Knicks must stop trending away from Karl-Anthony Towns

New York Times

23-04-2025

NEW YORK — The freeze-out, as most do, began in winter.
Karl-Anthony Towns did not attempt a shot during the fourth quarter of Monday's Game 2 loss to the Detroit Pistons, which evened the New York Knicks' first-round playoff series at one win apiece. He didn't score a point in the second half that night. But to better understand how the Knicks could drift so far away from their second-leading scorer during a postseason bout that came down to the final seconds, it's worth traveling back four months, when ice began to form around Towns.
Advertisement
In early December, the Knicks blew out a bottom-feeder. Towns had a gaudy stat line, as did every other New York starter. But the Charlotte Hornets, on an otherwise insignificant night, had pushed the Knicks' season to a new phase.
Cody Martin, a 6-foot-6 wing, defended Towns more than any other Hornet did. Opponents had placed perimeter players on the five-time All-Star — such as the Boston Celtics with Jrue Holiday or the Houston Rockets with Dillon Brooks — but for the first time since his October trade from Minnesota, a team without an elite defense was trying the strategy, one coaches have hurled at Towns for years.
Martin did not stop Towns, but the Knicks center changed his style, just as the Hornets hoped he would. Placing a smaller defender on Towns — a broad-shouldered behemoth capable of bruising Goliath without a slingshot — is a bet that the 7-footer will change his style, that Towns might get physical for a stretch or a quarter or a half but that he doesn't want to keep that energy for 48 minutes.
Wings can tread close to Towns, limiting the long-range attempts of a splashy 3-point shooter, without paying the price. And maybe, on the right day, they can goad the Knicks into less efficient 2-pointers.
On that night, Towns did not set many ball screens against the Hornets, in part because a big man could guard Josh Hart, who isn't a threat from beyond the 3-point arc, and roam into the lane
From then on, a trend emerged.
Later in the month, the Knicks played a couple of consecutive games against the hapless Washington Wizards.
The main assignment on Towns for both of them was a 6-foot-7 wing, Justin Champagnie. The result? Towns set fewer ball screens in each of those games than he had in any contest since the infamous, opening-night shellacking at the hands of the Celtics, according to Second Spectrum.
Advertisement
As teams manned Towns with wings more, Towns' habits changed. He didn't dominate the post enough to convince opponents to deviate. The Knicks' bread-and-butter, the action that was supposed to dominate the league this season, had been the Jalen Brunson-Towns pick-and-roll. The team strayed from it — and thus, strayed from Towns.
By the end of the season, the Knicks were 35-12 in games where big men were Towns' primary defender and 11-14 in games when perimeter players were his primary defender. Towns set 27.0 ball screens a game when bigs were primarily on him, according to Second Spectrum. He set just 15.9 when a guard or wing was his main guy.
The Pistons have been watching.
From the first possession of this series, veteran forward Tobias Harris has guarded Towns. A center, often Jalen Duren, takes Hart. And during these fights with the Pistons, what was once a blemish that only basketball geeks could brag about noticing has become obvious to anyone who could read Towns' shot total during Game 2's fourth quarter.
'He's getting touches. He's making the right play,' head coach Tom Thibodeau said. 'If he's getting double-teamed, I don't want him to shoot the ball over three people.'
In that case, the Knicks' job is to figure out how to get Towns shooting over just one person.
Towns attempted his last shot against the Pistons with 5:20 to go in the third quarter. Contrary to Thibodeau's statement, he played the entire fourth and touched the ball in the frontcourt only three times during the period, according to Second Spectrum. For perspective, Brunson had 15 front-court touches in the final period.
The Dallas Mavericks succeeded in tossing smalls onto Towns throughout last season's Western Conference finals. The LA Clippers disrupted him with perimeter players during the 2022 Play-In Tournament. So, how can the Knicks solve a problem that has plagued Towns for years?
Advertisement
It starts with getting him involved more in the offense — a process that falls most on three people: Thibodeau, Brunson and Towns himself.
Perimeter players, with Harris leading the way, have defended Towns for 82 percent of the Knicks' half-court possessions during Games 1 and 2, according to Second Spectrum. And yet, Towns isn't using his size advantage.
He hasn't ducked down low. Not once in this series has Towns muscled Harris, who he has four inches and more than 20 pounds on, to the block before catching the basketball. Instead, Harris wins the shoving match. All of Towns' post-ups in Game 2 began with his feet closer to the 3-point arc than the paint, a major no-no. If Towns received an entry pass with a just a toenail already near the restricted area, he could turn around for an easy bucket.
Instead, look at how Harris is winning the off-ball battle with him:
New York needs ways to attack the deep paint in the halfcourt. Brunson is best in the short mid-range. OG Anunoby will throttle to the hoop but doesn't facilitate from there. Mikal Bridges pulls up for jumpers before arriving at the rim. Drives are more difficult for Hart with Pistons waiting in the lane for him. Detroit's physicality has been persistent since the series began.
The Knicks don't create many 3s. Towns has put up only five and has made one all series (in games that a perimeter player was Towns' primary defender this season, he averaged 3.6 3-point attempts. When a big man was his primary, he averaged 5.3). But his size, if he chooses to use it, gives them a down-low weapon either to score or create.
The Pistons threw a curveball at Towns during Game 2. When Towns posted Harris up during the first game of the series, Duren would shade into the lane, stuck somewhat in no-man's land, not guarding his assignment or Towns just in case Towns bolted to the rim. No coincidence, Duren committed three three-second violations that night.
Advertisement
Come Game 2, the Pistons began to double-team Towns from the baseline.
On the rare occasions that he spun away from Duren, he appeared unbothered. Check out this second-quarter play, when Harris can't handle Towns alone as Towns twists to the middle, where Duren can't reach him:
Not only is Towns too strong for Harris; he also establishes solid positioning on this play, albeit after he catches the basketball. Harris can't stop him once he hits the paint.
But this isn't just a Towns issue.
The Knicks could prioritize his touches more. When Brunson missed time with an ankle injury this spring, they ran cross screens down low, actions where a teammate would screen Towns' man in the paint to get him open in the post.
Thibodeau could use him less as a spacer in crunch time.
He could urge Brunson and Towns to run more pick-and-rolls, as they did earlier in the season, when the offense hummed. Matchups aside, Towns doesn't set nearly as many ball screens for Brunson as he did earlier in the schedule.
Thibodeau could force the Pistons to make difficult decisions, too.
If Thibodeau were to replace Hart with Miles 'Deuce' McBride, even if the adjustment were just making McBride-for-Hart the first substitution of the game, the choice to guard Towns with a wing wouldn't be as intuitive. As constituted, it works because the Pistons can put their center on Hart or backup center Mitchell Robinson, who has played next to Towns during this series. Neither will hurt Detroit from deep. But place a center on McBride, Brunson, Bridges or Anunoby and prepare for open 3s aplenty.
The starters minus Hart, plus McBride barely played this season, only 160 possessions according to Cleaning the Glass, but annihilated opponents when they did, besting them by 43.7 points per 100 possessions. It was the top lineup in the NBA among the many units that played as many possessions as they did.
Advertisement
Of course, swapping Hart for McBride would not help the Knicks' rebounding struggles, which Thibodeau harped on after the Game 2 defeat.
And then there's Brunson, who took over fourth quarters all season — and did the same Monday.
The end of any close Knicks game is a declaration that this team is Brunson's. He is the Knicks' crunch-time engine. When games are within five points with five-or-less minutes to go, his usage is three times Towns'. In Game 2, Brunson took it to the extreme, and not just late.
The ball went into and mostly stayed in his hands. He ran 17 isolations against the Pistons, which would have tied his regular-season high, per Second Spectrum.
All the while, Towns remained a nonparticipant.
'It's very tough when there's definitely one ball,' Brunson said. 'We have a lot of great players on this team and definitely it's on my shoulders. … It's on me to make sure I set the table. So I'll go back, and I'll figure out what I need to do.'
Whatever the captain does, whatever Thibodeau changes, however Towns adjusts, they must end the freeze-out.
The Knicks' end-of-season struggles coincided with teams sticking wings onto Towns. During Towns' first 43 games played, a perimeter player was his primary defender only 10 times. But over his final 29 regular-season games, it happened more often than not: 15 times. New York went 6-9 in those games.
Not all of those defeats came to elite defenses. In late March, Towns scored an inefficient 24 points during a loss to the Hornets. A 6-foot-7 forward, Miles Bridges, followed him more than anyone else.
This problem is not going anywhere.
On paper, Harris shouldn't be able to guard Towns, but he will continue to as long as he wrestles with such verve — and as long as Towns allows it. If the Knicks skirt by Detroit, Boston will be no easier, whether it's Holiday or Jayson Tatum on Towns.
Towns has to figure this out, as do Thibodeau and Brunson. If the Knicks can't optimize their two stars, they can't reach their potential.