logo
HC quashes conviction & acquits all 12 accused in 2006 Mumbai train blasts case

HC quashes conviction & acquits all 12 accused in 2006 Mumbai train blasts case

Time of India4 days ago
Mumbai: Severely indicting the prosecution for the case it had made out and the state anti-terror squad for its shoddy probe, the Bombay high court on Monday quashed the conviction of all 12 accused found guilty a decade ago for the July 11, 2006 synchronised Mumbai train blasts between Mahim and Borivli that left 187 dead and 824 injured.
The HC refused to confirm death sentences for five and life sentences given on Sept 30, 2015 to seven by the special court set up under the anti-organised crime Act and acquitted all, directing their immediate release.
Punishment for an actual criminal is essential to uphold the rule of law, but "creating a false appearance of having solved a case… gives a misleading sense of resolution. This deceptive closure undermines public trust and falsely reassures society, while in reality, the true threat remains at large.
Essentially, this is what the case at hand conveys," a special bench of Justices Anil Kilor and Shyam Chandak observed in the introduction to their 671-page judgment, before shredding the prosecution case.
The identification parade was not conducted properly, witnesses identifying accused in dock after four years lacked credibility and MCOCA was invoked without application of mind, the HC said, discarding confession statements relied on for want of "trustworthiness and completeness."
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Gold Is Surging in 2025 — Smart Traders Are Already In
IC Markets
Learn More
Undo
The HC also accepted defence arguments of torture of accused vitiating confessional statements.
You Can Also Check:
Mumbai AQI
|
Weather in Mumbai
|
Bank Holidays in Mumbai
|
Public Holidays in Mumbai
"The prosecution utterly failed to establish the offence beyond reasonable doubt against the accused on each count. It is unsafe to reach the satisfaction that the accused committed the offences for which they were convicted and sentenced," the bench held.
After over six months of hearing and going through more than 44,000 pages of record, Bombay HC concluded the Maharashtra Anti-Terror Squad (ATS) had no case against the 12 accused in the 11/7 train blasts case.
Over two decades ago, bombs planted on first-class compartments exploded during the peak evening commute at seven locations on the Western Railway suburban network. They ripped metal and lives between Khar Road and Santacruz, Bandra and Khar Road, Jogeshwari and Mahim Junction, Mira Road and Bhayander, Matunga and Mahim Junction, and Borivli.
The prosecution case was of sophisticated explosive RDX being used, of accused being members of terror outfits like SIMI who received training in Pakistan, and of 15 wanted accused, mainly Pakistanis.
While the trial court's special MCOCA judge Y D Shinde in 2015 said special public prosecutor Raja Thakare had rightly described the accused as "merchants of death" and Thakare argued that the trial verdict could not be dislodged and the noose be confirmed, the HC noted the prosecution case had unravelled completely.
The HC also held that the prosecution failed to prove what kind of explosive was used. It said no importance can be attached to claims of recovery of RDX, circuit boards and detonators, as prosecution failed to prove custody chain before analysis.
The dozen men were in prison all along since their arrests in 2006. While one of them died in 2021, the 11 whose appeals were allowed joined on Monday via video-conferencing from prisons across the state, including Pune's Yerawada and prisons in Nashik, Amravati and Nagpur.
"Bahut bahut shukriya Sir," said a convict, in white prison uniform with a white topi, on video conference from Yerawada, when defence lawyer Yug Chaudhri, conveyed to them in Hindi that they all stood freed.
The HC, in a detailed analysis of the case and evidence on record, said while "prosecution has referred to Al-Qaeda Manual for many things, nothing is brought on record about it."
The prosecution case was that wanted accused Azam Cheema alias Babaji, a Pakistani national, and two of the accused given death sentence as planters had conspired since 1999 to wage war against the govt of India and were in touch with Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT).
Conspiracy meetings were held in Bandra and one accused brought six Pakistanis to Mumbai in 2006, ATS had said. HC wondered why no CDRs were brought on record. "The alleged connection of the accused with Azam Cheema and members of LeT could have been established with the help of CDRs," HC said.
The HC classified prosecution witnesses in four categories: for identification, eyewitnesses of bomb assembly, of conspiracy, and taxi drivers who allegedly ferried two planters.
The court discarded their testimonies as doubtful. For one who claimed to have been to a planter's (A3, an alleged 'jihadist') house where he allegedly saw a few Pakistanis whose names he recalled but did not know what the meeting was for, the HC, doubting his credibility, said that "at the same time, he could not recollect the name of a particular dancer, with whom he had a close relationship for over a month in the same year.
"
Kamal Ansari, given death sentence by the trial judge, died in 2021. He too stood acquitted by HC. Apart from convicts' appeals, before the HC was the state's reference for death sentence confirmation, as required by law for capital punishment to become executable. Thakare and Avdhoot Chimalkar for the state argued the appeals were fit to be dismissed. The conviction relied primarily on the confessions of 11 accused under the stringent MCOCA Act to nail them.
Before HC, an alleged planter Naved Khan, from Nagpur prison, had said he suffered "needlessly for 19 years" and while lives were lost, innocents could not be hanged.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Orphaned By Maoists, They Vow To Dismantle Red Infra
Orphaned By Maoists, They Vow To Dismantle Red Infra

Time of India

time25 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Orphaned By Maoists, They Vow To Dismantle Red Infra

Nagpur: In 2012, Maoists killed Suresh Alam, a former gram panchayat member in Nandigaon, Gadchiroli, suspecting him of being a police informer. His daughter, Naame Nagamani Alam, has now been directly appointed as a police constable. In 2005, a village warden Lalsu Pungati was lynched in a guerrilla kangaroo court in Nargunda, Gadchiroli. His son, Sainath Pungati, was directly appointed as a police constable. Both received their job letters from chief minister Devendra Fadnavis on July 22. The ceremony marked a significant step in rehabilitation of families affected by Maoist atrocities. So far, 56 victims have been recruited into the police force in three years. Once helpless and cringing under fear after Maoists dragged their fathers out of their homes and slaughtered them in public, these orphans of insurgency have transformed their grief into resolve. Years passed, and the fear diminished as law enforcement turned the tables on the guerrillas. "We witnessed our father's killing. His lifeless body and my inconsolable mother are still fresh in our memory. We will serve the police with sincerity and combat Maoists," said an appointee. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Is What First-Class Living Really Looks Like Explore Undo The Maharashtra govt has now stepped in and is offering an opportunity to those who bore the brunt of Maoist kangaroo courts. Their children are now joining the commando force, determined to dismantle the regime that abruptly snatched their fathers' protective care. "The recruitments are based on special relaxations for Scheduled Tribe categories, requiring only physical attributes and a minimum qualification of Class 7, with no written examinations," SP Gadchiroli, Neelotpal, said. These appointments are part of a 2018 govt decision to rehabilitate Maoist-hit families by offering direct appointments to Group C and D posts in various departments. Fadnavis, who also virtually inaugurated new administrative buildings for police posts at Dechalipetha and Jimlagatta hamlets, stated the govt is keen to rehabilitate families who suffered in the hands of Maoists. The appointment of Naame Nagamani and Sainath by the CM himself symbolizes a powerful shift, stated IG State Anti-naxal operation cell, Sandip Patil. Once victims of Maoist terror, they are now empowered to protect their communities, vowing to end the menace that shattered their families.

Body in canal: Autopsy reveals 14-yr-old boy sexually assaulted, filmed, stabbed 24 times; three minors held
Body in canal: Autopsy reveals 14-yr-old boy sexually assaulted, filmed, stabbed 24 times; three minors held

Time of India

time25 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Body in canal: Autopsy reveals 14-yr-old boy sexually assaulted, filmed, stabbed 24 times; three minors held

New Delhi: Weeks after a 14-year-old boy was murdered and his body discovered in the Munak Canal, the post-mortem report revealed that he had been sexually assaulted. Police had hauled up six people earlier, including two adults, and have now apprehended three more minors from a kanwar camp. According to police, the motive for the murder was the suspicion that the teen was passing on information to two antisocials, one of whom had beaten up the prime accused earlier. The entire incident was recorded on a phone by the accused, who then stabbed the boy 24 times before throwing his body into the canal. "We have apprehended three more minors who were found hiding in a kanwar camp in Meerut," a senior police officer said, adding that a team of nine policemen had disguised themselves as kanwariyas to nab the three minors. The phone in which the horrific act was recorded was also recovered from them. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi Police received a control room alert around 3.10pm on July 1 about a body spotted in Munak Canal in Haiderpur. A team rushed to the spot and found a boy lying naked in the canal with a scarf tied around his neck. There were numerous stab wounds on his body. Tattoo marks and the slender body structure helped police identify the body as that of a 14-year-old boy, a resident of Siraspur. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Medical Mystery Solved: Dementia and Memory Loss Has Been Linked To This Common Thing. Memory Health Learn More Undo A case was registered. Using local intelligence and technical surveillance, the investigators zeroed in on the suspects — two brothers from the same locality as the victim, who had a long-standing enmity with the boy. "The accused, Krishna, 19, and his brother Sumit, 27, allegedly suspected that the minor boy and his friends acted as informers for the Badhawar brothers, who are notorious bootleggers who had thrashed Krishna in public last year," said Hareshwar V Swami, DCP (Outer North). "The Badhawar brothers, Monu and Sonu, are currently in jail under MCOCA in another case at the same police station." The DCP added, "Plotting revenge for months, Krishna, his brother and other friends executed the plan on the intervening night of June 29-30. They abducted the juvenile from near Veer Chowk Bazar, assaulted him and took him on a motorcycle to the Munak Canal." On reaching the canal, the group gagged the boy's mouth with a gamcha, stripped him naked, dumped his clothes into the water and began beating him. In a gruesome sequence, the accused took turns stabbing the boy several times. After ensuring he was dead, they threw his body into the water and fled the scene, the officer said. The motorcycle used in the crime has been recovered.

Joy Taylor blasts Donald Trump over Epstein links just days after Fox firing amid sexual misconduct scandal
Joy Taylor blasts Donald Trump over Epstein links just days after Fox firing amid sexual misconduct scandal

Time of India

time35 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Joy Taylor blasts Donald Trump over Epstein links just days after Fox firing amid sexual misconduct scandal

Joy Taylor takes a jab at Donald Trump over Epstein files (Getty Images) Just days after her departure from Fox Sports, Joy Taylor stirred public debate by weighing in on reports linking Donald Trump to Jeffrey Epstein 's files. Her pointed social media post signaled a bold return to the spotlight, suggesting she's no longer holding back when it comes to political commentary. Joy Taylor takes a jab at Donald Trump over Epstein files just days after Fox Sports firing On July 24, Joy Taylor reposted a story from Complex on her Instagram Stories revealing that Donald Trump had reportedly been notified by the Justice Department that his name appears in documents related to Jeffrey Epstein, the late convicted sex offender. Alongside the post, Taylor wrote a biting caption: 'Water is wet.' The cryptic remark quickly caught fire online, with many interpreting it as a sarcastic confirmation that Trump's name showing up in such files was unsurprising — or perhaps long suspected. While Taylor didn't expand on her message, her decision to comment so soon after her Fox Sports departure suggests she's no longer interested in playing it safe in the public sphere. Joy Taylor's exit from FS1 followed sexual misconduct lawsuit and internal shakeups Taylor's social media moment arrives amid lingering questions surrounding her firing from FS1, where she co-hosted Speak with Keyshawn Johnson and Paul Pierce. Her name was recently included in a January sexual misconduct and discrimination lawsuit filed by former FS1 hairstylist Noushin Faraji. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo The suit also named Skip Bayless and former executive Charlie Dixon, accusing Taylor of downplaying a groping allegation and mocking PTSD symptoms. Taylor has denied the accusations outright, calling them 'meritless and attention-seeking.' However, internal reviews reportedly uncovered additional concerns behind the scenes. Former FS1 host Cris Carter commented on the matter during a podcast appearance, saying, 'They had to tear all those shows down… That thing was ugly… Had to happen.' Donald Trump's Epstein ties spark renewed scrutiny amid political pushback Meanwhile, the Trump-Epstein connection continues to make headlines. A report from The Wall Street Journal claims that Attorney General Pam Bondi informed Trump during a May briefing that his name had surfaced in DOJ files related to Epstein. The White House has dismissed the reports as 'fake news,' insisting that appearing in documents does not imply wrongdoing. Still, Joy Taylor's post suggests public figures are no longer willing to stay quiet — especially when they feel uncensored. Also Read: Joy Taylor's FOX Sports scandal: Everything about the backstage drama, show cancellations, and lawsuit that led to her exit FAQs 1. Why is Joy Taylor in the news after her Fox Sports exit? She posted a controversial reaction to reports linking Donald Trump to Jeffrey Epstein, sparking political backlash. 2. What led to Joy Taylor's departure from Fox Sports? Taylor was named in a sexual misconduct and discrimination lawsuit, prompting a major shakeup at FS1. 3. Did Joy Taylor comment directly on Donald Trump? Yes, she shared a cryptic post seemingly mocking the resurfaced Epstein allegations involving Trump. For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store