Providence sergeant who beat handcuffed man will be allowed to return to active duty
Get Rhode Island News Alerts
Sign up to get breaking news and interesting stories from Rhode Island in your inbox each weekday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
Hanley's own body-worn camera was not turned on, but his actions were captured by other officers' cameras.
Advertisement
April 2020 body camera video, Sgt. Joseph Hanley is seen kicking and verbally berating Rishod Gore, a man whom he was arresting on Tell Street in Providence.
Two mayors and two police chiefs have wanted to fire Hanley for the incident over the past half-decade, but state law gave Hanley the right to a hearing by the three-member panel of officers, and the process had to wait until after his criminal case is over.
After two trials — one
Advertisement
Hanley remained suspended during the long-drawn out case. He is no longer paid his salary, but receives medical and dental benefits from the city.
The decision says Hanley must be restored to active duty after serving his 45-day suspension.
'Sergeant Joseph Hanley has maintained an unblemished and exemplary record of service, one that distinguishes him not only within the Providence Police Department but throughout the broader law enforcement community,' Patalano and Boehm wrote.
In a 50-page decision, the panel of officers said Hanley was initially offered a 45-day suspension back when the assault happened in 2020. But while Hanley was contemplating accepting the punishment, the decision reads,
'The city subsequently moved to terminate Sergeant Hanley, a decision which he portrays was politically motivated and inconsistent with established disciplinary practices including the clear pattern of precedent-based disciplinary measures,' the decision says.
In his dissent, O'Hara said Hanley's behavior was 'outrageous,' and it was 'mind-boggling' that the seasoned sergeant would launch into 'such as volatile, unrestrained tirade and a violent criminal assault on a prone and handcuffed Rishod Gore, who was suspected of committing a misdemeanor.'
'Hanley's explosive reaction, insulting vulgarity, unhinged anger, and criminal physicality with Gore are a downright disgrace,' O'Hara wrote.
The long-drawn-out case prompted widespread outrage and was one of several cases that helped propel an effort to
Hanley's case was the last to be heard by a three-member panel of officers under the old Law Enforcement Officers' Bill of Rights. The makeup of the panel was widely criticized because the accused officer had a say in who was on it.
Advertisement
The new law, renamed the
Steph Machado can be reached at
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
19 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Police are tapping into private cameras — with permission — to solve crimes faster. The controversial technology is spreading across the country.
The detective sent images of the suspect to police on the ground, who apprehended him minutes later, Sergeant Jonathan Primiano said. The whole situation took 10 to 15 minutes from theft to arrest. The Get Rhode Island News Alerts Sign up to get breaking news and interesting stories from Rhode Island in your inbox each weekday. Enter Email Sign Up It's a 'faster, safer and more effective' way to do modern-day police work, said Colonel Oscar Perez, the police chief. But the cameras have raised Advertisement The Fusus system, run by the company Axon, allows detectives to see live feeds of Advertisement So far, 21 private citizens or businesses have given Providence Police access to 145 cameras, and another 145 city-owned cameras are part of the system. Providence Police Captain Dennis O'Brien stands inside the Real Time Crime Center room with a map of the city on display behind him at the Providence Police Department. Ben Pennington/for The Boston Globe The system is spreading throughout the country, including in New England. Kristin Lowman, a spokesperson for Axon, declined to list the police departments using it in New England, but confirmed it is in use in Massachusetts, along with 'hundreds of cities' including Atlanta, Miami, Cleveland, Minneapolis, and Orlando. Providence is the first city in Rhode Island to implement the real-time system, and it's also in use in Hartford, Conn. Madalyn McGunagle, a policy associate with the 'Anyone can be tracked throughout the day, so long as there's a reason to,' McGunagle said. 'We're always fearful of privacy erosion, and I think this is risking that.' Sergeant Jonathan Primiano uses a computer inside the new Real Time Crime Center room at the Providence Police Department. Ben Pennington/for The Boston Globe But police said system can give police real-time information about a crime scene while officers are still on the way, Perez said, potentially saving lives. 'In the '90s we used to go in blind to some of these calls,' he said. 'Many times we responded to a homicide, and the person who just did the homicide would be standing behind the crowd without us knowing.' Inside the operations center, a large monitor displays a map of the city, with icons for all the various cameras. When a call comes in, police can pull up the address, see if there is a camera there, and relay information and images to officers heading to the scene. Advertisement 'We're able to see what's unfolding in those locations before we're able to respond,' Perez said. Body cameras on the map are labeled with the name of the police officer wearing it; if blinking red, the camera is recording. Perez said police might access those cameras during a major event such as an active shooter situation or if an officer is shot. And it can speed up the process of solving a crime; previously, detectives would need to visit a business to ask for their security video after a crime is committed in the vicinity. If the owner wasn't in, or the employees didn't know the password, it could take days to get the footage, Primiano said. Private citizens and businesses can also Police stressed that detectives are not monitoring security cameras in the system 24/7, nor are they pulling up live feeds randomly. The inside of the new Real Time Crime Center system room at the Providence Police Department on Aug. 19, 2025. Ben Pennington/for The Boston Globe The city's written policy says police will prioritize using the system for homicides, assaults, robberies, burglaries, shootings, vehicle chases and 'incidents involving suspicious behavior.' Police will also proactively monitor the cameras during major events, such as While monitoring cameras during the Dominican Festival earlier this month, a detective looking at the camera system at a location nearby saw someone pull out a gun, police said. After arresting the suspect, they discovered he was the same man wanted in a double shooting earlier in the summer. Advertisement Right now, the system cannot integrate with cloud-based cameras such as Ring doorbell cameras, but such integration could happen in the future. The city's traffic enforcement cameras for red lights and speeding in school zones are also not part of the system, police said. The McGunagle said the ACLU, which fought against the 'These things will capture people walking on the street, people making deliveries, people dropping off Amazon packages. Those people didn't agree to having their likeness given over to the police,' McGunagle said. Providence Police Captain Dennis O'Brien stands inside the Real Time Crime Center room with a map of the city on display behind him at the Providence Police Department. Ben Pennington/for The Boston Globe Asked how police would avoid any misuse of the system, Primiano said a 'very limited' list of people have access to the it, including fewer than a dozen detectives, Perez, and a member of the Rhode Island National Guard who works as an analyst for the police department. 'All access must be logged and justified,' the written policy states. One of the private citizens who has given police access to his cameras is Providence police can access cameras mounted on Paolino's office building at 100 Westminster St., which overlooks Kennedy Plaza, and two downtown apartment buildings, the Case Mead lofts and Studley building, said Jim Washburn, Paolino's director of security and a former Providence police officer. Advertisement 'Any time I can help the Providence Police eradicate crime downtown or anywhere ... I will do it,' Paolino said. Cameras at the The city did not immediately provide a copy of its contract with Axon, which was signed more than a year ago, though spokesperson Josh Estrella said the system was not 'fully operational' until this month. A $1 million Byrne grant from the US Department of Justice is funding the contract. Despite privacy concerns, Perez noted police already accessed cameras throughout the city, there was just a delay in getting ahold of the footage after a crime was committed. 'All these data sources, we had them already,' Perez said. 'We're just now integrating them in a place where they can actually observe it and use it.' Steph Machado can be reached at
Yahoo
04-08-2025
- Yahoo
Girl, 4, dies following incident at Waterworld in Stoke-on-Trent
A four-year-old girl has died following an incident at a swimming pool in Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent. Police said they were "called to Waterworld on Festival Way at around 4.20pm to reports of a girl, aged four, in a critical condition". "Waterworld staff and colleagues from the West Midlands Ambulance Service treated the girl at the scene before paramedics took her to hospital for further treatment," officers added. "Despite the best efforts of hospital staff, the girl died a short while later. "The girl's next of kin have been informed and are being supported by specially-trained officers." Detective Chief Inspector Lucy Maskew from Staffordshire Police said: "Our thoughts are with the family at this terribly sad time. "We are now making enquiries and looking to establish the circumstances of the incident. We would ask that members of the public avoid speculating in these early stages of the investigation and allow the family to grieve." A Waterworld spokesperson said: "It is with great sadness that we learned of this little girl's passing this evening. "All our thoughts are with her family and loved ones during these extremely difficult times. Waterworld is in shock and has decided to remain closed tomorrow out of respect for the family. Waterworld is working closely with the authorities at this sad time." In a post on Facebook, Waterworld said the fatal incident happened at 4.15pm, "in the lagoon area of the aqua park". The girl was "found unconscious and treated on poolside by our lifeguard and management teams on site. Read more on Sky News:Storm Floris latest: UK hit by 124mph windsKremlin urges nuclear cautionHow Euros star juggled studies and training "They immediately provided CPR and called the emergency services, who arrived around 4.20pm. "All other visitors were asked to quietly leave the pool out of respect for the rescue operation underway, and we would like to thank them for their support and collaboration." Waterworld describes itself on its website as "the UK's number one tropical indoor aqua-park". It says it offers "an epic adventure for the whole family to enjoy, with over 30 different rides and attractions!" This breaking news story is being updated and more details will be published shortly. Please refresh the page for the latest version. You can receive breaking news alerts on a smartphone or tablet via the Sky News app. You can also follow us on WhatsApp and subscribe to our YouTube channel to keep up with the latest news.
Boston Globe
22-07-2025
- Boston Globe
Providence police oversight board slams department for ‘internal failures'
The three-page statement from the oversight board criticizing the city police on Friday afternoon came in light of the Get Rhode Map A weekday briefing from veteran Rhode Island reporters, focused on the things that matter most in the Ocean State. Enter Email Sign Up Hanley's reinstatement 'should come as no surprise to anyone familiar with the structural deficiencies in Rhode Island's police accountability framework,' the oversight board wrote. 'His return to duty, despite his admission to serious allegations of misconduct and a dissenting opinion from a high-ranking police official, reflects the deep-rooted ineffectiveness of current oversight mechanisms.' Advertisement The PERA board is a civilian panel created in 2002 that investigates alleged misconduct by Providence police officers and reviews policies, making recommendations for discipline, policy changes and training. While the group is ultimately advisory, the police department is required to cooperate with its work, and its findings and recommendations are made public. Advertisement The board members are unpaid, but currently has three staff members including an executive director, an administrative assistant and one investigator. Karoly, the executive director, is a lawyer and former deputy chief of the Middletown Police Department. In its letter, the panel claims the police department has ignored the majority of its policy recommendations, and also has not responded to a request to come up with a 'disciplinary matrix,' essentially a guideline for officer misconduct that lays out the recommended punishment for each offense, from harassment to excessive use of force. The ordinance that created the oversight board says the matrix should be developed by the board and the chief of police. 'We submitted one several years ago, and they've just never approved it,' Karoly said. 'It's just kind of stayed in limbo.' Multiple recommendations also went unanswered or were denied, Karoly said. Josh Estrella, a spokesperson for the city, said the police department has responded to policy recommendations, as recently as March of this year. 'The Department has been actively working on a matrix and will continue to respond to PERA's recommendations formally as it relates to discipline or policy,' Estrella said. 'The Providence Police Department remains committed to transparency, accountability and strengthening public trust.' He said the review authority's budget, along with other department budgets, was cut based on 'actual expenditures,' which were lower than the board's budget. Advertisement The budget cuts will limit the group's 'ability to conduct hearings and fulfill our oversight responsibilities,' members wrote. 'These actions do not reflect a commitment to accountability — they are deliberate obstructions.' The oversight board members also said the police department has repeatedly obstructed their investigations, sometimes taking more than a year to provide evidence so the board can review alleged misconduct. In one case, the board said it investigated a complaint from a person who was videotaping and 'verbally criticizing' a sergeant who was arresting someone on Broad Street in 2023. The findings, released May 6, said it took until December 2024 – more than a year – for police to share the case file for the PERA investigator to review. According to the board's findings, the person who was filming the arrest was 20 feet away and did not get in the way of the police, but the sergeant — whose name is redacted — kept engaging with him and 'bumping him with his chest' before having him arrested for disorderly conduct. The charge was later dropped. The police department's internal investigation found the accusations of wrongdoing against the officer were sustained, and gave him a verbal reprimand, according to the oversight board's findings. The board recommended that the punishment be modified to a five-day suspension and eight hours of retraining, but has so far been ignored, Friday's letter claims. 'Instead of cooperation, we have encountered resistance,' the civilian panel wrote. 'The Providence police department must acknowledge and correct its internal failures.' One of the board-recommended changes to the ordinance that created the Providence External Review Authority is that staff be given 'full user access' to police records, including internal investigations and the body-worn camera system, 'so that PERA may efficiently review and or audit all police internal investigations as well as complete its own investigations.' Advertisement The review authority staff members would be 'subject to the same confidentiality requirements as police users and will not disclose personally identifiable information except as allowed by law,' the proposed ordinance says. The oversight board has fought to get evidence in the past. When the city refused for months to release the Then-executive director Jose Batista, who is also a state representative, publicly released the video and was ultimately fired for doing so. (Batista sued for wrongful termination, and later settled with the city for $45,000.) The oversight board was not conducting investigations for a period of time after Batista's firing, but has ramped up its activities under Karoly. Last week, PERA said it would investigate Providence police officers' Related : The letter also criticizes the state law formerly known as the Law Enforcement Officers' Bill of Rights, or LEOBOR, which allowed Hanley to return to the force by leaving the decision to a panel of law enforcement officers, not the chief of police. The vote was 2 to 1 to reinstate Hanley. Advertisement While the law was recently But the state law alone cannot be blamed, the panel said. 'Accountability starts at the departmental level, and the issues raised in Sgt. Hanley's case reflect a broader failure within the Providence Police Department,' the board's letter said, citing Deputy Chief Timothy O'Hara's dissent in the LEOBOR case, which stated Hanley was 'a man prone to volatility, a man prone to violence, a man prone to vulgarity, a man prone to untruthfulness, and a man accustomed to lying.' 'The fact that Hanley achieved the rank of Sergeant, served in the Detective Bureau, and held supervisory responsibilities despite internal concerns about his behavior raises troubling questions,' the board wrote. 'We are ready to do our part,' board members said. 'But we cannot improve policing in Providence without the tools, cooperation, and political will necessary to challenge the status quo. The community deserves better — and we will continue to fight for it." Steph Machado can be reached at
