Farming group ‘not ruling out legal action' over NAP proposals for NI
The Northern Ireland Minister for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, Andrew Muir, launched a public consultation on the NAP for 2026 to 2029, last month, which he said contains 'additional measures which have been developed based on scientific research'.
The main additional measures include further restrictions on use of chemical phosphorus fertiliser and a farm phosphorus balance limit for more intensive farms.
According to Minister Muir research shows that around 62% of the high nutrient (phosphorus) levels in Northern Ireland's waterbodies 'come from agricultural sources'.
But the UFU believes these new proposals could 'devastate local farming' – a view it conveyed during meetings this week with the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs in Northern Ireland (DAERA) and the Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute in relation to the new NAP proposals.
According to William Irvine, president of the UFU, the organisation also told Minister Andrew Muir this week during a meeting that the consultation process around the new NAP proposals has been 'deeply flawed'.
(L-R) UFU president William Irvine and UFU deputy president John McLenaghan at Stormont Source: UFU
Irvine added: 'There has been no economic impact assessment and no thorough engagement was carried out with stakeholders ahead of the consultation publication.
'The farming community acknowledge the need to improve water quality and we will play our part in a holistic approach, but we feel totally blindsided.
'Our members are frustrated that proposals of such magnitude have been brought forward without thorough analysis of the real-world impact on farm businesses, food production and rural livelihoods.'
NAP
According to the UFU the new NAP proposals could impact on thousands of farmers across Northern Ireland and result in many having to find more land for slurry spreading or cut their livestock numbers.
Irvine has said the next step for the UFU is to its next 'course of action'.
''We are not ruling out legal action.
'Our members expect us to stand up for them, and that's exactly what we intend to do,' Irvine added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on climate policy: Government must avoid backsliding
Methane arising from agriculture and the fossil fuel industry is a notorious greenhouse gas, contributing significantly to global warming. While it breaks down relatively quickly in the atmosphere – unlike carbon dioxide – it is a serious threat to climate stabilisation. The quicker it is reduced, the more global average temperatures can be cut. Much can be done to reduce methane releases in oil and gas production, but it is much more challenging in agriculture. Livestock exporting countries like Ireland and New Zealand are supporting a new approach to classifying methane which is gaining political traction. This is based around achieving national 'temperature neutrality', also known as 'no additional warming'. The Government has yet to take a formal position on the concept. Significantly it got the backing of the Climate Change Advisory Council, its key advisory body. It chose to interpret Ireland's legally-binding climate neutrality obligations in terms of temperature neutrality – rather than the more onerous target of 'net zero emissions'. An international study , published in the Environmental Research Letters journal this week, has questioned this approach. It says that it 'grandfathers high emissions from wealthy, livestock-exporting nations', shifts the burden of cutting emissions to others, and limits space for lower-income countries to grow food systems. The approach fails on food security grounds, with trade data showing most exports serve high-income markets. This risks locking in inequality and misses 'a critical opportunity to reduce peak warming'. READ MORE The most concerning finding was highlighted by lead researcher Dr Colm Duffy of the University of Galway: 'If every country adopted a temperature neutrality target, we'd seriously jeopardise the Paris agreement's goal of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees or even 2 degrees.' The Government is in a bind on this. How methane is regarded in policy terms has big implications for carbon budgets up to 2040, which must be signed off on soon. Climatologist Prof John Sweeney has argued that the shift, which reduces the required emissions reduction target, is not aligned with scientific recommendations and could hinder Ireland's ability to meet its climate goals. The study emphasises that governments must set targets that are internationally credible and farmers need to be supported within a national framework, rather than targeted for blame. The bottom line is that Ireland will not meet the global climate challenge by redefining climate targets. Ireland has yet to deliver an honest appraisal of what a genuinely climate-neutral, sustainable and resilient agricultural sector could look like in coming decades. Avoiding this issue would amount to backsliding on vital climate action.
Agriland
6 days ago
- Agriland
TD: Forgotten Farmer scheme 'excludes many it was meant to help'
Independent Ireland TD Richard O'Donoghue has written to the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon to highlight "serious flaws" in the new Forgotten Farmer scheme. Deputy O'Donoghue warned that the current criteria for the scheme will 'once again exclude many of the very farmers it was meant to help". The TD believes that while the introduction of the scheme was intended to address a long-standing injustice, overly restrictive conditions and a rushed application process mean it risks repeating the same mistakes of the past. He said: "The idea of the Forgotten Farmer scheme was to give fair treatment to those who missed out on vital entitlements and supports. 'But the way it has been designed means that farmers who started in 2008, 2009, 2010 and thereafter – who also never received payments or installation aid – are still being shut out. They have been forgotten twice," Deputy O'Donoghue added. Deputy O'Donoghue also criticised the 'no older than 40 in 2015' age limit, pointing out that it penalises farmers who started later in life but are still genuine cases. 'The reality on the ground is that some people enter farming later for family or economic reasons, but they are still building a future in agriculture. They deserve to be included,' he said. The Limerick County TD added that the three-week application window – during peak summer holiday season – is 'farcical' and is preventing many eligible farmers from applying. He said: 'Farmers can't get the required paperwork from accountants, solicitors or agricultural colleges when they are closed or on holidays, and even when they have everything in place, they are facing issues. This needs an urgent fix and an extension to the deadline. Deputy O'Donoghue called on Minister Heydon to "widen" the eligibility criteria to cover all genuine forgotten farmers, extend the application deadline well beyond the summer holiday period, and to ensure the process is accessible and realistic for farmers and their advisors. 'If we want to encourage the next generation into farming, we have to start by rectifying the injustices faced by previous generations. This scheme should be about fairness and inclusion – not about creating a new group of forgotten farmers,' Deputy O'Donoghue said.
Agriland
08-08-2025
- Agriland
Farm safety survey: 75% of NI farmers fear being hit by an animal
More farmers are following safer work practices according to new figures from a farm safety survey released by the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) and the Farm Safety Partnership (FSP). The findings from the 2023 Farm Safety Survey also revealed 90% of farmers reported they had no minor injuries or near misses on the farm in the previous 12 months. DAERA Minister Andrew Muir welcomed the statistics saying they were useful to help understand further the risks. 'These farm safety figures are vital to help us understand the scale and nature of the risk's farmers are facing and the barriers preventing improvements to keep themselves, their workers and families safe," Minister Muir said. 'They also help us shape our policies and develop targeted practical measures to protect lives. Our goal is to use them to improve standards and save lives on our farms." Deputy chief executive of the Health and Safety Executive for Northern Ireland (HSENI), and vice-chair of the FSP, Bryan Monson welcomed the findings but said more still needs to be done to keep farmers safe. 'We're very encouraged by the figures that show fewer farmers never carry a child in a tractor, work with a loose bull, or remain beside an underground slurry tank while slurry was mixing," he said. "However, farming remains one of our most dangerous sectors with too many farmers still being injured or killed in what are preventable accidents. 'Worryingly, the statistics also show more farmers are suffering injuries that require medical attention and that they are taking longer off work as a result, possibly indicating an increase in the severity of the injuries,' he said. Other findings included: One in 10 (10%) experienced a minor injury and/or a near miss in the previous 12 months; 2% of farmers reported an accident that required medical attention with 48% suffering a fracture and 29% a laceration; Some 27% of those injured took more than 30 days off work compared to 16% in 2019; Less than half (45%) of those who had an accident did not require any time off work to recover; The main causes of accidents were being hit by an animal (33%) and slips at ground level (20%). The findings also revealed that 75% of farmers identified being hit or trampled by an animal as a hazard they are most concerned about while 71% are worried about slipping or tripping. Barriers to working safely included cost (77%) followed by time pressures from farm work (48%) or employment outside the farm (32%). Monson said farmers need to make safety a priority: 'I'd urge our farmers to take time each day, with every task, to stop, think and plan when working with machinery, livestock or carrying out maintenance. 'Our Stop and Think SAFE campaign is a simple but powerful message that reflects the four main causes of fatal accidents on local farms – slurry, animals, falls from height and equipment. "We know time and costs pressures are real but keeping yourself safe is not optional – it must come first to protect lives, families and livelihoods,' he added. The Farm Safety Partnership comprises: HSENI; DAERA; Ulster Farmers' Union (UFU); NFU Mutual; Young Farmers' Clubs of Ulster (YFCU); Farm Safety Foundation (FSF); Northern Ireland Agricultural Producers' Association (NIAPA); Rural Support. It is tasked with assisting Northern Ireland's farming community to work safely and tackle the problem of work-related fatalities and injuries on farms.
