
Govt urged to end bank subsidies
An independent think tank has urged the government to choose between subsidising already-profitable banks or diverting limited fiscal resources toward productive sectors by ending the policy of banks guaranteed returns on government borrowing.
The Economic Policy and Business Development (EPBD), a new policy research institute, released the statement the same day a federal cabinet body criticised excessive subsidies to banks in the name of attracting remittances.
The Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) of the Cabinet was informed Friday that banks had claimed Rs200 billion under the Pakistan Remittances Initiative during the current fiscal year — Rs115 billion more than the budgeted subsidy.
The EPBD stated that the current fiscal structure forces a choice between supporting economic growth and subsidising banking profits through guaranteed government payments. It argued that Pakistani businesses face structural disadvantages compared to regional peers who enjoy policies that enhance rather than restrict productive economic activity.
The think tank stressed that economic growth requires policy alignment with development objectives — not bank profit maximisation. The current approach of keeping policy rates at 11% while allocating Rs7.2 trillion for domestic debt servicing ensures stagnation, while regional competitors grow their industrial and export capacity.
The government has allocated Rs8.2 trillion for total debt servicing — equal to 46% of the 2024-25 budget. Of this, Rs7.2 trillion will go to domestic banks holding government securities. With 59% of public debt held in floating-rate instruments, the think tank argued that reducing policy rates from 11% to 6% would yield immediate savings.
The government worsened this burden by issuing Rs2 trillion in fixed-rate Pakistan Investment Bonds (PIBs) at peak interest rates of 22% over the past two years, locking in excessive costs to the benefit of banks, it added.
By cutting interest rates to 6%, in line with falling inflation, the government could save Rs3 trillion on debt servicing. Even a portion of this amount, the think tank said, could lower business costs and stimulate employment.
A 6% rate would still offer banks real returns while easing debt burdens. The savings could support manufacturing revival, industrial expansion, SME financing, technology upgrades, and export growth.
The statement added that Pakistan's future depends on diverting resources from guaranteed banking profits to investments that create jobs, enhance productivity, and ensure long-term growth.
Pakistani businesses cannot expand or generate employment while banks earn risk-free profits from public funds. In contrast, regional economies maintain 5.5% policy rates, allocate only 25% of budgets to debt servicing, and still achieve 6% GDP growth by prioritising business development.
The EPBD challenged the claim that lower interest rates fuel current account deficits. It cited the $19 billion deficit in 2021-22, which it attributed to exceptional, non-interest-sensitive imports such as $3.2 billion in COVID-19 vaccines, $15.6 billion in fuel, and $1.7 billion in smartphones. It said high interest rates did nothing to limit those imports and instead suppressed domestic activity.
The think tank added that guaranteed profits have led banks to retreat from commercial lending, opting instead for risk-free government bonds. With 97.3% of bank investments tied up in government debt, virtually no capital remains for working capital, expansion, or technology adoption.
Manufacturers struggle to finance inventory, exporters lose global competitiveness, and small businesses are excluded from credit. Pakistan's banks have effectively become bond traders, contributing no value to the real economy while earning from taxpayer-backed securities.
The think tank also criticised the remittance structure, noting that Rs87 billion went to banks for basic transfersfunds that could instead support small businesses and entrepreneurship.
Its statement came as the ECC met to deliberate the future of remittance-linked subsidies. The finance ministry has decided to end the subsidies in 2024-25 due to pressure from banks and International Monetary Fund (IMF) constraints. The State Bank of Pakistan told the ECC it could no longer offer implicit support under IMF rules.
Although the ECC requested a transition plan, the finance ministry said no study has determined any positive impact of these subsidies. Officials noted that funds largely benefit banks and exchange companies, not overseas Pakistanis sending remittances. The central bank informed the ECC that remittance promotion schemes have existed since 1985, but their effectiveness remains unverified.
Without reform, the remittance subsidy bill could swell to Rs500 billion in coming years, warned a finance ministry official.
The think tank reiterated that businesses do not need subsidies or special treatment — just a level playing field. Reducing interest rates to 6% would bring Pakistan in line with regional rivals, restore manufacturing competitiveness, and improve global market access for exporters. Such a move would also accelerate technology adoption and job creation across sectors, the EPBD argued.
Although manufacturing capacity exists, it remains underutilised due to lack of financing. With 97% of banks' balance sheets locked in public debt, there is little scope to support private sector growth.
Regional countries have demonstrated that supporting businesses through growth-oriented credit policies can deliver 6% growth while maintaining fiscal stability, it added.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
PAC lambasts govt's faulty sugar policies
Listen to article As a sugar crisis persists in the country, officials on Tuesday shared with the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) the names of the 67 sugar mills that exported 750,000 tons of sugar worth Rs111 billion to 21 countries over the past year. During a PAC meeting chaired by Junaid Akbar, the industries and production secretary said in 2023-24 Pakistan had surplus sugar of 1.3 million tons, of which 790,000 tons were approved for export. He said that 1.9 million tons of sugar was still available in stock, which could last until November, adding that the sugar crushing season runs from November 15 to March 15. Despite these figures, several committee members expressed dissatisfaction with the situation. The secretary for national food security claimed that the average retail price of sugar was Rs173 per kg but members, including Omar Ayub, said sugar was sold for more than Rs200 in their constituencies. Senator Fauzia Arshad reported that sugar was nearly unavailable in the market and what was available was unaffordable for ordinary citizens. PAC members heavily criticized the government's inconsistent sugar policiesexporting sugar one year and importing it the next. MNA Khawaja Shehraz Mehmood called it a "daylight robbery" and said that the same companies making huge profits from exports are now benefiting from imports. MNA Amir Dogar made direct allegations against political leaders, claiming that the highest number of sugar mills are owned by President Asif Ali Zardari, politician Jahangir Tareen, and the Sharif family. He alleged that Rs287 billion had gone into the pockets of a few powerful individuals. The remarks caused heated arguments between Dogar and other members, including Senator Afnan Ullah of the PML-N and Shazia Marri of the PPP, who demanded that such serious claims be backed with evidence. Further tension arose when Chairman Akbar questioned why the list of sugar mill owners and directors had not been submitted to the committee earlier. Officials from the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) assured that the list has now been obtained and will be presented soon. He questioned how long sugar remains usable in storage, to which the secretary of industries responded that sugar begins to spoil after 3-4 months unless special precautions are taken. The meeting was told that the government is planning to import 300,000 tons of sugar to meet demand before the next crushing season begins. Lawmakers demanded that the government ensure this import does not harm farmers and that sugar is not brought in from countries where it was earlier exported. The PAC directed all relevant ministries to submit detailed reports and warned that future briefings would not be accepted without complete documentation. According to documents seen by The Express Tribune, JDW Sugar Mills topped the list by exporting 73,000 metric tons of sugar worth Rs11.1 billion. Tandlianwala Sugar Mills came second with 41,412 metric tons worth Rs5.98 billion. Ramzan Sugar Mills exported sugar worth Rs2.41 billion. Chaudhry Sugar Mills exported sugar worth Rs1.49 billion while Al-Arabia Sugar Mills exported Rs1.2 billion worth of sugar. The Auditor General of Pakistan revealed that sugar mills earned over Rs300 billion from recent sugar price fluctuations.


Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Farmers suffer Rs1.26tr blow
Listen to article A troubling trickle-down effect is unfolding across Pakistan's agricultural landscape, where a mix of government apathy, flawed policies and unchecked input costs is pushing the sector towards collapse. Once considered the backbone of the country's economy, agriculture, especially cotton, is showing signs of irreversible decline, with millions of farmers suffering unprecedented losses. What began with a crisis in wheat and maize has now extended to cotton, vegetables and fruits, exposing deep-rooted policy failures and the lack of state intervention. According to official data for January-June 2025, Pakistani farmers endured collective losses of over Rs1.26 trillion. The most significant blows came from rice and maize, together accounting for a staggering Rs1 trillion in damages. Export figures paint an equally grim picture – a drop of over $1 billion in total agro-export value compared to the same period in 2024. Among export volumes of major crops, maize fell by 70%, banana by 69%, mango by 40% and onion and garlic by 31%. The harvest of cotton, a critical crop for Pakistan's textile sector, has gone down by 30.7%, according to the Economic Survey 2024-25, underscoring its worst performance in a decade. This steep fall forced the country to import 854,263 metric tons of ginned cotton in just six months at a cost of $1.66 billion. Yet, despite this financial haemorrhage, local farmers remain unsupported. Early PCGA (Pakistan Cotton Ginners Association) figures confirm only 1.3 million bales have reached ginning factories so far this year, a sharp decline from past seasons. Heavy rainfall in Sindh and Punjab has devastated fields and fibre quality, further threatening an already crippled cotton industry. Progressive farmer Shahid Jutt from Vehari said that they were already struggling with poor returns and now climate change has turned against us. "But the real damage is from the system – no price support, no subsidies and no planning," he added. The cotton price, standing at Rs5,500-6,000 per maund in 2010-11 when the dollar was at Rs85, equated to around $70. Today, despite a nominal rise to Rs7,600 per maund, the dollar equivalent has dropped to just $27 due to currency depreciation. Meanwhile, input costs have surged more than fourfold, with fertiliser, diesel and electricity becoming unaffordable for many small and medium-scale farmers. Fertiliser offtake has dropped drastically – 29% for nitrogen and 15% for phosphates – simply because farmers cannot afford the recommended doses. Farmers are applying fewer nutrients, resulting in lower yields and further income losses. In vegetable production, prices have crashed. Onion growers, for instance, saw a price drop of over 55%, leaving thousands of smallholders on the brink of financial ruin. Agricultural economist Dr Imran Awan said that this is not just a bad year, it's a culmination of years of negligence. "Government budgets continue to ignore pressing needs of the agriculture sector. Research, extension services and seed development have been left to die. Climate change is hitting us hard, but we are not investing in resilience or planning for contingencies." In the early 2010s, Pakistan's cotton sector was thriving, with annual output between 11.7 and 14.8 million bales. Cotton exports during that time reached 1.1 million bales and imports were minimal. Fast forward to 2025 and cotton production is hovering below 7.5 million bales. This year, with rain-damaged fields and substandard fibre, output may even drop below 4 million bales, while imports continue to cross 5 million bales, despite many textile mills working below capacity or even shutting down. Input costs have surged uncontrollably. Diesel, essential for farm machinery, is now priced at Rs284 per litre. Electricity for irrigation has become a luxury, costing over Rs42 per unit, while farmers in neighbouring countries benefit from subsidised or free electricity for agricultural use. This cost imbalance is crushing Pakistan's competitiveness in the regional market. Pakistan Kissan Itehad President Khalid Mahmood Khokhar said that farmers are working harder than ever before but are being punished with shrinking profits and soaring costs. "Fertiliser is unaffordable, diesel eats up our earnings and there's no relief in sight. This crisis began when wheat support price was ignored, which demotivated farmers. Now cotton is suffering and the government remains silent," he said. PKI called for undertaking urgent reforms, including improved investment in agricultural R&D and seed technology, regulated input prices and the formation of an independent price and commodity export commission to ensure fair pricing and manage exports based on domestic supply. It also demanded a nutrient-based subsidy system for phosphatic and potassic fertilisers to ease farmers' financial burden.


Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Pakistan-Kyrgyzstan trade, investment forum held
Listen to article Atif Ikram Sheikh, President FPCCI, President ECO-CCI, and VP CACCI, welcomed a high-profile Kyrgyz trade delegation to Pakistan. The visiting delegation included senior parliamentarians, diplomats, businessmen, and key stakeholders. The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) hosted the Pakistan-Kyrgyzstan Trade & Investment Forum at its head office in Karachi on Tuesday, amid growing interest from both countries' business communities, according to a statement. Sheikh expressed satisfaction over the outcome of the recent Pakistan-Kyrgyzstan Inter-Governmental Commission, which agreed to increase bilateral trade from the current $16 million to $100 million. He noted that the present trade volume is well below the two countries' true potential. The chief guest, Edil Baisalove, Deputy Chairman of the Cabinet of Ministers of Kyrgyz Republic, told Pakistani businessmen that Kyrgyzstan is undergoing rapid industrialisation. He said this presents numerous opportunities for joint ventures, investments, and trade cooperation between the two nations. Kylychbek Sultan, Kyrgyz Ambassador to Pakistan, said both countries are working to establish new trade routes to create a feasible and enabling environment for the bilateral trade to grow. Saquib Fayyaz Magoon, SVP FPCCI, stressed that the shortest route from Chinese city of Kashgar to Kyrgyzstan is about 200 km; and Pakistan is also linked with this province through CPEC; whereas two Kyrgyz passes of Torugart and Erkeshtam should be utilised for establishing linkages to the warm waters of Gwadar port. Magoon recommended holding reciprocal single-country exhibitions and regular trade delegation exchanges. He urged the immediate removal of non-tariff barriers (NTMs and NTBs) and closer coordination between FPCCI and Kyrgyzstan's Chamber of Commerce and Industry (CCI-KG).