Mbeki's intervention in TRC damages litigation criticised as 'absurd' and 'muddying the waters'
Image: DIRCO
The Foundation for Human Rights (FHR) has described former president Thabo Mbeki's application to intervene in the constitutional damages litigation by survivors and families of apartheid-era crime victims as unreasonable and 'muddying the waters'.
The application by Mbeki and his former justice minister, Brigitte Mabandla, is set to be heard on Monday, July 28, in the Pretoria High Court.
The families of victims who were forcibly disappeared or killed during apartheid, supported by the foundation, filed an application against President Cyril Ramaphosa and the government early this year, seeking R167-million in constitutional damages for the state's 'gross failure'. They say there was 'a gross violation of their human rights as the state failed to investigate and/or prosecute the cases referred by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission to the National Prosecutions Authority'.
They alleged that there was some political interference in the cases, leading to delays of about 15 years.
Speaking to eNCA on Thursday, FHR executive director Zaid Kimmie said they were not gunning for any individual or 'alleging that any particular individual was responsible'. He said they were seeking justice and the R167 million damages, and wanted to know 'potentially how this interference happened'.
Those seeking to clear their names or 'cast aspersions on others' would have their opportunity in the upcoming commission of inquiry set up by Ramaphosa, said Kimmie. He said they believed that the commission was 'the correct avenue' that Mbeki and Mabandla should follow. He said the two politicians' intervention in the damages case was 'absurd' and posed a danger of muddying the waters.
'It's clear to us and all families that there was some form of interference in these cases. You don't simply have a 15-year delay in investigations and prosecutions because someone forgot to do their job. It's very clear that there was some sort of interference, and what we've asked for was that, to get to the bottom of that interference we need a commission of inquiry,' said Kimmie.
He explained that the R167 million the families were seeking was carefully calculated based on the money used in supporting some of the families during inquests, investigations, prosecutions, and generally providing justice to them.
'Just to make it clear, the money that we're asking for is going to be held in trust. It will be available to any family who's in the same situation (as those in the damages case),' he said.
Responding to a question about the 'unfinished business of the TRC' and whether, in his view, the state dealt with the issues adequately, Kimmie said: 'It's clear that there has been a gross violation of the human rights of these families. The state didn't do its job, did not live up to its obligations. And when the state does not live up to its obligations, then it's incumbent upon the people involved to call them to account …
'It's simply not enough to say 'well, bad things happened, these things happen', and everyone walks away.'
The state had 'constitutional, legal obligations' and had officials paid to do their jobs, to investigate and prosecute cases. He said it was 'absurd' for them to 'simply decide' that a certain set of cases was 'not worthy' to be prosecuted.
There have been allegations in the past that interference by the government under Mbeki during former national director of public prosecutions Vusi Pikoli led to work on the case being stopped. There have not been any proper explanation as to why the TRC cases where amnesty was not granted were not pursued.
These cases include the killing of the Cradock Four — Matthew Goniwe, Fort Calata, Sparrow Mkonto, and Sicelo Mhlauli — members of the United Democratic Front and other community organisations fighting apartheid whose killings shocked the nation in 1985.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
Mbeki and Mabandla deny that political interference stopped the TRC cases and claim that the application is defamatory of them.
The families oppose their application, arguing that they couldn't intervene simply to rebut adverse allegations. They say the damages and other relief they seek are 'not directed' against Mbeki or Mabandla but against the state; and if they feel they are or might be defamed they have recourse through 'normal legal remedies'.
'The families assert that the application can be decided without the need to make findings in respect of individual roleplayers, which will be the task of the commission of inquiry already established by the President, although it is yet to commence its work,' the FHR said in a statement on Thursday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
12 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
South Africa seeks new export markets as US tariff looms
International Relations and Cooperation Minister Ronald Lamola (left) and Minister of Trade Parks Tau (right) during a briefing on Monday. (DIRCO) South Africa is preparing to diversify its export markets in response to the looming 30% tariff imposed by the US, which government officials say will cost jobs and shave 0.2% off economic growth. The country is one of several facing punitive tariffs from the US as it moves to protect its own manufacturers and labour force. 'The 'We have been strengthening trade and investment partnerships with various trade partners. These efforts are bearing fruit, targeting markets across Africa, as well as in Asia, Europe, Middle East and the Americas.' 'South Africa seeks to conclude deals that promote value addition and industrialisation rather than mimic extractive colonial-era trade patterns,' Lamola said, adding that talks with Washington were ongoing, with the government applying a principled approach through diplomatic channels. He said the 30% tariff had been factored into economic projections, with economists estimating a 0.2% reduction in growth. 'This depends on our ability to find alternative markets. Notably, 35% of exports remain exempted from the tariffs.' The director general in the trade department, Simphiwe Hamilton, said approximately 30 000 jobs would be at risk once the tariffs kick in. Lamola said value addition and beneficiation have been the government's priorities in its proposed trade framework, adding that its relationship with the US must be 'mutually beneficial and respectful'. The country is also pursuing other options including a clean energy trade and investment partnership with the EU, which has unlocked a R90 billion investment package for the export of sustainable aviation fuel by Sasol and of hybrid and electric vehicles. 'We've made significant progress in opening up vast new markets, like China and Thailand, securing vital protocols for products like citrus and others. With China alone being a $200 billion market, we are confidently expanding our reach and creating new opportunities for our agricultural producers,' Lamola said. 'Our government has not been idle; we are proactively and collaboratively diversifying our trade portfolio.' He said under the coordinated leadership of the presidency, the department of international relations and cooperation and that of trade, industry and competition, South Africa was 'making significant inroads into new, high-growth markets across Asia and the Middle East, including the UAE, Qatar and Saudi Arabia'. Trade minister Parks Tau told the same briefing that calls from some South Africans urging the country not to negotiate with Washington were irresponsible, while conceding that the US had not responded to the country's proposals. 'We can only make an offer, sit and wait, and hope. That is the reality,' Tau said. Asked about the potential for increased trade with China, Tau said negotiations were ongoing through the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation. China has offered a memorandum of understanding on green energy and industrialisation. Lamola said diversification efforts would include exporters collaborating to develop infrastructure, share market intelligence and coordinate activities to improve competitiveness. 'These efforts can help achieve economies of scale and efficiencies that enable them to be competitive,' he said. The department of trade, industry and competition has set up an export support desk as part of a diversification strategy 'to create resilience' in the economy. The desk is collaborating with export councils, industry associations and major exporters to the US to assist in accessing alternative markets. On Monday, acting deputy director for export in the trade department, Willem van der Spuy, said producers, mostly from the Western Cape, had been requesting clarity on when the tariffs would take effect and what support measures were in place. 'The issue is to create resilience in our international trade environment. And through this support desk, we will add practical areas of cooperation. We will link them up with embassies, we will link them up with potential buyers, we will take the journey with them in terms of the trade barriers,' Van der Spuy said. Lamola said the desk would 'provide updates, advisory services, guidance on market entry and linkages to South African embassies and high commissions'. According to Tau, the tariffs also presented an opportunity to accelerate implementation of the Lamola echoed President Cyril Ramaphosa's view that South African In his weekly He cited citrus exports as an example: 'They are counter-seasonal and don't threaten US production. The US sector has been in decline due to factors unrelated to imports — such as disease and low yields. Our citrus fills that gap.' South African firms also invest heavily in the US, including in mining, chemicals, pharmaceuticals and food, said Ramaphosa, adding that this makes the country the largest African investor in the US. Tau said Wednesday's cabinet meeting would finalise the export support package.
TimesLIVE
15 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Process to appoint ambassador to US at advanced stage: Lamola
The process to appoint a new ambassador to the US is at an advanced stage, international relations and co-operation (Dirco) minister Ronald Lamola told journalists on Monday. Lamola was speaking during a media briefing with trade, industry and competition minister Parks Tau. He said the process to appoint an ambassador was not easy due to the expulsion of former ambassador Ebrahim Rasool earlier this year, adding that President Cyril Ramaphosa has been giving careful consideration and due diligence. In March US secretary of state Marco Rubio shocked South Africans when he posted on social media platform X that Rasool was 'no longer welcome' in the US. 'Ebrahim Rasool is a race-baiting politician who hates America and hates at @POTUS. We have nothing to discuss with him and so he is considered persona non grata. ' This was in reaction to Rasool's comments at a foreign policy seminar where he reportedly told attendees US President Donald Trump was leading a white supremacist movement in America and the world.
The Citizen
21 hours ago
- The Citizen
What triggered Emma Powell's fall?
Emma Powell recently resigned from her position as DA spokesperson for International Relations citing a targeted campaign of intimidation. Politicians are fond of saying: 'If you expect loyalty, get a dog.' To which journalists might reply: 'If you expect basic human decency from a politician, get a grip.' Last week, the DA allowed the ANC to hound from office its own foreign policy lead. Emma Powell resigned from the position after a protracted campaign of abuse and threats from the ANC, which mobilised the state security apparatus and pliant media against her. Astoundingly, the DA parliamentary leadership uttered not a public word of rebuke that Powell felt so beleaguered by the campaign against her by their government of national unity partner that she threw in the towel. The biggest challenge for the DA in its partnership with the ANC was always going to be retaining its political integrity. It had to balance its place holder role – keeping at bay an alternative ANC coalition with the hard left – while continuing to challenge a corrupt and incompetent government. John Steenhuisen has failed to manage this tension well. The principled opposition part of the package has been largely abandoned. It's been traded for a handful of ministerial positions and the giddy excitement of accompanying Cyril Ramaphosa and Paul Mashatile on foreign jaunts, where the DA leader is trotted out as a show pony to illustrate the GNU's legitimacy. Not everyone in the DA is happy with this. While the parliamentary caucus and, more specifically, the ministerial handful, are preoccupied with preserving access and proximity to power, many within the party's broader membership base remain committed to the DA's traditional liberal-democratic values. Appeasement backfiring Ironically, appeasement does not strengthen Steenhuisen's hand with the ANC, but weakens it. Every DA red line that the ANC turns into a skipping rope makes inevitable the next concession. The campaign against Powell was orchestrated across multiple fronts, driven by intersecting resentments within the ANC, department of international relations and cooperation (Dirco). At the heart of it was her effectiveness – despite her comparative youth and only a couple of years in the job – as a critic of South Africa's foreign policy. This made her intolerable to a government that is increasingly allergic to scrutiny. First came ANC fury over Powell's participation, alongside then deputy minister of trade and industry Andrew Whitfield, in a DA delegation to Washington in March. Then came the backlash from the powerful pro-Hamas clique in Dirco to a fact-finding visit to Israel by opposition MPs. Perhaps most damaging to Steenhuisen's tjommie relationship with President Cyril Ramaphosa – now performing on the international circuit as the Smooth Cyril and Jovial John show – is her exposure of our president as a fantasist and flat-out liar about Mcebisi Jonas. Powell released an explosive statement asserting that the US had denied Jonas a diplomatic visa in May, had formally rejected his credentials as interlocutor and that the Presidency had repeatedly been told this. Now the heavy artillery was brought to bear. A leaked intelligence report originating from the National Security Council claimed that Powell was under investigation for treason for 'spreading misinformation' during her US trip. Again, the DA remained tjoepstil. In the face of the scale of ANC's disenchantment with Powell, it's not beyond imagining Ramaphosa laying down his own red line with Steenhuisen: get rid of that troublesome spokesperson, or else. NOW READ: The Jaundiced Eye: The building is burning – but it's fine
