
Nobody is cutting through government spin like the Act Party
Whether it's pay equity or the Waitangi Tribunal review, the person most committed to combatting government PR is government minister David Seymour.
Only 3.2% of The Spinoff's readership supports us financially. We need to grow that to 4% this year to keep creating the work you love. Sign up to be a member today.
When National moved to put an end to 33 fair pay claims for low-income women, it was adamant the move wasn't about rescuing finance minister Nicola Willis's upcoming budget. Prime minister Chris Luxon seemed annoyed at the suggestion of monetary motivations in a press run last Tuesday. 'It's got nothing to do with the budget, this is about making sure we have a piece of legislation that is incredibly workable, and not as complex as it has been,' he said.
Willis repeated the denial both in parliament and at a press standup alongside an honour guard of women.
More credulous observers may have been taken in by these assurances. Listening to National's senior ministers, this wasn't a case of low-income women paying for general tax cuts and interest write-offs for landlords; it was just a surprise effort to clear up some administrative issues under urgency with no public feedback, weeks out from an uncomfortably tight budget.
Unfortunately for National, its coalition partner Act was having none of that cynical government spin. Incoming deputy prime minister David Seymour was determined to pierce the PR puffery, assuring reporters Van Velden had absolutely bailed National out of having to spend money on stuff like fair wages for childcare workers and hospice nurses. 'I actually think that Brooke van Velden has saved the taxpayer billions,' he said. 'She's saved the budget for the government.'
These Act Party corrections have become common. Media organisations like to say they can cut through spin like Aragorn's sword Andúril through orc flesh, but few of them demolish government messaging more brutally than the second-largest party in the government.
Put out an anodyne press release or make a staid announcement, and Act will give it the Obama anger translator treatment. On Friday, Māori affairs minister Tama Potaka revealed plans to review the Treaty of Waitangi Act 1975 and the Waitangi Tribunal. The move, in his words, was about taking a load off our Tribunal members after years of hard work. 'Given the progress of historical claims and settlements and concerns about the Tribunal's current workload, it is timely to review the legislation that determines how it undertakes its inquiries.'
That sentence is almost boring enough to avoid adding to the anger over efforts to pare back Treaty redress. Potaka might have got away with it too, if it wasn't for those meddling libertarians. On his Facebook page, Seymour explained the true purpose of the review. 'We're reining in the activist Waitangi Tribunal,' he wrote. 'It's time to put the Tribunal in its place.'
Act's spin-killing efforts are, if anything, ramping up. Its statement on the Waitangi Tribunal review marked the third time in a week it lobbed a truth bomb into the National caucus room. Luxon had spent the Friday prior denying Seymour's claim he oversees a 'bloated' ministerial lineup filled with 'meaningless titles'. Once again Act's claims were more convincing to the commentators. Former National minister Chris Finlayson took its side, saying ministerial baubles are given out to placate unimpressive talents in smaller coalition parties such as Act.
Most of these contradictions stem from one foundational inconsistency. Back in January, Seymour claimed Act was wielding 'disproportionate' influence in government. 'If you look at these quarterly plans, often half the ideas come from the party that has only one sixth of the MPs in the government,' he said. Luxon disagreed, telling Morning Report he 'wouldn't describe it that way'.
Their dispute gets to the heart of the government's narrative divergence. In Luxon's telling, we have a mainstream National administration deftly balancing its coalition partners' preoccupations with its own primary focus on the economy and cost of living. In Seymour's, an ideologically malleable major party is being dog-walked into a series of financially iffy and increasingly politically disastrous moves by a coalition partner that won roughly a fifth of its vote.
It's up to you who to believe. Truth is hard to gauge at the best of times in the internet age. But in these situations, it's usually best practice to trust the guys with a history of telling it like it is.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Wool Carpets For State Houses A Win-Win
Press Release – New Zealand Government State housing agency Kinga Ora announced today that from next month, a new supplier agreement will deliver woollen carpets for the fit-out of new state homes. Minister for Economic Growth Hon Mark Patterson Associate Agriculture Minister The return of wool carpets to state homes has been welcomed by Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis and Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson. State housing agency Kāinga Ora announced today that from next month, a new supplier agreement will deliver woollen carpets for the fit-out of new state homes. 'The decision is great news for sheep farmers, and all the New Zealanders whose jobs and incomes are tied to the fortunes of our world-leading wool industry. 'The Government wants wool producers to have more opportunities like this, which is why in March we issued a directive to 130 Government agencies requiring them to purchase woollen products for building construction and refurbishment, wherever practical and appropriate. 'Kāinga Ora's new supplier agreement was made possible because the agency chose to re-open an initially nylon-only carpet tender and give wool a chance to compete. 'I'm told woollen carpet manufacturers responded very strongly to that opportunity and that the new carpet supply agreements come with no additional cost. 'The message is clear: When wool was put back on the table it more than held its own, delivering value for taxpayers and a win for sheep farmers. 'This proves the value of the Government's moves to give wool a fair shot in publicly funded procurement decisions. 'We have directed that from 1 July all public entities must use woollen fibres, where practical and appropriate, in government buildings. The new policy, announced in April, directs agencies to identify opportunities to use woollen products, and to properly consider a range of factors in procurement including whole-of-life cost, sustainability and health benefits. 'We're leveraging government spending to back the wool industry and the New Zealand economy. I hope private businesses will follow our lead.' Mark Patterson says the move continues to deliver on a New Zealand First and National Party coalition agreement to prefer the use of woollen fibres in government buildings. 'Woollen fibres create safer, healthier and more sustainable living environments for families. 'We know farmers will share our enthusiasm about this announcement. It is another example of us doing our bit. The Government is determined to help lift the fortunes of the strong wool sector in supporting our sheep farmers' Mr Patterson says. Notes The total value of the new Kāinga Ora contract is commercially sensitive and so can't be disclosed. Kāinga Ora is expected to fit out about 4500 homes in the next three years. Some contracts for carpet in homes have already been let, but under the new supply agreement, newly contracted fit-outs will be met through the wool-carpet supply contract. Where nylon carpet has already been installed in existing homes Kainga Ora will continue to use nylon carpet for single room or smaller patch repairs.

RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Kāinga Ora to use wool carpet in new state homes
Kāinga Ora has announced it will install wool carpet in state houses from 1 July. Photo: 123rf Kāinga Ora has announced it will use wool carpet in new state homes from July, following a directive that government agencies use wool in the construction and refurbishment of their buildings. The change in procurement rules , to make wool the preferred option in government buildings, was a directive to about 130 agencies in April and takes effect from July. On Wednesday the state housing provider announced it would follow suit, with 4500 new state houses expected to be fitted-out in the next three years. The return of wool carpets to state homes was welcomed by Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis and Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson at Fieldays the same day. "The decision is great news for sheep farmers, and all the New Zealanders whose jobs and incomes are tied to the fortunes of our world-leading wool industry," Willis said. Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis said the decision was great news for sheep farmers. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii She said the government wanted wool producers to have more opportunities to supply woollen products to the construction industry "wherever practical and appropriate". "Kāinga Ora's new supplier agreement was made possible because the agency chose to re-open an initially nylon-only carpet tender and give wool a chance to compete. "I'm told woollen carpet manufacturers responded very strongly to that opportunity and that the new carpet supply agreements come with no additional cost." The new procurement requirements covered government-owned buildings that cost $9 million or more, and refurbishments of more than $100,000. A spokesperson said the total value of the Kāinga Ora contract was commercially sensitive and couldn't be disclosed. They said some contracts for carpet in homes had already been let, but under the new supply agreement newly contracted fit-outs would be met through the wool-carpet supply contract. Where nylon carpet had already been installed in existing homes Kāinga Ora would continue to use nylon carpet for single room or smaller patch repairs. File photo. A new Kāinga Ora home in Richmond, August 2023. Photo: RNZ / Samantha Gee Willis said the message was clear. "When wool was put back on the table it more than held its own, delivering value for taxpayers and a win for sheep farmers." She said the new policy directed government agencies to identify opportunities to use woollen products, and to properly consider a range of factors in procurement including whole-of-life cost, sustainability and health benefits. "We're leveraging government spending to back the wool industry and the New Zealand economy. I hope private businesses will follow our lead." She previously said natural qualities allowed wool to dampen sound and absorb pollutants, while woollen fibres contributed to healthier indoor environments by naturally regulating humidity and improving air quality. Patterson said the move continued to deliver on a New Zealand First and National Party coalition agreement to prefer woollen fibres in government buildings. "Woollen fibres create safer, healthier and more sustainable living environments for families." He said the sector contributed $549m to the economy in the financial year ending 2024 from exporting processed and unprocessed wool products. "The government is determined to help lift the fortunes of the strong wool sector in supporting our sheep farmers."


Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Wool Carpets For State Houses A Win-Win
Minister for Economic Growth Hon Mark Patterson Associate Agriculture Minister The return of wool carpets to state homes has been welcomed by Economic Growth Minister Nicola Willis and Associate Agriculture Minister Mark Patterson. State housing agency Kāinga Ora announced today that from next month, a new supplier agreement will deliver woollen carpets for the fit-out of new state homes. 'The decision is great news for sheep farmers, and all the New Zealanders whose jobs and incomes are tied to the fortunes of our world-leading wool industry. 'The Government wants wool producers to have more opportunities like this, which is why in March we issued a directive to 130 Government agencies requiring them to purchase woollen products for building construction and refurbishment, wherever practical and appropriate. 'Kāinga Ora's new supplier agreement was made possible because the agency chose to re-open an initially nylon-only carpet tender and give wool a chance to compete. 'I'm told woollen carpet manufacturers responded very strongly to that opportunity and that the new carpet supply agreements come with no additional cost. 'The message is clear: When wool was put back on the table it more than held its own, delivering value for taxpayers and a win for sheep farmers. 'This proves the value of the Government's moves to give wool a fair shot in publicly funded procurement decisions. 'We have directed that from 1 July all public entities must use woollen fibres, where practical and appropriate, in government buildings. The new policy, announced in April, directs agencies to identify opportunities to use woollen products, and to properly consider a range of factors in procurement including whole-of-life cost, sustainability and health benefits. 'We're leveraging government spending to back the wool industry and the New Zealand economy. I hope private businesses will follow our lead.' Mark Patterson says the move continues to deliver on a New Zealand First and National Party coalition agreement to prefer the use of woollen fibres in government buildings. 'Woollen fibres create safer, healthier and more sustainable living environments for families. 'We know farmers will share our enthusiasm about this announcement. It is another example of us doing our bit. The Government is determined to help lift the fortunes of the strong wool sector in supporting our sheep farmers' Mr Patterson says. Notes The total value of the new Kāinga Ora contract is commercially sensitive and so can't be disclosed. Kāinga Ora is expected to fit out about 4500 homes in the next three years. Some contracts for carpet in homes have already been let, but under the new supply agreement, newly contracted fit-outs will be met through the wool-carpet supply contract. Where nylon carpet has already been installed in existing homes Kainga Ora will continue to use nylon carpet for single room or smaller patch repairs.