Former top RBA official says it risks falling into persistent policy error
Former RBA assistant governor Luci Ellis, who is now Westpac's chief economist, described the decision — by a six-to-three majority of the monetary policy board — to wait before cutting rates again as "uncharitable".
Westpac and its customers rely on her interpretation of what the Reserve Bank Monetary Policy Board will do with interest rates from meeting to meeting.
And, although she suspected the Reserve Bank might wait until August to cut interest rates again, she still switched her forecast to a July interest rate cut after weak monthly inflation figures were released by the ABS a fortnight ago.
"One of the reasons I [originally forecast the next interest rate cut in August] was a sense that … they would wait, thinking that they wouldn't use the full information set available to them now," she explained.
In other words, Dr Ellis assumed the Monetary Policy Board would wait for the more comprehensive June quarter inflation data before cutting interest rates.
"It felt a little bit uncharitable [to forecast that]," she said.
However, the majority of six opted for a cautious approach, waiting for that more detailed data to confirm that inflation was falling in line with the Reserve Bank's forecasts, which have it hitting 2.6 per cent — close to the mid-point of the 2–3 per cent target.
In a LinkedIn post late on Tuesday, Dr Ellis expressed some frustration over the RBA's decision to leave the cash rate unchanged.
"Why on earth wait?" she wrote.
In the post-meeting statement, the RBA explained that "the board judged that it could wait for a little more information to confirm that inflation remains on track to reach 2.5 per cent on a sustainable basis".
However, Dr Ellis found that explanation unconvincing.
"I think it was quite an unconfident call by the RBA not to move this time," Dr Ellis said.
"Unless they really think they might not move in August, it wasn't clear why [the RBA] didn't already have enough information to make that decision."
The Reserve Bank Monetary Policy Board said it would "be attentive to the data and the evolving assessment of risks to guide its decisions".
"In doing so," the board said, "it will pay close attention to developments in the global economy and financial markets, trends in domestic demand, and the outlook for inflation and the labour market."
The next ABS Labour Force data will be published on July 17, while the June quarter CPI data will be released on July 30.
But Dr Ellis argued the RBA was focused almost exclusively on the quarterly inflation data.
"This has been the rounds that we've been on for the last 18 months," she lamented.
"It shouldn't, in some sense, come down to one number, but each quarter it has.
"I mean the number of times that our [interest] rate calls have hinged on [the question], 'Was there a surprise [in that CPI data]?' — it's kind of a clunky way to have to make your [interest] rate forecasts.
"But on the other hand, they're at the point where they're trying to work out if inflation really is comfortably inside the 2 to 3 per cent target range, whether it's going stay there, whether it's going to get to that 2.5 per cent [inflation] rate."
Dr Ellis believed that was not the best way to make monetary policy decisions.
"It's going to keep coming down to the quarterly CPI, and it will mean that people focus so much on that number instead of on the broader assessment of the economy," she cautioned.
"And that's a shame."
Investment firm, Deutsche Bank, similarly took aim at what it perceived as contradictory language in the RBA's communications.
"The [RBA's] post-meeting statement notes that: 'While recent monthly CPI Indicator data suggest that June quarter inflation is likely to be broadly in line with the forecast, they were, at the margin, slightly stronger than expected,'" chief economist Phil O'Donaghoe noted.
"We struggle to interpret what the RBA means with this phrase.
There were a few economists, however, who anticipated the central bank's decision to leave interest rates unchanged.
Betashares chief economist David Bassanese was one of them.
"As I have consistently argued in recent weeks, the case to cut rates today was never compelling," he noted.
"While consumer spending remains stubbornly weak, the labour market remains strong.
"And while the recent monthly CPI report showed a large decline in annual trimmed mean inflation to 2.4 per cent, monthly reports are notoriously volatile.
"Only the month prior, trimmed mean annual inflation was at 2.8 per cent."
Underlying inflation at 2.8 per cent indicates price growth more broadly in the economy could easily move outside the RBA's 2 to 3 per cent comfort zone.
"To my mind," Mr Bassanese added, "the RBA [will] wait for the more reliable quarterly CPI report later this month to confirm a decline in underlying inflation before cutting rates again in August."
Dr Ellis, however, argued this approach could push the RBA into chronic policy error.
"I think where there is a risk partly around the idea that maybe the RBA is seeking so much certainty in the data that they end up continuously behind the curve more generally," she warned.
"So if it forms into a pattern of behaviour where the RBA doesn't have the courage of its analysis, isn't willing to make a forecast that is anything other than locked in based on backward-looking data, that would be a problem.
"But it's not what we're seeing yet."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Rooftop solar and home batteries could reduce the need for wind farms, research finds
At first blush, Suzanne Bradshaw and Greg Ash could be your typical household power consumers. They live in a house they built six years ago on a battleaxe block in the inner Perth suburb of Mount Lawley. Like so many households, theirs is one that increasingly relies on electricity — from the gadgets under their roof to the solar panels on top of it. But look a little closer and a different picture emerges. In a workshop attached to the house are a number of kilns — electric furnaces used by Ash to make glass. "I've been working on glass, this type of glass, for 23 years now," the 72-year-old says. "So they [the kilns] can consume a fair bit of power." Given their power needs, the couple have had to take steps to mitigate their exposure to the grid — and its associated costs. They were early adopters of solar power, forking out more than $20,000 for panels when the technology was still relatively expensive. In 2019, when they moved into their new house, they installed an even bigger system and followed it up with a battery a couple of years later. And to round it out, they have signed up for a type of dynamic pricing known as a time-of-use tariff, enabling them to draw dirt cheap power off the grid between 9am and 3pm every day. It costs them about nine cents for every kilowatt hour they buy from their retailer during those hours — but up to 45 cents per kilowatt hour at other times. "The good thing about that is if it's an overcast day and you're not getting as much solar coming in, you can top up your battery during the middle of the day," Bradshaw says. "That also means we're not using electricity during the peak… that other consumers need." The couple's circumstances are increasingly common among Australian consumers. Australia has long led the world in its adoption of rooftop solar and Western Australia is no exception. There are more than four million small-scale solar installations across the country's homes and businesses — equivalent to about one in three customers. It's a similar figure in WA, where about 400,000 small-scale customers have solar. And now, courtesy of generous subsidies led by the Commonwealth, uptake of batteries is booming, too. For the first time, registrations for batteries under the Federal Government's small-scale green energy scheme exceeded those for solar panels in July. A new report commissioned by the office of Brad Pettitt, the leader of the WA Greens, is urging the Cook Government to go much further. The report, written by green power advocates Sustainable Energy Now, suggests WA has barely scratched the surface of its rooftop solar capacity. It says "only 13 per cent of the potential capacity" for rooftop solar has been realised in WA's main grid, which spans the country's south-western corner. And it notes that of those customers who have solar, fewer than one in 20 have a battery as well. The lobby argues that better capitalising on WA's capacity for small-scale solar power and batteries could dramatically cut the need for large-scale projects required as part of the transition away from fossil fuels. "Fully utilising suitable rooftops" could slash the need for wind and solar farms while halving the requirement for new high-voltage power lines and saving billions, it argues. Crucially, it says small-scale solutions will also be much quicker than large-scale ones, a key advantage given the government's plan to get out of coal power by 2029. Pettitt says the state's current plan, which relies on large-scale projects, is off track. "The fastest and fairest way to decarbonise is actually utilising our rooftops," Pettitt says. "There are savings in the billions around needing less transmission. "We're saying 'let's get smart about this, using existing rooftops, we don't need to clear vegetation, we don't need to put in new transmission, we can do it now and we can do it quickly'." Not everyone supports the proposal. Greg Watkinson, the former chief executive of WA's economic watchdog and a director of Electricity Market Advisory Services, says there are risks for consumers in the plan. He says there are significant costs incurred by households and small businesses when they invest in solar panels and batteries and many can over-capitalise. By contrast, he says there are economies of scale when big businesses invest in large-scale projects such as major batteries and wind farms. What's more, he says those big businesses are sophisticated investors "who know what they're doing and it's their money to burn — if they waste it, it's on them". "The risk is that households end up spending too much," Watkinson says. "If we ended up having solar panels on everyone's roofs, maybe we'd be spending too much. "I expect we would be, so I don't think that's the way to go." WA Energy Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson declined a request for an interview. Instead, she issued a statement in which she said the government "recognises the importance of harnessing our vast rooftop solar resource". The Minister noted the government is helping up to 100,000 households to get batteries through its — albeit watered down — subsidy scheme. Glass artist Greg Ash thinks he's ahead of the game now he's got a battery along with his solar panels. "All you have to do is look at what's happening in the eastern states as opposed to here," Ash says. "We're better off with our power and gas than they are, but it will come back and bite us here, so people should be looking at solar and battery. "And hopefully that will get cheaper for the average person."
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Queensland's 'extreme' house price growth expected to continue amid new laws
Experts say south-east Queensland's "extreme rate" of property price growth is unlikely to be affected by new seller disclosure laws which came into effect in August. Under the new laws, sellers must provide a mandatory comprehensive disclosure statement before signing a contract. It must include any relevant information about land contamination, zoning, heritage listings, transport resumption plans and accurate rates and water charges. But with Brisbane leading the country in profitable property resales, Domain's Dr Nicola Powell said south-east Queensland remains a sellers' market. More than 99 per cent of properties on the market in Brisbane sold for a profit in the first six months of 2025, according to new data from Domain. The median profit from a house sale in Brisbane was $480,000 – up from $145,000 in 2019. "Brisbane's almost been in this kind of super cycle," Dr Powell said. "There are a lot of things happening economically for south-east Queensland and there's a lot of competition when you think about the lack of new homes being built." With the Brisbane 2032 Olympic and Paralympic Games on the horizon, competition from the infrastructure sector will draw workers away from residential building, Dr Powell said. Real estate agents claim the changes have led to a 'bottleneck' in sales, but Dr Powell said the laws bring Queensland in line with other states and territories. "This is about strengthening the property sector," Dr Powell said. "It's about ensuring buyers have all of the information they need. "We have to remember most people's largest asset [is] their home. If you've got a seller trying to manipulate the system or hide something about the property, what this is trying to do is add that level of transparency." Dr Powell said the high costs associated with the property market means owners are holding on to their homes for longer. "Things like stamp duty, which are really a disincentive to move. They add tens of thousands of dollars to a property transaction," she said. A new rate cut from the Reserve Bank — the third so far in 2025 — will have a "short-lived" impact on the Brisbane market, Antonia Mercorella from the Real Estate Institute of Queensland (REIQ) said. "There tends to be a bit of a holding pattern that occurs around the time of the [rate cut] announcement," Ms Mercorella said. "It's probably not as significant as one might think simply because the demand for property here is just so incredibly strong." Ms Mercorella said she believes the "scarcity problem" will continue to drive prices up. "Even if people aren't getting those interest rate cuts that they're hoping for, they're still needing to secure that shelter, so that's ultimately what's the biggest factor at play," she said. While it might not impact prices, the new disclosure scheme could initially see some contracts delayed, Ms Mercorella said. "There are concerns that it will slow things down. As time marches on, we will get better at preparing these disclosure documents." For sellers frustrated by a new legislative hurdle, Ms Mercorella said preparation is key. 'The moment you are engaging a real estate agent that's when you should start thinking about the preparation of that seller disclosure statement so that it doesn't lead to delays when a buyer comes along,' she said. Ms Mercorella said the changes could also help sellers and potentially lead to fewer contract terminations. "There is an argument to be made that actually they may reduce the number of contract terminations because a buyer is entering into the contract with better knowledge about the key matters affecting the property." "It enables you to identify any issues affecting the property of a negative nature that could be addressed before putting it on the market."
ABC News
5 hours ago
- ABC News
Homelessness grows in south-east SA as house prices rise
Housing costs have almost doubled in south-eastern South Australia over the past five years, which a charity says is leading to homelessness as people move to the area assuming it is more affordable than other parts of the country. Figures from PropTrack show the average price for a house or unit sold in the Limestone Coast, the Riverland, the Murraylands and the Fleurieu Peninsula in July was $518,000 — up 13 per cent on a year earlier and up 97 per cent since July 2020. Sale prices in regional South Australia have increased by 93 per cent in the same period — more than any capital city or regional part of another state. "Home prices are expected to break into new territory later this year, with further interest rate cuts expected to add momentum to price growth," REA Group senior economist Anne Flaherty said. New data from the Australian Taxation Office shows the largest city in the area, Mount Gambier, had a median taxable income of $50,567 in 2022–23 — up 15 per cent on five years earlier. Non-government organisation chief executive Shane Maddocks said homelessness was a big and growing problem in Mount Gambier, with high demand for the few houses available. "We have people — families — coming in from interstate as well. "They think, 'oh well, country South Australia, there'll be cheaper housing' — that's not the case and we prioritise local people [for help]." Over the past five years, weekly rents are up 73 per cent to $450 on average for a house in Mount Gambier, according to the state government agency Consumer and Business Services, where bonds are lodged for new leases. helped Danielle Malseed find a home in Mount Gambier. She moved to the South East from the Northern Territory, thinking she could find a house more easily than in the Top End. But she ended up sleeping on a floor. Ms Malseed said it was hard to afford a home on her and her partner's income because they had five children. "We searched for a house for a very long time, tried different services, different states," she said. "[ were the only people that actually listened to me and took my story seriously — I did get laughed at a few times, which was very weird." Despite the price increases and low income growth in the region, real estate agent Macey Humphries said there were people still able to buy their first home in Mount Gambier. "The most popular property for a first home buyer is under the $500,000 mark and we're definitely seeing properties come on the market like that," she said. However, she said quite a few buyers were people who had moved from Adelaide looking for more affordable properties. "We still are seeing first home buyers breaking into the market," she said. Kim Cawthorne recently sold a house in Mount Gambier for a record $1.46 million. "We've certainly got eyes on Mount Gambier from interstate and intrastate buyers," she said. "There's a lot of investment in business in Mount Gambier and that's bringing in buyers that are looking for nice properties."
