Egypt, Greece agree to protect status of Mount Sinai monastery, after court ruling
The St Catherine's Monastery, at the foot of Egypt's Mount Sinai, was founded in the 6th century and is the oldest Christian monastery still in use for its original function, says UNESCO, which has listed the area as a World Heritage site.
Revered by Christians, Muslims and Jews, the monastery is at the site where by Biblical tradition Moses received the Ten Commandments.
But last week, an Egyptian court ruling seen by Reuters ordered Orthodox monks to vacate several plots of land that the monks have used for years, including vineyards and gardens adjacent to the monastery compound, on the grounds that they were illegally sequestered, prompting a diplomatic flurry between Cairo and Athens over the site's status.
"We agreed in the immediate future to work towards safeguarding the rights of the monastery, as well as its legal status," Greek Foreign Minister George Gerapetritis said after meeting his Egyptian counterpart Badr Abdelatty in Cairo.
"Both Egypt and Greece intend to move forward based on the long-standing tradition and the already established status of an emblematic monastery for its Greek Orthodox character of worship".
Abdelatty said that the ruling preserves the monastery's profound spiritual value and religious standing, and confirmed that the monks would continue to have access to and use of the monastery and its religious and historical sites, according to a foreign ministry statement.
With a long history of diplomatic ties, Greece and Egypt have deepened cooperation in recent years.
St Catherine's is a sprawling complex, and according to tradition it was built around a burning bush where God was said to have spoken to Moses as described in the Book of Exodus. Its library is one of the most extensive worldwide, containing some of the world's earliest Christian manuscripts.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
16 hours ago
- Spectator
Unesco status is killing Bath
Last month, the Trump administration announced that the United States would once again withdraw from Unesco, the Paris-based UN cultural agency responsible for World Heritage Sites, education initiatives, and cultural programmes worldwide. The official line? Unesco promotes 'woke, divisive cultural and social causes' and its 'globalist, ideological agenda' clashes with America First policy. Predictably, the Trump administration framed it as a culture-war grievance. But, set aside the politics, and it soon becomes clear that Trump might not be entirely wrong. Unesco – founded in 1945 with the lofty mission of promoting peace and global cooperation through culture, education, and science – has devolved into something far less edifying. Once led by artists, architects, and scholars, Unesco's World Heritage Committee has become the Fifa of culture: a fiefdom of bureaucrats, political journeymen and international grifters who drift between departments, NGOs and consultancies with no accountability, while the list of sites has ballooned to 1,248. Its $1.5 billion annual budget fuels a self-perpetuating treadmill of capacity-building workshops, unread reports and relentless reputation polishing. The consequences are not merely abstract for Bath, a Unesco World Heritage Site since 1987. Some World Heritage Sites are a single chapel, a medieval bridge, or a protected ruin; Bath's listing covers the entire city – all 94,000 residents, its suburban sprawl, its industrial remnants, and its everyday working streets. The designation treats the Georgian crescents and Roman baths as inseparable from the supermarkets, car parks, and 1970s infill, meaning almost any change anywhere must be weighed against the city's 'Outstanding Universal Value.' At the same time, the city is grappling with a record housing crisis: house prices are more than 13 times annual earnings, social housing demand is soaring, and temporary accommodation has reached a 20-year high. Homelessness services like Julian House's Manvers Street hostel operate far beyond capacity, providing nearly 97,000 bed spaces last year alone while struggling to secure their own roof. But Bath's heritage status means it is almost impossible to get anything built. Although Unesco status carries no direct legal force in the UK, it is woven into planning policy through the Bath and North East Somerset Local Plan, which bars development deemed harmful to the 'qualities justifying the inscription' or its setting. In practice, this gives opponents of change a powerful rhetorical weapon: they need only invoke 'Outstanding Universal Value' to wrap their case in the prestige of an international mandate. The result is a permanent, low-level threat – that almost any proposal, however modest, might be cast as an affront to world heritage and fought on those grounds. In 2024, residents were warned that the city's Unesco status was 'at risk' after the council approved the replacement of former industrial units on Wells Road with 77 'co-living' apartments. The planning committee split four to four, with the chair casting the tiebreaker vote in favour. Councillors raised concerns about the building's bulk and potential 'cumulative impact' on the World Heritage Site, with one declaring the city was 'sailing close to the wind with Unesco.' It is extraordinary: a city struggling to house its own people, yet officials can menace its international status over a modest block of flats. Meanwhile, residents in nearby Saltford – whose own Grade II* Saltford Manor dates to the 12th century and is thought to be Britain's oldest continuously inhabited house – watch as Bath's tight planning restrictions push the housing burden outwards. With 1,300 new homes proposed for its green belt, the village faces development on a scale it can't sustain, without the infrastructure or political protection to resist it. Phil Harding, head of the Saltford Environmental Group and a resident for more than 30 years, recently made headlines when he spoke out about the impact of Bath's World Heritage status on neighbouring communities. 'I'm not against new housing, I'm against putting housing in the wrong place,' he says. Bath, he notes, is already a fantastic city that draws tourists in its own right, and Unesco status 'makes no difference.' The real problem, he adds, is that World Heritage designation makes it 'incredibly hard to build in Bath,' pushing development into nearby villages. Much of the employment for new arrivals will still be in Bath, leaving Saltford to shoulder the burden – green belt land lost, congestion rising, local services stretched – without enjoying the benefits. 'Bath doesn't need World Heritage Status,' he concludes. 'It distorts planning priorities, forcing the city to preserve appearances while shifting the real costs onto neighbouring communities.' It may sound unthinkable, but losing that status is hardly fatal. Liverpool provides the example: once celebrated for its maritime mercantile cityscape, it was stripped of Unesco recognition in 2021 after the agency judged that recent and planned developments had caused an 'irreversible loss' of the site's Outstanding Universal Value. Among the contested projects was Everton FC's new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock, which required filling in part of the historic dock to accommodate a 52,000-seat arena. Even the Guardian acknowledged it as 'the most striking, ambitious addition to the waterfront since the Three Graces were built in the early 1900s.' The £800 million stadium formed part of a broader £1.3 billion regeneration plan, projected to create over 15,000 jobs and attract more than 1.4 million visitors annually. The city did not crumble: regeneration pressed ahead, docks were revitalised, neighbourhoods transformed and tourism continued to flourish. The lesson is plain – Unesco's imprimatur is not the secret ingredient of urban vitality, and its objections can just as easily hinder development as they can protect it. If Unesco were merely symbolic, that would be one thing. But the status is far from meaningless: it exerts moral and political pressure, informs planning guidance, and lends weight to the opinions of advisory bodies like Historic England. For Bath, this translates into a city where development proposals are scrutinised through the lens of 'Outstanding Universal Value,' with councillors warned that new flats or infrastructure might unsettle international sensibilities. The result is a city frozen in amber, preserved more for the approval of tourists rather than for the people who actually live and work there. So when the America First brigade lashes out at Unesco, it is tempting to roll our eyes. But there is a logic to that disdain. World Heritage labels are increasingly badges for the international jet set, not the local people. The US may be leaving for its own vanity, but the reasoning – that Unesco is corrupt, politicised, and more interested in theatre than preservation – hits the mark. For cities like Bath, the real question isn't whether Unesco might disapprove, but why on earth they should care.
The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Riot police block protesters from approaching Israeli cruise ship in Greece
Riot police at Greece's largest port cordoned off an area around an Israeli cruise ship that arrived early Thursday to prevent several hundred protesters from approaching the vessel. Protests have been held at Greek islands and mainland ports along the route of the Crown Iris, several of which have led to clashes with police. At the port of Piraeus, near Athens, on Thursday demonstrators held flares and waved Palestinian flags behind a cordon formed with riot police buses. Protest organizers, citing online posts from travelers, said off-duty Israeli soldiers were among the passengers. 'They are unwanted here and have no business being here,' protest organizer Markos Bekris said. 'The blood of innocent people is on their hands, and we should not welcome them.' Greece is a popular holiday destination for Israelis. But the ongoing war in Gaza — and global attention on the widespread destruction and severe food shortages — has triggered hundreds of anti-Israel protests in Athens and other Greek cities, as well as a political confrontation. Left-wing opposition parties are calling on the conservative government to halt commercial and broad military cooperation with Israel.
Times
2 days ago
- Times
Giorgia Meloni rejects ‘unpatriotic' claim Italians are deserting beaches
As Italian politics ground to its customary mid-August halt this week and ministers vanished to the beach, the prime minister Giorgia Meloni was reported to be heading for Greece — yet evidently still ready for a row with the opposition. The topic was holidays, as Meloni angrily accused her opposition rival, Elly Schlein, of making unpatriotic allegations about Italians deserting the country's beaches because they are broke after three years of her premiership. The row began when Schlein, the leader of Italy's centre-left Democratic Party, seized on reports that the number of tourists renting umbrellas and sunbeds at Italian beach clubs have dropped by up to 30 per cent this year. 'Empty beaches are a postcard from the Meloni government — millions of Italians are not taking holidays because they can't afford it,' said Schlein. Images of happy holidaymakers on Italy's state TV channels were propaganda put out by Meloni-appointed managers to conceal the reality of a fading economy, she added. Meloni shot back with her own statistics showing that the overall number of Italians taking holidays in Italy in July was not down, but up by 1.8 per cent year-on-year. She accused Schlein of an unpatriotic attempt to sully the reputation of tourism in Italy in the eyes of the world. 'I consider it shameful that certain opposition figures spread fake news, damaging the image and the interests of Italy just to attack the government,' she posted. 'Who truly loves our nation should not discredit it before the world for political gain. We will work to make [Italy] stronger, more attractive and more proud of itself every day,' she added. Antonio Misiani, a senator with the Democratic Party, likened Meloni's attack to that of a North Korean politician, while the former prime minister Matteo Renzi pointed out Meloni was a fine one to talk about patriotism since she was reported to be sunbathing somewhere in Greece, rather than on an Italian beach. Support for Schlein came from Massimo Casanova, a former MEP with the right-wing League party and a beach club owner, who said empty beaches were due Italy's middle class running out of cash. 'The government should be helping Italians, not starving them,' he said. Meloni's claim that overall tourism numbers are up has been borne out in Rome, where 644,000 visitors are expected to arrive over the mid-August weekend, up 5.5 percent on last year, despite temperatures edging towards 40C. However, hotel owners say holidaymakers may be taking shorter trips this year, and the rosy statistics may have been inflated by thousands of previously unregistered B&Bs publishing their figures for the first time. Other reasons why beach clubs have fewer customers have little to do with the economy. Outrage has grown this month regarding price increases by the clubs, which are allowed to fence off wide swathes of sand and charge people to sit on it. Anger has focused on a club in Mondello, near Palermo in Sicily, that installed turnstiles at the entrance to the beach, despite the law permitting visitors to enter free of charge if they stay close to the water's edge and do not occupy one of the sunbeds set up by the club. • Europe's secret (and more affordable) beach clubs Experts have said that the traditional Italian habit of cramming into beach clubs in August is also changing as people avoid the growing heat and take breaks either side of summer. Beach clubs became part of Italian summer culture during the country's post-war boom years, but Gen Z Italians appear to be less inclined to pay to lie in rows under tightly packed umbrellas. As the Sardinian newspaper La Nuova Sardegna reported on Wednesday, 'The sea will always be there but habits are starting to change, just as the water does when the wind switches direction.'
