Australian woman found guilty of triple murder with toxic mushrooms
MORWELL, Australia (July 7): An Australian woman murdered her husband's parents and aunt by lacing their beef Wellington lunch with toxic mushrooms, a jury found Monday at the climax of a trial watched around the world.
Keen home cook Erin Patterson hosted an intimate meal in July 2023 that started with good-natured banter and earnest prayer — but ended with three guests dead.
Throughout a trial lasting more than two months, Patterson maintained the beef-and-pastry dish was accidentally poisoned with death cap mushrooms, the world's most-lethal fungus.
But a 12-person jury on Monday found the 50-year-old guilty of triple murder, a crime that carries a maximum of life imprisonment.
She was also found guilty of attempting to murder a fourth guest who survived.
'I think it's very important that we remember that we've had three people that have died,' said Detective Inspector Dean Thomas after the verdict.
'I ask that we acknowledge those people and not forget them.'
The trial has drawn podcasters, film crews and true crime fans to the rural town of Morwell, a sedate hamlet in the state of Victoria better known for prize-winning roses.
Newspapers from New York to New Delhi have followed every twist of what many now simply call the 'mushroom murders'.
– 'Delicious' –
Family members of the victims declined to speak after the verdict, asking for privacy in a statement issued through police.
A lone friend of Patterson appeared overcome with emotion as she left the courthouse through a jostling media pack.
'I'm saddened. But it is what it is,' she told reporters.
On July 29, 2023, Patterson set the table for an intimate family meal at her tree-shaded country property.
Her lunch guests that afternoon were Don and Gail Patterson, the elderly parents of her long-estranged husband Simon.
Places were also set for Simon's maternal aunt Heather Wilkinson and her husband Ian, a well-known pastor at the local Baptist church.
Husband Simon was urged to come but he declined because he felt 'uncomfortable'.
In the background, Patterson's relationship with Simon was starting to turn sour.
The pair — still legally married — had been fighting over Simon's child support contributions.
Patterson forked out for expensive cuts of beef, which she slathered in a duxelles of minced mushrooms and wrapped in pastry to make individual parcels of beef Wellington.
Guests said grace before tucking in — and prayed once more after eating — with Heather later gushing about the 'delicious and beautiful' meal.
Death cap mushrooms are easily mistaken for other edible varieties, and reportedly possess a sweet taste that belies their potent toxicity.
– 'Not survivable' –
The guests' blood was swiftly coursing with deadly amatoxin, a poison produced by the death cap mushrooms known to sprout under the oak trees of Victoria.
Don, Gail and Heather died of organ failure within a week.
'It was very apparent that this was not survivable,' intensive care specialist Stephen Warrillow told the trial.
Detectives soon found signs that Patterson — herself a true crime buff — had dished up the meal with murderous intent.
Patterson told her guests she had received a cancer diagnosis and needed advice on breaking the news to her children, prosecutors alleged.
But medical records showed Patterson received no such diagnosis.
The prosecution said this was a lie cooked up to lure the diners to her table.
She also lied about owning a food dehydrator which police later found dumped in a rubbish tip.
Forensic tests found the appliance contained traces of the fatal fungi.
'I agree that I lied because I was afraid I would be held responsible,' Patterson told the trial.
A computer seized from her house had browsed a website pinpointing death cap mushrooms spotted a short drive from her house a year before the lunch, police said.
– 'Super sleuth' –
Death caps are the most lethal mushrooms on the planet, responsible for some 90 percent of all fatalities due to consuming toxic fungi.
Baptist preacher Ian Wilkinson was the only guest to survive, pulling through after weeks in hospital.
He told the court how guests' meals were served on four grey plates, while Patterson ate from a smaller orange dish.
But he could not explain why Patterson wanted him dead.
Patterson was a devoted mother-of-two with an active interest in her tight-knit community, volunteering to edit the village newsletter and film church services.
She was also a well-known true crime buff, joining a Facebook group to chew over details from infamous Australian murders.
Friend Christine Hunt told the jury Patterson had a reputation as 'a bit of a super sleuth'.
Patterson said the meal was accidentally contaminated with death cap mushrooms, but maintained through her lawyers it was nothing more than a 'terrible accident'.
'She didn't do it deliberately. She didn't do it intentionally,' defence lawyer Colin Mandy told the trial.
'She denies that she ever deliberately sought out death cap mushrooms.'
The trial heard from doctors, detectives, computer experts and mushroom specialists as it picked apart the beef Wellington lunch in forensic detail.
Confronted with countless hours of intricate expert testimony, it took the jury a week to find Patterson guilty.
She will be sentenced at a later date. – AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Climbing should never kill
Treacherous descent: Rescue workers attempting to evacuate Marins, who fell into a ravine on Mount Rinjani, Lombok Island, West Nusa Tenggara. — AFP The safety standard of Indonesia's tourism industry has come under intense international scrutiny following the tragic death of Brazilian tourist Juliana De Souza Pereira Marins. On June 21, Marins, 27, fell while climbing Mount Rinjani, the country's second-highest volcano, situated on Lombok Island, West Nusa Tenggara. Her body was recovered four days later from a ravine approximately 600m deep near Cemara Nunggal, a narrow and precarious section of the trail close to the summit. Initial drone footage taken shortly after the fall showed her sitting upright partway down a 200m-deep slope, indicating she had survived the initial impact. However, when rescuers reached the site later that evening, she was nowhere to be found. An autopsy conducted at a hospital in Bali on June 26 concluded that Marins died from internal organ damage and bleeding caused by injuries sustained in the fall. She was believed to have died within 20 minutes of a second plunge into a deeper ravine. Despite the search and rescue team's relentless efforts from day one, including navigating treacherous terrain and unpredictable weather, public outrage remained unabated. Many Brazilians took to social media to condemn what they saw as Indonesia's inadequate rescue system, insisting that Marins did not die simply because of the fall, but due to neglect. Most recently, the Brazilian government has signalled its intention to pursue international legal action over the case, formally requesting the Federal Police Superintendence in Rio de Janeiro to investigate possible negligence on the part of Indonesian authorities. Marins' life might have been saved if help had arrived sooner. This was affirmed by Abdul Haris Agam, popularly known as Agam Rinjani, an experienced tour operator and volunteer who played a key role in retrieving Marins' body. Having taken part in numerous evacuation efforts on the 3,726m mountain, Agam said Marins' rescue could have been carried out soon after her initial fall had essential equipment, including ropes, been available at critical points along the trail. He also pointed to the lack of proper rescue training among the mountain's tour guides and porters. The 36-year-old further revealed that no helicopter rescue drills have ever been conducted along hazardous trails, despite similar accidents having occurred in the past. The Indonesian government pledged to improve standard operating procedures for climbing Mount Rinjani and other popular hiking destinations across the archipelago. However, superficial measures alone will not be enough. This effort must go hand in hand with broader reforms in tourism management, including limiting the number of visitors to prioritise safety. In the aftermath of the Rinjani tragedy, many hikers have criticised Indonesia's tourism system for prioritising commercial interests over the safety of its visitors. By contrast, Mount Kinabalu in neighbouring Malaysia is widely regarded a model of responsible management. The number of climbers is capped at just 120 per day, far fewer than Rinjani's 700-person daily limit. — The Jakarta Post/ANN
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Escalating tension: Cambodia says Thailand attempts to 'tarnish' it with hacking claims
BANGKOK PHNOM PENH (AFP): Cambodia accused Thailand on Monday of a "malicious attempt" to smear its reputation with accusations it has launched cyber-attacks on the neighbouring nation, as a diplomatic feud festers. The South-East Asian neighbours have been at loggerheads since a Cambodian soldier was killed in late May as troops exchanged fire in a disputed border region. Numerous crossings have been closed as Cambodia banned some Thai products, and Thai Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra was suspended last week pending an ethics probe into her conduct during the spat. Cambodia's communications ministry said Thai posts in Thailand were alleging "Cambodia engaged North Korean hackers to launch attacks against a few Thai institutions". "The Royal Government of Cambodia has no connection whatsoever with North Korean hacker groups," the Ministry of Post and Telecommunications (MPTC) said in a statement. "The MPTC considers this allegation to be a malicious attempt by Thailand to tarnish Cambodia's reputation on the international stage". It also issued a counter-claim that a Thai hacker group known as "BlackEye-Thai" attacked "nearly all of the Cambodian government's online systems" over the past two weeks, but said their attempts were "thwarted". Paetongtarn was suspended after the Constitutional Court found there was "sufficient cause to suspect" she breached ministerial ethics as she tried to quash the border feud. In a call with Cambodian ex-leader Hun Sen, she called him "uncle" and referred to a Thai military commander as her "opponent". A recording of the call, leaked from the Cambodian side, sparked allegations she had kowtowed to Phnom Penh and undermined the military. But the feud has continued since Paetongtarn's suspension. As a result of a cabinet reshuffle she organised just hours before being suspended, she is now Thailand's serving culture minister. In one of her first acts in that office on Friday, she halted the return of 20 ancient Khmer artefacts to Cambodia, citing funding issues despite pledging in April to hand them over. The border row between the countries dates back to the drawing of their 800-kilometre (500-mile) frontier in the early 20th century, during the French occupation of Indochina. Violence sparked by the dispute has led to at least 28 deaths in the region since 2008, but the issue had died down in recent years until the flare-up in May. - AFP
New Straits Times
7 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Pressed to confess: Japan accused of 'hostage justice'
YO Amano says he is unravelling in a cell where he has been confined alone almost 24 hours a day for over six years, despite not having been convicted of the fraud charges against him. In Japan's harsh criminal justice system, critics say innocence is not presumed and coerced confessions help drive the 99 per cent conviction rate. "From the moment I was arrested, I've been treated like I'm a prisoner," Amano, 36, told AFP through a glass screen at the Tokyo Detention Centre, where he is held alongside people convicted of violent crimes, including death-row inmates. "I'm sure something is wrong with me mentally, but I can't tell for sure because I can't even get a decent medical diagnosis here," he said. Campaigners argue that lengthy pre-trial detention is meted out too easily in Japan, especially if suspects remain silent or refuse to confess. That often makes confessions a de-facto condition for their release, one that rights groups say exists in few other liberal democracies. This alleged use of confinement as a way to elicit confessions – or "hostage justice" – is under renewed scrutiny after a group of victims recently filed a lawsuit challenging its constitutionality. Lawyer Takashi Takano, who spearheads the suit, slammed the "completely inverted chronology." In Japan, "if you contest your charges, your bail is denied and detention drags on. You get punished and robbed of everything first, sometimes before the trial even begins, followed finally by a verdict," he told AFP. AFP obtained rare, court-issued approval to speak to Amano, who denies the charges against him. Since his 2018 arrest, he has been locked up incommunicado, having "lost everything", including his job, partner and mental health. In summer, what little coolness there is in the detention facility filters through a small food slot into Amano's sweltering cell. Three tatami mats fill the floor space, and there is no air conditioning. For most of the day, Amano is not allowed to lie down or lean against a wall, so he spends hours sitting on a mat. The former restaurant owner says he has lost 30 kilogrammes (66 pounds) since his arrest. He can only contact his lawyers and is denied access to anyone else, including family, barring rare exceptions. This has left him estranged from the "daughter I doted on", now seven years old, and whom he last saw in 2019. "I don't know if she still remembers me." "Hostage justice" – a term popularised by ex-Nissan chief Carlos Ghosn's months-long, 2018-2019 detention – has been repeatedly decried by international rights bodies. The latest lawsuit challenges judges' ability to "rubber-stamp" detentions, and to reject bail without demonstrating "probable cause" that evidence will be destroyed, according to lawyer Takano. In Japan, pre-indictment detention can last up to 23 days, extendable by multiple rearrests. Only after indictment does bail become possible, but as with Amano, the option is often dismissed if the accused denies the charges, campaigners say. Judicial data from 2021 shows that those who confessed were released much more quickly than those who denied the charges. "In Japan, refusing to confess or remaining silent is seen as high-risk behaviour of someone likely to destroy evidence," Kana Sasakura, a criminal law professor at Konan University, told AFP. Furthermore, detainees are typically interrogated without attorneys – a stark contrast to most Group of Seven and East Asian democracies – which makes it harder to withstand the pressure of questioning. This, coupled with gruelling confinement, attests to Japan's overall reliance on confessions, Sasakura noted. "It's a structure where, by conducting interrogations behind closed doors and isolating the suspect from the outside world, extracting confessions is made easier," she said. The justice ministry told AFP that "prolonged detention solely on the grounds of remaining silent or denying charges isn't occurring." "We don't use physical detention to force confessions," it added, defending Japan's "fair" and "evidence-based" system. But Tomoya Asanuma, another plaintiff in the suit, recalls almost cracking under the strain. Last year, the 36-year-old transgender activist endured almost four months of detention for charges including assault that he was ultimately acquitted of in January. "Detectives would tell me, 'confess already, and we don't have to interrogate you so many times,'" Asanuma told AFP of the frequent, hours-long questioning. Life under constant surveillance, including when he bathed or relieved himself, was a source of extra humiliation as his body still retained biologically female characteristics. "The thought repeatedly crossed my mind that if I falsely confessed, I can maybe escape all this," he said. And therein lies the secret to Japan's astonishing 99-per cent conviction rate, lawyer Takano argues. "After such endless interrogations, most people break and confess," leading to statements adopted by courts as evidence, he said. A case in point is Iwao Hakamada, who was once the world's longest-serving death-row inmate. His convictions – quashed last year – relied partly on confessions made during what the Supreme Court ruled were "inhumane" interrogations. "That's what undergirds the '99-per cent' conviction rate. But do you really trust such guilty verdicts?" Takano said. In his cell with an exposed toilet, Amano languishes with little sense of the time or weather outside. The light remains on after bedtime, but he is not allowed to cover his face with bedding. But still he will not confess. "If I succumb now and choose an easy way out, I would disappoint people who still support me," he said. "I won't betray their trust."
