
HC quashes conviction & acquits all 12 accused in 2006 Mumbai train blasts case
The HC refused to confirm death sentences for five and life sentences given on Sept 30, 2015 to seven by the special court set up under the anti-organised crime Act and acquitted all, directing their immediate release.
Punishment for an actual criminal is essential to uphold the rule of law, but "creating a false appearance of having solved a case… gives a misleading sense of resolution. This deceptive closure undermines public trust and falsely reassures society, while in reality, the true threat remains at large.
Essentially, this is what the case at hand conveys," a special bench of Justices Anil Kilor and Shyam Chandak observed in the introduction to their 671-page judgment, before shredding the prosecution case.
The identification parade was not conducted properly, witnesses identifying accused in dock after four years lacked credibility and MCOCA was invoked without application of mind, the HC said, discarding confession statements relied on for want of "trustworthiness and completeness."
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Gold Is Surging in 2025 — Smart Traders Are Already In
IC Markets
Learn More
Undo
The HC also accepted defence arguments of torture of accused vitiating confessional statements.
You Can Also Check:
Mumbai AQI
|
Weather in Mumbai
|
Bank Holidays in Mumbai
|
Public Holidays in Mumbai
"The prosecution utterly failed to establish the offence beyond reasonable doubt against the accused on each count. It is unsafe to reach the satisfaction that the accused committed the offences for which they were convicted and sentenced," the bench held.
After over six months of hearing and going through more than 44,000 pages of record, Bombay HC concluded the Maharashtra Anti-Terror Squad (ATS) had no case against the 12 accused in the 11/7 train blasts case.
Over two decades ago, bombs planted on first-class compartments exploded during the peak evening commute at seven locations on the Western Railway suburban network. They ripped metal and lives between Khar Road and Santacruz, Bandra and Khar Road, Jogeshwari and Mahim Junction, Mira Road and Bhayander, Matunga and Mahim Junction, and Borivli.
The prosecution case was of sophisticated explosive RDX being used, of accused being members of terror outfits like SIMI who received training in Pakistan, and of 15 wanted accused, mainly Pakistanis.
While the trial court's special MCOCA judge Y D Shinde in 2015 said special public prosecutor Raja Thakare had rightly described the accused as "merchants of death" and Thakare argued that the trial verdict could not be dislodged and the noose be confirmed, the HC noted the prosecution case had unravelled completely.
The HC also held that the prosecution failed to prove what kind of explosive was used. It said no importance can be attached to claims of recovery of RDX, circuit boards and detonators, as prosecution failed to prove custody chain before analysis.
The dozen men were in prison all along since their arrests in 2006. While one of them died in 2021, the 11 whose appeals were allowed joined on Monday via video-conferencing from prisons across the state, including Pune's Yerawada and prisons in Nashik, Amravati and Nagpur.
"Bahut bahut shukriya Sir," said a convict, in white prison uniform with a white topi, on video conference from Yerawada, when defence lawyer Yug Chaudhri, conveyed to them in Hindi that they all stood freed.
The HC, in a detailed analysis of the case and evidence on record, said while "prosecution has referred to Al-Qaeda Manual for many things, nothing is brought on record about it."
The prosecution case was that wanted accused Azam Cheema alias Babaji, a Pakistani national, and two of the accused given death sentence as planters had conspired since 1999 to wage war against the govt of India and were in touch with Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT).
Conspiracy meetings were held in Bandra and one accused brought six Pakistanis to Mumbai in 2006, ATS had said. HC wondered why no CDRs were brought on record. "The alleged connection of the accused with Azam Cheema and members of LeT could have been established with the help of CDRs," HC said.
The HC classified prosecution witnesses in four categories: for identification, eyewitnesses of bomb assembly, of conspiracy, and taxi drivers who allegedly ferried two planters.
The court discarded their testimonies as doubtful. For one who claimed to have been to a planter's (A3, an alleged 'jihadist') house where he allegedly saw a few Pakistanis whose names he recalled but did not know what the meeting was for, the HC, doubting his credibility, said that "at the same time, he could not recollect the name of a particular dancer, with whom he had a close relationship for over a month in the same year.
"
Kamal Ansari, given death sentence by the trial judge, died in 2021. He too stood acquitted by HC. Apart from convicts' appeals, before the HC was the state's reference for death sentence confirmation, as required by law for capital punishment to become executable. Thakare and Avdhoot Chimalkar for the state argued the appeals were fit to be dismissed. The conviction relied primarily on the confessions of 11 accused under the stringent MCOCA Act to nail them.
Before HC, an alleged planter Naved Khan, from Nagpur prison, had said he suffered "needlessly for 19 years" and while lives were lost, innocents could not be hanged.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Team Amritpal to challenge MP's continued detention under NSA in SC
Amritsar: Team Amritpal has decided to challenge the imposition of the National Security Act (NSA) against Khadoor Sahib MP Amritpal Singh for the third time in the Supreme Court . The team also expressed resentment over Amritpal's continued solitary confinement in Assam's Dibrugarh Jail, even as nine other persons who were detained alongside Amritpal at the high-security prison had already been shifted to Punjab. Advocate Imaan Singh Khara, legal counsel for Amritpal Singh, informed that he recently met the Lok Sabha member from Khadoor Sahib at Dibrugarh Jail and following the meeting, they have decided to file a petition in the Supreme Court under Article 32 of the Indian Constitution seeking protection of Amritpal Singh's fundamental right to personal liberty and quashing of the third NSA order imposed on him. Amritpal Singh's detention under the NSA was extended for the third time on April 23. Imaan Singh also lamented that Amritpal Singh remained in solitary confinement, even as the other detainees had been transferred to different jails in Punjab. Out of the other nine detainees, four have been transferred to Bathinda Jail, three to Patiala Jail, and one each to Amritsar and Ropar jails, he said. It all began in Feb 2023, when Waris Punjab De activists, led by Amritpal Singh, stormed Ajnala police station under the cover of Guru Granth Sahib demanding the release of their associate Lovepreet Singh Toofan. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Are You From Bangladesh? You Might Qualify For AI Courses Artificial Intelligence Course | Search Ad Undo During the incident, which was widely described as an attack on the state, eight police personnel, including a deputy superintendent of police were injured. Such was the attack that the DSP required 18 stitches. In response, the police on March 18, 2023, launched an operation to apprehend Amritpal and after a month-long manhunt, he was finally arrested on April 23, 2023, from Rode village in Moga district. A senior member of the Team Amritpal, meanwhile, informed that Amritpal had not only given consent to contest the ensuing Tarn Taran byelection under the banner of Akali Dal Waris Punjab Dae, but also called upon the people of the constituency to support the party candidate. Sources said the party was still considering Paramjit Kaur Khalra's name for the bypoll and was in touch with the rights activist. Paramjit Kaur, however, in a post on X, had denied contesting any election. "Very soon we will announce our candidate and begin campaigning," said the source. MSID:: 122922747 413 |


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
AAP govt ridiculed Sikh sacrifice with song and dance: Badal
Chandigarh: Shiromani Akali Dal president Sukhbir Singh Badal accused the Aam Aadmi Party govt of committing an act of "grave sacrilege" against the Sikh religion by trying "shamelessly" to convert the solemn occasion of the anniversary of the martyrdom of Guru Tegh Bahadur into an "entertainment event" at Srinagar. "This is shocking beyond belief," said Badal, adding that this act cannot be dismissed as an "inadvertent" blunder because the chief minister, the minister concerned, Harjot Singh, and several other members of this govt claim to be steeped in Sikh heritage and come from Sikh families. No one in Punjab, not even a non-Sikh, is unaware of the solemnity of the occasion of the ninth Guru Sahib's martyrdom, and none can think of it as an occasion for entertainment. "Acts of sacrilege of Sikh scriptures and shrines are not only happening every other day, but the govt itself felt no shame or guilt in ordering its uniformed police to invade the historically sacred Gurdwara Sahib at Sultanpur Lodhi under direct orders of the chief minister. They opened unprovoked and indiscriminate firing against Sikh religious figures in our Gurdham, and since the CM himself was behind this sacrilegious police assault, no one has even been held accountable for the heinous crime," alleged Badal. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like AirSense 11 – Smart tech for deep sleep ResMed Buy Now Undo Reacting to reports about the performance of musical entertainment acts and items at an event organised by the Punjab government through its language department in Srinagar, Akali Dal chief Parkash Singh Badal described it as "a part of a deep-rooted conspiracy to dilute and belittle the unrivalled Sikh heritage." In a statement issued here, Badal said, "The real motive behind these acts of sacrilege is to distance our future generations from the uniqueness of our glorious history and the religious legacy of our great Guru Sahiban." "By organising song and dance events instead of recitation of sacred Gurbani at the most profoundly solemn occasion of the anniversary of the martyrdom of "Hind di Chadar" Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib, the AAP govt has deliberately sought to ridicule a sublime occasion and to belittle the world's most unique sacrifice in the defence of freedom of conscience, religious tolerance, peace, and communal harmony. This is the ultimate disrespect shown to the great Guru Sahib and an act of "grave sacrilege," said the SAD president. Badal demanded that all those behind the anti-Sikh mindset of this govt must be made to admit and explain the endlessly continuing series of acts of sacrilege against the Sikh heritage and Sikh scriptures in the state.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Custodial death case sparks protest after DSP accused of slapping deceased's son
1 2 3 4 Caption of photo: Villagers stage sit-in protest outside Mangali police post Caption of photo: personnel dismantle tent poles at the protest site in Mangali village Hisar: Tensions escalated on Saturday over the ongoing custodial death case at the Mangali police post, after the deceased's son filed a complaint alleging that DSP Kamaljeet slapped him inside his home and forcibly snatched his mobile phone. Despite the serious nature of the allegation, no action has been taken so far. In protest, villagers and the deceased's family launched an indefinite sit-in outside the Balsamand police post. Tents were set up at the protest site, but police later dismantled them in an attempt to end the demonstration. Undeterred, the villagers continued their protest under the scorching sun. Amit, the son of the deceased Sanjay, submitted a formal complaint to the superintendent of police (SP), stating that his father died in police custody on the night of July 23. He said that after the incident, family members' statements were recorded, a post-mortem was conducted, and the body was cremated. On July 25, around 4 pm, a police and forensic team visited the family's residence. According to Amit, officers recorded his mother's statement and questioned his sister outside the house without the presence of a female police officer. He also alleged that the police dictated statements to his sister and pressured her to sign them. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Libas Purple Days Sale Libas Undo Amit claimed that while the family was cooperating with the forensic team, DSP Kamaljeet entered their home and attempted to forcibly remove him. When he tried to record the incident on his phone, the officer allegedly slapped him and confiscated the device. Upon protesting, Amit said he was threatened and verbally abused by the DSP. He has demanded that an FIR be registered against DSP Kamaljeet, along with officers Sukhbir, Vinay, Jagbir, and police post in-charge Rakesh Kumar. Advocate Zile Singh Kantiwal, chairman of the Human Rights Foundation for Justice, who joined the dharna, said the DSP's actions were illegal and amounted to cognisable offences. He also noted that since the victim's family belongs to a scheduled caste, the incident falls under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. Kantiwal also condemned the dismantling of the protest tents, saying it forced demonstrators to sit in the open sun. He asserted that the protest would continue until an FIR is registered. Village leaders and supporters present at the protest included Mangali Jhara's sarpanch Jogendra, Mangali Aklan's sarpanch Rajesh, former sarpanch Satbir, Ravidas Sabha's former head Sanjay, and locals Virendra, Rohtash, Vinod, Amit, and Manoj Tank. Matter Under Investigation: SP SP Shashank Kumar Sawan confirmed receiving Amit's complaint and said the matter has been assigned to DSP Sunil Kumar for investigation. Attempts were made to contact DSP Kamaljeet for his response, including through text messages, but he has not responded. Hisar: Tensions escalated on Saturday over the ongoing custodial death case at the Mangali police post, after the deceased's son filed a complaint alleging that DSP Kamaljeet slapped him inside his home and forcibly snatched his mobile phone. Despite the serious nature of the allegation, no action has been taken so far. In protest, villagers and the deceased's family launched an indefinite sit-in outside the Balsamand police post. Tents were set up at the protest site, but police later dismantled them in an attempt to end the demonstration. Undeterred, the villagers continued their protest under the scorching sun. Amit, the son of the deceased Sanjay, submitted a formal complaint to the superintendent of police (SP), stating that his father died in police custody on the night of July 23. He said that after the incident, family members' statements were recorded, a post-mortem was conducted, and the body was cremated. On July 25, around 4 pm, a police and forensic team visited the family's residence. According to Amit, officers recorded his mother's statement and questioned his sister outside the house without the presence of a female police officer. He also alleged that the police dictated statements to his sister and pressured her to sign them. Amit claimed that while the family was cooperating with the forensic team, DSP Kamaljeet entered their home and attempted to forcibly remove him. When he tried to record the incident on his phone, the officer allegedly slapped him and confiscated the device. Upon protesting, Amit said he was threatened and verbally abused by the DSP. He has demanded that an FIR be registered against DSP Kamaljeet, along with officers Sukhbir, Vinay, Jagbir, and police post in-charge Rakesh Kumar. Advocate Zile Singh Kantiwal, chairman of the Human Rights Foundation for Justice, who joined the dharna, said the DSP's actions were illegal and amounted to cognisable offences. He also noted that since the victim's family belongs to a scheduled caste, the incident falls under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. Kantiwal also condemned the dismantling of the protest tents, saying it forced demonstrators to sit in the open sun. He asserted that the protest would continue until an FIR is registered. Village leaders and supporters present at the protest included Mangali Jhara's sarpanch Jogendra, Mangali Aklan's sarpanch Rajesh, former sarpanch Satbir, Ravidas Sabha's former head Sanjay, and locals Virendra, Rohtash, Vinod, Amit, and Manoj Tank. Matter Under Investigation: SP SP Shashank Kumar Sawan confirmed receiving Amit's complaint and said the matter has been assigned to DSP Sunil Kumar for investigation. Attempts were made to contact DSP Kamaljeet for his response, including through text messages, but he has not responded.