Supreme Court to review state bans on transgender athletes in girls' sports
The justices are set to hear challenges to laws in Idaho and West Virginia after lower court rulings in sided with transgender students who sued when they were blocked from competing.
'I am optimistic that after hearing the case, the Supreme Court will restore sanity to athletics and allow West Virginia to enforce its commonsense law that prevents boys from competing in girl's sports,' Mountain State Gov. Patrick Morrisey fired off in an X post.
Advertisement
The Supreme Court agreed Thursday to review whether transgender student athletes can be banned from joining female sports teams at public schools.
AP
Twenty-seven states have passed laws in recent years that restrict participation in female sports for male-to-female trans students.
In Idaho and West Virginia specifically, state laws specify that sports teams at public schools are based on 'biological sex' and ban 'students of the male sex' from joining female athletic teams.
Advertisement
The challenge to the West Virginia law was brought by Becky Pepper-Jackson in 2021 after her middle school banned her from joining the girls' cross country and track teams.
Pepper-Jackson has been taking puberty-blocking medication and has publicly identified as a girl since she was in the third grade.
The justices are set to hear two cases out of Idaho and West Virginia after earlier lower court rulings in each state sided with transgender students who sued.
Getty Images
A federal judge initially ruled in the student's favor at an early stage of the case, but later reversed course and ended up siding with the state.
Advertisement
The 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Jackson's exclusion from girls' teams violated Title IX, which forbids sex discrimination in education.
'[Pepper-Jackson] has been publicly living as a girl for more than five years. During that time, her elementary and middle schools created gender support plans to affirm her gender identity and ensure she is recognized as a girl at school,' the appeals court ruling read. 'To align with her gender identity, [Pepper-Jackson] has changed her name, and the State of West Virginia (whose Act is challenged here) has issued a birth certificate that recognizes her changed name and lists her sex as female. [Pepper-Jackson] also takes puberty blocking medication to prevent her body from experiencing male adolescent development and estrogen hormone therapy, which is leading her to develop the outward physical characteristics—including fat distribution, pelvic shape, and bone size—of an adolescent female. Her family, teachers, and classmates have all known [Pepper-Jackson] as a girl for several years, and—beginning in elementary school—she has participated only on girls athletic teams.
'Given these facts, offering [Pepper-Jackson] a 'choice' between not participating in sports and participating only on boys teams is no real choice at all.'
Meanwhile, the Idaho challenge was brought by Lindsay Hecox — a trans Boise State University student who had tried to join the women's track and cross-country teams, but failed to qualify.
Advertisement
Instead, Hecox has participating in sports clubs, including soccer and running, at the public university.
A federal judge blocked Idaho's law in 2020, ruling that it likely violated the Constitution's Equal Protection Clause and unlawfully discriminated based on sex and transgender status.
The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals upheld initial ruling in 2023 and again in an amended ruling last year.
While the Supreme Court agreed to take up the cases from Idaho and West Virginia, the justices opted not to act on a third case from Arizona that raises the same issue.
The cases will be heard sometime after the justices convene for the new court term Oct. 6.
Last month, the Supreme Court upheld Tennessee's ban on transgender puberty blockers and hormone therapy treatments for minors — a major win for states that have similar laws on the books.
With Post wires
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
an hour ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Raducanu frustrated by racket tension problem in Wimbledon loss to Sabalenka
LONDON (AP) — Emma Raducanu expressed frustration with having to get a couple of her rackets re-strung during her third-round loss to top-ranked Aryna Sabalenka at Wimbledon on Friday. The British player let leads slip in both sets of her 7-6 (6), 6-4 loss at Centre Court with the retractable roof closed. 'I felt like the ball was flying. I had all my rackets strung up fresh for the match, and it just felt like it was pinging completely different,' Raducanu said. 'It could have been a little bit because the roof was on. I sent a couple rackets to be re-strung. 'But it takes, like, 20 minutes by the time they turn it over. Still, it was a bit difficult. So I'm frustrated with that part maybe, small details. But I don't think I could have made different choices. I think I should have just executed better.' Sabalenka agreed 'the balls were flying more,' she suspected, because of higher humidity with the roof closed. The three-time Grand Slam champion said her team typically has extra rackets ready. 'They always have like two extra rackets with the higher tension and two extra rackets with lower tension. They prepare it. You don't have to wait for another racket,' Sabalenka said. Sabalenka said she lost in the 2023 French Open semifinals to Karolina Muchova 'because I didn't have racket' with the right tension. 'We weren't prepared. I didn't have a right tension. I had to play with a lower tension. I didn't control the ball, didn't feel well,' she said. 'After that experience,' she continued, 'we learned it's four extra rackets in my team's bag just in case. You never know. You can wake up and feel great with one tension. Another day you wake up and you don't feel at all. You got to be prepared.' ___ AP tennis:
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Raducanu frustrated by racket tension problem in Wimbledon loss to Sabalenka
Emma Raducanu of Britain returns to Aryna Sabalenka of Belarus during a third round women's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Friday, July 4, 2025. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung) Emma Raducanu of Britain returns to Aryna Sabalenka of Belarus during a third round women's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Friday, July 4, 2025. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung) Emma Raducanu of Britain returns to Aryna Sabalenka of Belarus during a third round women's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Friday, July 4, 2025. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung) Emma Raducanu of Britain returns to Aryna Sabalenka of Belarus during a third round women's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Friday, July 4, 2025. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung) Emma Raducanu of Britain returns to Aryna Sabalenka of Belarus during a third round women's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Friday, July 4, 2025. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung) LONDON (AP) — Emma Raducanu expressed frustration with having to get a couple of her rackets re-strung during her third-round loss to top-ranked Aryna Sabalenka at Wimbledon on Friday. The British player let leads slip in both sets of her 7-6 (6), 6-4 loss at Centre Court with the retractable roof closed. Advertisement 'I felt like the ball was flying. I had all my rackets strung up fresh for the match, and it just felt like it was pinging completely different,' Raducanu said. "It could have been a little bit because the roof was on. I sent a couple rackets to be re-strung. 'But it takes, like, 20 minutes by the time they turn it over. Still, it was a bit difficult. So I'm frustrated with that part maybe, small details. But I don't think I could have made different choices. I think I should have just executed better.' Sabalenka agreed 'the balls were flying more,' she suspected, because of higher humidity with the roof closed. The three-time Grand Slam champion said her team typically has extra rackets ready. Advertisement 'They always have like two extra rackets with the higher tension and two extra rackets with lower tension. They prepare it. You don't have to wait for another racket,' Sabalenka said. Sabalenka said she lost in the 2023 French Open semifinals to Karolina Muchova 'because I didn't have racket' with the right tension. 'We weren't prepared. I didn't have a right tension. I had to play with a lower tension. I didn't control the ball, didn't feel well,' she said. 'After that experience," she continued, "we learned it's four extra rackets in my team's bag just in case. You never know. You can wake up and feel great with one tension. Another day you wake up and you don't feel at all. You got to be prepared.' ___ AP tennis:
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Liberty badly missing injured Jonquel Jones' presence on defense
We've got you covered on the Liberty beat Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Madeline Kenney about all things Liberty and WNBA. tRY IT NOW The importance of Jonquel Jones has never been more evident than over the two-plus weeks when she's been sidelined by an ankle sprain. Jones is the glue of the Liberty on both ends of the floor. Without her, their play looks out of sorts. Offensively, the Liberty have managed to make do without Jones, for the most part. They're getting plenty of good looks and still lead the league in points per game, though possessions, at times, can lag. Defensively, though, is where the Liberty missed Jones most. She is, in a lot of ways, the air traffic controller of the paint and the team's best rim protector. The Liberty's defensive rating when Jones is on the court is 83.7, but when she's on the sidelines, it balloons to 102.6, per WNBA advanced stats. The Liberty have struggled without Jonquel Jones (No. 35) on defense. Getty Images Jones said this week she was upset that her ankle injury derailed her All-Star campaign. But there's no doubt in Sandy Brondello's mind that Jones, when healthy, has been one of the league's best players. 'Look JJ, I think you see when you look at someone, [do] they also have an impact on their team? And you see that she has a very big impact on our team,' Brondello said. 'She was playing great. She's just this comfort blanket. For me, she's an All-Star.' It's still unclear when Jones might be cleared to play. The Liberty said June 21 that she'd be out for 4-6 weeks. Breanna Stewart wasn't happy with the way she started the season, especially when it came to her rebounding efforts. Stewart had three or fewer rebounds in four of the team's first eight games. To put it bluntly, Stewart said her rebounding 'wasn't up to my standard.' But as of late, especially with the Liberty missing Jones, Stewart has been far more aggressive in that area. Jonquel Jones (No. 35) blocks a shot during the Liberty-Mystics game on May 30, 2025. NBAE via Getty Images Stewart notched her third double-double this season Thursday, recording 17 points and a season-high 14 rebounds. Over the last five games, Stewart is averaging 9.4 boards per game. 'I want to clean up everything for my teammates and really getting back to that standard of just being aggressive on the boards, even on the offensive end,' Stewart said. 'It's hard. It's hard when you have to box out the other teams on defense and I want them to feel that same pressure.' Might Unrivaled co-founders and UConn alumni Stewart and Napheesa Collier team up at All-Star weekend later this month? Stewart didn't rule out the possibility that a backroom, handshake deal has already been made with Collier. 'I know things that you don't,' she quipped. 'So that's all I got to say.'
