TD: Forgotten Farmer scheme 'excludes many it was meant to help'
Deputy O'Donoghue warned that the current criteria for the scheme will 'once again exclude many of the very farmers it was meant to help".
The TD believes that while the introduction of the scheme was intended to address a long-standing injustice, overly restrictive conditions and a rushed application process mean it risks repeating the same mistakes of the past.
He said: "The idea of the Forgotten Farmer scheme was to give fair treatment to those who missed out on vital entitlements and supports.
'But the way it has been designed means that farmers who started in 2008, 2009, 2010 and thereafter – who also never received payments or installation aid – are still being shut out. They have been forgotten twice," Deputy O'Donoghue added.
Deputy O'Donoghue also criticised the 'no older than 40 in 2015' age limit, pointing out that it penalises farmers who started later in life but are still genuine cases.
'The reality on the ground is that some people enter farming later for family or economic reasons, but they are still building a future in agriculture. They deserve to be included,' he said.
The Limerick County TD added that the three-week application window – during peak summer holiday season – is 'farcical' and is preventing many eligible farmers from applying.
He said: 'Farmers can't get the required paperwork from accountants, solicitors or agricultural colleges when they are closed or on holidays, and even when they have everything in place, they are facing issues. This needs an urgent fix and an extension to the deadline.
Deputy O'Donoghue called on Minister Heydon to "widen" the eligibility criteria to cover all genuine forgotten farmers, extend the application deadline well beyond the summer holiday period, and to ensure the process is accessible and realistic for farmers and their advisors.
'If we want to encourage the next generation into farming, we have to start by rectifying the injustices faced by previous generations. This scheme should be about fairness and inclusion – not about creating a new group of forgotten farmers,' Deputy O'Donoghue said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
3 days ago
- Agriland
TD: Forgotten Farmer scheme 'excludes many it was meant to help'
Independent Ireland TD Richard O'Donoghue has written to the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon to highlight "serious flaws" in the new Forgotten Farmer scheme. Deputy O'Donoghue warned that the current criteria for the scheme will 'once again exclude many of the very farmers it was meant to help". The TD believes that while the introduction of the scheme was intended to address a long-standing injustice, overly restrictive conditions and a rushed application process mean it risks repeating the same mistakes of the past. He said: "The idea of the Forgotten Farmer scheme was to give fair treatment to those who missed out on vital entitlements and supports. 'But the way it has been designed means that farmers who started in 2008, 2009, 2010 and thereafter – who also never received payments or installation aid – are still being shut out. They have been forgotten twice," Deputy O'Donoghue added. Deputy O'Donoghue also criticised the 'no older than 40 in 2015' age limit, pointing out that it penalises farmers who started later in life but are still genuine cases. 'The reality on the ground is that some people enter farming later for family or economic reasons, but they are still building a future in agriculture. They deserve to be included,' he said. The Limerick County TD added that the three-week application window – during peak summer holiday season – is 'farcical' and is preventing many eligible farmers from applying. He said: 'Farmers can't get the required paperwork from accountants, solicitors or agricultural colleges when they are closed or on holidays, and even when they have everything in place, they are facing issues. This needs an urgent fix and an extension to the deadline. Deputy O'Donoghue called on Minister Heydon to "widen" the eligibility criteria to cover all genuine forgotten farmers, extend the application deadline well beyond the summer holiday period, and to ensure the process is accessible and realistic for farmers and their advisors. 'If we want to encourage the next generation into farming, we have to start by rectifying the injustices faced by previous generations. This scheme should be about fairness and inclusion – not about creating a new group of forgotten farmers,' Deputy O'Donoghue said.
Agriland
5 days ago
- Agriland
Agri committee chair: More funding needed for 'Forgotten Farmers'
The chair of the Oireachtas Committee on Agriculture and Food Aindrias Moynihan has called for increased funding to support Long Established Young Farmers, commonly referred to as 'Forgotten Farmers'. The Fianna Fáil TD for Cork North-West said that the €5 million allocated in Budget 2025 to provide support to this group is 'only a first step in righting historic wrongs'. The so-called 'Forgotten Farmers' are individuals who were under 40 in 2015 and began farming before 2008. Due to the timing of their entry into agriculture, they were excluded from young farmer supports under the 2015 Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), missing out on installation aid and other key supports available to their contemporaries. The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) said that the scheme for Forgotten Farmers will open for online applications until 5:30p.m on August 13, 2025. The department said that applicants can avail of a payment of up to €5,000 (depending on application numbers). Commenting on the scheme, Deputy Moynihan said: 'This is about justice and fairness. These farmers were unfairly excluded from critical supports through no fault of their own". "They've been overlooked for far too long, and this scheme is a long-overdue recognition of their contribution to Irish agriculture. 'While I welcome the scheme's introduction, it is only the beginning. Justice must be meaningful. These farmers deserve not just recognition, but adequate compensation. "I'm glad to see the scheme come to fruition, but now we must build on it to ensure those who were left behind finally receive what they are due," he said. Deputy Moynihan said these farmers 'met every requirement, except the cut-off date". "That was the only thing that disqualified them. Despite this, they've kept working hard without the supports others received, placing them at an unfair advantage. "While the scheme offers payments of up to €5,000 per farmer, it won't fully make up for the years of lost support," he added. Deputy Moynihan said that he will continue to raise this issue with the Minister for Agriculture Food and the Marine Martin Heydon throughout the upcoming budget negotiations. "If we're going to right a wrong, we must ensure we get it right," he said.
Agriland
6 days ago
- Agriland
UFU: Impartiality 'extremely important' for NI NAP stakeholder forum
Everything is yet to be played for in developing a new Nitrates Action Programme (NAP) for Northern Ireland, according to Ulster Farmers' Union (UFU) president, William Irvine. Speaking at this year's Clogher Valley Show, he said: 'We still have to see the terms of reference for the new stakeholder forum. 'The appointment of an independent chairperson will be extremely important within this process.' According to the UFU president, the direct appointment of a chair by Minister of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, Andrew Muir is not acceptable. Irvine added: 'Such an approach cannot be considered as being an impartial process. The farming and food industry stakeholder groups must have a role in the appointment of the chairperson, whose job it will be to drive forward the work of the new forum. 'Minister Muir says that he wants to see a new NAP agreed that will not harm the future prospects for food production. 'The UFU will be holding him to this commitment.' Irvine has also confirmed that getting key changes to the recently published UK finance bill will remain a key priority for the UFU during the period ahead. This legislative measure is the parliamentary vehicle through which the chancellor can introduce changes to Inheritance tax. The UFU president explained: 'We want to come up with a solution that meets the unique circumstances that confront farmers here in Northern Ireland. 'However, all the UK farming unions are at one on this fundamentally important matter.' According to Irvine, the union will make every effort to lobby politicians from all parties in the UK government on the inheritance tax issue over the coming weeks. It is anticipated that these measures will include a meeting with the chancellor, Rachel Reeves. Meanwhile, an alternative inheritance tax proposal has been drawn up by the UK farming unions and the Central Association for Agricultural Valuers (CAAV). If implemented, proposal would see potential inheritance tax liabilities reduced by a seventh every year for seven years after an agricultural holding is passed on to the next generation as a working farm business. According to Irvine: 'It's an approach that would mean that no inheritance tax would be paid on land and assets that are retained as part of a working farm business. 'But at a more general level, the envisaged measure would act to draw in more tax for the exchequer than the proposals that are currently on the table.'
