logo
Exclusive: Why did Shedeur Sanders slide in draft? NFL team execs give blunt views

Exclusive: Why did Shedeur Sanders slide in draft? NFL team execs give blunt views

USA Today08-05-2025

Exclusive: Why did Shedeur Sanders slide in draft? NFL team execs give blunt views
Show Caption
Hide Caption
Former QB Alex Smith shares advice for Shedeur Sanders
Former NFL quarterback Alex Smith shares advice for Shedeur Sanders after his shocking fall in the draft.
Sports Seriously
Listen to some of the key voices from inside NFL draft war rooms. Let them tell us why Shedeur Sanders, projected by plugged-in analysts as a surefire first-round pick, became the man with arguably the most precipitous slide in draft history.
What the heck happened?
The former Colorado quarterback, son of Hall of Famer Deion Sanders, lasted until the 5th round, when the Cleveland Browns drafted him 144th overall.
'It's never strictly football,' contended a high-ranking decision-maker for an NFL team.
'I think his dad's involvement hurt him,' a high-level executive from another team maintained. 'Some of the things his dad said, I think that weighed on people's minds.'
'It was talent-based,' insisted the top personnel executive from an NFC team. 'There were other factors, but you can't chalk it all up to that.'
The three executives who shared those perspectives were among several who agreed to speak to USA TODAY Sports in the days following the draft, assessing Sanders' tumble. All spoke on the condition of anonymity, not wanting to be identified due to the sensitivity of the issue – which undoubtedly raises questions about the subjectivity of the NFL draft process and by extension the influence of cultural bias.
'We liked Shedeur,' added the high-ranking decision-maker, whose team was clearly in the market to draft a quarterback. 'But you can't separate the other stuff from the physical abilities.'
The 'other stuff' he alluded to didn't involve any of the major off-the-field issues (such as arrests or substance abuse) that can get prospects removed from a team's draft board. Instead, he expressed concerns about Sanders' leadership style and a flashy persona that included flexing a customized, diamond-studded watch that he wore during games and promoting his personal clothing line, '2Legendary.'
'It's not about being a brand,' the decision-maker added. 'It's about being a teammate and earning a job.'
We knew for months that Sanders, poised to report to the Browns rookie minicamp this weekend, represented one of the draft's biggest storylines. He was clearly the most polarizing player in the draft, as suggested during and since the three-day event by the barrage of opinions, analysis and yes, conspiracy theories hatched, which followed intense scrutiny and controversy in the weeks leading up to the late-April draft.
Yet even with that, few, if any, in the NFL universe – including some charged to evaluate prospects for NFL teams – suspected that he would last until the third day of the draft.
'I didn't think 'first-round,'" the decision-maker added. 'But I thought higher than fifth.'
'We never had him as a first-round pick'
Of course, where Sanders ranked on the draft board of any given team reflects the traditional crapshoot nature of the draft and nuances that include variations in standards of evaluation for one team versus another. When it comes to the draft, consensus often is not the ticket after the blue-chip players from any given crop are accounted for.
One high-ranking executive described the marks his team puts on prospects as three separate grades. In addition to grades for pure football and a medical grade (which considers the effect of past injuries), there's an 'intensity' grade that covers intangibles. Standardized cognitive testing used by the NFL, off-the-field issues, culture fit concerns are factors weighed in the latter grade.
Sanders remained on that team's board, but the executive said, 'We never had him as a first-round pick.'
However, another high-ranking executive from an AFC team that was not in the market to draft a quarterback projected Sanders as a possible first-round pick because of the premium on quarterbacks. He said Sanders did not rank among the top 32 players on their board for overall grades but projected as a 'capable starter.'
'Usually, that guy goes in the first round,' he said. 'As a running back, you'd think second or third round. But it's different for a quarterback. The quarterback position is more valuable. We expected him to go early.'
Sanders, he added, was clearly rated as the second-best quarterback prospect on their board after Cam Ward, who was drafted No. 1 overall by the Tennessee Titans. As the draft unfolded, though, Ole Miss product Jaxson Dart (Giants, 25th overall), Louisville's Tyler Shough (Saints, 40th), Alabama's Jalen Milroe (Seahawks, 92nd) and Oregon's Dillon Gabriel (Browns, 94th) were all drafted before Sanders.
Interestingly, the Browns passed on Sanders in selecting Gabriel. After Day 2 of the draft, Browns general manager Andrew Berry said 'fit comes into play' in explaining why the team passed on Sanders.
The next day, Berry rationalized the decision to draft Sanders in the context of value acquired by taking a quarterback at that point in the draft.
Who knows? If Sanders blossoms into the answer for a franchise that has floundered repeatedly in seeking a franchise quarterback, his bargain-basement price for draft capital and cap dollars (he will count for less than $1 million against the salary cap), it would be quite the counter to the enormous price paid ($254 million guaranteed, three first-round picks) for the bust that is Deshaun Watson, injury mishaps or not.
The AFC team's executive who saw Sanders as a first-rounder said that his team had no formal interaction with the quarterback during the draft process, opting not to put resources in evaluating a prospect they viewed as a starter rather than backup. Although they were aware of reports from other teams – such as the story that surfaced during the combine when an assistant coach from another team declared that Sanders was 'arrogant' during what he rated as the worst interview he ever encountered – there were no knocks to document from first-hand experience.
Conversely, the executive from an NFC team offered a scathing rebuke of Sanders. He said Sanders refused to interview with his team, which has an established quarterback in his prime. He said that in turning down the interview at the combine, Sanders told one of his team's scouts: 'You've already got a quarterback and you're not picking in the top 5.'
An unrealistic view of value
It's typical for teams to conduct 15-minute, formal interviews with top prospects at the combine or all-star bowl games, even if they have no plans to draft them. It's an opportunity for teams to become familiar with players and file impressions, perhaps for future reference, such as with free agency or trade talks.
That exchange, though, also underscores something else that multiple voices from teams expressed: Sanders had an unrealistic view of his value.
In any event, in this case the executive said Sanders' refusal to interview wasn't a factor in his projection of the quarterback as a third or fourth-round pick. Nor was Sanders' decision not to work out at the combine a factor, he insisted, while mentioning that in 2024, Caleb Williams didn't work out at the combine before becoming the No. 1 pick overall.
Shedeur Sanders takes high road after NFL draft plunge. His response: gratitude
'We grade the position the same every year,' he said.
While he praised Sanders for his accuracy and toughness, he considered his arm strength as 'good, not great' and questioned his process in reading progressions. Sanders led the nation with a 74% completion rate in 2024 and in two seasons at Colorado fired 64 touchdown passes (13 interceptions). The executive said the high number of sacks Sanders absorbed (94 as a junior and senior) couldn't be blamed solely on a suspect offensive line. Sanders, he maintained, too often held onto the football for too long while locking in on targets.
Although he had reservations about some of the non-football questions, he doubled down on the talent-based assessment by referencing a controversial Cincinnati Bengals pick from the 2017 draft.
The executive said: 'Joe Mixon slapped a woman on TV and still got drafted in the second round.'
In other words, the executive underscored the notion that talent so often eclipses other factors when it comes to opportunity.
Still, the standards are typically different for a quarterback pegged to be the face of a franchise. Sanders' supporters, considering race, will point to Baker Mayfield and Johnny Manziel, as examples in recent years of flashy white quarterbacks who became first-round picks. By the same token, one of the executives pointed to a Black quarterback, Cam Newton, like Mayfield a No. 1 pick overall, as a cautionary example.
The son-of-coach score usually carries weight
Before he was drafted in 2011, Newton raised eyebrows when he maintained that he wanted to become 'an entertainer and an icon.'
More recently, Newton fueled buzz by stating that when he got to the Carolina Panthers he arrived to a 'locker room of losers.'
It's a stretch to project that mentality on Sanders. But one team decision-maker contends that the quarterback's persona rubs him as a 'look-at-me' form of selfishness – even in an age where players are more prone to social media exploits and creative on-the-field celebrations.
'The quarterback's already getting the money and attention,' the decision-maker said. 'They don't have to make more attention. It doesn't play well with your team.
'All the red flags are there. If it was a different position, it probably wouldn't have the same level of importance.'
For Sanders, it's even deeper than being a quarterback. Another layer of standard is attached to his famous father.
This seems a bit sticky. On one hand, you'd think that prospects (Shedeur's older brother, Shilo, a safety, signed as an undrafted free agent with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers) raised by one of the greatest athletes of his era would have traits instilled in them that would aid in their pursuit of pro football careers. And throughout their lives, they've been exposed to resources (like Shedeur calling Tom Brady for advice) that many could only dream of. Also, the father happens to be an immensely successful college coach.
Typically, son-of-coach scores well on the NFL evaluation meter. Yet one NFL executive viewed Coach Prime's impact on Shedeur's draft process as a detriment.
Sure, some might fret about the possibility of the Hall of Famer publicly skewering a team if adversity strikes with his son. Deion has spoken in the past about teams he wouldn't want Shedeur to play for and opined on why some teams repeatedly pick high in the draft.
Yet the team executive maintains that Shedeur's draft stock suffered because of the approach to the draft process.
Shedeur Sanders' dramatic NFL draft slide seems deeper than pure football
'I think he had some bad advice from his father,' the executive said. 'He needed a traditional agent like other players. He and his dad, they felt like they didn't need that. I think that affected him.'
That's debatable, to some degree. Yet an agent might have urged Shedeur to employ a different strategy for dealing with teams during the draft process.
Shortly after he was drafted, Sanders, without being specific, owned up to regrets.
'I feel like in life, there's always a way I can improve,' he told Cleveland media during a conference call. 'I'm able to improve. And some things that I (did) seemed right at the time. I could've went about it in a different way.'
The executive whose team pegged Sanders as a first-round pick said he hopes the young quarterback will learn a valuable lesson about humility from the draft process.
'You're not your dad,' he added. 'You don't have that type of ability.'
Another key executive also threw some shade at the Hall of Fame father.
'The way he reacted as the draft unfolded, I thought he handled himself well,' he said of Shedeur. 'The best thing to happen might be to get away from his father and be on his own.'
Then again, with so many strong opinions about his ability, traits and process, too, Sanders embarks on his NFL journey with no shortage of motivational fuel to prove that some particular NFL power players were so wrong.
Follow Jarrett Bell on social media: @JarrettBell

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Vikings Urged to Pounce on Rival $84 Million CB Who Just Became Available
Vikings Urged to Pounce on Rival $84 Million CB Who Just Became Available

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Vikings Urged to Pounce on Rival $84 Million CB Who Just Became Available

Vikings Urged to Pounce on Rival $84 Million CB Who Just Became Available originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The Minnesota Vikings used free agency to plug holes in the secondary last offseason and could be poised to employ a similar strategy heading into training camp. Advertisement The NFC North Division rival Green Bay Packers parted ways with All-Pro cornerback Jaire Alexander on Monday, two years into the two-time Pro Bowler's $84 million contract. When Alexander signed that deal in May 2022, it made him the richest cornerback in NFL history at the time. Things haven't gone great for Alexander since, however. He missed 10 games in each of the past two seasons due to injury issues and was also served a one-game suspension by the team, as personality clashes between Alexander and the Packers' front office/coaching staff became more evident with time. Former Green Bay Packers cornerback Jaire Banks-Imagn Images That said, when healthy, the 28-year-old defensive back is still capable of playing lockdown defense. Green Bay may not have let him go were it not for the $17 million in savings the team recouped by doing so. Advertisement Alexander isn't going to come cheap, per say, though right now is the time to sign him to an affordable one-year contract. The Vikings make sense in that regard in several ways, as the team has one lockdown cornerback in Byron Murphy but lost its other two starters at the position during the offseason. Brian Flores also plays an aggressive style of defense that led to a league-leading 24 interceptions by the Vikings last season. Alexander could potentially rebuild his value in a big way statistically in such a scenario, while also playing on a team with legitimate playoff/Super Bowl aspirations and one that will afford him at least two opportunities to inflict direct revenge on his former employer during division play. Kay Adams of FanDuel TV's "Up & Adams" had similar ideas on her Monday broadcast. "My vote for landing spot for one Jaire Alexander would be the Vikings, of course," Adams said. "We can do the funniest thing ever here. Join forces with he who you like jawing against (in Justin Jefferson). Advertisement "Go to the Vikings. So much has gone on between him and Minnesota over the years. They need a corner." Related: Two NFL Teams Stand to Benefit from Trades Involving Dolphins Star DB This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 9, 2025, where it first appeared.

Chiefs Turn Heads After Announcement on Patrick Mahomes' Teammate
Chiefs Turn Heads After Announcement on Patrick Mahomes' Teammate

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Chiefs Turn Heads After Announcement on Patrick Mahomes' Teammate

Chiefs Turn Heads After Announcement on Patrick Mahomes' Teammate originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The Kansas City Chiefs may have hit a speed bump last season, but they have been at the top of the NFL world for much of the past several years. Advertisement Kansas City has been to three straight Super Bowls, having won in 2023 and 2024. Last season, Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs suffered a loss to the Philadelphia Eagles in the Super Bowl, ending their chances of winning three straight titles. Before their loss to the Eagles, the Chiefs defeated the Houston Texans and the Buffalo Bills in the postseason, earning the AFC championship. After the season, the Chiefs headed back to the whiteboard, looking to improve on their quest for four straight Super Bowl appearances. During the offseason, Pro Football Focus dropped its center rankings, listing Chiefs star Creed Humphrey as the No. 1 center in the NFL. Advertisement The Chiefs reacted to the announcement on social media, adding a strong statement to their post. "Giving credit where it's due," posted the official social media account of the Kansas City Chiefs. "PFF named Creed Humphrey the 𝙗𝙚𝙨𝙩 center in the league headed into this season." Upon the release of the announcement, some fans took to social media, sharing their thoughts on the ranking. "Congratulations Creed! You deserve it! Go Chiefs," said one fan. "Protect QB1," said another fan. "It's about time," mentioned one fan. "That's my center," commented one fan. "Too bad his qb is Mahomes," said one fan. Advertisement "Congrats Creed!!! You are the man," said another fan. Kansas City Chiefs coach Andy Reid talks with quarterback Patrick Mahomes. Jim Dedmon-Imagn Images Creed Humphrey was drafted by the Kansas City Chiefs in 2021 after starring at Oklahoma at the collegiate level. Since joining the Chiefs and helping lead the offense with one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL, Patrick Mahomes, Humphrey has been named a three-time Pro Bowler. The Chiefs star, who has already earned three Super Bowl titles, has also been honored as a Second-Team and First-Team All-Pro. Related: Patrick Mahomes Turns Heads with Personal Announcement on Sunday Related: Patrick Mahomes Had No Words for Kansas City Star Amid Offseason This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 10, 2025, where it first appeared.

Wan'Dale Robinson Seeing Early Returns From Giants' Russell Wilson
Wan'Dale Robinson Seeing Early Returns From Giants' Russell Wilson

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Wan'Dale Robinson Seeing Early Returns From Giants' Russell Wilson

Wan'Dale Robinson Seeing Early Returns From Giants' Russell Wilson originally appeared on Athlon Sports. New York Giants quarterback Russell Wilson will be tasked with more than just leading the 2025 offense. He'll be asked to mentor Jaxson Dart and lead the team through the turbulence that may come. Advertisement But for much of the roster, Dart's long-term fate isn't a huge priority. They may not be on the next good Giants team. In such a ruthless game, they may not even be in the league at all when Dart starts Week 1 of the 2026 season. Players will do what they can to make Dart successful, but performing on Sundays comes first. For as long as Wilson is the starter, New York will trust him to give the team the best chance to win. By default, he should be an upgrade over Daniel Jones, and his teammates are already taking notice. Receiver Wan'Dale Robinson revealed his first impression of Wilson after the Giants' organized team activities (OTAs) on Thursday. 'That deep ball just drops right in the bucket, for sure,' Robinson said. 'And then whenever he's throwing just the shorter routes and stuff like that, it kind of comes in like a pillow. It's really, really easy to catch, which I like.' Advertisement Wilson is far from a sure thing. His play is volatile, winning six of his first seven starts in 2024 before losing five consecutive games, including the AFC Wild Card Round contest against the Baltimore Ravens. He can avoid the middle of the field and make questionable plays under pressure, too. But even Wilson's decline has been more effective than recent quarterbacking in New York. Since 2022 (and coincidentally in 2024 itself), he has posted 0.019 expected points added per play, a below-average mark that falls between Aaron Rodgers and Bryce Young's production from this past season. In the Brian Daboll era, the Giants have generated -0.054 expected points added per dropback, ahead of just four teams (rbsdm). Wilson, undeniably, is an upgrade. Robinson, and seemingly his peers in the receiving room, know it. '​​Even the first time we threw, me and (Darius) Slay(ton) were both like, this is actually better than we expected,' he said. 'And so, no, we were ecstatic about it, and couldn't be more happy that he's our quarterback.' Advertisement Related: NFC East Receiver Rankings: Giants Steady As Rivals Improve Related: NFC East Positional Rankings: Do Giants' Quarterbacks Matter? This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 9, 2025, where it first appeared.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store