logo
How are Scottish parties set for Holyrood election? John Curtice's view

How are Scottish parties set for Holyrood election? John Curtice's view

The National11-05-2025

The General Election last June represented a dark day for the SNP as their presence at Westminster significantly diminished, but Labour's time in the sun has been short-lived.
Meanwhile, the English local elections earlier this month confirmed what the polls have been telling us; that the rise of Reform UK is real.
So what is the state of play with the Scottish parties as we move into the final year of the Parliament? We spoke to top pollster Professor John Curtice for his verdict.
The 'lucky general' John Swinney
First Minister John Swinney feared the SNP would be wiped out at Westminster, which didn't quite come to pass, but they were left with just nine MPs following the vote last June.
Curtice said there hasn't been a tremendous amount of progress made since the General Election, with them polling at about 34%, just a few points ahead of what they attracted last year.
But Curtice explained the rapid decline in support for Scottish Labour on the back of unpopular UK Government policies has played into the SNP's hands.
READ MORE: Is time running out for Anas Sarwar to stand against Keir Starmer?
'There's not been a great deal of progress by the SNP, but this is where Swinney is a lucky general,' he told the Sunday National.
'The collapse in Labour support and the rise in Reform has just turned a third of the vote from a losing share to a winning share.'
Consecutive polls have suggested the SNP look like the only party capable of forming a government and a pro-Yes majority looks promising.
But they are set to end up with fewer MSPs than they have now, meaning they will need significant help to get budgets and legislation over the line.
(Image: Jane Barlow) Curtice said the NHS is likely to be a huge issue for the SNP in ensuring they keep their nose in front.
'Until Sturgeon resigned, it was as though the SNP's record in government didn't matter. The opposition could constantly criticise them, but it was like water off a duck's back because the constitutional question dominated,' he said.
'When Sturgeon resigned, the insulation of the constitution became thinner, you then began to see that people who had voted for the SNP in 2019 or 2021 were now less willing to do so if they felt the health service was not working very well.
'The question is can they or can they not be as effective as Wes Streeting in turning it around? If Labour do turn it around south of the Border, and the same thing doesn't happen in Scotland, that will be an issue for the SNP.'
The only way is up for Reform UK
If anyone was in any doubt about whether Labour's popularity has plummeted quite as fast as everyone has been suggesting, the English local elections last week confirmed it.
Reform are coming and while Curtice says they are not as popular in Scotland as they are south of the Border, the polls indicating their rise in the nations are becoming more alarming by the week.
They were predicted to clinch 21 seats at Holyrood in a Survation poll last week, which would make them the main opposition ahead of Labour and the Tories.
(Image: PA) 'Reform are fragmenting the Unionist vote and thereby potentially paving the way to a pro-Yes majority,' said Curtice.
'The SNP now have to hope that Reform are close to the top of their curve, or they could start challenging for constituency seats.'
Sarwar back to square one
Labour swept Scotland at the General Election, but the high was brief, and they've been left with quite the hangover.
According to Curtice's analysis of a poll by Survation last week, Anas Sarwar's party would end up behind Reform in third place with just 18 seats – four fewer than they currently have. So much for 'change'.
Curtice said: 'They are all the way back to where they were in May 2021.
'The rise of the Labour Party in Scotland had nothing to do with Scotland. It started with partygate and then the Liz Truss fiscal event. They were already at 30% when Sturgeon resigned.
READ MORE: Richard Tice left fuming on BBC Question Time by trade union boss
'The resignation of Sturgeon did enable them to pick some votes off the SNP but the foundations of the rise was all to do with what was happening at Westminster and therefore [their position now] is everything to do with what is happening at Westminster.
'It's very difficult for him [Sarwar] to escape the shadow of the performance of Labour down south.'
An all-time low for Conservatives
If the downward trajectory in support for Labour has been staggering, then the one for the Conservatives has been colossal.
The Tories polled at 11% and 12% in the constituency and list vote in the Survation survey last week which would only get them 13 seats, leaving them firmly in fourth place in the chamber.
'All the gains made in the Ruth Davidson era are gone,' said Curtice.
'It takes them back to more or less the all-time low, but again it's not Russell Findlay (above) or his predecessor's fault.
'Blame Boris Johnson and Liz Truss.'
Greens 'unscathed' despite rollercoaster
The Greens have been on quite the journey since amassing their greatest haul of MSPs ever in 2021.
In government under Nicola Sturgeon, then out of government under Humza Yousaf, but Curtice says they have come off the rollercoaster relatively unscathed.
Polls suggest they will secure at least the number of seats they already have and potentially a few more, but they do have a leadership contest on the horizon with Patrick Harvie stepping back as co-leader in the summer.
So far, Lorna Slater and Gillian Mackay have put themselves forward for election, with Ross Greer expected to follow.
Curtice said: 'What matters to the Greens is the list vote so they could pick up about 10 seats which is a few seats up.
'They have come through the coalition and the unravelling of it largely unscathed. Of course, they will have to survive Patrick Harvie standing down as leader.'
Curtice also questioned whether Swinney was 'throwing bait' to the Greens with his decision to get rid of peak rail fares after the trial was deemed to have failed just a few months ago.
Alba's new era
Polls have seemed to disagree on where Alba are at, with some suggesting they wouldn't get any seats and others indicating they could get seven.
Currently, the party has just one MSP in Ash Regan (below).
Curtice said: 'Some people will question whether they can survive the death of Alex Salmond, and I would say it's equally true there was no chance there were ever going to go anywhere with Salmond as leader.
'Alex's personal reputation was destroyed by the court case. No matter the rights and wrongs, he had become toxic.
'Their average list vote, and at the moment it does vary by poll quite a lot, is 4%. You've got to get 6, and then you're in the mix.'
LibDems back on the bureau
Following the defection of Jamie Greene from the Tories, the LibDems have been enjoying life back as a recognised party on the Scottish Parliament bureau, increasing their influence and gaining more speaking time.
Looking at the polls, Curtice says they are running at about 10% and look to be in a position to potentially make gains.
'It looks as though they might now be doing well enough to pick up the odd list seat,' he said.
'They certainly should be able to get past the threshold to be a recognised party on the bureau. They ought to emerge in a better position than they did in 2021 and their position at a UK level is as strong as it has been at any stage since 2019.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Reform's new chairman is Most Haunted TV star
Reform's new chairman is Most Haunted TV star

Telegraph

time23 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Reform's new chairman is Most Haunted TV star

Reform UK's new chairman is a former TV presenter known for fronting a reality show about hunting ghosts. Dr David Bull, who is also an ex-hospital doctor, will take over from Zia Yusuf, who dramatically resigned from the party last week before rejoining just two days later. Dr Bull is a former deputy leader of Reform, having held the role from 2021 to 2024, when he was replaced by Richard Tice on Nigel Farage's return as leader. For around a year, the 56-year-old shared the job with Ben Habib, who has since quit the party and become an outspoken supporter of Reform critic Rupert Lowe. Before entering politics, Dr Bull worked as a TV host, starting as an on-screen doctor for Sky TV in the mid-1990s before joining Newsround, the children's news show, and going on to present the paranormal series Most Haunted Live. He has also appeared on BBC's Watchdog, going on to host the spin-off Watchdog Healthcheck and the live science show Tomorrow's World. He is now a presenter on TalkTV, the news channel owned by Rupert Murdoch, which went online-only last year. Dr Bull, who reportedly backs 'binning the burka', was revealed as Reform's new chairman by the Daily Mail. He will replace Mr Yusuf, who stepped down from his position in spectacular fashion last Thursday before rejoining in a new role on Saturday. His resignation followed a disagreement within the party over whether to ban the burka, an idea he branded 'dumb'. Senior Reform figures also said that Mr Yusuf's professional style, born of his former career as a Goldman Sachs banker, had led to personality clashes at the top of the party. The former chairman will now lead Reform's so-called UK Doge team, inspired by the US Department of Government Efficiency set up by Donald Trump and run by Elon Musk. Dr Bull is also a former doctor and has written two books: Cool and Celibate? Sex and No Sex and What Every Girl Should Know. According to his website, he qualified as a doctor in 1993 and went on to work for the NHS at St Mary's Hospital, Ealing Hospital and the Whittington Hospital, all in London, in the fields of general medicine, emergency medicine and general practice. He was briefly a Brexit Party MEP and initially ran as the Tory candidate for Brighton Pavilion in 2009 before stepping down to lead a Conservative policy review on sexual health. A Reform source told the Daily Mail: 'He looks and sounds good and he's been out and proud for years, so we have no worries about any skeletons in his closet.'

Labour's reasoning for winter fuel cuts never did make sense
Labour's reasoning for winter fuel cuts never did make sense

The National

time24 minutes ago

  • The National

Labour's reasoning for winter fuel cuts never did make sense

If Labour's by-election candidate had been able to hail a Westminster U-turn on Winter Fuel Payments (WFPs), perhaps he wouldn't have been so camera-shy in the days before the vote in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse. That said, it's not immediately clear what the impact of this Westminster decision will be on Scotland's devolved Pension Age Winter Heating Payment, which the Scottish Government last year decided would be £100 for every pensioner household, with means-testing for higher payments. Will universality be maintained, even if the sums are increased to match the payments in England and Wales to which only some pensioners will be entitled? READ MORE: Labour 'left us to see winter fuel U-turn on social media', SNP minister says The Scottish Government received no more notice than any of the rest of us that this U-turn was coming, so will now need to reassess its plans. The whole situation is a guddle, highlighting once again the limitations on Holyrood making its own decisions that best meet the needs of its people. Given our colder climate, it seems likely the payments will be increased. But what a lot of wasted energy has been devoted to mitigating the impact of a UK Government policy decision that went down like a lead balloon as soon as it was announced, and has been blamed for the Labour Party's poor showing in the English local elections. The policy never quite made sense, given that it was trumpeted as a way to save the Government money but it could actually have ended up costing more than the previous universal system. Chancellor Rachel Reeves has largely U-turned on her Winter Fuel cuts (Image: PA) By linking eligibility for WFPs to receipt of pension credit (and certain other income-related benefits), Labour quite deliberately encouraged more benefit applications. Nearly 60,000 extra awards of pension credit have been made since the means-testing of WFPs was announced, and at an average value of around £4000 this will have cost an additional £235 million or so. It's a small sum compared to the £1.3 billion Labour hoped to save in the first year of limiting fuel payments, but it's a tiny fraction of the estimated unclaimed pension credit. The Government believes 880,000 households are missing out, but must have banked on far fewer than half of them making successful claims in response to the ending of WFPs for all. Had 440,000 been spurred into action and made successful claims, the bill could have been in the region of £1.76bn. This would have been no bad thing – the policy would have redistributed pensioner support from those who possibly didn't need it to those who definitely did. But this was not how Labour sold the policy, and indeed not how it worked out. READ MORE: SNP urge Rachel Reeves to abandon disability cuts after winter fuel U-turn The number-crunchers presumably took into account two important factors: one, that applying for pension credit is not particularly easy to do, and two, that many pensioners are strongly resistant to being perceived as benefit claimants, regardless of how low their incomes may be. I say 'perceived as', rather than 'being', because they are happy to accept their state pensions, which they do not consider to be benefits because they have 'paid in' for them, but are more reluctant to apply for means-tested top-ups. I can already hear some of our letter-writers cracking their knuckles ready to scold me for suggesting their pensions are benefits as opposed to simply entitlements. While pensioner pride is one factor in low benefit take-up, others include lack of knowledge about what is available – including the fact that even a modest pension credit payment acts as a 'gateway' to other benefits including Council Tax reduction, the Warm Home Discount and free TV licences for over-75s. Worryingly, between last July and this May a whopping 146,000 claims were refused, representing a 99% increase on the year before. Reporting on the high proportion of such claims in the months following the WFP change, the BBC suggested this could be 'due to people failing to meet the criteria, or failing to submit the 24-page, 223-question form properly'. Back in November, opposition MPs were critical of the fact that people were waiting 10 weeks for a decision, but appeared less curious to know why so many were being rejected. Is it plausible that so many of those who applied were actually ineligible, given what we know about low take-up rates? Or is it more likely that the application process is too arduous for many to complete correctly? Yes, some people may have felt it was worth applying even if they weren't sure they were eligible, but with the form taking an average of 16 minutes to complete it's certainly not a simple case of a few clicks. Labour will be hoping to move on from this policy disaster, and will stick to their line about desperate measures being required last summer. However, the matter of unclaimed pension credit, and the high number of rejected claims, is arguably far more important. Is the complexity of the application process a barrier too far? And how likely are proud pensioners to challenge decisions, or resubmit their claims, if they were disinclined to apply in the first place?

Nicola Sturgeon and Irvine Welsh join Edinburgh Book Festival line-up
Nicola Sturgeon and Irvine Welsh join Edinburgh Book Festival line-up

Daily Record

time30 minutes ago

  • Daily Record

Nicola Sturgeon and Irvine Welsh join Edinburgh Book Festival line-up

The former first minister is preparing to launch a mammoth promotional tour ahead of the publication of her long-awaited political memoir. Nicola Sturgeon and Irvine Welsh are among the big names appearing at this year's Edinburgh International Book Festival, organisers have announced. The ex-SNP leader will appear at the event's venue in Chartlotte Square in August - just yards from Bute House, her official residence when she spent almost a decade as first minister. ‌ Sturgeon is preparing to launch a mammoth promotional tour ahead of the publication of Frankly, her long-awaited political memoir. ‌ The former first minister has said she "poured my heart" into writing the book, which hits the shops on August 14. Sturgeon, who will stand down as an MSP next year, is being paid a six-figure sum for the book deal. The Scottish Parliament's register of interests showed that she will earn £300,000. It comes after Scotland's top civil servant was this week accused of fawning over Sturgeon after wishing her success with her £300,000 memoirs. Permanent Secretary Joe Griffin cheered on the former First Minister after clearing the 464-page book, titled 'Frankly', for publication. In a letter telling her no changes were required for national security reasons, he gushed: "I wish you well with publication of the memoirs". Meanwhile, Trainspotting author Welsh will appear at the festival to promote his new book Men in Love, which continues the stories of classic characters like Sick Boy, Renton and Spud. ‌ It will follow the Edinburgh gang as they try to leave heroin behind and pursue romance in the late 1980s and early 1990s. 'I'm really, really excited about bringing these characters back', Welsh previously said. "It was that time at the end of punk and just before acid house, it was that quite fallow time of Thatcherism,' when the 'end of history' thesis was popular, said Welsh. 'Of course, that's really been shown to be nonsense.' ‌ Book festival bosses said the theme of this year's event is "repair". Festival director Jenny Niven said: 'This year's key theme of Repair starts from the belief that the brilliant ideas of writers and thinkers can help us repair a host of seemingly 'broken' things in our society, from the cycle of fast fashion and our relationship with the environment, to cultural reparations and the state of our politics. 'It's a statement of hope and resilience, and an invitation for our audiences to think about what 'repair' might mean for them. 'At a time when important conversations can feel impossible to have without igniting conflict and anger, we want the Edinburgh International Book Festival to provide a safe place for challenging but considered discussions. ‌ 'This year our programme features over 600 writers and artists from 35 countries, who have a wide range of perspectives on topics of personal, social and global importance. 'We invite you to come and learn something new, feed your curiosity and to broaden your horizons.' John Swinney previously quipped he had no plans to write his own tell-all book as he was focused on his job running the Scottish Government. ‌ The First Minister was asked if he planned to read the memoir written by one of his closest SNP colleagues. "I've not got a copy of it as it's not been published yet - but I'm sure it will be a good read," he told reporters. Asked if he had ever heard Nicola Sturgeon talk 'Frankly' - as per the title of her memoir - Swinney said: "I'm sure I have... maybe on the odd occasion". Swinney added: "Just for absolute clarity - I have no immediate plans to write my memoirs, as I intend to be in office for a long time to come."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store