Crown calls man accused of driving 196 km/h while impaired ‘Morally bankrupt'
Jefferson Dance, 47, is pictured outside the courthouse in Barrie, Ont., on Wed., May 28, 2025. (CTV News / Mike Arsalides)
Closing arguments were heard inside a Barrie, Ont. courtroom Wednesday in the trial of a Wasaga Beach man accused of driving nearly four times the legal limit at about 200 kilometres an hour prior to the deadly crash three years ago in Wasaga Beach.
Jefferson Dance, 47, is on trial charged with dangerous and impaired driving causing the death of Jim Lynne, 62, whom the court heard was delivering pizzas at the time his Nissan Juke was crashed into from behind by a grey Tesla Model Y along Mosley Street just before midnight April 9, 2022.
Jefferson Dance
Jefferson Dance, 47, is on trial charged with dangerous and impaired driving causing death in the crash April 9, 2022, along Mosley Street in Wasaga Beach. Jim Lynne, 62, died of his injuries in the crash. (Court Exhibit)
The Crown in delivering its closing arguments called Dance 'morally bankrupt' for getting behind the wheel with about four times the legal limit of alcohol in his system then driving his Tesla up to 196 km/h before crashing into the car driven by Lynne. The crash killed Lynne instantly, the court heard.
Crown Attorney Indy Kandola told the court Dance turned Lynne's Nissan Juke 'into a soda can, crushing it.'
The court was shown surveillance video inside a nearby bar where Dance and a friend shared drinks while watching a hockey game that night. They were in the bar for more than four hours.
Tesla
Jefferson Dance, 47, is accused of speeding and crashing his grey Model Y Tesla second prior to midnight April 9, 2022, when the car driven by Jim Lynne was hit from behind along Mosley Street. (Court Exhibit)
'He got in after drinking alcohol for hours and as soon as he got into his Tesla he started flying,' said the Crown.
The court heard evidence from police, a vehicle believed to be Dance's Tesla was seen travelling 148km/h along Mosley Street seconds before the crash happened. The defence said the Crown could not prove the vehicle in question belonged to Dance.
Related Articles:
The court heard Dance, and his friend had gone out to dinner that night in Thornbury where they shared wo bottles of wine then went to the bar in Wasaga Beach about two kilometres from the crash site.
The crash happened minutes after Dance and his friend were seen leaving the bar.
'He literally had the pedal to the metal,' said Kandola, 'Literally flooring it up until two seconds before the crash.'
He said the vehicle driven by Dance hit the Nissan driven by Lynne from behind and sent it spinning before the Nissan landed on its roof. Lynn was travelling the speed limit, the Crown said, but looked stationary in comparison to the Tesla, which recorded the crash on several of its on-board cameras.
There were no 'mechanical defects,' said the Crown. 'The speed was outrageous.'
Jefferson Dance
Jefferson Dance, 47, is on trial charged with dangerous and impaired driving causing death in the crash April 9, 2022, along Mosley Street in Wasaga Beach. Jim Lynne, 62, died of his injuries in the crash. (Court Exhibit)
The defence for the first time in trial, Wednesday, all but conceded Dance was behind the wheel that night, however, his lawyer Robert Geurts told the court the case against Dance had several problems.
'This entire case has been misunderstood from the very beginning,' said the experienced defence lawyer.
The defence called witness testimony in some instances absurd. Geurts alleged officers and witnesses 'accommodated' their evidence that was then 'tainted' because of pressures and a perceived rush to judgement.
Geurts also took aim at the crash reconstructionist from the OPP, who was qualified as an expert witness in collision reconstruction. Geurts called the report findings wrong.
The defence did not call any evidence in trial but suggested to the OPP crash reconstructionist there may have been a defect in the Tesla that caused it to speed up on its own. Data had been provided by Tesla to police, of the final five seconds prior to the crash, from the vehicle's Airbag Control Module.
Tesla
Jefferson Dance, 47, is on trial charged with dangerous and impaired driving causing death in the crash April 9, 2022, along Mosley Street in Wasaga Beach. Jim Lynne, 62, died of his injuries in the crash. (Court Exhibit)
The defence alleged the vehicle should have decelerated without pressure applied to the pedal, but it accelerated instead.
The defence said it did not dispute toxicology results based on blood drawn from Dance in hospital following the crash which showed Dance had between three and a half to four times the legal limit of alcohol in his blood.
'You cannot come to the conclusion he was the most blameworthy and put the pedal to the metal' as the Crown suggested, he said.
Justice Mark Edwards is scheduled to deliver his judgement next Tuesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
9 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Jobs Minister presses Canada Post, union to reach a deal
Jobs Minister Patty Hajdu is calling on Canada Post and the union representing 55,000 postal workers to return to the bargaining table and hash out terms for binding arbitration. In a social media statement Wednesday, the minister also asked the Crown corporation and the Canadian Union of Postal Workers to continue to work toward a deal outside of that process. She says arbitration is 'not the preferred path,' but suggested the stage would be set for an imposed settlement if the two sides could not find common ground themselves. 'Canadians expect the parties to resolve this dispute one way or another. To do that they must meet and pursue these two paths with urgency,' Hajdu said on X, formerly known as Twitter. Federal mediators are standing by to help, she added. Canada Post asks Jobs Minister Patty Hajdu to force union vote on 'final offers' Canada Post workers rally in 13 cities to raise awareness of labour dispute On Friday, Canada Post asked the minister to force a union vote on its 'final offers,' while the union requested binding arbitration, which the employer rejected. The union said Tuesday that a forced vote on a new contract would amount to a 'government attack on our rights to free collective bargaining.' It also said it had been given a Wednesday deadline to respond to the latest offers, which include an end to compulsory overtime and a signing bonus of up to $1,000, among other concessions. But the employer stuck to its proposal for a 14 per cent cumulative wage hike over four years, a 'dynamic routing' pilot that could see mail carriers' routes change daily in response to parcel volume, and part-time staff on weekend shifts – a major sticking point in the talks. Canada Post has warned that arbitration would be 'long and complicated' and would likely last more than a year, adding to its significant financial challenges. The Crown corporation said last week it logged nearly $1.3-billion in operating losses last year, raising further questions about its business model as letter volumes plunge and fears of a second disruption in six months persist. The union again adopted a legal strike position starting May 23, but it has opted instead to ban members from working overtime while negotiations continued. The 32-day work stoppage in November and December halted millions of letters and packages in the peak shipping season ahead of the winter holidays last year. Shippers fled Canada Post in droves when workers went on strike Nov. 15. Rather than be caught flat-footed a second time, plenty of e-commerce companies have played it safe by booking with other couriers. Canada Post says parcel volumes are down 65 per cent from the same time last year due to uncertainty over the contract negotiations.
Globe and Mail
9 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Anime convention in Toronto brings together comics fans and cosplayers
Costume-clad Skylar Spalla stood on the curb at the Toronto Congress Centre on a recent weekend, watching hundreds of fellow cosplayers pass by. His twin brother flitted around him, making sure Spalla's massive suit of armour, which they strapped on using zip ties, held together. Every few minutes, a person approached to ask for a photo with him, from muscle-bound warriors to little kids with their parents. The art student's costume, a recreation of the character Havel from the video game Dark Souls 3, was made of little more than papier mâché, paint and pop tabs. It took him countless hours to make, and showing it at Anime North, an annual fan-run convention celebrating anime, manga and video games, he said, brings him a great sense of pride. Anime North is not only Toronto's biggest anime convention – it is also a fashion show where everyone is a star. Outside of the convention buildings, people gathered in the shade or on the grass near the food trucks to take photos and make friends. One was dressed like Star Wars' Kylo Ren, amplifying their voice with a speaker. Another was costumed as A.B.A., the shy homunculus from the game Guilty Gear with her demon-axe partner Paracelsus (made out of pool noodles and cardboard). One man came to Anime North with a Furby head fashioned with remote-controlled eyes and mouth. For many cosplayers, the annual convention provides a chance to show off their costuming handiwork, and make others happy by bringing beloved characters to life. 'Coming to a convention like this gives me the opportunity to share in the joy that this brings me with so many other people,' said Elijah Kamaras-Garland, a photographer and cosplayer from Toronto who dressed in multiple costumes over the convention weekend as characters from the video game Star Fox. He was accompanied by a friend cosplaying as King K Rool, the malevolent crocodile from the video game Donkey Kong. That costume, made of foam mats, 'had to be built around him by a couple of his friends,' Kamaras-Garland said, because it was so large. Since the late 1980s, Japanese comics (or manga) and cartoons (also known as anime) have found an audience outside of their home country. That popularity has exploded over the past decade, as major television channels such as YTV and streaming services have offered anime shows in English for international audiences. This year's convention (attended by an estimated 36,000 visitors) hosted a variety of panels and workshops where attendees could learn about Japanese culture or their favourite fan pursuit, including a Japanese tea ceremony demonstration, a talk about the philosophy of the series Attack on Titan, a comedic live reading of poorly-written fan fiction and a discussion of accommodating cosplay for people with chronic illnesses. Huge halls were dedicated to artists selling their work. Many vendors were Canadians who said that events like Anime North offer exposure and revenue that keeps small businesses afloat. 'It's a great opportunity to be your own boss, and be able to make a living off of something you actually like' said Vincent Leclerc, an assistant of Savage Mojo, a French-Canadian artist, illustrator and animator who specializes in fan art of fantastical dinosaurs. Conventions like Anime North also provide a real-life space for people to meet fellow hobbyists. While anime fandoms have flourished in online spaces including Reddit and Tumblr, it can be difficult to connect in person with others who share the same interests in shows or games. That community is part of why so many people return to Anime North. It was Maxx Romphf's second time at the convention. 'I've seen every anime you can think of [and] video games,' said the Monster High series cosplayer. 'It's just really nice.' At the end of the convention, visitors headed home in their bright, colourful outfits, many to ready themselves for work the next day. Like the day after Halloween, the costumes go back in the closet and it's back to business as usual. But judging from the smiles on attendees' faces, it was an unforgettable weekend for them.
CBC
11 minutes ago
- CBC
Stanley Cup final: Follow our live coverage before Edmonton Oilers vs. Florida Panthers
Social Sharing It all comes down to this. The Edmonton Oilers and Florida Panthers clash in Game 1 of the Stanley Cup final at Rogers Place in Edmonton. Watch our live show starting at 4:30 p.m. MT and follow along here as we bring you all the colour from downtown as well as some of the interesting stories we've covered leading up to the game. Live pregame from the Edmonton arena and fan zone Live in 5 hours 11:50 a.m. — Oilers and Panthers: a high-stakes rematch We're just hours away from puck drop for Game 1 of the Stanley Cup final between the Edmonton Oilers and the Florida Panthers. It's a rare Stanley Cup rematch, which hasn't happened since 2009. In 2008, the Detroit Red Wings defeated the Pittsburgh Penguins to win the Cup, with the Pens exacting revenge the following year. The Oilers are hoping for a similar scenario. They are also hoping to become the first Canadian team to win the Cup since 1993. The Oilers' road to the final had them cruising past the Los Angeles Kings, Vegas Golden Knights and Dallas Stars to earn their chance to compete for Lord Stanley's Cup. The Panthers bested the Tampa Lightning, Toronto Maple Leafs and Carolina Hurricanes to get their spot in the final. Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl have been leading the way offensively for Edmonton, and are No.1 and No.2, respectively, in points in this postseason. While McDavid has produced 26 points, nobody has lit the lamp more in the playoffs than Panthers forward Sam Bennett, with 10 goals. In goal, it'll be Sergei Bobrovsky vs. Stuart Skinner for the second year in a row. Bobrovsky has an even better save percentage this playoffs than he did last year, but Skinner has been spectacular after some early struggles that saw him benched in favour of Calvin Pickard. While the two franchises are set for a rematch, there are some new faces in the mix who are making an impact. Jake Walman has helped solidify things for the Oilers' blue line, while depth forwards Trent Frederic, Vasily Podkolzin and Kasperi Kapanen have been chipping in offensively. Florida, meanwhile, has made two big additions: Seth Jones and Brad Marchand. And both have made their mark on this postseason.
