
House endorses Ayotte's bail reform bill
Mar. 13—The sweeping bail reform bill sought by Gov. Kelly Ayotte cleared its first major legislative hurdle Thursday.
The House of Representatives voted 205-170 to approve the measure after it rejected attempts by Democratic critics to water it down.
"Today the House brought us one step closer to shutting the revolving door for violent criminals," Ayotte said in a statement after the vote.
The House took four votes on the measure, none by a recorded roll call, however. All four were by division under which the votes of individual legislators were not identified.
The proportions of the vote roughly matched the ratio of Democrats and Republicans in the chamber Thursday.
The House debated the measure as many law-enforcement professionals supporting the cause sat in the gallery.
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety Committee Chairman Terry Roy, R-Deerfield, said last year lawmakers made changes to a 2018 bail reform law, but Ayotte and GOP legislative leaders wanted to go further.
"The bill last year was a good bill; it wasn't a Republican bill," Roy said. "We don't have to compromise; it is now a Republican majority, and we are going to pass a Republican bail bill. We don't have to be ashamed of that."
The most significant change would lower the standard of proof that prosecutors need to convince a judge that someone accused of a violent crime is dangerous enough to be held without bail.
The current standard is "clear and convincing evidence" while this year's bill, which has Ayotte's backing, would lower it to "probable cause."
Ayotte said higher standards have proven difficult for prosecutors to achieve in court.
"You are really requiring them to hold a mini-trial to reach that kind of standard, which isn't fair," said Ayotte, a former attorney general.
"Probable cause is a recognized standard that is used when someone in law enforcement seeks a warrant to search someone's private property. It is known and well understood in the criminal justice system."
Critics: violent crime down
Rep. Buzz Scherr, D-Portsmouth, was one of the chief architects of the 2018 law as an appellate law expert and professor at the University of New Hampshire School of Law.
Since then, Scherr said, the number of serious violent and property crimes has dropped from 19,000 in 2017 to just over 13,000 in 2024.
"Despite the rhetoric, the bail reform law is working," Scherr said. "We don't need to fix bail reform."
House Majority Leader Jason Osborne, R-Auburn, said during her campaign for governor, Ayotte had made the issue a top priority, and the entire GOP leadership team backed that decision.
"Upholding law and order and finishing our work to fix New Hampshire's bail system were a key part of the mandate which voters handed us when they sent a Republican trifecta to represent them in Concord," Osborne said.
Court administrators have maintained the bill could increase taxpayer costs since it will likely lead to detaining more accused offenders in county jails while awaiting trials.
Ayotte said the correctional system "has the capacity" to jail more offenders if that's necessary.
"Twenty-five to 30 percent of all people charged with crimes have their charges dismissed or are found not guilty," Scherr said.
"We will be jailing pre-trial people who have not been found guilty and some of whom will never be found guilty."
The legislation also would do away with three magistrates whose positions were created as part of a 2024 bail reform law.
These magistrates are charged with conducting initial bail matters on nights or weekends when full-time judges are not working.
Court officials said the three magistrates were named to five-year terms, and it would be appropriate for any change in law to phase them out of that judicial post over time.
+++
What's Next: The bill now heads to the State Senate.
Prospects: Excellent. Senate Republican leaders have already endorsed the measure.
klandrigan@unionleader.com
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Arnold Schwarzenegger Mocks Politicians for Being Surprised Voters Are ‘Using Our Middle Finger' With Protests
As protests continue over ICE raids in Los Angeles and more, Arnold Schwarzenegger doesn't think politicians should be surprised. According to the former California governor, pushback is the only logical outcome, given their actions. Schwarzenegger stopped by 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' on Wednesday night in support of the new season of his show 'FUBAR' on Netflix, but before anything else, he and the ABC host got into politics. Looking back on Schwarzenegger's time as governor, Kimmel joked 'Remember when you were the governor and everything was pretty good? Everything was — everybody seemed pretty happy back then, huh?' Schwarzenegger retorted that even now, people are happy around him, just because of who he is. But, speaking seriously, he turned his attention to the protests in Los Angeles, saying they wouldn't even be happening if politicians just actually worked on solving issues. 'For decades, almost four decades, we have had a problem where they talked about immigration reform, comprehensive immigration reform,' Schwarzenegger said. 'But the Democrats and the Republicans, both of the parties, have no interest in solving this problem, because they use that to raise money.' 'And so what they do is they just keep pointing the finger at each other, and then they're surprised if all of a sudden we are using our middle finger on them, right?' he continued. The actor also lamented that the severity and reach of the protests is being exaggerated by both media and the Trump administration. 'They make it out to like it is a war zone, the whole Los Angeles, the whole city or the county,' Schwarzenegger said. 'And the fact of the matter is, maybe 0.001% of the area of Los Angeles has problems, and there's a protest.' 'And so I think that this is important for people to know, because I don't want all of a sudden, tourism to suffer in Los Angeles, because what they see on television,' Schwarzenegger continued, with Kimmel agreeing. 'Because the media sometimes shows it as if the whole Los Angeles is a big war zone, which isn't really the case.' You can watch Arnold Schwarzenegger's full appearance on 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' in the video above. The post Arnold Schwarzenegger Mocks Politicians for Being Surprised Voters Are 'Using Our Middle Finger' With Protests | Video appeared first on TheWrap.
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Live updates: Pritzker testifies before Congress on Illinois sanctuary laws
The Brief Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker is testifying Thursday morning in front of a House committee about the state's sanctuary laws. Pritzker has said some GOP committee members want to question him "for a dog-and-pony show." The hearing could serve as another opportunity for Pritzker to position himself as a top contender in the Democratic Party. WASHINGTON, D.C. - Gov. JB Pritzker is set to testify before a U.S. House committee on Thursday morning about the state's "sanctuary" laws aimed at limiting local law enforcement cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. Pritzker, along with fellow Democratic governors Tim Walz of Minnesota and Kathy Hochul of New York, appeared in front of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. The entire hearing is being streamed live in the media player at the top of this story. 9:34 a.m. - Pritzker addresses the busloads of migrants that Gov. Greg Abbott of Texas sent to Chicago starting in August 2022. "Illinois chose a different path. Faced with a humanitarian crisis, our state made sure children and families did not go hungry or freeze to death," Pritzker said. 9:30 a.m. - Pritzker begins opening remarks: "I have seen firsthand how states have had to shoulder the consequences of a broken immigration system. I'm proud of how we've and compassionate immigration policies I believe are vital." Pritzker then recounted his family history, the arrival of his great-grandfather escaping pogroms and coming to Chicago. It feels like Pritzker might utilize this moment to introduce himself to a national audience who might not be familiar with him. 9:24 a.m. - Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi (D-Ill.), similar to his role in the Brandon Johnson hearing, hyped up Pritzker's investments and leadership in Illinois. 9:21 a.m. - During Lynch's opening remarks, Florida Rep. Byron Donalds, who is running for Governor there, walks out and puts his finger to his head, mouthing the word "crazy." The political context of these hearings is inescapable: Chairman Comer is running as a Republican for Governor of Kentucky. Donald is running in Florida. Pritzker and Walz may be running for president. There will be fundraising pitches based upon the content today. 9:15 a.m. - Rep. Stephen Lynch (D-Mass.) follows Chairman Comer, condemning the Trump administration's mass deportation policies. Lynch used his opening remarks to tie the hearing to the "militarization of American cities" under Trump and the administration's deportation of young U.S. citizens with undocumented parents. 9:07 a.m. - Hearing begins as House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer opens the meeting with opening statements on "dangerous sanctuary policies." "Let me clear, sanctuary policies don't protect Americans. They protect criminal illegals," Comer said. 8:56 a.m. - Pritzker has entered the building. 8:50 a.m. - Members of the Illinois House Freedom Caucus are in attendance for Pritzker's remarks. 8:40 a.m. 8:25 a.m. - Pritzker's office released his planned remarks hours ahead of the hearing. Among his talking points, Pritzker highlighted how Illinois mobilized quickly to offer shelter, food and services to over 50,000 migrants sent from the southern border without warning. Pritzker blamed both parties in Congress and the federal government for their failure to act. He also said that Illinois cooperates with federal authorities on criminal matters but won't misuse state resources for immigration enforcement that doesn't serve public safety. 8:12 a.m. - We are less than an hour away from the opening gavel. Pritzker, Walz and Hochul are expected to kick off the hearing with planned opening remarks. FOX 32's Paris Schutz laid out what he expects to hear from Pritzker's testimony. Hours ahead of the hearing, Pritzker released his planned opening remarks, which touched on how Illinois is handling the influx of immigrants and prioritizing public safety. Read his full remarks here. What we know The governor has said he believes some GOP members want to question him "for a dog-and-pony show" and who "simply want to grandstand in front of the cameras." He added, "I'm going there in a serious matter to give them my views about how we're managing through a problem that's been created for the state by the federal government." In a statement, Committee Chairman James Comer (R-Kentucky) said, "The governors of these states must explain why they are prioritizing the protection of criminal illegal aliens over the safety of U.S. citizens, and they must be held accountable." Back in March, the same committee hosted Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson, along with the mayors of Boston, Denver, and New York, to testify about the city's sanctuary policies. The national spotlight could also serve as a chance for Pritzker to further cement his status as a top potential contender for the Democratic nomination for president in 2028. The 60-year-old has not yet said if he'll run for re-election to the governorship in 2026. Pritzker has been garnering national headlines from calling out "do nothing Democrats" during a speech in New Hampshire, a key primary state, to appearing on late night talk shows. The governor, who is worth $3.7 billion per Forbes, is seen as a top contender for his party's nomination in 2028. He boasts a long list of progressive accomplishments in Illinois since he first took office in 2019, including codifying abortion rights, banning assault weapons, a big infrastructure funding plan, the legalization of recreational marijuana, and stabilizing the state's notoriously shaky finances. Dig deeper In 2017, Illinois enacted the TRUST Act under Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner. The law bans local police from complying with federal requests to detain or arrest a person in the country illegally, unless ordered by a judge. Local law enforcement also cannot stop, search, or arrest anyone based solely on their immigration or citizenship status. In 2021, the state legislature passed laws expanding protections for immigrants in Illinois. The updated laws required local officials to end partnerships with ICE to detain immigrants. Lawmakers also prohibited officials from inquiring about the citizenship or immigration status of an individual in custody, unless they're presented with a federal criminal warrant. Among other measures, the state legislature also required state and local law enforcement agencies to report requests from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. Despite the moves to protect migrants from potential arrests and deportations, Republicans have criticized the policies. U.S. Rep. Mary Miller, a Republican who represents much of the rural cental parts of the state, called on local sheriffs earlier this year to defy the state's sanctuary laws. She said such policies have turned Illinois into a "cesspool of crime and drugs."
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Walz, Hochul, Pritzker face off with Congress as Newsom battles Trump
Democratic "sanctuary governors" will face a barrage of tough questions at a highly anticipated congressional hearing Thursday morning, as California Gov. Gavin Newsom and President Donald Trump continue to throw jabs over immigration policy. Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul and Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker will testify before the House Oversight Committee and sources tell Fox that Los Angeles riots over Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids and Newsom's battle with Trump will likely be prominent topics of discussion. Gop Leadership Unleashes Fury On Dem Governor Ahead Of Blockbuster Congressional Hearing Fox News Digital obtained opening remarks to be delivered by Oversight Chairman James Comer, R-Ky., which will set the tone for the fiery hearing. "These Governors handcuff law enforcement from doing their jobs, harbor predators, and call it 'compassion,'" Comer's opening remarks explain. "It is NOT compassion, and it is costing lives, hurting Americans, and draining taxpayer money. Congress must consider whether to defund every single penny of federal dollars going to cities and states that prioritize criminal aliens over the American people." Gavin Newsom Mocked For Tech Issues During Anti-trump Address To Californians: 'Absolute Fail' Read On The Fox News App "Americans want a return to common sense. The Trump Administration and this Republican Congress aims to restore our safety and sovereignty. It is past time for these governors to put Americans first." All three Democratic governors testifying at the hearing sided with Newsom in a statement Sunday addressing Trump's use of the National Guard to dispel riots that have been raging over the past few days in Los Angeles. Rioters set cars on fire, looted businesses, and clashed with law enforcement. "We stand with Governor Newsom who has made it clear that violence is unacceptable and that local authorities should be able to do their jobs without the chaos of this federal interference and intimidation," the statement signed by Walz, Pritzker and Hochul reads. Los Angeles Business Owners 'Sick And Tired' Of 'Stupid' Anti-ice Rioters Looting Their Stores Since LA's riots, protests over President Trump's immigration policies have since spread to Pritzker and Hochul's states on Tuesday with large gatherings in Lower Manhattan in New York and Federal Plaza in Chicago, blocking off streets and causing disruptions. Fox News Digital also received J.B. Pritzker's opening remarks, where the governor and potential 2028 presidential candidate said his state "could not simply ignore the suffering" illegal migrants faced in Illionis. "The crisis at the southern border in recent years has been devastating; the response from some of our political leaders even more so," Prtizker's statement reads. "As individuals fleeing poverty, violence, and persecution arrived at our border, our nation's leaders were confronted with a choice: would we do everything possible to make the promise of America the practice of America?" Jb Pritzker Rips Trump As 'Authoritarian,' Responds To President Calling Out His Weight "Some border state governors and mayors abandoned our nation's highest ideals – instead of choosing to spend millions of taxpayer dollars to treat people as pawns, busing them to states like ours in a dehumanizing attempt to leverage the crisis for political gain. The State of Illinois chose a different path." Republican members on the Oversight Committee spoke to Fox News Digital ahead of Thursday's action, saying the three governors testifying "are willing to trade public safety for left-wing virtue signaling." "Democrat-run sanctuary states shield criminal aliens from federal immigration enforcement, put law enforcement in unnecessary danger, and disregard the safety of millions of Americans," House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan told Fox News Digital. "Seventy-seven million people gave President Trump a mandate last November to put an end to the Democrats' prioritization of illegal aliens over American citizens. And he's doing just that." National Guard Troops Detain Anti-ice Protesters In Los Angeles Under Trump's Orders "To folks like Walz, Hochul and Pritzker, sanctuary state policies are a badge of honor. They are willing to trade public safety for left-wing virtue signaling," said Rep. Pat Fallon, R-Texas, told Fox News Digital. "Perhaps Governor Gavin Newsom will take a break from defying federal authority to tune in and see why Americans are fleeing California in droves to escape his failed policies that invite illegal migrant crime and anarchist thugs," Fallon added. The stage is set for the hearing, which will take place on Thursday at 10 a.m. Eastern time. Fox News Digital reached out to Hochul and Walz but did not receive a article source: Walz, Hochul, Pritzker face off with Congress as Newsom battles Trump