a 'Mom-and-Pop Tsar' to cut red tape, streamline permits, reduce fees and fines (including not charging first-time offenders), and increase funding for small business support agencies by 500 percent. His platform promises to cut business fees in half.
How realistic are the plans?
Nowhere is Mamdani's message more resonant than in housing. As rents skyrocket, nearly half of New Yorkers say they've considered leaving the city, according to the think tank, the 5boro Institute.
His campaign promised to freeze rent increases on rent-stabilised units, which account for about 28 percent of New York's housing stock, which is important to voters like Lankau, who currently lives in one. These are typically buildings built before 1974 with six or more units. While some newer buildings opt in, they do so in exchange for tax breaks.
Under the current law, rent increases are approved annually by the city's Rent Guidelines Board, an independent panel appointed by the mayor. Mayor Eric Adams, the incumbent, approved a combined 9 percent hike in his first three years in office, followed by another 4.5 percent earlier this month. If elected, Mamdani would appoint new members to this board and seek to reverse course.
But the proposal has drawn criticism. The New York Apartment Association (NYAA) – a pro-landlord group that backed Cuomo – says a freeze could worsen the city's housing shortage. Landlords, they argue, may choose to leave apartments vacant rather than perform costly repairs that can't be recouped through rent increases due to a 2019 law. As a result, tens of thousands of rent-stabilised units are currently vacant.
'Freezing rents will just accelerate the distress and physical decline of these buildings,' NYAA CEO Kenny Burgos told Al Jazeera.
Mamdani's platform doesn't currently include a proposal to address these vacancies or to cap rent increases on market-rate apartments directly.
But to elevate pressure on the housing market, which does indirectly impact the cost of market-rate apartments, the campaign has proposed building 200,000 new affordable units over 10 years – tripling the city's current pace. His housing plan also includes overhauling zoning laws, eliminating parking minimums, and supporting mixed-use development.
'I think those two, hand in hand, [freezes on rent-stabilised units and plans to build more housing] would be the kind of holistic programme that would make New York more affordable,' Lenchner said.
It remains unclear whether Mamdani would adopt policies proposed by Brad Lander, the third-place primary finisher who endorsed him. Lander had proposed converting some city-owned golf courses into housing. Lander did not respond to a request for comment.
Mamdani also wants to raise the city's minimum wage to $30 per hour by 2030 – up from $16.50. A Cornell University study estimates a true living wage in New York would be $28.54, meaning Mamdani's proposal would exceed that. It would also tie future increases to inflation and productivity metrics.
Even so, the gap between 'living' and 'comfortable' is wide. A SmartAsset study found that a New Yorker would need to earn $66 per hour to live comfortably. Mamdani hopes to relieve some of that pressure through policies like universal childcare, free bus service and a public grocery store option.
The city-run grocery store plan would start with one location in each borough to address food deserts. Much similar to city-owned hospitals or public housing, it would not replace the private sector but augment it. Regardless, this proposal has sparked backlash from John Catsimatidis, the Republican megadonor and owner of Gristedes, a local grocery store chain. He threatened to close his stores if Mamdani wins.
Catsimatidis, who donated over $500,000 to Republicans this year, according to Federal Election Commission records, did not respond to a request for comment.
Grocery costs remain politically sensitive. The latest Consumer Price Index shows grocery prices are up 2.4 percent over last year.
Mamdani also wants to make city buses permanently free. He championed a successful pilot programme in the State Assembly, which boosted weekday ridership by 30 percent and weekend ridership by 38 percent. Making that permanent would require cooperation from state leaders and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), which is state-run, and might require some concessions on his part.
'The kind of momentum and energy behind this campaign makes a powerful case in arguing before Albany to make those kinds of investments, giving him that kind of public mandate to pressure state lawmakers to move this kind of proposal forward,' Lenchner said.
This, however, comes as the MTA is under additional pressure from the federal government. The US Department of Transportation recently threatened to withhold funding over New York's congestion pricing plan, a toll on cars entering parts of Manhattan during peak hours, designed to fund transit improvements.
The political calculus
Like any mayor, Mamdani wouldn't govern in a vacuum. He'd have to navigate complex City Council dynamics, work with borough presidents and contend with powerful interest groups.
Democrats have struggled across the country because they have such a broad coalition, suggesting little conviction on policy positions which has turned off their base. Even if Mamdani's proposals are seen as more 'radical', he enters negotiations with a clear starting point and non-negotiables – something Republicans mastered a decade ago when they embraced it and Democrats still have not figured out, Lenchner suggested.
'It's hard to think in recent memory of a campaign that spoke with such clarity about its objectives, about its convictions, about its moral clarity, and about its practical policy objectives,' Lenchner added.
To win in November, he'll need to expand his coalition, particularly among Jewish and Black voters where he underperformed.
In a city still defined by finance, Mamdani will also have to show he can hold Wall Street accountable without alienating it. His campaign appears to be trying. The Partnership for New York City – a business group representing more than 300 top firms – hosted a meeting between Mamdani and executives, at the campaign's request, which according to reporting from the outlet The City, went well and attendees left feeling that he was 'willing to listen' and 'find solutions to the city's challenges that will work for all' but they were sceptical if he was genuine.
Mamdani's campaign did not respond to a request for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Jazeera
11 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Florida governor announces deportation flights from Alligator Alcatraz
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has revealed that deportation flights have begun to depart from a remote detention facility known as Alligator Alcatraz, as the Republican leader seeks to put his state at the forefront of President Donald Trump's immigration agenda. Speaking from the south Florida site on Friday, DeSantis framed his efforts as a model for other states seeking to partner with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). 'I'm pleased to report that those flights out of Alligator Alcatraz by DHS have begun,' DeSantis told reporters. ' The reality is this provides an ability to enhance the mission, to increase the number and frequency of deportations. And so what's been done here has really been remarkable.' A representative for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), Garrett Ripa, also confirmed that 'two or three removal flights' had already been conducted from the Alligator Alcatraz facility and that more were planned. He indicated that those flights contained ' up to a hundred individuals who were illegally present in the state of Florida'. Delegating resources President Trump campaigned for re-election last November on the promise that he would undertake the 'largest deportation operation in American history'. But with more than 11 million undocumented people believed to be living in the United States, critics have pointed out that his ambitions may outstrip the amount of detention space and resources the government has available. That has led the Trump administration to seek additional resources from state and local authorities, as well as assistance from foreign governments. He has also deployed the military to assist in immigration enforcement operations, a task traditionally outside its scope. Part of Trump's toolkit has been deputising state and local leaders through Section 287(g) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. While the federal government is solely responsible for immigration enforcement, Section 287(g) creates a loophole that allows ICE to enter into written agreements with state and local authorities to perform specific immigration-related functions. Speaking alongside DeSantis on Friday, Larry Keefe, the head of Florida's newly established State Board of Immigration Enforcement, said his team has already taken advantage of such arrangements. 'Just within the last couple of days, the federal government has issued credentials to over 1,200 Florida sheriff's deputies and over 650 FDLE [Florida Department of Law Enforcement] agents and other state and local law enforcement agencies,' Keefe said. 'We have more than doubled our capability and capacity to effect arrests.' Florida at the forefront Florida, however, has been testing the limits of what it is able to do independently in terms of cracking down on undocumented immigration within its state lines. Earlier this year, for instance, the Florida's Republican-led government passed a law, known as SB 4-C (PDF), that imposes stiff criminal penalties on adult undocumented immigrants who knowingly enter the state. But federal courts placed an injunction to prevent the law from taking effect, on the basis that it preempts the federal government's authority over all things immigration. Still, President Trump has hailed the aggressive immigration efforts in Florida, his adopted home state, where he maintains a residence, Mar-a-Lago, as well as golf courses. Earlier this month, he visited Alligator Alcatraz, applauding its fast-paced construction. 'This is what you need,' Trump said at the time. 'A lot of bodyguards and a lot of cops in the form of alligators.' Critics have denounced the facility as an exercise in cruelty, with reports emerging of poor conditions inside Alligator Alcatraz. Some immigrants have said they faced floodwater, poor sanitation, clogged toilets and clouds of mosquitoes as they stayed in fenced-in units where the lights were never dimmed. Environmental groups and Indigenous members of the local Seminole and Miccosukee tribes have also criticised the facility for its location in the middle of the Everglades wetlands, a sensitive ecosystem prone to seasonal flooding. Utilising an old airfield Built across eight days in June, Alligator Alcatraz sits atop the site of the former Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport in Ochopee, Florida. That set-up has been a benefit for plans to also use the facility for deportation flights, DeSantis said on Friday. He described transferring immigrants from their detention cells to planes with relative ease. 'One of the reasons why this was a sensible spot is because you have this runway that's right here,' DeSantis explained. 'You don't have to drive them an hour to an airport. You go a couple thousand feet, and they can be on a plane and out of here.' He added that the site already has runway lighting and 18,927 litres — or 5,000 gallons — of jet fuel on site. That, he hopes, will help pave the way for the number of deportation flights to increase in the coming weeks. ' The cadence is increasing,' DeSantis said. 'We've already had a number of flights in the last few days.' Alligator Alcatraz — named for a forbidding island prison in the San Francisco Bay that closed in the 1960s — has the capacity to hold up to 3,000 people, according to Florida officials. DeSantis has long positioned Florida as the 'blueprint' for what Republican leadership in the US could look like, and in 2023, he launched a short-lived presidential campaign to challenge Trump for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination. Increasing the pace In his remarks on Friday, DeSantis briefly acknowledged the shortcomings in Trump's mass-deportation plans, playing up the efficiency of the Alligator Alcatraz system. 'ICE has been understaffed — you know, is not scratching the surface of what would need to be done to get to where you have the largest mass deportation in history,' he said. 'So you've got to increase that tempo. You have a limited amount of time to do it. I think we've got to assume we've got these four years under the Trump administration to really get the job done.' DeSantis also brushed aside concerns that the isolated facility cuts immigrants off from their legal representation and their right to be heard before a court. He pointed out that he plans to have immigration judges on site. But he also questioned whether undocumented people should be allowed the same due process rights as US citizens and immigrants with legal status. 'To me, it's like, if you are subjected to a traditional criminal process, there's a whole a bunch of due process that goes into that,' DeSantis said. By contrast, DeSantis argued that the immigration process 'should be a pretty simple process. You either have a right to be here or you don't.'
Al Jazeera
13 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Players' union hits back at ‘autocratic' FIFA and Infantino
The global football players' union has hit back at FIFA and its President Gianni Infantino, saying their autocratic style of leadership was harming the rights of its members. 'Football needs responsible leadership, not emperors,' the FIFPRO network said on Friday after a meeting of 58 national player unions responded to FIFA pursuing its agenda with unofficial player representatives. 'It needs fewer autocratic monologues and more genuine, inclusive and transparent dialogue,' the union added. FIFA announced two weeks ago that it reached a consensus on key issues after Infantino hosted a group of mostly non-recognised officials in New York before the Club World Cup final. The latest rift between soccer's governing body and its players' unions flared while the European Commission in Brussels is considering a formal complaint against FIFA. It was filed by FIFPRO's European division and national leagues in Europe against FIFA's style of governance and decision-making. FIFPRO said FIFA's core agenda included an overloaded global match calendar with too many games for elite players, a lack of physical and mental recovery periods and extreme playing conditions. Players at the monthlong Club World Cup in the United States, who played in the heat of daytime games to appeal to worldwide TV audiences, reported feeling dizzy and unwell. The 63-game tournament backed by Saudi Arabian money was lucrative for clubs, especially in Europe, though FIFA added it to the schedule without formally consulting players. The tournament, FIFPRO said, was 'celebrated by President Infantino despite being held under conditions that were extreme and inappropriate for any human being, demonstrating a troubling insensitivity to human rights, even when it concerns elite athletes. 'FIFPRO reaffirmed its unwavering commitment to protecting the rights of men and women players – rights which are being seriously undermined by commercial policies imposed by its autocratic system of governance,' the Netherlands-based union said of FIFA. 'This is a model that puts the health of players at risk and sidelines those at the heart of the game,' FIFPRO said, adding it was 'unacceptable for an organization that claims global leadership to turn a blind eye to the basic needs of the players'. FIFA was approached for comment. FIFPRO has not had a formal working agreement with FIFA since the previous one expired in 2023.
Al Jazeera
14 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Trump signals positive meeting with Powell on US interest rates
US President Donald Trump says he had a positive meeting with Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell and gained the impression that the central bank's head might be ready to lower interest rates. The two men met on Thursday when Trump made a rare visit to the US central bank to tour its ongoing renovation of two buildings at its headquarters in Washington, which the White House has criticised as costing too much. Trump clashed with Powell during his visit and criticised the cost of renovating two historic buildings at its headquarters, and they sparred over the project's actual price tag. 'We had a very good meeting … I think we had a very good meeting on interest rates,' Trump told reporters on Friday. The central bank said on Friday it was 'grateful' for Trump's encouragement to complete the renovation of its buildings in Washington and that it 'looked forward' to seeing the project through to completion. Trump, who called Powell a 'numbskull' earlier this week for failing to heed the White House's demand for a large reduction in borrowing costs, said he did not intend to fire Powell, as he has frequently suggested he would. On Friday, Trump called Powell a 'very good man' when speaking to reporters. Rather than lowering interest rates, economists widely expect the central bank to leave its benchmark interest rate in the 4.25 percent – 4.50 percent range at the conclusion of a two-day policy meeting next week. Tariffs stall rate cuts The central bank has held rates steady since December, and earlier this year, Powell said that if it were not for Trump's imposed tariffs and the economic uncertainty it has caused, the central bank might have been ready to lower rates by now. The visit comes as President Trump is expected to meet UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, where the two sides could potentially approve an already announced trade deal, as trade negotiations with Canada stall. Trump said his administration could set a tariff rate unilaterally on Canada. 'We haven't really had a lot of luck with Canada. I think Canada could be one where there's just a tariff, not really a negotiation.' Trump also said there is a 50-percent chance of Washington being able to strike a deal with the European Union to reduce import tariffs. 'I would say that we have a 50/50 chance, maybe less than that, but a 50/50 chance of making a deal with the EU,' Trump told reporters at the White House. The president has been pressing his case for reduced interest rates, including falsely claiming, 'We've wiped out inflation.' Inflation actually rose last month to 2.7 percent. Despite continued pressure from the Trump administration, Powell has long maintained that the central bank must preserve its independence from the White House. In late May, the Fed reiterated that point, saying in a statement that it makes 'decisions based solely on careful, objective, and non-political analysis.'
