Tense meeting as Carney rejects Trump's call for Canada to join US
'Having met with the owners of Canada over the course of the campaign in the last several months, it's not for sale. It won't be for sale, ever.'
Trump then replied: 'Never say never.'
Carney won the Canadian election of April 28 on a pledge to stand up to Trump, warning that ties between the North American neighbours could never be the same.
Trump has sparked a major trade war with Canada with his tariffs while repeatedly making extraordinary calls for the key Nato ally and major trading partner to become part of the United States.
Despite that, the two leaders began their meeting with warm words towards each other.
Twice-elected Trump hailed Carney, whose Liberal Party surged from behind to win the election, for 'one of the greatest comebacks in the history of politics, maybe even greater than mine'.
But while they expressed a willingness to work towards a trade deal to end the tariffs, it became clear that common ground would be hard to find.
'Little blow-up'
Carney at points gripped his hands tightly together and his knee jiggled while Trump spoke.
'No. It's just the way it is,' Trump said when asked if there was anything Carney could say in the meeting that would persuade him to drop car tariffs in particular.
And when the US President pressed his claim that Canadians might one day want to join the United States, Carney raised his hand and pushed back.
'Respectfully, Canadians' view on this is not going to change on the 51st state,' said Carney.
A visibly tense Trump then referenced his blazing Oval Office row with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in February – if only to insist that there would be no repeat.
'We had another little blow-up with somebody else, that was much different – this is a very friendly conversation,' Trump said.
Carney gave a thumbs up to reporters as he left the White House after just over two hours.
The meeting was highly anticipated after a Canadian election during which Carney vowed that the United States would never 'own us'.
Carney has since vowed to remake Nato member Canada's ties with the United States in perhaps its biggest political and economic shift since World War II.
Trump has slapped general tariffs of 25% on Canada and Mexico and sector-specific levies on autos, some of which have been suspended pending negotiations. He has imposed similar duties on steel and aluminium.
'Important moment'
The US President inserted himself into Canada's election early on by calling on Canada to avoid tariffs by becoming the 'cherished 51st state'.
Pierre Poilievre's Conservative Party had been on track to win the vote but Trump's attacks, combined with the departure of unpopular premier Justin Trudeau, transformed the race.
Carney, who replaced Trudeau as Prime Minister in March, convinced voters that his experience managing economic crises made him the ideal candidate to defy Trump.
The political newcomer previously served as governor of the Bank of Canada and the Bank of England, and in the latter post he played a key role reassuring markets after the 2016 Brexit vote.
Carney is known for weighing his words carefully but still faced a challenge dealing with the confrontational Trump on the US President's home turf.
'This is a very important moment for him, since he insisted during the campaign that he could take on Mr Trump,' Genevieve Tellier, a political scientist at the University of Ottawa, told AFP.
One point in Carney's favour is that he is not Trudeau, the slick former Prime Minister whom Trump famously loathed and belittled as 'governor' of Canada, she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Trump taps Palantir to compile data on Americans
The Trump administration has expanded Palantir's work with the government, spreading the company's technology - which could easily merge data on Americans - throughout agencies. In March, President Donald Trump signed an executive order calling for the federal Government to share data across agencies, raising questions over whether he might
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
ASB Business Survey: The Impact Of Trump's Tariffs, According To Kiwi Businesses
Research released today by ASB, supported by Talbot Mills Research, shows Kiwi businesses see US tariffs as more impactful than Covid-19 or the Global Financial Crisis. More than 300 business leaders, including CEOs and founders, contributed to the study, giving their insights on President Trump's recently announced trade policies. Two-thirds (67%) of businesses are concerned about the impact of proposed US tariffs in the next 12 months, with nearly 80% of exporters concerned Kiwi business leaders believe Trump's tariffs will have a more severe global impact than Covid-19 and the GFC Meat, dairy and wine are seen as the most vulnerable within Food and Fibre sector, while businesses predict wool and seafood would fare better Nearly one-quarter (24%) of Kiwi businesses see at least some opportunity in the tariffs More than one-third (39%) of respondents listed support of banks as critical to navigating the current environment Tariffs: a threat and an opportunity for Kiwi businesses ASB's Executive General Manager Business Banking Rebecca James says: 'We're seeing sustained market volatility with the ever-changing political decisions around tariffs, which naturally creates a heightened sense of uncertainty for businesses. It's clear businesses view any proposed US tariffs as troubling, but it's pleasing that nearly a quarter of respondents see opportunity in tariffs too. New Zealand has a reputation on the world stage for ingenuity and a can-do attitude, and we want businesses to know there are things they can do to future-proof and manage risks in turbulent times.' President Trump first announced tariffs in April as part of the 'America First' trade policy, aimed at protecting US industries and addressing the trade deficit. The tariffs are set at 10% for most countries, including New Zealand, with China a notable outlier where a larger tariff has been applied to Chinese origin goods. Additional proposed tariffs higher than the 10% baseline were paused for a 90-day period and will be reviewed in July. Businesses are split on how long potential disruption could last. A slight majority (51%) of Kiwi businesses are optimistic that the economy will recover quickly, while 38% predict a prolonged economic downturn for the country and the remainder were unsure. Taking action key to growth 14% of those surveyed view US tariffs purely as an opportunity, while 10% see them as both a potential risk and an opportunity. Ten percent of businesses and 14% of exporters have already taken action to reduce the negative impacts of tariffs including raising prices, shifting markets or cutting costs. Just under one-third (30%) believe they can make up losses through new customers or cost savings; 25% from operational efficiencies, and 22% from other revenue streams. 22% are unsure, with uncertainty highest among small businesses. 'The current market volatility and geopolitical tension may be our 'new normal', but we've been in positions of global uncertainty before and the research shows Kiwi businesses are already thinking about actions they can take to make their business more resilient and generate returns.' Ms James encourages businesses to stay connected to industry partners, trade advocacy groups and their banks to share knowledge and ideas when it comes to growth and scale. 'Business customers are relying on us more than ever to navigate the current environment, and we're seeing this through an increase in trade finance and a rise in currency hedging enquiries. Our advice is to start exploring options now. We're seeing customers adapting their business strategy in all sorts of ways, so solutions for your business might look like assessing AI to improve workflow, adjusting your supply chain, selling down stock before new inventory orders, building new trade relationships or exploring untapped markets.' Businesses shifting their focus to closer to home More than three-quarters of Kiwi exporters expect the cost of doing business with the US to increase by 10% or more in the next year. Concern is higher among exporters (78%) and increases with business size, with worry growing to 88% among 100+ staff businesses). The potential impacts of tariffs which were of the most concern to businesses include slowing economic growth (39%), increased operating costs (32%) and supply chain disruptions (28%). Nearly one-quarter of businesses are worried about consumer backlash due to price inflation (24%), along with 23% who see a China-US Trade war as unsettling for business. Some of the most explored markets by businesses are China (51%), Australia (37%), European Union (28%) and Southeast Asia (25%). 'The research shows a pendulum swing when it comes to trading partners, with businesses redirecting their attention to our close neighbours. Location seems to be king, with our customers prioritising relationships much closer to home,' says Ms James. 'We're also seeing exporters maintaining high standards and doubling down on premium products to give us an edge on the global stage, even where it costs more for consumers.' The role of banks as a critical support function Businesses see Government lobbying as the most critical tool in helping to reduce the impact of tariffs, with banks the next most important. More than one-third (39%) of respondents listed support of banks as critical, specifically working capital support (31%), risk advice (26%) and trade finance (24%). 'ASB has provided $4.6 billion dollars to Kiwi businesses over the past five years including considerable support to companies looking to expand and navigate opportunities abroad. We have seen increased use of trade finance products, aided by trade credit insurance, enabling businesses to sustainably leverage balance sheets while derisking payment default. We encourage companies doing business overseas to speak with their banker and engage with a trade specialist to ensure your business is in the strongest position," says Ms James. ASB Bank Helping you get one step ahead. In 1847, ASB opened as the Auckland Savings Bank with the pledge: 'to serve the community; to grow and to help Kiwis grow'. And that is very much what ASB is about today. ASB is a leading provider of integrated financial services in New Zealand including retail, business and rural banking, funds management and insurance. ASB strives to consistently provide its customers with outstanding service and innovative financial solutions. They're dedicated to providing simple financial products that allow their customers to bank with them how and when they want. We all have our own ways to measure progress, and our own stories about the things that matter to us. Whatever way you choose to measure progress, and whatever your goals, ASB is there to help you get one step ahead. Contact ASB Bank
Otago Daily Times
6 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
World closing down — when it reopens is anyone's guess
Los Angeles Airport. Straws in the wind: recently I ran across a post by the chief executive of a nationwide professional association in Canada. People like him are used to hopping across the United States border for various meetings several times a month, but he was remarking on what people had been talking about at the association's recent annual conference in a big Canadian city. His post said "consensus here is that it's risky to travel to [US flag emoji] but if you have to go, bring a burner phone". "Have a plan in case you get detained. Watch what you say. Who you meet." And I thought "yeah, me too". I am a journalist so I will still go to the US if I absolutely have to, but not for pleasure, not for paid lectures and things, and yes please on the burner phone. Back when I started out in this trade half the world was off limits, especially for freelance journalists. The Cold War reached a second peak in the early '80s and you couldn't go to the Soviet Union unless you had a big media organisation negotiating for you. Even then it took months for a visa, and you were followed everywhere. The communist-ruled "satellite" countries in Eastern Europe were a little easier, and China was letting tourists in to some parts of the country — but not stray journalists. Albania, North Korea and Iran were completely closed, and most of Southeast Asia and much of Central and South America were ruled by military dictators who ran death squads. Then non-violent democratic revolutions began all over the Third World, the communist regimes of Eastern Europe collapsed, and the old Soviet Union itself followed suit. Soon almost the whole world opened up. It was a nice ride while it lasted but then the whole process went into reverse. You won't feel the effects much if you travel as a tourist or even do business abroad, but journalists — including foreign journalists — are the canaries in the coalmine on this and I'm certainly feeling the change. The number of countries I won't go to any more is growing every year. It started, weirdly enough, with Turkey, a place I thought I knew well. I've lived there, I speak the language — or at least I used to — and I even thought President Recep Tayyip Erdogan was a welcome change from a militantly secular government that ignored the rights of the pious half of the population. Then the editor of the newspaper that ran this column in Turkey was jailed, the publisher went into exile and the new regime turned the paper into a government propaganda outlet. I know there's a fat file on me somewhere in Ankara and I've seen the inside of a Turkish jail (as a visitor), so I don't go there any more. Twenty years now. Next was Russia, where I had been practically commuting in the early '90s. Vladimir Putin was elected in 1999 and it was still all right for a while, but by 2005 he was killing opposition leaders and I started reporting from afar. Note, by the way, these changes were happening after more or less free elections — although they tended to be the last fair elections. Then came a round of non-violent pro-democracy uprisings in the Middle East, most of them drowned in blood. That set off a whole cluster of civil wars, and the whole region became very hard to work in. It still is. Next was China, where they arrested, tried and jailed two random Canadian businessmen in 2018, really as hostages to exchange for a Chinese citizen in Canada whom they wanted back. It wasn't aimed specifically at journalists and the victims were freed after 1000 days in prison, but I and many other people took it as a signal to do your Chinese business from afar. However, I never thought that I would be adding the US to the list. Even during Donald Trump's first term foreign journalists were no more at risk of arbitrary imprisonment than the average US citizen, and nobody followed you around or listened to your phone calls. Well, no more than they listen to everybody else's calls. Now, quite suddenly, the US has become just another great power where foreigners watch what they say, try to minimise contacts with official bodies, or just stay away. The thought even occurs that, as in so many other cases, there will still be elections but we will know the outcome in advance. It sounds almost hysterical to talk like this and many non-journalist travellers won't even notice it, but the world is closing down again. I have no idea if or when it will reopen. • Gwynne Dyer is an independent London journalist.
