Labour leader Chris Hipkins says NZ is not in 'economic shape'
Photo:
RNZ / Mark Papalii
Labour leader Chris Hipkins has told the Queenstown Business Chamber the economy is not recovering, and more spending is needed to get the settings right.
Hipkins and several of his MPs are in the city ahead of a caucus retreat in Christchurch this week, aiming to speak to South Island communities.
In Thursday's speech to the Queenstown Business Chamber, he said the government's strategy for growth was not tackling the underlying economic problems.
"While there are pockets of positivity around economic growth, overall the country is not in the economic shape that we need it to be.
"Despite a lot of talk about economic growth, actually the most recent indicators are pretty concerning for us - they're suggesting that New Zealand's economy isn't recovering and if anything we may be going in the other direction."
He said government policies were contributing to rising costs and leading to a "two-speed economy" where those worse off were ending up much worse off.
"Rates, which councils primarily influence but central government actually has a role in... things like car registrations, public transport costs, even things like insurance levies which government is contributing to through EQC levies, electricity prices which government contributes to through transmission charges - all of these things are now made one of the major contributors to inflation in New Zealand."
It was more than just mining which had seen Australia leapfrog New Zealand economically in the past 40 years, he said, pointing to higher rates of savings, infrastructure investment including schools, hospitals and energy generation.
"Let's be really frank - and I know that this is huge in Queenstown - we have an over emphasis on the housing market... We can't get rich as a country just by buying and selling houses from one another, we need to invest in the productive economy, and our over emphasis on the housing market as our primary source of investment has meant that we haven't been."
The comment hints at a capital gains tax policy Labour has
long been rumoured
to be working on, having promised a tax policy of some sort by the end of the year.
The party has had an
on-again-off-again history
with
the policy
which taxes a portion of profits gained from selling assets that grow in value, but it appears to have
some support from voters
- depending on the settings.
One argument for the tax is that it would decrease the incentive for people to put their wealth into housing, making other forms of more productive investment more attractive.
"Simply reinflating house prices and growing the population through further inbound migration might mask some of the problems that we see, but it's not going to deal with the underlying ones and some of those underlying ones will get worse if that's our strategy for economic recovery," Hipkins said.
"The sort of innovation that we're seeing in New Zealand is really exciting, some of the best in the world, but our challenge is to scale that - it's to continue to grow that. All of those businesses talk about the shallowness of our capital markets when it comes to innovative companies and startups."
He also criticised the government's decisions on curbing spending for schools, hospitals and transport.
"Reviewing transport projects against a new government policy statement meant a lot of just the basic day to day ongoing upgrade of our transport infrastructure stopped for about a year and a half. It's starting again now, and that's really encouraging, but we don't want to repeat that cycle."
Answering questions afterwards, Hipkins said New Zealand's self-imposed debt limits made it one of the most fiscally conservative countries in the world, making an argument for more direct government investment.
"It's based on a narrative that says that government spending should be constrained to 30 percent of GDP ... that puts us as such an international outlier around the world and it makes us one of the most fiscally conservative governments in the world.
"Government spending as a percentage of GDP in a small economy like New Zealand needs to be able to fluctuate, so in a period of economic crisis or in a significant shock like a pandemic you need to be able to increase government spending to get through it - the question is, what you spend that money on?"
He said the current strategy was an ambulance at the bottom of the cliff approach.
"Government spending needs to be focused on areas of investment rather than kind of subsidising day-to-day activity and I think that that's where this government have got the analysis wrong... by saying they want to spend less, they're spending more in the areas of subsidy, because the more people you end up with on a job seeker benefit, the more money you're spending on day to day consumption."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Season 3 Episode 15: Greens co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick on homelessness, energy poverty, Gaza, and electoral law changes
Greens co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick says National MPs she's spoken with want to support a stronger stance on sanctions against Israel but are too terrified to take on their party leadership. The sanctions are prompted by Israel's 22 month bombardment of Gaza and its refusal to allow aid to flow freely into the occupied region. Swarbrick lodged a member's bill in December and argues with all opposition parties backing it, the support of just six backbench government MPs would mean it could skip the "biscuit tin" ballot and be brought to Parliament for a first reading. She told Mata with Mihingarangi: "All we need is six of 68 government MPs to get it on the floor of the House ... I've spoken to a number of National MPs in particular and ... they're telling me, and look I'll be crystal clear about this, they're telling me that they're terrified about the future of their career because the indication that they've got from their leadership is that if they were to stick their neck out and do the right thing here they would be losing their place on the pecking order. "And my question, that I've put back to them is: What the hell is the point of your job?" Standing Order 288 allows MPs who are not ministers or under-secretaries to indicate their support for a member's bill. If at least 61 MPs get behind it, the legislation skips the "biscuit tin". If six government MPs indicated their support for this bill it would be the first time this process was followed. Late last month Foreign Minister Winston Peters called for a ceasefire in Gaza in a statement delivered in Parliament, but stopped short of promising further aid funding, or promising to join efforts to prevent weapons being sold to Israel. His speech coincided with New Zealand supporting a joint statement with 27 other countries calling for a ceasefire, and condemning the "drip-feeding of aid , and the inhumane killing of civilians, including children". A week later the coalition government signed an additional joint statement with 14 other countries expressing a willingness to recognise the State of Palestine as a necessary step towards a two-State solution. After 22 months of a devastating Israeli military campaign Greens co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick says there's a need for more than speeches and statements. "Gazans can't eat empty words, and this government has, for the better part of two years now, said that they're doing everything they can as they make statements and sit on their hands. "The very least that we could possibly do is apply the same standard that we did to Russia for its unlawful invasions into and occupation of Ukraine. "That's why we drafted the Unlawful Occupation of Palestine Sanctions bill which, after a year plus of waiting for the government to do something we put into the biscuit tin to remove any of the excuses. "The other important thing to note about the process we initiated by putting this into the biscuit tin is that we no longer need Winston Peters, Christopher Luxon or that other guy. We just need six of 68 government MPs to say that they are willing to stand by their conscience and do the right thing in the face of a genocide being live streamed to each of us 24/7 on our phones."
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Treasury briefing points finger at government spending during Covid-19 pandemic
The Treasury briefing said the Covid-19 response showed the challenges of using fiscal policy to respond to shocks and cycles. Photo: FANATIC STUDIO / SCIENCE PHOTO L The previous government spent too much during the Covid-19 pandemic, despite warnings from officials, according to a briefing released by the Treasury. The Treasury's 2025 Long Term Insights Briefing said debt had risen in recent decades, partly because responses to adverse shocks were not met by savings between those shocks. The higher debt meant less capacity to respond to future shocks, like natural hazards, weather-related risks and biosecurity risks. Treasury estimated the total cost of the pandemic was $66 billion over the 2020-26 financial years and about 20.4 percent of GDP. The IMF and OECD estimated it was among the largest Covid-19 responses globally. The agency releases a briefing every three years, with this one looking at the role of fiscal policy through shocks and business cycles. The briefing said the Covid-19 response showed the challenges of using fiscal policy to respond to shocks and cycles. Initially, Treasury recommended "strong fiscal stimulus" at the start of the pandemic, which was cited as "perhaps" causing the economy to be much stronger than expected by the end of 2020. The wage-subsidy scheme in particular was seen as making an important contribution to the strong initial recovery, limiting the increase in the unemployment rate and enabling economic activity to resume when restrictions relaxed. Treasury then moved away from recommending broad-based stimulus, preferring more targeted and moderate support. Its post-election advice to the then-Finance Minister in late 2020 highlighted "the importance of controlling ongoing spending and ensuring it was high value to meet the medium-term fiscal challenge." By August 2021, with the Delta lockdowns coming in, Treasury recommended any decisions to provide support to businesses "should take account of macroeconomic trade-offs". It recommended against any further stimulus from Budget 2022 onwards. Wage subsidies and similar schemes during lockdowns made up about 35 percent of the costs of the response. A further 18 percent came from health-system costs, like vaccination, contact tracing, and managed isolation and quarantine. The remaining "nearly half" was made up of a wide range of initiatives that Treasury said had "varied objectives". Some were aimed at directly responding to the impacts of Covid-19, others were aimed at providing fiscal stimulus or "achieving social or environmental objectives". They included "tax changes, training schemes, housing construction, shovel-ready infrastructure projects, increases to welfare benefits, the Small Business Cashflow Scheme, Jobs for Nature, additional public housing places and school lunches". Programmes within the fiscal response that were not tied to the shock were seen as having "a lagged impact on the economy and proved difficult to unwind in later years". The report suggested cyclical management was best left to monetary policy, run by an independent central bank. It also suggested governments set out clearly when fiscal policy will be used ahead of time, including pre-defining responses. Ideally, this would have cross-party agreement. An independent fiscal institution, which could scrutinise and report on the sustainability of fiscal policy, was also suggested. The previous government had considered setting up a watchdog to cost election policies, but it could not get cross-party support. National then changed its tune, with current Finance Minister Nicola Willis supporting such a measure, but New Zealand First and ACT were opposed to the idea. Willis jumped on the report's release, saying Treasury's language was "spare and polite", but its conclusions were "damning". She said the briefing showed the challenges of using "big spending measures" to respond to one-off shocks. Willis singled out the briefing's focus on the money spent on initiatives not directly tied to the Covid-19 response. "That is a very diplomatic way of saying New Zealanders are still paying the price of the previous government extending a big-spending approach, initially intended for a pandemic response," she said. RNZ has approached Labour for comment. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Labour MPs gather in Christchurch to formulate election strategy
Labour leader Chris Hipkins addressed the Queenstown Business Chamber on Thursday. Photo: Screengrab Analysis: Labour MPs are gathering in Christchurch for a team 'away day', as the party inches closer to announcing its tax policy. Last year's mid-winter retreat was held in Auckland to re-engage with 'supercity' residents , after the party's bruising defeat in Election 2023 The caucus is now pushing to connect with the South Island - leader Chris Hipkins addressed the Queenstown Business Chamber on Thursday, while other MPs visited flood-affected properties in Moteuka. They will all come together in Christchurch on Friday to look to the year ahead and talk strategy for the run-up to next year's election. The meeting comes as the government works against a tide of negative headlines about the economy, with unemployment jumping to 5.2 percent on Wednesday. National campaigned on rebuilding the economy and Prime Minister Christopher Luxon heralded 2025 as the year of "going for growth" in his State of the Nation speech in January . The party is now battling the headwinds of an economic downturn, with some business voices, like former National leader-turned Auckland Chamber boss Simon Bridges, criticising the coalition for not doing more to stimulate the economy. Labour has been near silent on the policy front, choosing instead to criticise the coalition's ideas and hone its messaging on the cost of living to better resonate with voters feeling the pinch. Responding to an update on the government's transition to a universal road-user charges system , Hipkins said the timing could "clobber" those already struggling to pay the bills, but as for Labour's alternative timeline, who knows? The strategy thus far shows some promise, with the left bloc parties - Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori - holding a narrow lead over the coalition in several political polls this year. Labour has also emerged as the party New Zealanders think has the best handle on the cost of living, according to the latest Ipsos Issues Monitor , but the race remains tight and the coalition parties are poised to pounce, when Labour unveils its tax plan this year. On Sunday, The Post reported Labour was one step closer to endorsing a capital gains tax (CGT) - insiders say the party's policy council has narrowly voted for a CGT over a wealth tax . While MPs will most likely discuss tax policy at today's mid-winter retreat, the public shouldn't hold its breath for an announcement. Party process requires both the council and caucus to sign off on policy. In the meantime, the party is clearly preparing to pitch - and defend - its approach to tax. Hipkins told TVNZ's Q+A in March he would need time to "counter the misinformation that often goes with tax changes" before the 2026 Election. Hipkins will give an opening speech to his caucus in Christchurch on Friday, before MPs have policy and strategy discussions behind closed doors. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
