Bombshell new push for Anthony Albanese's proposed super tax to go even further: What it will mean for YOUR money
A 15 per cent earnings tax applies to super balances during the accumulation phase when someone is working.
But the superannuation becomes tax free when someone turns 60 and can enter the retirement phase of super, an option now available to all baby boomers.
Ken Henry, a former Treasury secretary, wants retirees to pay a new earnings tax, depriving them of that tax-free status, now available for super balances of up to $2million.
'There are other ways of increasing the taxation that applies to high superannuation balances and improving the intergenerational equity of the superannuation system,' he told The Conversation's chief political correspondent Michelle Grattan.
Dr Henry said it was unfair for wealthier, older Australians to get superannuation tax breaks.
'The thing that stands out is this big difference between the taxation of superannuation fund earnings in the so-called accumulation phase and the treatment that they get in the so-called pension phase,' he said.
'So, young people, again, these poor young workers, struggling and see the earnings on their accumulating superannuation balances being taxed at 15 per cent whilst those who have big superannuation balances and are in the retirement phase, well the earnings in their superannuation funds are completely tax exempt. And that just seems rather weird.'
Dr Henry's 2009 tax review for Kevin Rudd's government proposed halving the superannuation earnings tax to 7.5 per cent, but applying it to both the accumulation and retirement phases of super.
'Halving the tax on superannuation earnings to 7.5 per cent would further increase retirement savings,' it said.
'Applying the earnings tax to the pension phase would considerably simplify the compliance requirements of superannuation funds.
'A structural weakness in the current retirement income system is a failure to provide products that would allow a person to manage longevity risk.'
Chalmers was former treasurer Wayne Swan's deputy chief of staff when Dr Henry proposed taxing the retirement phase of super.
The Actuaries Institute last year proposed replacing the 15 per cent superannuation tax on earnings with a 10 or 11 per cent tax on both the accumulation and retirement earnings phases of super.
Dr Henry, however, is not campaigning against Labor's plan to slap a new 15 per cent tax on unrealised gains on super balances above $3million.
This means super capital growth would be tax on the notional or paper value of retirement savings above this threshold before assets are sold - marking a departure from the usual capital gains tax practice of a taxing kicking in after assets are sold.
'I'm not opposed to it. The thing that stands out most, when you look at the way that superannuation is taxed is not that unrealised capital gains is not taxed,' he said.
Labor needs the Greens in the Senate to pass its Better Targeted Superannuation Concessions bill.
Parliament is resuming on July 22 and the government is proposing to have its super tax plan backdated to the start of this new financial year, July 1.
The Greens want the threshold lowered from $3million to $2million but indexed for inflation.
Nick McKim, the party's economic justice spokesman, said richer Australians needed to pay more tax.
'Over time Australia's superannuation system has become less about providing a dignified retirement for working people, and more of a vehicle for wealth accumulation. This needs to change,' he said.
'The Greens want to ensure that very wealthy Australians pay their fair share of tax, so that governments can do more to support people who need it.'
'Obviously we have not yet seen the legislation or regulations that Dr Chalmers intends to introduce.'
A productivity-focused economic roundtable is being held in August, which will include discussions on tax policy.
Chalmers in March praised Dr Henry when asked about his observation that relying too heavily on income tax revenue was hurting young people.
'I think the world of Ken Henry. I take his opinions very seriously. I worked with him very closely in this building, actually not that long ago and so I respect Ken and when he makes comments like that, I take them seriously and I do reflect on them,' he told Sky News.
Super earnings have been tax free in the retirement phase since July 2007 but an indexed cap was introduced in 2017.
A spokesman for Chalmers suggested Dr Henry's suggestion would be unlikely to become government policy.
'Our tax policies haven't changed. We've got a significant tax reform agenda that we're rolling out,' he told Daily Mail Australia.
'Our focus when it comes to tax is our tax cuts for every taxpayer, improving tax compliance, ensuring multinationals pay a fairer share of tax, our changes for high balance super.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
8 minutes ago
- Reuters
US Treasury yield forecasts anchored despite rising debt load and inflation concerns
BENGALURU, July 15 (Reuters) - U.S. Treasury yields will trade in a tight range over the coming months, with a strong majority of bond strategists surveyed by Reuters predicting demand for Treasuries lagging an expected deluge of new supply. President Donald Trump's sweeping tax-cut and spending bill, which cleared its final hurdle in the U.S. Congress earlier this month, is expected to add $3.4 trillion to the nation's $36.2 trillion debt pile, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. Inflation risks from a renewed U.S.-led trade war, which includes Trump threatening a 30% tariff on imports from Mexico and the European Union starting August 1, has also pushed the U.S. "term premium" - the compensation investors demand for holding longer-term bonds - higher. With net Treasury issuance expected to approach nearly half a trillion dollars this quarter a rising risk premium makes it considerably harder to finance those expenses at higher interest rates. Nearly 77% of bond strategists, 23 of 30, responding to a July 10-15 Reuters survey said demand for U.S. Treasuries would lag supply slightly both this quarter and the next. Those respondents generally held a higher yield view than the wider monthly panel of 71 bond yield forecasters. Most bond strategists in Reuters surveys over the past year have repeatedly overestimated declining yields. "I think rates will over time structurally drift higher until either they're too restrictive in the real economy or the to rein in spending in order to right-size the budget," said Connor Fitzgerald, fixed income portfolio manager at Wellington Management. "While the government will be fine financing all the supply they need it will, over time, come at a slightly higher risk premium or cost." Sustained expectations the U.S. Federal Reserve will cut interest rates is one main reason strategists expect the benchmark 10-year Treasury yield , currently 4.42%, to roughly hold that level in coming months, falling a bit to 4.40% by end-September and 4.30% by year-end. "We think we're going to be in a range-trade for the next few months, maybe a marginal drop by year-end - not a huge move. There's a limit to the sell-off in the long end, but then there's a limit to a rally and lower yields too," said Jason Williams, director of U.S. rates research at Citi. "There are certainly risks the unemployment rate can go higher and though we haven't seen much tariff-led inflation yet there are definitely risks tariffs will cause a one-time price shift and that really complicates the Fed's reaction function." U.S. consumer prices likely rose sharply in June, potentially signaling the start of a long-anticipated tariff-driven rise that could limit how much the Fed can cut rates. That would further strain the already-tense relationship between Trump and Fed Chair Jerome Powell. "A key risk is the impact inflation will have on consumer spending and the extent to which firms will pass that on. If firms are unable to absorb the cost pressures and pass them off to would be a major factor in driving an economic slowdown," said Matthew Vegari, head of research at Clearwater Analytics. The interest-rate-sensitive 2-year Treasury yield , currently 3.90%, will decline 27 basis points to 3.63% at year-end, survey medians showed. If realized, that would steepen the yield curve, widening the spread with the 10-year yield to 67bps from around 50bps.
The Sun
37 minutes ago
- The Sun
Big savings boost for millions as ‘game changing' pension rules confirmed by government
HOUSEHOLDS will get new support to help them boost their savings under new government and watchdog plans announced today. Previously savers who had cash with pension and investment firms couldn't get help with where to put their money without paying for financial advice. 1 But under huge new plans announced today by the Treasury and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) financial firms will be able to give "targeted support" to savers. This will help them to decide where to invest their money to get the best return. Firms will also be able to make recommendations to customers based on groups of similar people in comparable circumstances. The Sun first revealed the proposals exclusively last August. The plans will help people to understand how to make the most of their pensions. Many people are not saving enough for retirement and need more help to prepare to stop working. Most people with a pension that is run by an FCA-regulated firm access their pension pot without taking financial advice or guidance, the regulator said. The Treasury intends to bring in the changes with a Statutory Instrument, which is a way to introduce and refine laws without needing to create a new Act of Parliament. This is often quicker than trying to pass a new law. The changes come after warnings from the Treasury and FCA that too few people are able to get the help they need to manage their finances. Fewer than 9% of adults accessed financial advice in the year to May 2024. Meanwhile, many are turning to informal and unregulated sources of advice, including social media. Estimates suggest that 13million people are not investing where they could be. Plus, £430billion is being held in cash, even after taking out emergency savings. What are the different types of pensions? WE round-up the main types of pension and how they differ: Personal pension or self-invested personal pension (SIPP) - This is probably the most flexible type of pension as you can choose your own provider and how much you invest. Workplace pension - The Government has made it compulsory for employers to automatically enrol you in your workplace pension unless you opt out. These so-called defined contribution (DC) pensions are usually chosen by your employer and you won't be able to change it. Minimum contributions are 8%, with employees paying 5% (1% in tax relief) and employers contributing 3%. Final salary pension - This is also a workplace pension but here, what you get in retirement is decided based on your salary, and you'll be paid a set amount each year upon retiring. It's often referred to as a gold-plated pension or a defined benefit (DB) pension. But they're not typically offered by employers anymore. New state pension - This is what the state pays to those who reach state pension age after April 6 2016. The maximum payout is £203.85 a week and you'll need 35 years of National Insurance contributions to get this. You also need at least ten years' worth to qualify for anything at all. Basic state pension - If you reach the state pension age on or before April 2016, you'll get the basic state pension. The full amount is £156.20 per week and you'll need 30 years of National Insurance contributions to get this. If you have the basic state pension you may also get a top-up from what's known as the additional or second state pension. Those who have built up National Insurance contributions under both the basic and new state pensions will get a combination of both schemes. Experts have hailed the move as a major step for savers. Tom Selby, director of public policy at AJ Bell, said: "Targeted Support could be a game changer for Brits, enabling millions of people to get more useful help about saving and long-term investing. "This should ensure millions of people are better prepared, from building a rainy-day pot to saving for retirement.' Mike Barrett, consulting director at The Lang Cat, agrees and described the announcement as "a real positive step forward". He said: "Customers will be able to call their provider directly to ask for help. "The provider will be able to monitor your pension to check if you are in an expensive fund, not on track or withdrawing too much from your pot. There will also be lots of regulatory protection." The announcements are part of a wider government plan to help people make the most of their money. The FCA is working on reforms to help the public understand the risks and benefits of investing. It is also working to reform pensions in order to make sure people have enough money in retirement. Meanwhile, it is also developing a strategy to combat the barriers that stop savers from accessing the right financial products and services. How will the changes work? Banks will let customers know when there is an opportunity to move their money from a low-return current account to higher-performing stocks and shares investments. The firms will need to explain the nature and limitations of the service they are providing. This will help customers to understand they are not receiving a more personal type of advice. Customers will be warned of the risks when investing, which will help them to judge where best to put their money. They will also be guided through the different investments on offer, which often puts savers off investing. Firms that offer targeted support will be subject to special conduct standards, which are designed to protect customers. They will need to apply to the FCA or the Prudential Regulatory Authority (PRA) before they can offer targeted support. This will give both regulators the chance to check that a firm meets the criteria to offer the support. Who will benefit from them? The Treasury said the changes will help three key groups of investors. People who are not saving enough for retirement Currently firms can warn customers that they may not be saving enough for retirement. But through targeted support firms will be able to suggest an alternative pension contribution rate. The firms will also be able to help customers choose between their options when they are close to retiring. Consumers who are struggling to access their pensions At the moment firms can give savers factual information about their retirement options. For example, they can explain the key features of an annuity or pension drawdown. But under targeted support firms will be able to suggest a course of action, such as a certain investment product. New investors The plans will also allow firms to help those with substantial savings to consider investing. It will be able to suggest investment products to help customers get started. What else has been announced? Alongside the introduction of targeted support, the FCA has also published several other proposals. It wants to simplify its advice rules to make clear the difference between simplified and more widespread advice. This will give firms confidence that they can provide simple, focused advice to customers who have straightforward needs. It also wants to improve its guidance on what counts as advice. This will help firms to understand the opportunities they have to give customers support that does not count as advice. .
Daily Mail
39 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
New 'Tell Sid'-style drive to get people investing revealed by Rachel Reeves in 'Leeds reforms'
The Government has launched a drive to encourage more ordinary people to start investing in a package of reforms to boost economic growth. A new consumer campaign will lay out the long term benefits of investing for better returns, rather than keeping savings in cash. Banks will nudge customers with large cash balances to consider investing instead. Rachel Reeves revealed the plan today ahead of her Mansion House speech, in an echo of the 1980s 'Tell Sid' campaign around the privatisation of British Gas that is held up as a successful drive to engage the public with the stock market. A much feared cut to the £20,000 annual cash Isa limit was not announced, though the Government says it will continue to consider ways to strike the right balance between cash savings and investment. The 'Leeds reforms', unveiled in the West Yorkshire city by the Chancellor include reforming the bank ring-fencing regime and reducing burdensome regulation in the City. The changes will reintroduce 'informed risk-taking' into the financial system, and 'represent the widest set of reforms to financial services for more than a decade', says the Government. The new measures are intended to help drive increased levels of investment among both financial firms and individuals. The Treasury said the ring-fencing regime - which was brought in after the 2008 financial crisis to separate banks' retail and investment banking activities - will be reformed. Economic Secretary Emma Reynolds will lead a review into balancing between growth and stability - including protecting customers' deposits. The UK is a global outlier in enforcing ring-fencing, and major banks have been divided over whether the system is necessary to protect savers or is overly burdensome. The Treasury said it was backing regulatory reforms for mid-sized banks to free up money for lending and investment. It also plans to cut layers of red tape for businesses in the City. This will see the UK's Financial Ombudsman Service - which settles complaints between consumers and businesses - watered down and simplified to address backlogs in the system. There will also be an accelaration of changes to the senior managers regime, which was also brought in after the 2008 crisis to vet individuals before they are appointed and hold them accountable for problems and risk-taking. Meanwhile, efforts to encourage more individuals to invest rather than keep savings in cash include rolling out 'targeted support' from April next year. This will involve banks alerting customers with cash sitting in low-return current accounts about investment opportunities. Major banks and financial firms including Barclays, Lloyds, Vanguard and Hargreaves Lansdown are backing a new advertising campaign highlighting the benefits of investing. Reeves told finance chiefs, when setting out the reforms in Leeds: 'We are fundamentally reforming the regulatory system, freeing up firms to take risks and to drive growth. The 'much-needed' measures are intended to 'really invigorate our financial services sector, but with the core purpose of therefore reinvigorating the whole economy,' she said. Susannah Streeter, head of money and markets at Hargreaves Lansdown, said the planned retail investor campaign would act as a loudspeaker to amplify the message about the opportunity investing can offer. 'It will be important to stress the value that investing can bring to support crucial life events and retirement planning. 'A reinvented 'Tell Sid' campaign, which shows how investment is helping people with their long-term needs like retirement, will build confidence and pave the way for greater participation in financial markets.' The famous 'Tell Sid' adverts encouraged people to buy shares in British Gas when it was privatised in the 1980s.
