UK Lenders Face $12 Bn Plus Compensation Bill Despite Court Ruling: Watchdog
The Supreme Court on Friday partially overturned judgments that the loans were unlawful, giving relief to banks which had been bracing for compensation claims from millions of car-buyers.
It did, however, uphold one of the three cases, which allows the claimant to seek compensation.
And in a similar but separate probe, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said that the cost of any redress scheme relating to discretionary commission arrangements for car loans would likely be higher than GBP9 billion.
"While there are plausible scenarios which underpin estimates of a total cost as high as GBP18 billion, we do not consider those scenarios to be the most likely and analyst estimates in the midpoint of this range are more plausible," the FCA said in a statement.
The FCA estimates that most individuals will probably receive less than GBP950 in compensation.
The court ruling had given the FCA "clarity... because we have been looking at what is unfair and, prior to this judgment, there were different interpretations of the law coming from different courts," it said.
"It is clear that some firms have broken the law and our rules. It's fair for their customers to be compensated," said Nikhil Rathi, chief executive of the FCA.
The Supreme Court decision mostly overturned Court of Appeal rulings last year that it was unlawful for car dealers to receive a commission on loans without sufficiently informing borrowers.
In some cases, the loans -- available from 2007 -- allowed car dealers to offer higher interest rates in return for a bigger commission from banks.
The ruling means that dealers have some leeway when arranging loans, without requiring explicit consent from borrowers for terms that may benefit lenders.
The case that was upheld involved Marcus Johnson, who in 2017 bought a Suzuki Swift from a car dealer in Cardiff for GBP6,500 including loan costs -- unaware that interest on the loan amount would fund a commission of more than GBP1,600.
When the Court of Appeal ruled in favour of Johnson, ordering FirstRand Bank, a South African based lender, to refund the commission plus interest, it sparked panic across the finance sector.
That ruling was upheld by the top court due to the high level of commission Johnson was charged and the complexity of the contract setting out the fee, which limits the scope of other compensation claims.
HSBC bank analysts had suggested before the trial that the total cost to the banking sector could have reached GBP44 billion.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local Germany
5 days ago
- Local Germany
Which UK phone companies offer free roaming in Germany?
EU agreements mean that phone companies are banned from charging EU residents extra 'roaming' fees for data use in any country within the bloc. Additionally, all mobile phone operators in Germany continue to treat the UK as part of the EU as far as roaming is concerned – although none have ruled out introducing roaming charges at some point in the future. But for travellers from the UK to Germany, the situation is rather different. In the aftermath of the UK's exit from the EU, many British telecommunications companies have begun charging additional 'roaming' fees for people visiting the EU. Here's the latest list of companies that continue to offer free roaming, as well as those that don't (and details of what they offer instead). Free roaming in Germany O2 – O2 includes free roaming as part of their standard monthly SIM plans – Classic, Plus and Ultimate, ranging from £16 to £34. O2 customers can make calls and send texts within the Europe Zone to any other country in the Europe Zone, including the UK. Users can also benefit from their monthly data allowance – but there is a roaming limit of 25GB. COMPARE: What's the 'best' mobile phone network in Germany? When approaching the roaming limit, you will receive a text message warning that if you keep using data, you will be charged extra. BT – Although BT and EE are merging, the company still allows customers to opt for BT mobile plans, including the 50GB SIM , which starts at £13 a month. As for roaming, customers benefit from Roam like Home free roaming in Germany and the rest of the EU. The plan includes 50GB of data usage as part of their fair use policy allowance. You can make calls and send texts from the EU, including Germany, to UK landlines and mobiles at no extra charge. You should also receive a notification if you are at 80 percent of your data usage allowance. BT warns that Roam like Home is only available for people "usually based in the UK". You may face a surcharge if you have been using the Roam like Home plan for over four months in the EU. Smarty – Smarty's SIM-only plans include roaming within the EU, with free unlimited calls and texts. Customers have a 'fair use' data limit of 12GB per month for a maximum of 60 days. Advertisement To go above that, you'll have to buy a data add-on. Giffgaff – Giffgaff allows people to use their usual allowance of calls and texts in the EU "at no extra cost". As for data, the cutoff is set at 5GB. If you go over the limit, you'll have to pay 10p/MB or purchase a travel add-on. Lebara – Lebara allows free data roaming in EU countries including Germany, subject to fair use policies. Customers who remain in the EU for longer than four months will receive an sms informing them that a surcharge of €0.02618 per minute will be levied on outgoing calls, €0.00238 per minute on incoming calls, €0.00476 per text message and €1.85 per GB. Additional roaming fees Vodafone – Some of Vodafone's mobile plans include roaming in Germany, which falls into their 'B destination list'. For instance, you can opt for the 5GB Xtra Euro Roam , which costs £27 a month. Otherwise, you can purchase a plan that does not include roaming and pay an extra daily charge of £2.57 a day when roaming, or purchase an eight-day European Roaming Extra pass . EE Mobile – EE Mobile has been changing its approach to roaming following Brexit, with some of the contracts it offered before July 2021 no longer available. Roaming: Where can I use my German mobile abroad without being charged? The company, however, still has several plans that do include EU roaming (the Max Plan, Full Works, Essentials Plus, and All Rounder). For customers whose plans do not include roaming, they can purchase temporary passes, with fees of £2.59 per day, £15 per week, and £21.50 per 12 days. Advertisement Calls, texts and data would be available at your normal UK allowance. You can decide which pass to purchase upon arrival, as you will receive a link listing the available options. Tesco Mobile – Customers who joined Tesco Mobile before June 16th, 2022 will continue to be able to use their UK plan allowance in the EU, including Germany. However, those who have changed contracts or joined after June 16th, 2022 will "be subject to roaming charges from 2026," the company warns on its website. Customers should receive 30 days' notice before the changes are implemented. For the time being, people on monthly Tesco Mobile SIM plans will still be able to have roaming in Germany included in their standard bill. Three – Similarly to EE Mobile and Vodafone, Three offers some plans (like Value and Complete) which include roaming in the EU. Customers whose plans do not include roaming can pay a daily charge of £2 for the 'Go Roam in Europe' pass. Data is capped at 12GB in any Go Roam destination. Sky – Sky doesn't offer plans including free roaming in the EU. However, customers can opt for the 'Roaming Passport Plus', which grants access to their UK data, calls and texts allowance for a £2 daily charge. With reporting by Tom Pugh. Advertisement
Int'l Business Times
05-08-2025
- Int'l Business Times
Guinness Owner Diageo Ups Savings As US Tariffs Hit
Diageo, the maker of Guinness stout and Smirnoff Vodka, reported Tuesday a sharp drop in annual net profit and raised its cost-savings targets as US tariffs hit. Net profit tumbled 39 percent to $2.4 billion in its financial year to the end of June, compared with one year earlier, the British group said in an earnings statement just weeks after the sudden departure of chief executive Debra Crew. Diageo's revenue dipped slightly to $20.2 billion. "Macroeconomic uncertainty and the resulting pressure on consumers" has weighed on the spirits sector, interim CEO Nik Jhangiani said of a "challenging year" for the group. Diageo last month announced the abrupt departure of Crew after two years at the helm. The company had already experienced a tough trading environment ahead of announcing in May that it faced a financial hit from US President Donald Trump's tariffs onslaught. Diageo, which also makes Don Julio tequila, ramped up its cost-saving programme on Tuesday to around $625 million over three years, from a previous target of $500 million. Its annual profit was hit also by restructuring costs and impairment charges. Shares in the company, however, jumped more than six percent in morning deals on London's FTSE 100 index as investors cheered the new cost-saving targets and better-than-expected sales. Diageo reiterated that it expects operating profit to take a $200-million hit from Trump's tariffs, though around half the amount would be offset by cuts to costs. Its forecasts assume that spirits imported from Mexico and Canada will remain exempt from tariffs, while a 10-percent tariff on imports from the UK and a 15-percent levy on imports from the European Union will apply. Diageo added that sales of key brands Don Julio and Guinness stout grew 37 percent and 12 percent respectively, offsetting weakness elsewhere. Investors "need to determine if the downturn in alcohol consumption is a short-term effect of squeezed disposable income or the start of a broader trend away from drinking altogether for health and lifestyle reasons", said AJ Bell investment director Russ Mould. "Sales of some brands may be on the agenda for any incoming new boss given a need to get the balance sheet in better shape -- although the company will not want to lose any of its crown jewels."
Int'l Business Times
05-08-2025
- Int'l Business Times
Oil Giant BP Surprises With Better Than Expected Earnings
Oil giant BP, which recently pivoted away from green energy, posted Tuesday better-than-expected quarterly earnings and announced a fresh review of costs. The British group's return to profit in the second quarter contrasted with weaker results from energy rivals, as lower exceptional charges offset falling oil prices. Profit after tax came in at $1.63 billion in the April-June period, compared with a net loss of $129 million in the second quarter of 2024, BP said in an earnings statement. Stripping out exceptional items, underlying net profit was down nearly 15 percent. "This has been another strong quarter for BP operationally and strategically," chief executive Murray Auchincloss said in the earnings statement. BP on Monday said it made its biggest oil and gas discovery in 25 years off the coast of Brazil. In February, BP launched a major pivot back to its more profitable oil and gas business, shelving its once industry-leading targets on reducing carbon emissions and slashing clean energy investment. However, energy prices have come under pressure in recent months on concerns that US President Donald Trump's tariffs will hurt economic growth, while OPEC+ nations have produced more oil. BP managed to post a profit for the second quarter thanks to impairments which were lower than one year earlier, along with a revaluation of assets -- notably in relation to liquefied natural gas (LNG) -- and divestments. By contrast, US rivals ExxonMobil and Chevron, along with French group TotalEnergies, posted heavy falls to their net profits in the second quarter. As did oil giant Saudi Aramco, which on Tuesday announced its 10th straight drop in quarterly profits as a slump in prices hit revenues. The average price for Brent North Sea crude, the international benchmark, stood at $67.9 per barrel in the second quarter, down from $85 one year earlier. British rival Shell still managed to post a slight increase to its profit after tax for the latest reporting period. As for BP, Auchincloss said the company was launching "a further cost review and, whilst we will not compromise on safety, we are doing this with a view to being best in class in our industry". Shares in BP gained 2.2 percent in London morning deals following its results and news of a fresh dividend and share buyback. "A slick turnaround plan pumped up BP's second-quarter results," noted Derren Nathan, head of equity research at Hargreaves Lansdown. "Despite lower oil and gas prices, it's managed to push underlying profits up by nearly $1 billion from the first quarter to $2.4 billion, well ahead of analyst forecasts." Nathan added that "shareholders will be glad to see this matched with financial discipline". BP already announced plans this year to cut cleaner energy investment by more than $5 billion annually and offload assets worth a total of $20 billion by 2027. It recently agreed to sell its onshore wind energy business in the United States, while Shell has also scaled back its climate objectives. BP last month named Albert Manifold as its new chairman, replacing Helge Lund, whose departure was announced amid the strategy reset. The group's net profit plunged 70 percent in its first quarter, hit by weaker oil prices.
