Woodside's environmental plan for $12b project ‘corporate puffery', court told
They also say Woodside's submissions to court misinterpret the Australian offshore regulator NOPSEMA's reasons for granting the approval.
The Federal Court of Australia in Melbourne on Monday began hearings into Doctors for the Environment Australia's legal challenge to the $12 billion project, part of the company's Burrup Hub plan.
It involves tapping the field off Western Australia's north-west coast and running the gas through a 430-kilometre pipeline to its onshore Pluto plant.
The Environmental Defenders Office's Chris Young, KC, argued on behalf of the doctors' group that Woodside's court submission misinterpreted NOPSEMA's reasons for approval in suggesting the regulator considered Scarborough's projected emissions negligible to its assessment.
Woodside's environmental plan estimates Scarborough's total emissions across its life would be 878 million tonnes, equalling 0.37 per cent of the world's remaining carbon budget for a 1.5-degree warming scenario, and that its emissions within Australia would make up 0.9 per cent of Australia's remaining emissions budget to 2030.
Young told Judge Shaun McElwaine Woodside's environmental plan contained statements to the effect that emissions associated with Scarborough could not be linked to climate change impacts to the environment.
'NOPSEMA has not accepted this claim previously,' he said, citing a letter from the regulator to Woodside stating such a view was 'unsupported', especially given Woodside's ability to calculate Scarborough's expected emissions as a 'clear and measurable contribution' to Australia's total.
'The environmental plan should establish the context of Scarborough emissions, established emissions budgets, and clearly acknowledge the linear relationship between emissions and global warming,' the letter had said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AU Financial Review
18 minutes ago
- AU Financial Review
Private equity giant TPG to buy listed flower supplier for $280m
TPG Capital Asia has made a second push to take a listed Australian company private this month, swooping on listed flower wholesaler Lynch Group in a $280 million all-cash acquisition through its subsidiary Hasfarm Holdings. The move follows TPG's $651 million bid for automotive software company Infomedia and highlights the private equity firm's strategy of acquiring public companies to consolidate market leadership in key sectors.
Perth Now
18 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Grim warning for state's biggest export
Premier Chris Minns has warned that NSW's biggest export, black coal, is under threat as demand dries up. Mr Minns told budget estimates that Southeast Asia nations had indicated they would reduce their purchases of black coal 'to a point where they don't buy any at all'. 'Our largest export is still black coal, and it still goes to effectively a single market,' Mr Minns said on Wednesday, adding it accounted for much of the $40bn in exports. 'Now, those countries will continue to buy it, and there's a future for those jobs. I accept that. 'But, they've all indicated to us, over a different time horizons, in different ways, they'll be buying less of it in the future to the point where they don't buy any of it at all. 'NSW is facing a situation where our single biggest export, we are being told in explicit terms, will decline in the years ahead.' Premier Chris Minns says the state can't rely on black coal forever. NewsWire/ Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia Australian coal is predominantly exported to countries in Asia and Southeast Asia, including Japan, China, India, South Korea, and Taiwan. A NSW government trade and investment strategy, released in May, indicated a need to diversify the state's exports, including in Southeast Asia. This includes plans for a $100bn increase in goods and services exports by 2035. The revelations come as Mr Minns is questioned about the conservation hunting Bill, which is before a parliamentary inquiry and seeks to expand hunting rights. Mr Minns indicated a 'bounty' scheme, in which NSW hunters were paid for kills of invasive species, was being considered, although he said it did not 'have blanket support'. He urged for a focus on 'export industries native to us', namely the state's agriculture sector, with combating native species being integral to that. Glencore's massive Ravensworth open cut coal mine northwest of Singleton. NewsWire / Peter Lorimer. Credit: News Corp Australia 'We want to grow our agriculture sector. It's a huge and important part of the future growth, future economic growth for the state,' Mr Minns said. 'But, that's not going to happen if both the actual product is threatened by invasive species or the perception about Australian agriculture and primary products is threatened as a result of invasive species. 'So, I just think it's all hands on deck.' The Bill has faced pushback from nature conservation groups who say such hunting would not have a meaningful impact on feral animal populations.
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
‘Strength not measured by bombs': Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke lashes out at Netanyahu over Albanese ‘weak' dig
Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke has made extraordinary comments about Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, saying 'strength is not measured by how many people you can blow up'. Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke has lashed out at Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for calling Prime Minister Anthony Albanese 'weak', saying 'strength' is not measured by blowing people up. The extraordinary remarks came after Mr Netanyahu called Mr Albanese 'weak', following the inflammatory decision to reocgnise Palestinian statehood. Speaking to ABC RN Breakfast on Tuesday, Mr Burke said Israel was 'lashing out' and isolating itself on the world stage. 'Strength is not measured by how many people you can blow up, or how many children you can leave hungry,' Mr Burke said. 'Strength is much better measured by exactly what prime minister Anthony Albanese has done – which is when there's a decision that we know Israel won't like. 'He goes straight to Benjamin Netanyahu. He has the conversation, he says exactly what we're intending to do, and has the chance for the objections to be made… 'And then having heard them, makes the public announcement and does what needs to be done.' Mr Burke said the government will continue to pursue its long-standing position of a two-state solution. The feud between Australia and Israel has progressively deteriorated in recent months, intensified by the decision to recognise a Palestinian state ahead of a peace deal. — Prime Minister of Israel (@IsraeliPM) August 19, 2025 In retaliation, Israel revoked the visas of Australian diplomats to the Palestinian Authority, following Australia's cancellation of the visa of Israeli MP Simcha Rothman. Mr Rothman's visa was denied over concerns that his presence could spark counter-protests, despite his advocacy for the elimination of Hamas. Shadow foreign affairs minister Michaelia Cash condemned the government's decision, saying it had 'badly mismanaged' the relationship. 'To suggest that calls for the destruction of Hamas are 'inflammatory' or grounds for visa cancellation is absurd,' he said. Opposition Leader Sussan Ley also described the visa rejection as 'a very unusual thing' and lamented the deterioration of ties with Israel. The diplomatic row escalated further when Mr Netanyahu wrote to Mr Albanese, calling him 'weak' and accusing him of pouring 'fuel on this antisemitic fire'. 'It is not diplomacy, it is appeasement… Prime Minister, antisemitism is a cancer. It spreads when leaders stay silent. It retreats when leaders act,' Mr Netanyahu said. 'I call upon you to replace weakness with action, appeasement with resolve, and to do so by a clear date: the Jewish New Year, September 23, 2025.' New polling for The Sydney Morning Herald recently revealed that voters were divided over recognition of Palestine. Just 24 per cent of voters supported recognition of Palestine regardless of who holds power in Gaza. Thirty-two per cent said recognition should wait until terrorist organisation Hamas is removed from power or Palestine recognises Israel's right to exist. Forty-four per cent opposed any change to Australia's current stance of not recognising Palestine.
