Chris Broussard predicts Mike Tomlin's first losing season despite Aaron Rodgers joining Steelers
Chris Broussard on Mike Tomlin's first losing season (Image via AP)
Chris Broussard didn't hold back when assessing the Pittsburgh Steelers' playoff hopes after acquiring veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers. On FS1, Broussard gave a sobering projection that this could mark Mike Tomlin's first losing season as head coach — despite optimism surrounding Rodgers' presence.
Analyst says Aaron Rodgers' arrival won't be enough as
AFC North competition
looms large
The longtime analyst argued that Aaron Rodgers' arrival has been overhyped, especially given the brutal competitiveness of the AFC North. 'This is going to be the 1st losing season of Mike Tomlin's career,' Broussard said. 'I'm going to give them some benefit of the doubt. Now, I'm not saying they will definitely, but let's say they start 3-0. That's a big if.'
Broussard laid out a scenario where the Steelers split their six division games in the AFC North — going 3-3 — and still finish the season at 8-9.
'Even if I say they start 3-0, go .500 in the division, they're still 8-9. I just think it's going to be failure,' he added.
Rodgers hasn't made playoffs since 2021
Broussard also questioned Rodgers' recent form and injury history, suggesting the hype around his arrival is misplaced. 'He (Aaron Rodgers) hasn't made the playoffs since 2021. His last three seasons — or really two, since he got hurt with the Jets in his first year — he's 13-21.'
Aaron Rodgers gives Steelers best QB play in years, will not make a difference | FIRST THINGS FIRST
Given the strength of the AFC North — with Joe Burrow's Bengals, Lamar Jackson's Ravens, and a resurgent Browns defense — Broussard argued that Rodgers may not be enough to push the Steelers into contention.
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Stylish New Mobility Scooters Available for Seniors (Take a Look)
Mobility Scooter | Search Ads
Search Now
Undo
Not everyone agrees with Broussard. Former NFL player and FS1 analyst James Jones offered a completely different outlook, suggesting Rodgers' arrival instantly elevates the franchise.
'Well they're a playoff team now,' Jones said on The Facility. 'Once you get to the playoffs, anything can happen. Coach Tomlin should have a smile on his face this morning because now your team has a chance to compete,' he continued.
'A couple of days ago, your team did not have a chance to compete, but Aaron Rodgers walking into that building — instantly you're a playoff team. I believe Aaron Rodgers still has a lot of good football left in him.
'
Aaron Rodgers signs one-year deal with Steelers, team "now has a chance to compete" | THE FACILITY
Also read:
Eagles double down on Saquon Barkley – Jalen Hurts takes backseat as Philly commits to run-first era
The Steelers last made the playoffs in 2021 and have remained on the fringe since. Tomlin, renowned for never having a losing season since taking over in 2007, now finds himself in the crossfire of conflicting projections — with the 2025 campaign shaping up to be one of the most scrutinized of his career.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Australia vs South Africa WTC Final: Bowlers dominate as 14 wickets fall on Day 1 at Lord's
Kagiso Rabada's 5/51 stole the show on Day 1 at Lord's in the WTC Final (Image via AP /Kirsty Wigglesworth) Australia fought back against South Africa on day one of the World Test Championship final at Lord's, London on Wednesday. After being bowled out for 212 with Kagiso Rabada taking 5-51, Australia's Mitchell Starc led a bowling comeback that left South Africa struggling at 43-4 at stumps, trailing by 169 runs. The match began with South Africa captain Temba Bavuma winning the toss and choosing to bowl in overcast conditions favorable for bowling. Rabada quickly put Australia in trouble at 16-2, dismissing both Usman Khawaja and Cameron Green in a single over. Rabada, returning to Test cricket after serving a one-month ban for cocaine use, demonstrated his prowess by taking two wickets for just four runs in four balls. The 30-year-old pace bowler now has over 300 Test wickets to his name. Marnus Labuschagne, Australia's latest opener following David Warner's retirement, managed 17 off 56 balls before falling to Marco Jansen. Travis Head could only score 11 before being caught by Kyle Verreynne off Jansen's bowling. Bold prediction! Astrologer Greenstone Lobo picks winner of Australia vs South Africa WTC Final 2025 Steve Smith and Beau Webster helped stabilize the Australian innings with a crucial 79-run partnership for the fifth wicket. Webster, who scored 72, had a lucky escape when he would have been lbw to Rabada on 8 had South Africa reviewed the decision. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Buy Brass Idols - Handmade Brass Statues for Home & Gifting Luxeartisanship Buy Now Undo Smith reached his fifty but eventually fell for 66 to part-time spinner Aiden Markram, caught by Jansen at slip. Australia's innings quickly unraveled as they lost their final five wickets for just 20 runs, with Rabada finishing with figures of 5-51. In response, South Africa's batting struggled against Australia's pace attack. Starc removed Markram for a duck and dismissed Ryan Rickelton for 16, reducing South Africa to 19-2. Poll Who do you think will win the World Test Championship final? Australia South Africa Wiaan Mulder, batting at number three, survived an early chance when wicketkeeper Alex Carey dropped a straightforward catch off Starc. However, Mulder only managed to score six runs from 44 balls before being bowled by Pat Cummins . Bavuma took 31 balls to get off the mark, scoring a two off Josh Hazlewood that drew cheers from South African supporters. Hazlewood later claimed the wicket of Tristan Stubbs before the close of play. South Africa trail Australia by 169 runs at the end of day 1 (Image via X) At stumps, David Bedingham remained unbeaten on eight, having hit consecutive boundaries off Cummins in the final over. Bavuma was not out on three, with South Africa facing an uphill battle to match Australia's first innings total. The match situation mirrors Australia's position in the 2023 final against India at the Oval, where they recovered from early trouble through centuries from Smith and Head to win the match.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
7 hours ago
- First Post
Tilak Varma rises to third in ICC T20I batting rankings; Chakravarthy top-ranked Indian in bowling section
India's Tilak Varma has climbed to third in the ICC Men's T20I Batting Rankings, while Varun Chakaravarthy and Ravi Bishnoi retain their top 10 spots in the bowling charts. Hardik Pandya has retained his top spot in the all-rounder rankings. read more Tilak Varma has climbed to the third spot in the ICC T20I batting rankings. Image: AP Dubai: India's Tilak Varma climbed one spot to third in the ICC Men's T20I Batting Rankings, while spinners Varun Chakaravarthy and Ravi Bishnoi held on to the third and seventh positions respectively in the latest bowling chart released on Wednesday. Tilak now has 804 rating points, behind compatriot Abhishek Sharma, who is placed second. Australia's Travis Head continues to lead the batting chart while Suryakumar Yadav, who slipped one place to sixth, is the only other Indian in the top 10. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD In the bowling rankings, besides Chakaravarthy (706) and Bishnoi (674), left-arm pacer Arshdeep Singh is also in the top 10 with 653 points. Hardik Pandya continues to lead the all-rounders' list with 252 rating points. Among others, England's Adil Rashid moved up a spot to second in the bowling rankings following a strong showing in the 3-0 T20I series win over West Indies. The 37-year-old picked up 1/22 in Chester-le-Street, 1/59 in Bristol, and 2/30 in Southampton to surpass Wanindu Hasaranga and Chakaravarthy. Rashid now has 710 points, just 13 behind top-ranked Jacob Duffy of New Zealand (723). Brydon Carse, Rashid's teammate, also made gains with two wickets across the last two games, jumping 16 spots to 52nd with 493 points. England's Ben Duckett rose 48 places to 16th after his blazing 84 off 46 balls in the final T20I, while Harry Brook moved up six spots to joint-38th following knocks of 35 not out and 34 in the series. For West Indies, captain Shai Hope moved up 14 places to 15th with two knocks in the 40s, while Rovman Powell entered the top 20 after an unbeaten 79 off 45 balls in the final game. All-rounder Jason Holder also made progress, moving up 16 places to 26th in the all-rounder rankings after contributing 70 runs and a wicket in the series. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Hindustan Times
8 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Aaron Rodgers says his decision to play in Pittsburgh this season was 'best for my soul'
PITTSBURGH — Aaron Rodgers doesn't need to keep doing this. He knows that. The four-time NFL MVP's decision to return for a 21st season and to do it in Pittsburgh was not about trying to prove something to himself, the New York Jets or anyone else. The game has given a lot to him. Stardom. Wealth. A title. Relationships that will last long after he decides to stop playing. The next seven months — if they are indeed the last seven months of a career that almost certainly will end with a gold jacket and a bust in the Hall of Fame — are about trying to pay it forward while finding peace in the process. Standing in front of a sea of cameras more suited for the week ahead of a conference championship game rather than what Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin calls 'football-lite' in June, the 41-year-old Rodgers made a compelling case that the coda he is trying to author in Pittsburgh is about something deeper. 'A lot of decisions that I've made over my career and life from strictly the ego, even if they turn out well, are always unfulfilling,' Rodgers said Tuesday after the first day of Pittsburgh's mandatory minicamp. 'But the decisions made from the soul are usually pretty fulfilling. So this was a decision that was best for my soul.' And one the Steelers believe is best for business, one of the reasons they put no pressure on Rodgers during the spring as he dealt with off-the-field issues that he's said included having multiple people in his inner circle battle cancer. Rodgers said those issues 'have improved a bit,' clearing the way for him to join Tomlin and a team that has bounced from one quarterback to another since Ben Roethlisberger retired at the end of the 2021 season. While Rodgers is hardly a long-term solution, he believes he has enough left to help a club that has gone nearly a decade without winning a playoff game. The path from the second Tuesday in June to late January and beyond is a long one, and Rodgers balked when asked if he could help Pittsburgh get over 'the hump." He pointed out it was simply Day 1, with all the awkwardness that comes with it. Rodgers couldn't 'stand' the new helmet he was forced to don after the model he'd worn for the last 20 years was finally banned by the league. He didn't know many of the names of the other 88 guys who joined him on the practice fields on a day All-Pro outside linebacker T.J. Watt skipped in hopes of landing a new contract. It took all of one step outside the locker room for him to immediately get lost. And yet, there was a familiarity to it all. He's known Steelers quarterbacks coach Tom Arth since Arth made a cameo appearance alongside Rodgers as a player in Green Bay in 2006. Rodgers then rattled off a list of people he's come across with Pittsburgh ties and then added with a smile that he has 'a lot of Yinzers' in my life, a colloquialism for Western Pennsylvania natives. None of those names, however, convinced Rodgers that Pittsburgh was the right choice. That was all Tomlin. The two stayed in contact over the last two-plus months following Rodgers' semi-undercover visit to the team facility in March, producing what Rodgers called 'some of the coolest conversations I've had in the game." 'He's a big reason I'm here,' Rodgers said. 'I believe in him.' The feeling is mutual. Unlike last year, when there was a quarterback competition — at least in practice if not in spirit — between Russell Wilson and Justin Fields, there is not one this time. While Rodgers, wearing a white jersey with the No. 8 on it and a towel unfurled over the front of his black shorts, mostly stood and watched while Mason Rudolph, rookie Will Howard and Skyler Thompson took the reps there is no mystery about who will work with the starters when Pittsburgh arrives for training camp at Saint Vincent College in late July. The last few groups of quarterbacks, from Wilson and Fields to Rudolph to Mitch Trubisky to Kenny Pickett, never missed a practice or an OTA. They are also not Rodgers. 'I trust that whatever issues or learning curve things that he needs to get through will be handled during the down period of the summer for sure,' Tomlin said. Rodgers, who has worked out with recently acquired DK Metcalf in recent months, hopes some of the Steelers' skill position players can join him in Malibu, California, sometime between when minicamp opens on Thursday and they report to Rooney Hall on July 23. If they do, maybe they'll get a chance to meet Rodgers' wife. Rodgers was spotted wearing what looked like a wedding band in a picture the Steelers shared when he signed his contract. Rodgers confirmed Tuesday that he was married 'a couple months' ago but declined to get into details. The revelation, made late in his 13-minute session with reporters, hints at the many layers to Rodgers that extend far beyond the field. He's not afraid to express his views about many topics, from vaccines to politics and beyond. Yet there was none of that on Tuesday. There was only his firm belief in why he's here, and the optimism that this perhaps final chapter of his career will be rooted in joy. 'It's hard to think of anything in my life that's positive that wasn't impacted by directly or indirectly by playing this game,' he said. 'So just want to give love back to the game, enjoy it, pass on my knowledge to my teammates, and try and find ways to help lead the team.' /hub/nfl
