Owner of Dominican nightclub where 236 people died in roof collapse appears in court
The collapse killed 236 people. Nearly 200 people were also injured.
As the owners appeared in court for the first time Wednesday, one victim's sister told CBS News New York she doubts they will ever be held accountable.
"Nothing's going to fill that void"
Among those killed was 24-year-old Jennifer Contreras.
"That was my best friend. We were really, really close," her sister Luz Contreras said. "Nothing's going to fill that void. I'm going to forever miss my sister."
An aerial view of the Jet Set nightclub days after its roof collapsed, killing more than 200 people, in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, Friday, April 11, 2025.
Matias Delacroix / AP
The criminal indictment against the Espaillats says the roof collapse was the result of "complete disregard for building and safety laws." It goes on to say they operated the famous club with systematic and gross negligence which put hundreds of lives at risk.
Antonio Espaillat entered the courtroom surrounded by armed officers. He was followed by his sister Maribel. Prosecutors blame the Espaillats, who owned and managed the nightclub, for April's collapse.
Dozens of families showed up at court Wednesday, including the sister of merengue singer Rubby Perez, who was killed while performing the night of the collapse.
Prosecutors say because of the country's outdated legal framework, involuntary homicide was the highest charge they could pursue. The attorney for the Espaillats calls the charge appropriate, saying the family had no ill intent.
If convicted, the Espaillats face 3 months to 2 years in prison, and a small fine.
"OK, two years and a fine? That's not fair, because you changed everybody's life. Hundreds of people's lives you changed. That's what you did," Luz Contreras said. "He'll probably get away with house arrest. You're living in the comfort of your own home. The comfort of my home has changed. My sister lived with us. Her room is empty now."
The Espaillats also face at least 109 lawsuits filed on behalf of victims and their families.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
10 minutes ago
- CBS News
Judge's order could pause bike lane safety project on Spruce and Pine streets in Philadelphia
A judge issued a decision Wednesday affecting bike lane safety in Philadelphia. The new court order prohibits the city from creating loading zones on Spruce and Pine streets, which was part of the city's larger Spruce and Pine Bike Lane Safety Upgrade Project. The purpose of the new loading zones was to give people somewhere to temporarily stop their car without blocking the bike lanes. The new loading zones were created after new legislation was enacted changing bike lanes from "no parking zones" to "no stopping zones." That means drivers could now get a ticket for blocking the lane, even for a short time. Previously, when the lanes were "no parking zones," cars could legally block the lanes for 20 minutes before getting ticketed. In June, a neighborhood group, Friends of Pine and Spruce, filed a lawsuit seeking to block the city from moving forward with the bike safety plan. George Bochetto, the attorney for Friends of Pine and Spruce, said this ruling is a victory, adding, "We stopped the city in their tracks. They're trying to act illegally. They're trying to sweep in enormous changes in the living conditions on the full length of Pine and Spruce streets by administrative fiat, and you can't do that." He believes this order also stops any further action by the city to protect bike lanes. "A sweeping injunction order preventing the city from altering the parking arrangements on Pine and Spruce streets and from taking any other related actions regarding the bike lanes issue and that includes the city's stated intentions of putting up concrete barriers, which I think is now DOA," said Bochetto. Caleb Holtmeyer with Philly Bike Action has been fighting for bike lane safety for years. He sees the ruling differently. "There's nothing in the junction that says that (preventing concrete barriers). I do think it makes it harder for the city to do things that will make our streets safer because now they have to address this lawsuit," Holtmeyer said. He says he's optimistic the city will do what it takes to make streets safer, but admits this ruling is a big roadblock, adding, "It's unfortunate that life-saving concrete protection might be delayed because of this lawsuit." The city sent CBS News Philadelphia a statement saying: "The City's goal from the start has been to increase overall safety on Pine and Spruce Streets. The loading zone regulations were put in place simultaneously with the beginning of PPA enforcement of the No Stopping Anytime ordinance to allow for temporary parking space which had previously been allowed in the bike lane." "The Friends of Pine and Spruce have now obtained a preliminary injunction that effectively eliminates all legal options for vehicles to legally stop for short-term loading along Pine and Spruce Streets," the statment continues. "The City is working with PPA to ensure compliance with the Court's order. We are not commenting on any further proposals at this time." It's unclear if the loading zones recently installed this past summer will have to be removed.
Washington Post
2 hours ago
- Washington Post
Blackwater founder to deploy nearly 200 personnel to Haiti as gang violence soars
SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — The security firm of former U.S. Navy Seal Erik Prince will soon deploy nearly 200 personnel from various countries to Haiti as part of a one-year deal to quell gang violence there, a person with knowledge of the plans said Thursday. The deployment by Vectus Global is meant to help the government of Haiti recover vast swaths of territory seized in the past year and now controlled by heavily armed gangs, said the person, speaking to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity to discuss the plans.
Associated Press
2 hours ago
- Associated Press
Blackwater founder to deploy nearly 200 personnel to Haiti as gang violence soars
SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico (AP) — The security firm of former U.S. Navy Seal Erik Prince will soon deploy nearly 200 personnel from various countries to Haiti as part of a one-year deal to quell gang violence there, a person with knowledge of the plans said Thursday. The deployment by Vectus Global is meant to help the government of Haiti recover vast swaths of territory seized in the past year and now controlled by heavily armed gangs, said the person, speaking to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity to discuss the plans. The company, which provides logistics, infrastructure, security and defense, is run by Prince, a major donor to U.S. President Donald Trump. Prince previously founded the controversial security firm Blackwater. The deployment was first reported by Reuters. Vectus Global also will assume a long-term role in advising Haiti's government on how to restore revenue collection capabilities once the violence subsides, the person said. A Trump administration official said the U.S. government has no involvement with the hiring of Vectus Global by the Haitian government. The U.S. government is not funding this contract or exercising any oversight, said the official, who requested anonymity to discuss the situation. The private contractors, which will come from the United States, Europe and other regions, are expected to advise and support Haiti's National Police and a U.N.-backed mission led by Kenyan police officers that is struggling to suppress gang violence. The U.N.-backed mission has 991 personnel, far less than the 2,500 envisioned, and some $112 million in its trust fund — about 14% of the estimated $800 million needed a year, according to a recent U.N. report. The upcoming deployment of private contractors comes after the recent appointment of André Jonas Vladimir Paraison as the country's new police director general. Paraison once served as head of security for Haiti's National Palace and was involved in a new task forced created earlier this year made up of certain police units and private contractors. The task force has operated outside the oversight of Haiti's National Police and employed the use of explosive drones, which some human rights activists have criticized. Diego Da Rin, an analyst with the International Crisis Group, said that while there's an obvious need for more anti-gang operations, 'there is a risk of escalating the conflict without having enough personnel to extinguish the fires that Viv Ansanm can ignite in many places.' Viv Ansanm is a powerful gang federation created in September 2023 that saw the merging of gangs, including G-9 and G-Pèp — once bitter enemies. The United States designated it as a foreign terrorist organization earlier this year. The gang federation was responsible for coordinating a series of large-scale attacks early last year that included raids on Haiti's two biggest prisons that led to the release of some 4,000 inmates. Viv Ansanm also forced the closure of Haiti's main international airport for nearly three months, with the violence eventually prompting then-Prime Minister Ariel Henry to resign. Jimmy Chérizier, a leader of Viv Ansanm and best known as Barbeque, recently threatened Paraison. 'Viv Ansanm has a military might that they don't always show,' said Da Rin, the analyst. At least 1,520 people were killed and more than 600 injured from April to the end of June across Haiti. More than 60% of the killings and injuries occurred during operations by security forces against gangs, with another 12% blamed on self-defense groups, according to the United Nations Integrated Office in Haiti. Gang violence also has displaced some 1.3 million people in recent years. ___ Associated Press writer Joshua Boak in Washington contributed to this report.
