US judge says Apple defied order in App Store case
SAN FRANCISCO: A US judge on Wednesday accused Apple of defying an order to loosen its grip on the App Store payment system to the point that criminal charges could be warranted.
US District Court Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers found that Apple "willfully" violated an injunction she issued at trial, with the company instead creating new barriers to competition with the App Store and even lying to the court in the process.
"That it thought this court would tolerate such insubordination was a gross miscalculation," Gonzalez Rogers said in an order allowing Epic Games to enforce the injunction against Apple.
"As always, the cover-up made it worse. For this court, there is no second bite at the apple."
Fortnite-maker Epic launched the case in 2021 aiming to break Apple's grip on the App Store, accusing the iPhone maker of acting like a monopoly in its shop for digital goods or services.
After a trial, Gonzalez Rogers ruled that Apple's control of the App Store did not amount to a monopoly, but that it must let developers include links to other online venues for buying content or services.
The judge also found at the time that the 30 percent commission Apple charges on App Store sales allowed it "supracompetitive operating margins" that were anticompetitive, according to the injunction.
Apple's response to the trial order included charging a commission on purchases made linking out of its app store, according to the judge.
Apple also imposed new barriers and new requirements including "scare screens" to dissuade people from buying digital purchases outside of its App Store, the judge concluded.
"In the end, Apple sought to maintain a revenue stream worth billions in direct defiance of this court's injunction," Gonzalez Rogers said in the ruling.
"In stark contrast to Apple's initial in-court testimony, contemporaneous business documents reveal that Apple knew exactly what it was doing and at every turn chose the most anticompetitive option."
An Apple spokesperson told AFP it strongly disagrees with the judge's decision and will appeal to a higher court, but plans to comply.
"Apple's 15-30 percent junk fees are now just as dead here in the United States of America as they are in Europe under the Digital Markets Act," Epic Games chief executive Tim Sweeney said in a post on X, formerly Twitter.
Sweeney's post included a "peace proposal" promising to drop current and future litigation on the matter if Apple extends the court's "Apple-tax-free framework" worldwide.
The judge called on the US Attorney's office to investigate whether punitive criminal contempt sanctions against Apple are warranted "to punish past misconduct and deter future noncompliance."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
From fishing family to Big Tech: French CEO takes on Silicon Valley
As OpenAI's number two, Simo will free up CEO Altman to focus on research and infrastructure while she tackles the company's operational challenges. — AFP NEW YORK: At just 39 years old, Fidji Simo is poised to become OpenAI's second-in-command after leaving her mark at two other major tech firms, including Meta. Reporting directly to CEO Sam Altman, the move to the ChatGPT-maker represents the latest chapter in a career that has taken Simo from a fishing family in France's Mediterranean port of Sete to the heights of Silicon Valley. As the current CEO of grocery delivery platform Instacart, she cuts a unique profile: a French woman in the male-dominated American tech landscape -- who resists advice to blend in. "I can put all my energy trying to be someone else or I can be myself and pour all of that energy into what I can create," she told CNBC in February. This philosophy will likely be on display when she appears Thursday at the VivaTech conference in Paris. Raised in Sete, Simo attended the elite HEC business school before joining eBay in 2006, first in France then in California. "People expect a very business-like story for why I decided to come to the US. It wasn't. The American Dream was on TV every night and that was an incredibly appealing thing," she said. 'Never Intimidated' In 2011, Simo joined Facebook, now Meta. She was given responsibility for video and monetisation in 2014, a role she considers the defining moment of her career. Simo championed the company's pivot to video, which became central to Meta's strategy despite initial internal scepticism. "She never let herself be intimidated," recalled David Marcus, who worked at Meta alongside Simo and now serves as CEO of online payment company Lightspark. "She had an ability to challenge Mark (Zuckerberg) and push him, when others would have hesitated." Joining Instacart in 2021, Simo inherited a company that had been bleeding money for a decade. Under her leadership, the grocery delivery platform achieved profitability in 2022 through aggressive diversification: data monetisation, expanded retail partnerships and a robust advertising business. Now Simo faces her biggest test yet. As OpenAI's number two, she'll free up CEO Altman to focus on research and infrastructure while she tackles the company's operational challenges. Despite being one of history's most highly funded startups and ChatGPT's phenomenal success, OpenAI is burning cash at an alarming rate. The company has also weathered significant leadership turnover, including Altman's own brief ouster and reinstatement in 2023, raising questions about management stability. But French investor Julien Codorniou, who worked alongside Simo at Facebook, said she will more than rise to the occasion. "Fidji's arrival is a declaration of ambition by OpenAI," he said. – AFP
Malaysian Reserve
20 hours ago
- Malaysian Reserve
Everything new coming to iPhones, iPads and Macs later this year
APPLE Inc. kicked off its annual Worldwide Developers Conference on Monday with a roughly 90-minute presentation where it unveiled a slew of updates to its various software platforms. Consumers and investors alike had high expectations ahead of the event, after Apple indefinitely delayed some artificial-intelligence features it announced at least year's conference. While Apple's effort to start an AI comeback at this year's conference fell short, with a limited number of enhancements, there are several new non-AI upgrades. Accompanying the changes is a major visual overhaul, a new look that Apple calls 'Liquid Glass.' As the name suggests, it's lighter and transparent — a nod to the idea that more devices in the future will feature glass of some kind. Bloomberg News reported on Sunday the new look is in preparation for the 20-year anniversary iPhone coming in 2027. As part of its rebranding efforts, the company also confirmed that it will use years, not version numbers, to identify its software. The upgraded platforms announced Monday, for instance, include iOS 26, iPadOS 26, tvOS 26, macOS 26, watchOS 26 and visionOS 26. Here is a list of the most significant new features coming to your devices later this year: The interface now has new icons — including a fully transparent option — as well as redesigned navigation bars, menus and in-app interfaces that are reminiscent of those on the Vision Pro headset. Hot on the heels of the Nintendo Co. Switch 2 launch, Apple showed off a new Games app, allowing users to track what their friends are playing, start challenges with others, and explore new titles from both the App Store and Apple Arcade. The Phone app has a new view that combines recent calls, favorite contacts and voicemails. It also adds hold detection with real-time updates to the iPhone user for when a live person comes back on the line. Messages now has support for polls, background images and Apple Cash integration in group chats. Both the Phone app and Messages get better spam screening, while the Messages app gets improved filters between unknown senders, spam, recently deleted and unread messages. The Camera app has a streamlined interface that's meant to be simpler and give quicker access to video and photo capture. On the lock screen, the time will adjust to photo composition, while there are also motion-responsive 3D wallpapers and smarter photo shuffling. The Safari web browser is getting an edge-to-edge layout. Apple Music now has lyrics translation and assistance for pronouncing words. Apple Wallet is getting live updates for flight tracking, airport maps and luggage updates via the Find My app. You can also create a so-called digital ID for domestic travel using a passport. The Maps app gets understanding of preferred routes and a section for visited places. Apple is making substantial improvements to multitasking on iPads this year. A new windowing system gives users the ability to resize apps, freely place them around the screen, and have several windows open at once. Apps will reopen at the same size and position they were last left at, and Exposé provides a convenient overview of everything. In another nod to macOS, a new menu bar will be accessible with a swipe down from the top of the display (or by moving the mouse cursor there). Developers are able to customize the menu bar based on what works best for their app. Apple's Preview app is coming over to iPad, offering a dedicated option for viewing, editing, or annotating PDFs and images. Preview also supports AutoFill for quickly filling out forms. The Journal app is coming to iPad after exclusively being available on the iPhone until now. The Files app has an updated list view, resizable columns and collapsible folders. It also shares the same folder customization options that are coming to macOS like custom colors, icons and emoji. Users can now set a default app for opening file types or even specific files. Background Tasks make it easier to carry out intensive processes (like video exports) without losing progress if users need to multitask and switch apps. iPadOS 26 includes more flexible audio input options, letting users select different microphones for each app and making it more practical to record podcasts with Apple's tablets. Local Capture helps this further by saving a high-quality local backup of audio and video files from popular videoconferencing apps. The Apple Watch gets the Liquid Glass interface across many parts of the system. Widgets are now smarter and can appear based on routine and location. For instance, walking into a gym will trigger a workout widget. A new tool, called Workout Buddy, aims to help with coaching based on fitness history. A new gesture, a wrist flick, is present for dismissing calls or notifications. There's also smarter ambient noise interpretation to determine how loud the device should buzz when alerts come in. The Notes App will finally make its way to the Apple Watch for quick note jotting on the go. Control Center now supports third-party actions from apps. Refreshed look with refined dock, toolbars and sidebars that showcase Apple's Liquid Glass design user interface elements. The Games app is coming to the Mac with the same features available on iOS. Control Center and the Menu Bar are both now more customizable. Folders can be customized with different colors, emoji or symbols. The Mac gets the same Phone app as the iPad as well as the revamped features coming to the iPhone. Syncing with iPhone Live Activities, such as tracking your Uber Eats order from the desktop. Spotlight Search feature is getting a major upgrade, allowing users to more easily find files, folders, events, messages, apps and PDFs in one place. The Journal App is making its way to macOS, allowing users to log daily moments and sync entries across devices. Apple's new Liquid Glass design language comes to the TV screen, keeping the focus on your content even when accessing Control Center or fast-forwarding through a video. The Apple TV can be set to display all user profiles whenever it wakes from sleep, making it quick for people who live together to get to their own recommendations and content. Streaming app developers can now link logins to an Apple Account, simplifying the sign-in process whenever users set up a new Apple TV device. iPhones can double as microphones when using Apple Music's Sing karaoke mode. And if you've got a group together, people can queue up songs or react with emoji using their phones. Widgets are coming to visionOS, letting users place photos, calendars or other useful information wherever they'd like in their space. Widgets will remain fixed in place and reappear even after the Vision Pro headset is restarted. Apple is vastly improving the realism of its Persona avatars with full side profiles, enhanced complexion, accessories and more styles of glasses. Vision Pro users in the same room can now view spatial experiences together including movies, games and FaceTime calls. Spatial photos have increased realism in visionOS 26 thanks to a new generative AI algorithm that creates scenes with multiple perspectives. Sony Group Corp.'s PlayStation VR2 Sense controllers are fully supported with six-degree motion tracking, finger touch detection and vibration haptics. Apple is making the Vision Pro more enterprise-friendly with team device sharing and new software frameworks. You can now automatically unlock your iPhone while wearing a Vision Pro headset tied to your Apple Account. Incoming iPhone calls can now be answered directly from the Vision Pro. –BLOOMBERG
The Sun
21 hours ago
- The Sun
Govt ensures essential goods stay tax-free, safeguarding food security
KUALA LUMPUR: The government will continue to ensure essential goods like rice, cooking oil, vegetables, chicken and fish remain tax-free to safeguard the people's food security. Minister of Agriculture and Food Security Datuk Seri Mohamad Sabu said the implementation of revised Sales Tax (ST), effective July 1, only involves selected and premium goods, at a rate of 5 per cent or 10 per cent. According to him, the items in this category include truffle mushrooms, racing bicycles and king crab. 'This is a balanced approach where most people won't be affected, while those who are better off can contribute fairly to the country's development. 'Insya-Allah, the MADANI Government will continue to ensure policies that are formulated are centred on the principles of social justice and well-being of the people,' he posted on Facebook. Based on the Ministry of Finance's explanation, the zero per cent sales tax is maintained for daily essential goods, like chicken, beef, lamb, fish, shrimp, squid, vegetables, local fruits, rice, barley, oats, wheat, flour, canned sardines, sugar and salt. Also included are white bread, pasta, vermicelli, noodles, instant noodles, milk, cooking oil, medicine, medical devices, books, journals, newspapers and pet food. Zero per cent sales tax is also retained for basic construction materials like cement, bricks and sand as well as agricultural sector inputs such as fertilisers, pesticides, and agricultural and livestock machinery. The ministry added that the MADANI Government had taken measures to ensure the ST is not imposed on daily essential goods to avoid directly affecting the cost of living for the majority of Malaysians and to maintain a controlled inflation rate.
